CHAZARAH - Bechoros Daf 14 | "Nothing but the Daf" with R' Eli Stefansky

[music] But boys, I tell your friends that's not to watch Nothing But the DAFF. I had a hunch. Seriously, I don't watch nothing but the DA, but this morning I was like, I wonder if they put the donkey in there. It's nothing but the daff. The donkeyy's not. I go there. I scroll through. There's no donkey. So, I I called him out on it. He's like, "I thought I put it in. He really I really wanted to. You're 100% right. I should But I'm saying, you know, he said he said it on the side. He he sliced it and he forgot to put it in. But lisa l for 30 seconds. Just got to taste the flavor of it. And then you get FOMO and you come back to the regular shear. You know, you got to you got to lure them back in." Okay. So, We're talking about whether or not a has a king invar says like this when you purchase pieces of silver from he's an idol worshipper you bought a whole package in the package deal in the bag there was a aka If he didn't give the money yet, but he did a masher. What does this tell us right now? The does nothing. Why? Because you need moes for the guy. You need money. You can give it back. Just give it take. Give it right back. But if he gave the money and then he did, what do you do? You should throw everything out into the Dead Sea. Actually, you know, this is not so much for the English speakers, but we have a guy that makes >> So, if you say money is what makes the mash, why does it say that he did a on the reason why he needs is because the non-Jew accepted upon himself. He says, "Yeah, I live here in let me do the of the Jews." Whatever whatever the the rules of the the land are, that's what I'm going to do. So you hear this asking if this guy accepted him upon himself to use all the laws of the Jews which is why in the world I have to use money even if you use money it doesn't work even though money is what works in this particular case I'm sorry yeah in this particular case you have to do why because he accepted upon himself the rules of the Jews ratio why do you tell me the ratio that doesn't work if he accepted upon himself why shouldn't work so we have a number of answers here why what's means had I known something I wouldn't have bought it had I known had I known that there's a getka there's in this bag. I wouldn't have done any business with this guy. It makes no sense what you're saying. What is the difference between the two cases in all cases both the question if he made a mash not when he would get money not money but in terms of the it's a bad deal there's a desire in both of the cases. So we have four answers now. Here they are. There's a meto but there's a difference between the is there a maris. Does it look like you're doing a a deal with what's since he never paid for it. So when he returns it to the non-Jew, it doesn't look like there was a transaction. There's no money changed changing hands here. The go gave him the say he gives it right back the zuzie. But when the Jew gives money, the Jew gives the go $1,000. Then the guy gives $1,000 back to the Jew and what does the Jew do? He gives him back. So there's a transaction and it looks really really bad if you're watching from the side. So many people for the very first time in their life are being right now. What does it mean? Some people didn't know what it meant. What's on the under remember you say tukim and the tum I timed it for me it never took me more than ever it doesn't take more than 8 minutes a day and usually it's 5 minutes the way I do it I do one alyah I do the whole thing so sorry I do from beginning to the end from beginning to end the whole para in one sitting real quick just the third part and that's it the next day I do the the first aliyah just the take a long time 5 to 8 minutes and something that you should do we're so far from from learning of this is an opportunity to do it we're starting so we have to wait though until start then you know it's a little tough but we have a week right what do we You have a whole week. It's a great year to start. It's the best year to start because you have a full year. Next teroto the first case, he didn't know what's in there. Do he didn't give money. He didn't know what's in there. But like the guy, the phone man, the cucumber guy that has cucumbers on his eyes. Why didn't he look in the bag? He gave money without looking. You hear this? You cannot come and complain and say, "Oh, I didn't know. I didn't know. Had I known." You should have checked. It's up to when it's up to you to check and you didn't check. It's your fault. Given the when you're about to do, you're supposed to look in the bag and see what's in there. And you should have noticed there's an idol in there. >> Huh. >> Right. Exactly. Some you say, "Oh, so let's say they never told me she's like this and like this and like that." Well, you're dating and you should have you should have like looked into it. Maybe it's your fault. I don't know. Not every time. But let's say that's it's a new site here. Megataus is not a fact. It's not like oh, you're fooled. It's if you had the opportunity to look into it and find out what >> due diligence. There you go. So we're going to have two reverses. The famous Raven and Ravashi who wrote the Gimmorra they say the reverse raashi says look at the beginning the first part of the mash doesn't work second part doesn't work I don't need the money is what what creates the kenyan over here but it's just because to that it should it should be the it should be written what do we use what word do we It should have the same wording, the same >> symmetry, >> symmetry, consistency and symmetry. And the the same people say the same word every time when he asks for it. We have to come up with one word and finish. Same symmetry maybe is better. No, the opposite. We start from the end. Mash does do the So then if does the Why are you permitted? You hear this boy say why you permitted to give this back? You did a mash. It's yours. You're Jewish. It's your What are you giving it back? Take responsibility. Throw it out in the answer is if you didn't do any then you to take it back. What do you mean you can take it back? You didn't do any Kenyan. What is the problem? You walk into a store, you look around. Oh says you're allowed to walk out without B. You didn't do anything. You didn't take anything off the shelf. You didn't give money. You didn't do mashik. So, what's the problem? Oh, oh, oh, Rabo, we have to We're here in Donnie Fine is going to love this. He's going to love