Barley Matzah

The Ram Shik in his Sefer Hamitzvos, this is mitzvah yud by the mitzvah of matzah. So he brings Shamati Mimoran Hagoyim Zecha Tzaddik Livracha Balak Sams Sofer. Said I heard from the Sams Sofer that the Mishna says in Psachim Daf Mem Mem Aleph that a person can make matzah from any one of the Chamisha Shiminim, right? The Chamisha Shiminim Dagan. Any one of those minim, if you make matzah from it, it's going to be kosher matzah. What are the five minim? Chitim So'irim Kusmin, Shiboless Shu'al Veshiflon. Said the Ram Shik, I heard from Moran Hagoyim Zatzal, that said "Afילו Hachi Lo Ya'aseh Lechatchila Kimcha Masoyah." That Lechatchila, a person shouldn't go and make matzah from So'irim, from barley. Why? The Issur Bisforim, as it states in Sforim, the Kimcha So'irim Kosher Lishikra. That if somebody eats Kimcha So'irim, it's Kosher Lishikra. Uvematzah Is K'siv Lema'an Tizkor. The idea of eating matzah is to remember Yetzias Mitzrayim, right? To remember the fact that we went out quickly and there was no time for the dough to rise. So being that the whole tachlis of matzah is Lema'an Tizkor, and Kimcha D'So'irim is Kosher Lishikra, so said the Ram Shik Shamati Besheim Moran Hagoyim Zatzal, Balak Sams Sofer, that a person Lechatchila should not make matzos out of So'irim, even though the Mishna says in Psachim Mem Mem Aleph that it's one of the Chamisha Shiminim Dagan, this is something that if you want to do, B'Etzem you're allowed to do. I saw Rav Dovid Weiss in Parshas Bo, he brings this Ram Shik and he has a beautiful Arichus with incredible Biurim K'Darko Bekoidesh. One of his Mar'ei Mekomos is the Sams Sofer in Maseches Shabbos Daf Kuf Mem Mem Beis. So this is in Chidushei Sams Sofer Al Hashas. The context over there is a very famous Gemara, where the Gemara mentions a whole bunch of different pieces of advice that Rav Chisda gave. It concludes with the advice that he gave to his daughters, Kiyeru'ah, but that's the very very famous Gemara on Daf Kuf Mem Mem Beis in Maseches Shabbos. And he keeps on giving advice to a Bar Be Rav, right? That's who he was talking to. He was talking to Young Alight. He was talking to Tamid Chachamim. Omar Abba Chizda, right? Just to get a feel for it. Bar Be Rav doing officially Riff To Lay Decho Yarkon Mishon Degor. Omar Abba Chizda, Bar Be Rav doing officially Riff To Lay Riff To Abba Tzoi. Bar Be Rav doing officially Riff To. V'chulu V'chulu, it's mamish piece of advice after piece of advice after piece of advice all being given by Rav Chizda to a Bar Be Rav. Said the some sofer that if you look closely, there's two things that are mentioned in that Sugya that are not talking specifically to the Bar Be Rav. One is Rav Chizda and the other one is actually Rav Pappa. Omar Abba Chizda, this is Maim Hashmini. It's the eighth member. Rav Chizda all of a sudden he changes his niggun a little bit. He said, "I am on the absolute make on the Ham and the sorry." If someone's able to eat soy, he can survive on barley. For all the and it's said he decides, he's a fine schmacker, he's going to eat it. Omar Abba Mishon Bal Tashchis, he's going to be over Bal Tashchis. Over here, over here, Rav Chizda is not talking to the Bar Be Rav. He says, "I am on the absolute make on the Ham and the sorry." Then the Gemara concludes this is Omar Abba Pappa, the Indian Indian voice Indian "I am on the absolute Mishon Shichra." If someone was able to drink beer, the Shasi Cham ran and said he drinks wine, right? This is a very famous member for Rav Pappa in the right bites. "I am over Mishon Bal Tashchis." He's going to be over Bal Tashchis, right? Rav Pappa was a Mike Saker, that's what the Marsha says. Marsha says Rav Pappa was trying to promote his business. He was a Mike Saker, that's why he said if someone's able to drink beer and he drinks wine, he's over Bal Tashchis. This was a very good marketing slogan. The great Rav Pappa comes out with a psak, all of a sudden business is booming, right? A little inside information, some people start trading on it. The next thing you know is a psak given, right? That's a little bit what it sounds like. This is what the Marsha says. We mentioned in the past that the Rashash says that the Gemara says in Maseches Shabbos Kuf Yud Tes Mem Beis that if somebody is ever a chashud on something and really he's innocent, the s'char that he's going to get in the next world is incredible. He said, I want to get to Haba." of a person who people were accusing him of doing something wrong and it wasn't MS cuz the that he's going to get for the that he had to endure in this world is going to be absolutely incredible. And all of a sudden the person said, it happened to me. You should know I had that. People were me and I'm so happy I heard this number from cuz that means I'm going to have a says what was referring to? So says I think he meant this Marshall. He said that the Marshall said the way said that if someone's able to drink drinks he's about he did it to bump his business cuz he was a what? How can you say that about says this is what he was referring to right now for