Bechoros 31

You probably know Ribsilli Bournestein from the DAFF. Now Ribsrilli brings his signature depth, clarity, and energy to Kamisha Torah. Don't just learn Kumish, experience it like never before. Just click the banner or find it under their category on the Lakewood Dafomi app or on whatever platform you're listening from right now. Today's is and we are at the very first word of the very first line of so we're in the middle of a we've been discussing the of someone who takes upon himself to be nizer in certain areas of we discussed it in the context of in the context of miserus. We talked about it in the context of a ley being mabalon himself the laws of a being himself the laws of kahuna uh who himself but most notably we talked about it in the context of someone who takes upon himself to be nizer in the area of tumyra. So the background to that of course is that once upon a time to vetra regulated so much of the Jews lives and there were people that were miser and there were people that were non- miser and in [snorts] order to become a trustworthy person it required some sort of a kabalo we saw in the previous a whole bunch of different in terms of what that kabalo would have to look like but the bottom line is we're in the midst of discussing related to the now if you The latter part of yesterday's d was a bunch of bryes. We had four bryces and then we interrupted the bryces with a simmon and which seven words and is a to seven additional bryes on this topic. We went through and which means that what we're up to is and on that note we conclude the and really conclude the fourth parac says the we learned in that any person that made a kabala to be mabalon himself some that requires kabala if you take a Rashi Rashi says that this Brya is really safe for the it's the end of a Bryce that we spoke about in the previous stuff. Now that Brya we actually read Rashi inside it's three lines from the top of Dlam with [snorts] Brycea talks about how exactly a person is Macabal on himself different uh inim of so as it relates to all the people that could be macab and by the way be it someone that's taking upon himself to be Nisarin [snorts] Tyrus and be it someone that's being nizarin or maestris or even in Levia And in Kohuna the all of those people if after they made this they were meaning they started slipping and they went back to their bad ways right they were not they were in the reverse way at that point whenever meaning we give you an opportunity but if you show that we can't trust you at that point you're out you know said that shockingly this said in the event that they were but they did it. They did it when nobody was looking. So at that point we're not going to be them. If however they went backwards then if they say that no we want to come back then we would accept them. So it's a little bit counterintuitive but if they had their urida bits and they were caught and then they say you know something no take us back. I don't trust you. you're diaspor at least they're at least they're so they're showing you exactly where they're holding they're wearing their on their sleeve. So to the extent they're willing to do that and now they want to make a comeback and at that point we're going to be mab. Ramor takes the stronger stance as it relates to whether or not we're going to take them back and Rabi seems to be more of a make. Rome says that if somebody makes a cabala and he backs out even if he decides he wants to beer this time we're not going to accept it. Rabi Huda says then a different in what said not but rather what he meant to say was that in the event that they did their so then we are going to be mab them if they did a we're not going to be them what's So this is an opposite sar if they did a bit. So they did a bit they did a bit you're not such a bal you want to do will be if the person did aio so then because the a is a worse a noise continues they said it doesn't matter if they did either one of the in terms of as the says so This is half of we're discussing is the biggest it's not who is willing to cut the baby in half and literally play against and they say you hold in every single situation. Now who do we ask like this is also of a fellow is not like it's not like it's meaning of course what are we referencing we're referencing the is it or only or it doesn't matter hold that the Only time we consider is when we behave like famously said and we know from the truth that is the even though when it comes to this we like so we like in the one we're called and over here we like as it relates to if somebody was and then he slipped whether we would or we wouldn't uh take him back. So again we're going through this quickly but fascinating in terms of looking at this in light of the between and either way that was the fifth referring back to the right so we were up to what does this do everything that's what we're discussing somebody who was and then he was he went to the next and that is called in the bish right? They used to say if somebody was a and then he became a he became a tax collector which we already spoke about a little bit yesterday that's like the lowest of the law. So if he became a tax collector that in of itself means you automatically relinquish your rights to be let's say he stopped becoming a at that point we're not going to take him back. This was this is what they used to say but then they had a change of heart. They said so he doesn't go back to being right you have to be then he becomes a a regular person which means what is good and if not not says the anecdote related to this once had to come on to okay went to him wow and he went with 400 peers Raon we know the number 400 is a misperma sometimes but he went with 400 raus heard that rais the two big and 400 piers of not coming he went [snorts] and he prepared 400 cheers or 400 sets of chairs [snorts] either way and the are coming they're about to get this tremendous covet they're going to give tremendous covet and they heard somebody told that Rafa, you know, he