CHAZARAH - Chullin Daf 127 | "Nothing but the Daf" with R' Eli Stefansky

[music] Good morning. We're holding boys [clears throat] right away says over here because you probably asking yourself we just learned of B and B the same hey to the the juices of these yummy delicious saying that the hides are also like their flesh And here we go. >> [clears throat] >> The femur of the sher also isma thing that for instance this egg right over here is not fertilized. This is just from a female not a fertilized egg. A nonfertilized egg is different. Maybe there should be tum [clears throat] what's the fact that there's it's not just the white it has it's going to be it's going to be a chick. It's going to be a bird that that's why it's [clears throat] basically is is developed. So too, the egg has to be developed. It's going to form a real a real maybe even without a hole in it. You have to be able to touch it. It [clears throat] needs to have a small hole. If you can't if you can't get to it, then it's tar. How wide of a hole? As wide as a because if you have a small tiny hole, you could put a here in there and you could touch the tuma and the tum will go out through the hair into your hand and you saw this interesting. We don't know what it is exactly. The Ram doesn't know what it is. Everybody talks about what's going on here. It's only if this mouse [snorts] is on the red side where it has a red arrow. It's completely mouse from head to toe. If it's only half of that up to his hand, let's say, then it's not the the shirts we're talking about. If you were to touch a mouse that's only 25% mouse, 75% dirt, then you wouldn't become it has one full side from it seems like this side from top to bottom right side. Some say this goes on the end. Not that you're touching the red arrow, you're touching the green arrow, you become fine. So it's either on the first part. Let's go back to this picture. Either you're touching where the red arrow is. It has to be the whole the whole side or you're touching on the green side and you become tummy also. So [clears throat] if we say that you touch on the red side it means even on meaning that if you touch on the dirt side you'll also become if you become by touching the dirt on the right side you'll become even if there's only 25% mouse on the left side or half of what you have on the left You don't need the full amount. So, as we're going to see soon, everything in the on land, there's something that rep that's represented in the ocean. >> It's a counter. There's a seahorse. There's a something called a yam. Looks something like this. Looks like a mouse a little bit. Where's the like? I don't know. There's the different here. This one, let's say, doesn't move as fast as a mouse, but okay. It resembles a mouse. It's actually called a sea mouse in English. It's called in in Hebrew. It's the counterpart. So, that is not a sher. How do we know it's not a sher? His name is a mouse. The Pik says together it's in the same P weasel a rat whatever you want to call it. So you say that a tummy and a and a mouse's tummy just like the only grows on land. It's the only animal in the world, maybe the the the fox, but the only animal that we know of that grows only. There's no counterpart in the water. So too, it's only the mouse, the land mouse, and not the sea mouse. That's often you could learn a little differently both here it says in the name it's all the mice of the world even a seam mouse as long it has the name that's why I need a it says take a look at the thing it's going to change we're we're highlighting those words it has to be on land, not a sea creature. What about a mouse that decides to go jump into the ocean and dies over there and then you touch it? Maybe it shouldn't be because it's not on the ground. You only become on the ground. >> Exactly. >> New York sewers. So the next the word right before Allah it's tells us anything that um that's a in other words wherever he's even in the water maybe the word a comes to say something else only something that could reproduce what can't reproduce believe it or not makes a lot of sense this half dirt half mouse can't reproduce why can't it reproduce because it was produced from the dirt. It wasn't born from aa >> spontaneous generation. >> Spontaneous generation. [clears throat] Anything that's created through spontaneous generation whatever that means can't continues whatever it is continues in that part of so maybe I could take this word to say that it's not it's not doesn't reproduce and therefore from this that we have over here. By the way, the top line over here is something that we should remember from those words. You see anywhere that okay similar to what we said before has a name maybe this half mouse is also his name is mouse half mouse but still mouse Mickey Mouse half mouse all the mice or perhaps you could say a different logic maybe has to similar to the which reproduces and and any mouse that reproduces to but not a half a half mouse and that comes to include also a half mouse a half mouse is also so here's go to that word [clears throat] great or another last fine I'll give you that the comes to say that also a half mouse maybe is different different than you learn maybe comes to say that you're no different even a sea mouse no because we were learning that a regular mouse that went into the ocean is tummy now he's learning that A female should become to that's different is different. Even a female should be but it says has to be on the land and not something that that that grows in the sea that that lives in the in the ocean. [clears throat] [cough] So the word [snorts] tell us that if it goes into the ocean should become so tells once we established that there's tuma in the ocean from the word in the top