Can Someone Who Is Not Fasting Get an Aliya on Yom Kippur

Okay, Rabbi Sai, today's Arab Kipper, it's a Yamiff, but we always like to say any day that you learn Arabika is a good day. So, I want to tell you the amazing suffic of Rabiar regarding someone who eats on Yum Kipper and he gets called up to an aliyah. Could someone who's not fasting get an aliyah on Yamiper? Normally on a tightness, if you're not fasting, you cannot get an aliyah. Someone who's not fasting on a tightness cannot get an aliyah. Could someone who's not fasting on get an aliyah? You hear the shila why would you be able to get an aliyah says that in our is someone who's not fasting cannot be says well one second thera of the morning you're we don't l the tora in the morning of yamipper because of the fast we l because of the yumpt it's not a of the tus the ka of shakus is not from the fast it's from the yumptive So whether you're fasting or not, you're still obligated in the yumpt of yum. Therefore says it's p that even if someone's not fasting, they could get an aliyah in the morning. But the shil is what about time? Why do we l time on yamipper says? You don't l on a regular sukus. You l on sh you l. You don't l So why are we linger? Oh, it's because it's a tightness. Because it's a tinus, the guy can't get an aliyah. Or maybe no. Maybe we lay ma the same way we lay ma on Shabas. On Shabas, we do lame by. So suffic how do we categorize how are we the is it and then someone who's not fasting could get an aliyah or is it the tus and therefore someone who's not fasting cannot get aliyah that's the of you now today is a double it's because it's yamipper and it's yumpt because you learned okay comes The Yesterday Napali showed me a picture of aish theas. I had never seen a picture of the marshes. He was speaking to the safer of he says like this the tomorrow by the halfra. Do you say do we say that? So you say so what's the says you say it the says you don't say it. What's the do you say it or not? Thees were according to the reason we're laning the is says you say the holds you don't say it because laning the hyra is not because you don't lyra even on shabas by when do we l by on a tinus so says You don't say it. So the says holds the the is and therefore you say and therefore if you're fasting you could get an aliyah even for the and holds the the laning of the hyra is mid the tus because on a regular shabas there is no hyra. Therefore, if you're fasting, you can't get an aliyah. So, the says whether someone who could uh who's not fasting could get an aliyah would be the and the Rama holds that at least the is the Ram would say you can't fast and you can't get the aliyah and the would say you could get the aliyah. So let's say somebody's not fasting, they should go to Sharia and take the aliyah. Let's say a guy bought, but he's not fasting. So he could go to Sharia and get the aliyah because according to the it's the but he can't go to Morai and get the aliyah. But what he could do is he could buy it in and then maybe we could make a transfer and then let him get the aliyah across the street. However, if you look in the Morai, he writes explicitly the is not but it's the quotes but the says not only is the not the in other words the is about whether the is made or not where the says the is the says thera is not the quotes that even the isus now >> so according to >> one minute one minute one minute according to the crea is then someone who's not fasting cannot get any aliyah at all but according to that the safer listen to this argues is according to that it's only the which is not me it's he wants to say that if you're not fasting you can only you could get or lei but you can't get >> cuz that's connected to the ma that's like mafia >> I would say no I would say even if the ha is from the tinus you could still get shishi because shishi is the ka you just can't read Tyra >> are they saying that that's like that's connected to >> anyway it's very interesting again well just to review has a suffic whether someone who's not fasting on he concludes you could because the ka is for the and the says that the question would be dependent on whether you say that you say it. Then if you're not fasting, you could get an aliyah that you don't say it. If you're fasting, you don't get an aliyah. And the seems to say that if thera is connected to the tinus, so is the creass hatra itself. Okay, we'll hold it here. We want to thank Dr. Jakob Bim for sponsoring today's shirim leishmas, both of his grandfathers. Yesterday >> and today all of the zas should have should be for your whole family for oh my god.