became a guy by uh not a guy, right? A guy, he got involved in taxes. [snorts] So when they heard that, they said, "We're not going to him." Even though they needed him, but we're not going to him. In fact, they said they sent to him. He said, "You know what? Take what you uh wanted." Mean meaning you want that job. You can have that job because the hype, but I'm letting you know it comes with an invoice. invoices. We're not going to have anything to do with you. Heard that he sent back. I I already quit that job. I'm on to the next. So says didn't care went. So again, they always see the world differently. It's fascinating, right? How many zoo pun intended for this you have where sees it one way the other way. We're both going [laughter] right. I can see Rob asking the first. He says, "Well, let me hear what you're doing first." Right. But it's like unbelievable said how could I go because that was the way it was. [snorts] It doesn't matter. This is exactly what happened because you have this was being treated very very but he became a Gabby. Okay. But he was pish but he held you said that's the way it used to be. And it's for that reason I'm doing it in this way. The bottom line is what does this have to do with gab again has everything to do with gab. And finally the last and that is under the word we [snorts] learned in a another of the a person is allowed to see meaning if you're and you have all the criteria that you need. So if you want to be you can with the exception of your own. So persons not let us see his own moment you know right this is something else but this is where a person has an animal and we're trying to determine whether it has a moment doesn't have a mind of community you have to bring it to the you like any so you have to show it to say that a person ordinarily is ker but when it comes to your own that's not okay a person couldn't can evaluate his own to determine whether it it has a mum or doesn't have a mum meaning if the kim has a mum then you could be and if not you can the mically as relates to that's what this means a person could be on his own or not on his own in addition if he has a shila with regards to this pis whether that or he could pos his own sh so ordinarily a person shouldn't pus in his own shilas right that's what you would think stating that here we have price says not so positive when it comes to determining whether your has a doesn't have a that you can't do that but when it comes to determining whether your has a not whether your has a or not or that's something you can do so now is going to analyze this last what are we talking about is talking about where this person on his own wants to be the he wants to determine whether there's a m one person is anyways not okay. Why? Because you have to have three people. It's a little bit must be to talk about there were three people. Well, if there's three people there should be we learned inn this is a so if somebody was on a where there was a girl that did in that or there was a that was done in that. So the is you're allowed to marry her. This is a little bit of because you would think that maybe there's like a issue over here. Maybe this person allowed the khalita to take place because um he wanted to marry her. So you would think that really this shouldn't be okay stating that it is okay. And the Mishna says why the reason is because it's a bezdon over here because you need three people for a you need three people at least for a so you have to have a bezdon as it relates to and you have to have a bezdon as it relates to being that there has to be a bezdon. So therefore even if one of the people you assume maybe you know was about the other two the would be on that one person that wants to marry but being that there are two other people anyways so therefore it removes so says I don't understand this of a person being pled to paskin on his own to determine whether it has a or doesn't have a because if he's doing it by himself it's anyways an issue and if he's doing it with two other people so why is it different than that Mishna regarding me and Khalisa the mission was talking about where it was one person and the beer is based on something not but based on that and that is that is allowed to do it and there he would be but at the same time you don't have the two other people that's obviously where this would be now we mentioned this bryo So referring back to it very. So again this person is not allowed to he's not allowed a puskin on his own but his own to determine that is something he's allowed to do says why what's the reason what's the difference between has doesn't have a memorial your other says the reason is the reason is because you could always be ones can't be on the is but the regular that you created it so there's a right you have the ability to go ahead and So it's for that reason if you wanted to be you could do it. And let's just explain this a little bit better. You know, we just mentioned in the sense of why it is that you can't be. But if you take a look at says actually uses the beautiful. But the bottom line is that's the between and between regular the same is true with regards to there too you're going to be okay. Now that's a little bit of aesh. Why is it a kadesh? Because you can't be on is also so why is that fine? That should be like is always together. So you would think it goes together. The reason is something else says that if you would have an entire that has m because requires so being that you had a malak this is something you could have done. So it's for that reason now you could have only done it before it was messer but at the same time that's enough of a reason to remove this issue of ngas we're not being that maybe now all of a sudden it came about we're assuming that you know you being there was a time you could have addressed it and you didn't you're probably telling the truth finally initial aly you want to be on your tyrus meaning if you want to be your own judge and jury with regards to your tyrus that's