of the first line of that if it jumps into the ocean into the water it's malihal why should a why should a sher that lives on land if it goes into the water shouldn't become Okay. But what does that mean? We know that if there's a is if you're not sure if you touched or not something you walked over a grave you're not sure if the grave was here or there or you walked here or there your tummy because if you have a water let's say you have a little pond in your backyard and there's a floating rat there and you're just swimming and you're not sure if you touched it even if it's very very it's a very small area the word. We already used it to tell me that if you you're not sure if you touched the rat, you're not tell me there's actually three times it says today's also right it says twice. You're right. We're going to learn from one allar for this is and >> yeah it says twice is twice what's it what's it people always confuse it is not a turtle like in Hebrew sav is a toad here this guy why why is he sad and angry I don't know toad because ah because he's a shar not >> he's Yeah, I can't do this. I can't read it the way it says it here. So, he went put his foot on the the hole of drov got bit but there was a water source there. He was able to touch it and Darvad died and he came Darvad died. >> Yeah. The Rashi says there was water over there. So he takes the arvad on his thing and people said oi oi to the person whoad bites or or meets and oi to the the idea that it's not the car it's not the this it's the that kills a person it's theim the is some sort of lizard they the salamandra. So if you were ever in the country when I was a kid, the the we had these kind of salamanders. Those who watch those videos of me in the in the safari, that's the I used I guess I got it from here. that when you the idea of looking at creations and to to see the godless the fact you go into the water and and this these creatures that live in the water they're larger than than land animals there the blue whale is the size of I don't know like umund and something feet long the heart is hard as >> bigger than a school bus >> yeah something crazy but they live over there they're able breathe. You put us in there for a second and it's all over. What happened in Nepal this week? >> The water came and just in seconds everybody gone and is it a we we live here. We think it's normal but take a tuna fish put him over here and he doesn't survive a minute. If you take the the sea creatures, the aquatic creatures, put them on the on the on the on earth, they'll die immediately. If you put us in the ocean, I'm thinking now they they go down with these machines. They built against pressure little tiny uh submarines and they go down thousands of feet and and sometimes they they implode push from the pressure and all of a sudden there's like a little fish swimming around there as if nothing happened. They live only there 3,000 ft below. I don't know. They're crazy. They can live and there are creatures that can live in fire. Looked it up. They couldn't really find anything like that. But as I state there are creatures, there are organisms that can live in extreme heat like even beyond boiling but not in fire. Fire is already like you know thousand degrees. It's already there's a lot of things we don't know and understand. There are there are there are creatures that live in the air. The ones, the ones that live in the fire, if they come out into the regular, they die. And the ones that [cough] live in the air and they go down into the fire, they'll die immediately. You should know continuing with that. Anything we have on earth, we have in the ocean besides the micro. Where do you see it in the call? It's a that's call meaning anybody on earth. We call the earth because that's the only one that only lives on the earth. The beavers that live in stuff. So a guy came over to me after she yesterday and told me a beautiful thing about a beaver. It's true. I remember uh learning about it. The only way to enter the beaver's house is through the water. The entrance to his house. So he builds a dam above water. So he could live above water cuz he really he breathes above water. But the only way to enter it is through the water. So maybe you're saying maybe that's the why the considers him an aquatic creature. He swims a lot and he has the kids are he builds he builds this dam but it's very what's going on here a land creature can't let's a wolf or a fox can't get him because the entrance is through the water a fish can't get him because he lives above the water in the house the only way to get there is if you if you know how to swim you could swim and survive on the water for a while it's a anyway So the gar calls him, listen to this. These are not land animals. These are aquatic creatures. To me, it's a once we're talking about this beaver that comes from we have to put in the whole place. They're fat, their skin, their tail. In other words, their children, their adults, everybody. They're all bad or three times. In other words, it's a great land. Land of America, the best. Oh, but they're they're in big trouble. They're doing terrible stuff. They have the best land, but they're bad. They don't they don't want to listen. If a guy from Norish kisses you, you better go to Nick, check out your teeth cuz he must have taken one of your teeth. That's why he'll kiss you away one of your teeth. If a guy from accompanies you, if he's going to accompany you, he wants your jacket. If a guy from accompanies you, you got to change your room. I once went to this place called and I saw a snake trying to mate with the with the turtle and sure enough we had oh yeah toad. Well, yeah, maybe. Yeah. And then all of a sudden the came between them. They had a they