this. Why? I'm telling you, you're going to love it. Tell me afterwards like this. You're allowed to take back your words. There is a concept in Yiddish called It means that you're not allowed to take back your words. And if you take back your words, you're not trustworthy. So Tyson says we're not going to here but says no but it's the same idea sometimes you do what does it say here I'm allowed to take back my words from the non-Jew from the idol worshipper look he has idol in his hand when you say something you tell your friend you're going to purchase his apartment you're you're going to sell him your apartment your word is a word forget about the contract A word is a word. A Jew from a Jew, you have to be very careful with your words. But when you're dealing with a non-Jew who doesn't keep his word, maybe that's why some Jews use this gimmar as a as a oh, we're dealing anyway with a person that doesn't keep his words. I don't have to keep my word. So I was shocked. I was shocked. You guys are not going to be shocked. We learned this Mishna almost word for word three weeks ago. Three weeks ago. So you're going to start reading it unless you're like I don't remember this. So let's think about it. If you have a regular animal and you say this is this is and then it befalls a what do we call that but it's already kadesh it's already has too late so what do you do you redeem it but most of the remains in it we'll see in the Mishna you cannot shear its wool you can't work it you can't just we can't there's there's different but what if it has a terri terrible mom. It has a bad m and then you made a kadesh. That's the only what did you make here? The same way you made a horse kadesh. The same way you made a computer kadesh. It's only good for the money for the value of the money. So it's so therefore you have to still treat it as a regular animal. It still has it still has the gifts. It's still you can check it in your house if you want. All that stuff. Let's see. He got a terrible moment. A refrigerator fell on his leg and you redeemed it. But now that you redeemed it, it became complete. You redeemed it because it's only monetary. So you can redeem it and it becomes totally. So what do you do? If this particular animal gave birth to a firstborn, treat it like a give it to the every animal that we sh outside of we give gifts to the if you have to give the gifts. It's a regular because of it. You're allowed to work it. You're allowed to shear its wool. You're allowed to drink its milk. You allow to use its uh its the offspring. It's great. Oh, so what's the famous? We'll just show it one more time. Means I have an animal that I designated as anah. It's right over here. And then I see something much better, much bigger. In my mind, it's bigger and better. I try to transfer the ducha from the small one to the large one. I believe this is the >> and they both become kadesh. Now we have to start off with the no. They both are. Okay. But you have to start off with in our case the animal is not kesh at all. In our case the animal is so nothing. You cannot look at it and say this giant animals instead of this small animal or large animal. Doesn't matter what, right? You can't do it. Why? Because the animal we're dealing with now has a mum before it became. Therefore, it's only if it's you can't use it as an example. And again, I want to be clear means that the animal we're dealing with is the number one. It's the in this case on the screen, it's the small guy. He was the first one, not the second one. Yeah. Doesn't mean you're using it and saying this should be instead of it is already and you're trying to use that as the as the principle we call it the Ken. How do I explain it better? I don't know. In this p picture >> it cannot create very good it can it can't create. Why? Cuz it itself is and if this animal that has a and then you made a kadesh died before before you redeemed it, you should redeem it after it's dead so that you could use it. If it was born of a newborn, firstborn, it has inheriting. If it's micer, it has inheriting. When this animal was 100% good and you made it and then it broke its leg, a m that doesn't go away or he had a simple a broken bone or something, but it get goes back to normal. Afterwards, you got of course you have to redeem it if you want to use it. It's anytime it has a big mo you got to redeem it. But the remains there now you treat it like it has no gifts. You cannot shear its wool. You cannot work it. You're not allowed to drink its milk. You're not allowed to use the offspring. And if you this animal even though you already redeemed it and has a broken leg, you're not allowed to you could make another animal similar to it because it has and since it has you cover you bury it. Check out this nice video before it befalls a we just saw before it has a I'm sorry the beginning of the Mishna when there was a and then you made it is because you redeemed it then you're allowed to use and do all the stuff you didn't redeem then you don't do on But why? It's only monetary value. How does that give you a fork? Because he holds that it's enough to push off. You don't have to do firstborn when it's next. Once again, he had a and then you made a kadesh and then you redeemed it. It goes out to because he redeemed it beer. That's a good listen to this. If I donate my sheep as an for money, not not a sorry [clears throat and cough] money to go for an money for an it's not an I want my money not to go to fix the walls of the I want to go to the mak take my money and purchase an oil [clears throat] have the right to do that. So that's what the gar is saying over here. No, no, no. You didn't understand who earmarked money that should go for. And what's the problem? You saw I even made the mistake by mistake for real. Not I wasn't trying to make I started saying it's money for an it's very close and money to buy an it's two different things. I could take my sheep and say this sheep is anah or I could take my sheep and say sell the sheep and buy an with it. They're confusing. They're almost the same but they're not. One is monetary value. One is when I give the sheep to the that's an when I give a sheep to sell to buy an that's only and people are going to get confused. If he designated it earmarked it for anything of the of the mdash then we're not have an issue. Nobody's going to get confused. If this animal has a terrible break in its leg, it's never going to heal. And then the guy was mocked. So, and then he was so drink. I love what Yoshi did here. I