something that's Okay. Why why you're not worried about the because at the end of the day again there's this what are you worried about? You're worried that um you're going to be lying. Why would you be lying? Because I don't know if you wanted to uh it's much simpler for you to just be and not lie. I what am I going to do with these tyrus that suddenly became I want them to be t I'll use the one I'm said the nas is not so strong and it's for that reason we can trust you. So the last bry is an interesting just in terms of just in general ordinarily we think that you can't judge for yourself you're but the has a place in like all things have a place in obviously when it comes to moment and there's different areas where you can't be a dian for yourself that's you know [snorts] but at the same time there are certain areas as long as there's a malak then we trust you in the context of certain is that you thinking clearly and it's going to be okay. The big exception to the rules, the laws of and uh just has a lot to do with that we're learning in. And on that note, and on that note, we turn our attention to the fifth bar oft. So clear from the title of the bar, which is the opening sentence of the Mishna that we're about to talk about. Let's just over quickly the Indians. This is one of the um sub themes of most notably the buttto is a very important point in the world of because and are unique in that world. Again what's you have regular that develops the is that at that point if you wanted to be you'd be allowed to be ped in other words ordinarily if somebody wants to be you can't be ped in the event that it develops at that point you have the right to go ahead and to be ped now made a very big deal with regards to when the animal developed relative to when it became was it or was it we said there's a huge because if it's then the way we look at the is so that when you're if it was so then the is grandfathered in already before it developed the mum if you're later which you could once it develops at that point it's not going to be it's still going to maintain certain levels of but the bottom line is that without getting involved in that nuance right now is where you have regularish you have an you have a carbon that developed as a result now it's something that is subject to the laws of opinion on that note and we're going to read the parenthesis because [snorts] it's goes to meaning if you have that right now has a and you're gonna be ped you're gonna sell it who's going to be the beneficiary of it is gonna be the beneficiary of it it's for that reason if you want to sell it on the shook You're allowed to sell it in the shook. If you want the shook, that's okay. And if you want to weigh the meat using the weights that were popular popularly used in the shook, this is something that you would be allowed to do as well. Now, why would you think not? So, Rashi says because it's not so to take an animal and to sell it in the shook. It's not so to weigh it in the and when it comes to you have to be a certain way stating that that's the whole punch line. Hectish is the beneficiary of it. So we're going to look away. Why? Because at the end of the day if you sell it in the shook and you weigh it in the shook, you're going to get more money for it. So it's a few shekels to look away from this. When it comes to mish you have to be very very careful. And it's for that reason Kazal said we're willing to look away from these sensitivities to go ahead and do it. What's the exception? Which type of would be different would be different? Because over there the beneficiary is going to be the the how. So when it comes to who's the beneficiary of the beneficiary of the he's a he's a big deal but he's the you don't give to anybody. It's your own. It's the bum. So being that as it relates to when they have a they're in the state of and the thing was going to be sold who would be the beneficiary of it the beneficiary of it would be the so if it's the now we have to be sensitive to the so now we have to be sensitive to not sell it in not and not be and not wait as well concludes and says now what what are we trying to say didn't we say that that's why some people are not in the first line of the Mishna because it's repeating itself was in the first line of the Mishna. We don't know for sure because it's not evident from Rashi but it would seem that maybe Rashi wasn't git over here but regardless we read both and finally the Mishna says that even though you're not and with and the reason is because it's not considered but to be that you're allowed to do so. What does that mean? That means if you have that you once weighed with a literal and you want to use that as the weight that's already something you could do. So to use the weight that I can't do but to use the flesh that you know it's weight because it was used by the way is already a cliche is not in that situation everything is going to be okay either way. Do we have related to a Mishna? Well, we have a Mishna related to that's related to the idea of has a but at the same time you have to be sensitive. Okay. Well, yeah. how you sell it, how you weigh it, when you Okay, I'm intrigued with the exception of and the reason is because even though you're being mul a little bit in it obviously it's not a huge it's a little bit of a zul and for the money it's sometimes we look away but when it comes to being that the beneficiary will not be hakish the beneficiary is going to be the bin in the case the it's the who received the gift in case once it's a now it's his own thing. So he's the in those situations you have to be sensitive and therefore this these are add this to the list of things that make unique in the world of now one thing the Mishna wasn't clear about and that is this that we're talking about is it talking about that you were that you were not very big for sure has a high level of again it doesn't matter if it regardless the level of kadusha is very intense once you if it was by the way at that situation it's