had a child. People are creating these new creatures. They're making mules and who knows what. All sorts of creatures. So, I'm going to I'm going to do the the if when they mate, they mate the same way and they have the same pregnancy, the same length of pregnancy. How could an how could a a snake and a uh a toad have offspring? It's not the same months. It's not the same way. There are actually two here. The fact that the the snake would go with a with a a toad. And second of all, that there's actually a pregnancy. Ask the nar is a very bad thing. It kills people. Hyper. It's not a it's not a nace. It's a piranus. Why? Why do you call it a n is a good thing? Says my pironos. It's designed to destroy and get rid of the rish. That's the nace. I once heard like talking about, oh, here's a liger. It's a real thing. I saw it with my own eyes. It's massive. It's larger than a lion. Larger than a tiger. So, I don't It didn't look like this, but yeah, it does have like stripes, says the I want to ask you a question. If you have here, I'm going to show you. I pretend this is a real tree and you have a dried out fig dry and I yanked this off on chabas. I yank it off on chabas. It's dry. Am I over on chabas? >> No. No, it's attached. This tree is attached to the ground. It's trashing ground. But the the the fig is completely dead. Dead. >> Yes or no? Another [cough and clears throat] question. Let's say a dead sher touches this. Does this become tame? Yes or no? >> Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. >> Why? It's attached to the tree. Attached to the tree. >> So says the we have a very similar thing. It's dancing on two. It's two opposite in the same thing. It's fascinating. You have an animal. Here we go. You have an animal that leg is dangling by a thread. Is it Abraai? Is is it detached that it's Abraai? No. But because it's 99% detached, it could it's susceptible to tum. If a dead sher touches that leg, it becomes tame. And if that leg touches something else, it will make it. But it's not. If you eat it, same. We're going to see with this tree. Where are we holding? >> We have four minutes left. No to an hour. I'm serious. We started late. If Rashik says if we'll see also he had to think that it's food for a but you have to put a bunch of water on it to make it susceptible activated. If you sh the animal so the animal's not in the veil anymore then the blood that comes out of it makes it's not you don't become through it the the this animal dies so this is a concept we spoke about it a lot and I'll remind [clears throat] many of you don't remember this mis I know you know the those who did means that the moment the animal dies retroactively 2 seconds before the piece of it its limb fell off. When it dies 5 seconds before it limb fell off what then it becomes. So since it's not an this piece is not an what is it? The whole animal's a veil dropped dead. But this piece is what's the difference if it's a going to say but it's not. We can view this piece as if then it then it detached all of a sudden it detached the limb is because of because it detached from the animal a moment before it died but it's not we have to understand what he says says we said that if the limb is detached 99% it becomes as food but not as an avail heal itself. How could it become as food when it's a healed a if it doesn't if it's not going to heal then it should be a complete right now it's not going to heal it has to fall since it's hanging by a thread it is not and therefore it's not avail If they're attached by a by a thread, maybe there should be that has to fall completely. And nevertheless, there's a a what's the word I'm looking for in English? A dichotomy. Is that the right word? Dichotomy. that there's like a on the one hand it's not on the other hand it's detached there's a massive contrast there and we see the same contrast by a fig or by fruit on a tree these figs if a a rat a dead rat touches a mouse touches this this becomes but if I pull it off on chabas I'm over is of pulling it off on chabas is it detached are attached. If it's attached, so it's attached. So something a fruit that's attached to the tree cannot become but it does become. So I don't know. Should we stop here? It's like let's finish to where again the same idea with a with a vegetable that shriveled when it's on its stem. You have these guys um some sort of cabbage that completely um dried out. They're not food. It's a a dried out leaf. And if you chopped it off and dried it out makes no sense. If it became dry, he just said it's not says tremendously. They are completely edible right now. But he he cut it off the ground unconditioned to dry it out. So think that is works and is considered dry. No, it's not. These uh the the the the cabbage is not edible. Even though these fruit that are attached to the gr to the tree, they do create tum. What's the case? Like this picture right over like this physical date with the stem. It's all dried out. If it's all dried out, it's completely not attached. meaning that the the stem is still green but the fruit isn't. So you see like what when you have a limb dangling by thread it's like the is green. So on the one hand it's not it's not detached but on the other hand it's like this fig that's says no everything became dried out and you ask me it's oh it's the is not in the the fact that it's dry and it's nothing and that's and we don't need to say it at all but we're what we're trying to say is the other the other thing that what that if the person had in mind to dry it out later that doesn't work right now it's not dry and it Have a wonderful day. Have a wonderful Shabas. >> Merit the of spreading Torah throughout the world. Sponsor Ashir today. mdysponsor.com or [music] sponsor atmop.com.