now. But the bottom line is said the some say for that if you look carefully again that is talking to the entire but here he doesn't mention the it's and also he didn't say what do you mean? We're giving advice to no. This has nothing to do with the why not? Some say for says half love of he says because it's in the matter. In the stuff you that there are that are machine even as a and one of the one of them is if somebody eats because the game but but if you look in the case what was the real not past that means is something that's as opposed to is something that's so you got to tell your younger man that if you're able to sustain yourself on the the salary don't eat in the cuz it's about what do you mean? He's eating the needs us to be able to he needs it to be so there's no way in the world you'd be able to say that. No of us if someone's not a he's an maybe an issue someone that's not holding by learning someone that's not holding by learning this is very good advice but a barber here it's not allowed. And then the said that I believe that's why also said because knew what said. He knew that and this is from that that even though he would have never ever told the younger man to buy his beer, right? He was that salesman. Don't buy my beer. I know this is how I make a but I have to be honest with you. Develop a taste for wine because at the end of the day you're going to end up working better. Said Papa, I hold that and he would have never told him to a barber and I meant so that's not a person like that is going to be a person like that is going to be said that it's this here in this brought that that even though one of the is the mission of the mission of the mission of the mission of the mission of the mission of the mission of the mission of the mission of the mission of the mission of the mission of the mission of the mission of the mission of the mission of the mission of the mission of the mission of the mission of the mission of the mission of the mission of the mission of the mission of the mission of the mission of the mission of the mission of the mission of the mission of the mission of the mission of the mission of the mission of the mission of the mission of the mission of the mission of the mission of the mission of the mission of the mission of the mission of the mission of the mission of the mission of the mission of the mission of the mission of the mission of the mission of the mission of the mission of the mission of the mission of the mission of the mission of the mission of the mission of the mission of the mission of the mission of the mission of the mission of the mission of the mission of the mission of the mission of the mission of the mission of the mission of the mission of the mission of the mission of the mission of the mission of the mission of the mission of the mission of the mission of the mission of the mission of the mission of the mission of the mission of the mission of the mission of the and he is very much the reason we have the way we have it. But he wrote on the culture so this is in a footnote on so far and the Torah of so in the middle of a on the the says such a he says for mayor like and over there there's a whole that some say for said that I am and he says really where do you find it? It's not here in right? We went through now you find that is measure you don't find anywhere that is that the makes a little bit of a in terms of what said he doesn't believe for one second really believe that is that I am a little But what he meant is really what the says in that if somebody could eat and it's that he eats that it's a because why you eating bread from barley which is not going to help you remember your learning when it said you could eat bread that was made from wheat that's going to allow you to help you to remember your learning. Who brings that he heard from so far that from the so far that he heard that he heard that don't eat from because it says he says it's wasn't focusing on he meant cuz people used to make maybe from he said don't it's not that the punchline is more that you don't have the that you would have from because you don't find anywhere in the that is really what you do find is is that is something that's but you eating not going to have the so just to end the water of says that he can be of the that he saw said he found the who it's always going to be in this is where the those things and nobody could do here must go with I'll be shaking now we must have a very he said that he saw that this guy as the guy on the I am from the so far that's story is a dominant he said that my show me the big deal that how come by the parish in the staff of Israel we don't mention the desires we mention the desires it's cuz desires is a dominant so he asked if that's the case why does it say so it's something that says why is that what that the is not really it's just a not going to have the Milo you're not going to have the added advantage of eating the which is nation that that's all the man that's why it has no to this martial that's why you can't find this anywhere in your dream of a day