uh it's and if not at the very least it it has a qualitatively much less level of so it's not clear whether this mission is talking about that's once it develops you could be but are we talking about that's And that is going to be the first clare of the now to beat fear ordinarily when you see the language it usually means and we'll see in one mas of the gum that is what the Mishna is referring to but at the same time the will see why wonders out loud are we talking about which is what it usually is or maybe here we're talking about are we talking I have a problem with that. I can't even read the mishes and the bum right what would it mean would mean that somebody bought right how you buy it from essentially so the money now becomes kadesh and this is let's say it's called let's keep it simple at this point it's it's [snorts] but either way it's for sure right so the mission said that's why we're or that's why we're allow you to do things that really are maybe unbefitting the sanctity of heish but it's not True. Cuz to the extent that you appo it already. So right now if I want to sell it, I want to shock it. I want to weigh it. It's all mine. Act is has $100 somewhere that that belongs to them. This is it must be. And what did the mission say? And really the punch line is the next part. If you want to go ahead and weigh it, you could weigh it in the now if it's talking about you. You weren't ped yet. So it's so [snorts] essentially what you're about to do is you're about to you're going to sell it in the sh and the question is are you going to weigh a you now when you sell it in the sh that will be the pigeon right? If it's pig then selling it will be the pigeon right let's let's get that clear on the side of the that the mission is talking about pig then really what the mission is saying is that you want to be you could be in the you and then afterwards go ahead and weigh it but the point is I can be by selling it or by weighing it with the liter the mishna's Right. If it's if it's apt I was how do I deal with it? If it's you're teaching me well I have a problem with that because once you can't be why not what happened to the infamous I mean infamous heart but what can happen says that holds we went through this. So then it's very good because there's no when it comes to remember there was one that holds counterintuitive that is very good that holds are included what are you going to say then it says you have to say meaning we're stuck over here if we're talking about so then we understand that you could sell this is all good but the problem is notion that That would explain and it would give us a new in the Mishna that the Mishna is discussing. But how could you be after the is going to happen through your weighing to figure out what you're going to sell for? Once you at that point you you can't be anymore. So we have a little bit of a problem. says is talking about okay what was the problem by saying it's not says that's at that point in the Mishna when you're going ahead and you're selling it was already but here's the point when he has a carbon and this carbon has a m and they want to go ahead and they want to sell it. So, they're going to go out into the market to see what they can get for it. The buyer is going to have to say to himself, I'm going to buy this behemoth from Hectish. If I buy it from Hectish, I'm not going to be able to sell it in the shook. I'm not going to be able to in the shook. I won't be able to wait with a literal. I'm not going to get top dollar for it. I want to be able to sell it to the people that overpay. Right? That's who you're looking for when you're a seller. So, you want to sell it to the guy that Right. That's always the the greater fool theory, right? That's so is the so you're trying to find the person that's going to pay maximum money. I'm going to give hectish less money in the pigion knowing that I don't have such a good ability to turn around and flip it and to sell it for the amount that I'm trying to get. So it's for that reason it's for that reason said that if you want to sell it and weigh it with a you can do so like this you'll be willing to pay more money. like this will be tough for you maker we're talking about where if it was problem so at the end of the day is the mission talking about really there's two ways you can learn if you hold that so then you could say very simple it's talking about the is telling me if however you hold that then you have to say that the is referring to either way going back to the mission So the said and the reason is very simple. Now is about to make a that if a wants to sell his he could sell it. If a has and it has a and he wants to sell it he could sell it. Now you're gonna tell me why is that? What would be the meaning? You can't sell it. So is like this. If you take a look in the Tory, the POS says as it relates to it says so we have a PK that says regarding the and we have a PK that says with regards to what does it mean what does it mean? It sounds a little bit like maybe you can't sell it, right? It certainly sounds a little bit like that. Truth is it's the bright [snorts] the gar is going to bring now. It's also going to be the opening uh part of tomorrow's going to say gfa and revisit this but a very very important in terms of understanding the laws of this is an area again that have in common as we're going to see but at the same time there's a little bit of a deviation here it says there it says and again the kash is coming off an obvious in the you could sell you could sell you just can't sell it in a way that's going to be disrespectful. You can't sell it in the and you can't weigh it with the lit but in terms of selling it that's something you can do. again was says within I understand that you're not let us sell it in the but you could sell it in a house very relates to this is bothering me could you sell it in your house to the price it says regarding and we learn from there at once the gets it that the is allowed to sell it even if it's and by