think we could use this in many, many sugas and shas. Check this out. It's beautiful. I don't know if you guys can see what it says on the screen. The first one says, second one says, it just gives you a certain reference here. It has a m. Boom. Broke it leg. He made a turn gold. Nabra became pregnant. >> There's a timeline. There's a time p. He takes money and now the douche the yellow comes off the animal cuz it goes and it goes into the money. You saw she gives birth. [music] Now if we look at the timeline, the question is when exactly was there a pig? If she gave birth like in this case what we just saw the birth was after the what's going on here? What's the It's a regular animal. has no she became pregnant before the sorry let's go back not like in this case over here the the the the purple flag the third flag from the right abra goes after the the pigeon flag if there's after pigeon It's like in this picture right over here. There was a pregnancy flag number three. Flag number four, there was a redemption. They redeemed her. And flag number five is the birth. Pregnant redeeming birth. But so it seems like if that's the case if they were born before you redeemed them and that then the question is these these these babies these animals that were born before aim is there could you redeem it without a broken leg Or you have to wait until they break a leg or something. Why? Why would you have to do that? You only do that when it's when there's you have to wait until there's a broken leg. But if it's not what's the mother said, what da did the mother have only dim. So now you have a situation is asking maybe the baby should be more cuddish than the mother. I have to tell I have to speak to my heart. The we're making it's a very small very small and there are going to be people insulted. they weren't invited and they're people invited and I had to disinvite the wives and they're insulted and I did not most of my cousins my first cousins I'm very close but I did not invite to the hospital that's that's the so if you weren't invited I'm asking we're doing a tremendous large als and it's going to be a beautiful amount of inl and there's going to be information forthcoming soon so I'm asking please respect and I know everybody wants to come and it's hard for me it really is and we're think and there is only for 30 people don't ask the less questions asked the better I'm not I'm not a put it that way my hands are tight if it's not up to me I made for all of them why comments and that but again they they reminded me hey it's not about you it's about And I understand that and the has her and her things I respect that and my son also has thanks for understanding and then just because and there's people I'm looking I can't believe I forgot to invite the guy what happened to me invite this it's situation next we all do if somebody says this this brokenlegged animal but not a broken leg that's never going away reminds So the guy goes like this. [laughter] It doesn't go away. And so he says all this this this animal should be for the so that one day we could bring a carbon with that money. We all do and it gave birth. This is our question rabbis. So the answer is right here. You sell it. You don't need the the the Vlad does not need a M. We asked what's the question that we asked on top of the do you need a not you have to you redeem it with a without it says here why is there no it's like a sort of you can't say that the baby has more than the mother. The mother is only monetary value. Why? Because she's a balas. You tell me that the baby that comes out from her is going to be a larger and heavier than her should be. No way. It's only. So now the just goes on. So the ray we have great. Now what's the you don't need a m this animal just redeem it. But I I'll tell you something else that's super interesting. If you take a who has no listen to this if you take any male sheep let's say you take the sheep that came into the yesterday it didn't look like it has a m and you say I'm being mist this for the whatever only it's money you can't use this for the automatically goofy it without it you don't want it and this goes back to what Abby was saying before. We don't care about what you say. What could happen to what's the top this animal could achieve? It could achieve you could put it on. I don't care that you said it's for the money said this also that if you say this money should be for the upkeep of the I don't listen to you. It's a great animal on it. Why waste it on money? Let's put it on the If you an animal out this kind of animal that first had a and then you made it then you redeemed you section in potter. Oh, why are you We should have had Oh, here we go. That's a bum. Some guy has a misbear private misbear. Wow. There's different times periods in in inrol. Sometimes the bum was mut sometimes. Once it's mder. So when you where is this bama outside mdash if you outside you're not on that but you malus because you put it on the bama that's what you're not the but the malus on putting it on [snorts] if you this is a period of time that the bama's motor and you took the balm And you put it on top of the What are you using for? That's not what you give to the It says, "What's the I think I put it in here. I hoped I did." Yes. Perfect. You now ought to put on a balm and you put a bal on the Bama means the the public. This is a private bum in somebody's backyard. It's also awesome. Ask now very very simple. Repetitive. So let's let's try to push the the metal to the pedal. Yeah, I know what you're saying. Who says talking about carbon? Maybe talking about that has you put on the So you're right. But who says it's talking about it's talking about putting on maybe and then this is the sh because at the end of the day has even though it has it still has maybe put on why fine it can't be that it can't be talking What about the You can make a 10th animal. There's no difference between a good one and a bad one. What's a bad one? Bad one means you should be you should by or you should put it on with why why not? Why don't you say it's talking about a learn from? So what are we talking about? Maybe we're talking about a tomorrow of culture. Maybe that's what the This is the same thing over and over, right? The the offspring of they become through their mother. No, you can't say that. So, we have we should see each other in the of him. Love the secular boy. Oh, good. Merit the of spreading Torah throughout the world. Sponsor a shir today. mdysponsor.com [music] or sponsor atmop.com.