the way not only if it's even if it's a it doesn't have a he's always allowed to sell it as it relates to it says and what we learn from there is is that so aar you could sell could sell aar means not you can't sell it. when it comes to what's the kasha the cash is you're telling me you can't sell you want to sell in your the privacy of your home you can that makes a lot of sense the only said but as it relates to this is now this is already a little bit more of a for tomorrow's I just want to bring out one point clar and that is by The says I think is helpful the says the way the understands it is is that there's to bear what does that mean? It means just in in it means you have a bar of so the firstborn you have to give to the firstborn cast or you have to give to the says the I know what's going through your mind I don't want to give away my I'd rather give away one of my other you can't be it's an on that says you are not allowed to go ahead and do that once Once you give it to the kayan, the kayan is not bound by anything. The never said a k want sell. And by the way, he could sell it even if it's alive. Even if it's a tom, you're allowed to sell. That's not a kayan's allowed to sell. When the spoke about the said something very sharp, the spoke about right don't switch. And if you do that and then the comes and says a a punch line which is gonna tomorrow's but means that you can never sell. I'll forget about being po and swapping it out is is is a going to explain where you see that in the word but is a and it teaches me that so when the Torah talked about the Torah just said don't you know swap out the firstborn with the but when the Torah spoke about the said full stop you go so as it relates to no who's thear the is if the decides that he wants to go ahead and he wants to sell it That's something he's allowed to do. So Misha, it's a very clear Mishna. Mishna has to let the co know that you could sell it in he can't sell it in but as you go the says why are you even having this conversation? So right he went to sleep at night with he woke up in the morning was ai and by pulling out one of his bryes he was able to come up with a terret what he said was he said that the mission is talking about not just any but and the reason here it's different is because when you're dealing with there's an we have to protect them concept of the apatropus a lot of coolers you find when it comes to and it's for that reason because of that we were and even though at first glance it sounds like an lavender of you go we'll see more about that now but in this situation it's going to be okay so before we get into the lumbness of this Bryce and it's a gishmaka ending to the gumar gives a little bit of an interruption a little says Sarly Ravidi was Rafious's gaba sh. He heard at a very nice terrace. He walked into Bish and he said over the test and he didn't say over the name of heard about this but he got very angry. He said the person that bit me says person that bit me says why does so much that his saying over not in his name says I'll tell you what this might sound familiar I'm going to live in your in two worlds a person live in two worlds is talking he said I hope that after I die people are going to say over about me in this world why any person who is that people say over from him even after he died his lips move in the ke and that's what meant when he said he met with right he wasn't quoting but he met me with said that there's a concept of living in living in two worlds and that's the reason that was by the way continues there to this yeah your pallet is like good wine so like comparing right sounds like someone's sleeping but lips are moving and has something to do with something says it's like a vat that people put in when they're making wine. If [snorts] somebody would put his finger into the vat of wine, so it would cause the wine to boil. You want to know had this ped says my bry. So going back to the bryce. Once again had this kasha this bondasha says that if you want to sell the you could sell it but it has to be out of the comfort of your home. Why said you're allowed to sell even though it says in the it's in this opinion but as it relates to the says which means full stop you can have a salad. So if that's the case why are we even having this conversation? So the said just woke up in the morning he said I know the terret it's talking about but when he said this terret he based it on a right that means he had a said that is going to be a little bit different my what is this [snorts] you're allowed to sell and as it relates to seemingly that and you want to sell it now [snorts] you should sell it. So don't sell the boss. That's what the real Mah is. But rather what [snorts] you should do is you should sell the the and the and charge a little bit extra. But if you do like this, it's going to be okay. Now [snorts] the says my I don't understand this price. But before my let's just understand what we could understand about this. So based on the he of the one thing is going to be clear spoiler alert that this entire bry is talking about right. I think if you looked at the bryer slowly and tried figuring out what the bryer means, you know, without seeing the analysis of it, this is a little bit what the bryer feels like. That's before, right? It sounds like that's the between the in the we're making a big deal about so it sounds a little bit going backwards that no but the truth is the whole price is talking about that's there's no one in the world that's going to tell you that you could ever sell even it's never going to happen to the extent that there was no so there's no question we're dealing over here where it was already okay so now let's look at the price again. So the says and the is a richer cash the cash I think I have a little bit of a steer over here because from the sounds like get the best price and from the it sounds like you're right it's really one case not two case it's a it's a little misleading right this is a price that needs a little bit of a tweak Every has a price like that. How that's the meaning the way you have to sell it is sell meaning if you want to sell even that's not something you'd be allowed to do. The only way you could do it is again the whole price is dealing with and the only time it's ever going to be is now how could uh let's just speak this out. Let's interrupt. I'm gonna have to do this a few times. personally, why would it be okay to go ahead and sell it even in the it says right made a big deal about that you can't sell not if it's not so if that's the case that as long as you sell you're not being is to sell it straight out but the minute there's at this point you're not being and it's for that reason if all is going to be isn't we're going to allow you to do it. And that's really what the Bryce is saying. What the B is saying is I know you're never allowed to sell it and therefore if someone's not a Yasum and Yasum means a Yum he's out of the picture. There's no way in the world we're going to allow this to happen. But because of the and because of the fact that we're looking out for them. So in that situation where all it is is have a right to look away. Says one thing is for sure. It sounds like if a would want to sell that wouldn't be okay, right? We're saying it's but if the god would want to it would be a prophecy says why is I'll show you a case where you now let us sell something but it's not everybody where is that somebody buy from his friend that's a problem right because he can't do business he can't just go ahead and buy uh love him and these things so >> [snorts] >> is like this mat the he has to give him mat right the you can sell him the is the priest that's the problem so if you want it he has to give you right try that uh at home but he has to give it to you why you're not allowed to do a shaft with it what do you do doesn't want to give it to you so you should do is you should do but you seem a foolish This is an so if the is such a good it should work for everybody. Why is it only working for the and why isn't it only so explains you know there's levels of if you go to and you buy and you walk out with and he throws in an you can somehow make that work is a very good it's it really doesn't look like necessarily you're paying for the aster but anyways as it relates to uh this where I'm buying flesh and no he's not buying meat he's buying is you know he wants all the things you throw in the garbage that's what he wants all the things that and I'm charging him prime rib prices so there it's not so good now it is and it could work but it's only going to work either way this is the way was when when if it's ra heard what said and he wasn't happy he He said if the safa is not a real saf it's just a perish on the ratio. So why are you telling me? You should have not mentioned the second mention of because of that said come this way [laughter] as it relates to you can tell must be the ratio is talking about because you're always allowed to sell ready for the You're always and when the price talks about doesn't mean and by the way that's the between the safe we said in the safe is not because you can never sell what is the talk about the s not talking about when you're dealing with you don't need when you're dealing shalo beim then you don't Let's just uh hit the pause button now for a second. I'll just speed this up. The fact that says even right makes a lot of sense. That's like right that's the but you see how works don't understand that's but the ratio of at first glance needs beer because what does the ratio say? One second. It says, "How you allowed to do it?" It should even be he said abundant help. But we understand why the biblical aspect of it is not a factor. But the way is learning he's allowing you to go ahead and sell it. Why you allow to sell it? Even you can't be right. You're not going to go ahead and be over. If that's the case, what we need to be bothered with right now is what's in. And really what Roa needs to explain it's all of he's going to have to have a there's no period to sell even though it says in the it has to be that yeah it's can't be that is true does have a mar let's learn the next what is my that's what he's going to find the marto because this is the part that requires me or he said he said that if you look carefully at the talks about let's read it again right so if the 10th animal should be the 10th animal don't stop making and figuring out I want this to be the 10th don't try manipulating the math whatever it is that's what it should be [snorts] let's say you go ahead and you switch oh the joke's on And finally it says the Tory juapose the concept of right very relevant to the with the what do we learn from there when is really when is if that's the case when are you not let it But after if you would want to go ahead and sell it, you would be allowed to sell it went ahead and made as it relates. So this is an important addendum to this as well as it relates to buser something that people right if you bought the live animal you're buying the buser for sure. So for that we were and we said don't buy it but as it relates to but the and those parts that a person doesn't really buy when it's so relates to the said that if you want to buy you're allowed to buy it. So in this situation if you're going to want to sell it to being that all it was was okay. So we have two shot how to learn this at first glance the safest seem to literally contradict each other. The says just go ahead and sell it. And then the safest you can only sell. So which one is it? said that the whole price is talking about and the whole price is talking about selling and the save is really just really what the price is saying is that even though it says in the but it's okay now it's so why is your going to play a role there is no and therefore all it is is we're going to be aren't we very often make even for not it depends on not all were created equally for this we're only going to be make for had a different said no the are not talking to each other the safe is not appear on the two different cases the is talking about and when it says it means I'm sorry when it says right and then the it's talking about not and if you want to sell it that's something you'd be allowed to do what's the is because rub a hole that the is only true. It's not true. It's only that it's going to be awesome being that the whole is only the whole not which is so the whole is only they went ahead and they were as it relates to they were they were stating that the whole was only with regards to the it wasn't with regards to the on the counter because when you buy that's not what you're buying therefore oh if you wanted to buy the that's a regular classic so if you wanted to do that that would be something that you would be allowed to do let's hit the pause button now and that is why are we talking about this price because Rashes had a kasha it bothered him so much he went to sleep with this kasha he woke up with a terret but he went to sleep with this casha the kasha was the mish says If you want to sell in the you could sell it in the when it comes to the only place you could sell it is is in your bias was bothered that how you selling in your bias there's an is to sell he woke up in the morning and he said oh it's we're talking about right we're talking about and it must be based on once said my price it's on zero price okay so let's see we have two understand we have a understanding's understanding How would this uh how would this fit? So I'll leave it at first glance you would be able to make this price of work right we could say it's talking about now was only selling right by this one over here and it's all the only in you and he's only make for okay so maybe that's what's going on what the Mishna means is that you're going to sell it but you're going to sell for sure it's going to you have no choice, right? It's all going to be because there's no right by the reason there's no is there's no way to get around this right. So there's no that you should be able to do that. So the only time there's even a is it'll be talking about where it was done by right and he went well what he meant was even more you could say right holds that the ratio of the price is saying that you're even right even [snorts] and as it relates to the of that's something that you're allowed to sell. That's something that you're allowed to sell only with so you can make it work with regards to the ratio with regards to the you could say it's talking about and when the Mishna says you could sell it you could sell or you [snorts] could say that it's talking about in which case you wouldn't have to make that it's talking about because if you're selling a then it doesn't have to Either way you'd be able to. So this Bryce is a if you're looking for a where do you have a anywhere in the world that you let us I gave it to you. It's a is one way it's either or as long as it's now what say made a Why did he say so? There's two ways you can learn. Either you could say and he held the whole is only he didn't say but it was it was sort of understood that that's what's going on over here. There's another way to learn and that is he held like and he didn't want to make an aim that it's talking about. So to not make the talk about he said it's talking about either way they discuss a little bit but we're just going through the math but just from understanding the circling back just closing the loop on the there's really two ways to come out just either way. So what emerged of the way understood the is that the holiest in the that says only is only but there's no anymore. It's because we put it in the same breath of says is not the only one who held this. holds what held and that is that you're sell but he had a different how do you know that when it comes to you're allowed to sell it meaning which is a roundabout way of saying is hence you don't have to come on when you're dealing with because it says in This is an example by the way where the garra assumes you know the rest of the and where is that now this is talking about two amikash that's what it's talking about it's talking about that has and it says and afterwards righte is the punchline of this Russian And the gar didn't even mention it. That's why we assume you know the end of the but it says says the it's a little bit mash that we're dealing with something that the only time you would be able to have the time you would have the is only after is only after the but you wouldn't be able to have what's an example of something you have you have no you can't do anything with it. You do have a it must be why does it be? Because ordinarily if you have and it develops you could sell it but we know when it comes to if you have a you can't sell it right you can't sell it well you go you can't sell it stating that stating that that's the only time stating that in the event that it was it was now we're ready. So you see that once you shed it at that point now you could have that you didn't have when it was if you want to go ahead and sell you'd be able to sell it. So it's a little bit of a a roundabout but we have two to this idea that the even though it sounds like a but it's only true it's not going to be true. So one thing for sure that Bryce mentioned there's a concept of selling and what did we mention? What could you be in? You could be in the what's missing? What's very noticeably missing? Yeah. There's nothing to do with. So if you do have in those it's uh it's not legit and as a result it doesn't work. the the at some of the behemas have value and for that reason it's okay if anybody else says it could be it could be it wasn't not ple because one's talking about a doctor one's talking about both talking about but at the same time ple marshi says that by the one who said you could be mafia they used to make kalem from the of thea as a result if you want to do you could do maras he came from a place where they didn't make kalem and as a result this is not something you'd be able to