Preparing video...
0:00 / 0:00
Daf Yomi Bechoros Daf 34 by R' Eli Stefansky
2,492 views
Thanks for learning with us! - Good Morning - MDYsponsor.com - Questions/Intro - 33B - 34A - 34B - Have A Wonderful Day Support the Shiur: MDYsponsor.com Where to Watch & Listen Find us on your favorite platform: https://mdydaf.com/learn#platforms US: 605-562-0066 Israel: 055-DAF-YOMI (055-323-9664) UK: 03-333-661-463 Belgium: 0480-201-272 #DafYomi #EliStefansky #Bechoros #MDY
Chapters
Featuring:Daf Yomi
Categories:Torah/Gemara
Comments
Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
Good morning.
>> Oh. Oh.
Welcome. Welcome. Beautiful breakfast
there.
So upgraded. Very upgraded. Eagle. It's
not
fourth
>> started February 17, 1997
today's
the big
and menda
and maybe Even By I heard Yakov
we have a brand new location number 47
here in number 47 in Yaz.
This following video it's very
interesting. Let me give you a little
background. We were um
sending our some of our clips to this
influencer. He's an influencer here in
has a lot of followers
and uh so we we gave him the clips. We
paid him a little to put on a status.
And uh I forgot how they say in they say
it's you know I peaked and I uh so he he
peaked. He's been doing this for like
almost a year and all of a sudden he
started watching a little clip here, a
little clip there and then he started
taking he decided but he's going to go
come on board.
Two weeks in, two weeks in, he he
decided to make his own video as an
influencer about this year. And I showed
that video. So since then, since then,
he brought, listen to this number, 386
people. 386 people. But yesterday, as I
was debating,
this came in. I remember I cried like a
little kid from this video. You probably
won't, but me, it touched me.
This is the influences.
WhatsApp.
technolog
Rebell. Foreignech.
Fore.
So I I guess look, not everybody is as
talented as him in speaking and editing
and all that, but he brought 386 people.
You could bring six. You can bring two.
You know, everybody get on that. You get
that's the power of the technology
today. It's it's it's incredible what a
person could achieve today in in two
minutes of him speaking into his phone.
Rebelli, remember the free gumar you
sent out 5 years ago to get people to
join him? Well, here it is which I took
off the shelf today as you swear with
the funny part is that I didn't sign up
because I wanted the gumar. I signed up
because it was free. 5 years later, I'm
still keeping up with the daff and our
kabur now 3 years in is going strong. It
has a picture of that original gumar
along with a picture from last night
with my kabur and my rabbi David Bfeld.
I guess that the free market turned out
to be a pretty good investment. Thanks,
Rebelli. Mati wine rib mi harstro New
York sukav bay. Now mi is the one in the
forefront over here with the color
shirt. If you remember he he put
together once on
migilla on the migillas
based on the shar.
>> This is a long time ago. This is like
four or five years ago. She's been with
us for that long. Plus he did like ndy
kids in my you remember that? So this is
from a one free garra that he didn't
want the garra. He wanted something
free.
>> These guys these guys unbelievable. The
guys in Thomas River.
>> There's a reason like the of a place
>> is the guy behind it.
Every night. Every night.
>> I love that. Dan, this is the best part.
Hold on. It's coming up.
A big thank you to Kalamada Cafe for
sponsoring the Melv Mala. Once again,
Tisku Litzvos.
>> Ah, boy. I almost forgot. A huge
maztovix
baby boy. Not him.
The first grandson. That would be a big
boy.
>> Oh, really?
What is this?
>> Hold on. What is this?
knocking my door.
>> Wow.
>> So Lauren, I when I came out of my
building, I saw your card there. I was
like, "Wow, he's back." Maz love to you
also. First grandson,
>> second grandson. No first.
>> Sandic sand.
>> The boys this Tuesday night.
>> One more. One more.
Rafi Goldmire granddaughter.
>> Granddaughter. Yeah. Rafi Goldmire from
my boys are kicking off the new Los
Angeles satellite location. You're not
going to believe this. The three mim we
have three meet in this year. All three
of them are going to be in the same spot
in Los Angeles.
>> And they actually have like a group.
They smoke meat together. They talk
about it. They discuss it all week long.
Who
>> Yitz?
>> New and Hill.
All three of them. All he's going he's
going to be there. He's going to be
there. What are you talking about? Check
it out. Yeah. With the southside. He's
bringing his rabbi. If you want to know
what the brothers was like,
it's kada to fly out to Los Angeles just
to be there to be. It's crazy.
That's what he got out of the whole
thing.
>> That's not bad.
>> All right. The
I have to say this, Deus. I thought
you'll never hear about it, but I can't
control myself. My filter. Yeah. They
interviewed me in the moment.
>> In the Moment newspaper, whatever. They
going to do a magazine.
>> So, I It just came out of my mouth. I
goes, "You think somebody wants to hear
Lat.
I thought it was a great thing, but that
was my muscle that just came up. I threw
it. I figured Mendy's never going to
read the How's it possible, but I didn't
think that I'm my filter is going to
fail like cuz he said it. He said it. He
started off.
>> It was a great speech like and he said
it seven times and it stuck in my head.
Soyard
Nathan Kamyanski
is the sponsor per Ellen artificial in
memory of our parents. Paul W. Rosenberg
and philos
dedicated in memory of
dedicated by Dr. Nick Sabo Sheridan
Dental Services, the Pas Foundation
granted to YKMA BR and all you do for
MDY, otherwise known as
granted to all MDY, otherwise known as
anonymous. Wow, three anonymouses in a
row.
Also known as anonymous in honor of the
MDY family. Anonymous. Here we go.
Another one.
Simon not so anonymous for
I got your message
the Spanish year sponsors for Olga daily
sponsors we wineburgger in honor of
12year-old
who does not miss a day because it's not
about the dav it's about the yo 12 years
old family
should be a for the Bellski family
Mr. Aelski's brother on his yesterday
did not know this
sponsor anonymous
moist in honor of Mati mdy.com/
mi sent me uh a text I'm just going to
put on the screen here in the past 10
days over 800 new profiles created
810 days. That means all the people that
are on site, all the 5,500 people that
were on site previously, they now have
new options. Over 430 couples, matches,
over 125 couples went on dates in the
last 10 days. There are currently 60
couples dating and there's 16 couples
going on dates tonight on a Thursday
night. 16 couples
and
riddle. It's almost impossible to get
this riddle unless you did the daff
yesterday or you did chas. So y eagle,
please don't answer your fourth cycle,
your fourth time around. Iris Simon and
Ruven Schwarz, people who did the daff
yesterday, please try to control. Here's
a galaldica riddle. A person does not
have teras. Tarass is a
an infliction of a discoloration on the
skin and the client comes and says that
you're tummy.
How is it possible when a person does
not have an affliction at all? Zero. You
look at him, he's he's he's clean.
>> But he won't become tar unless he has
another affliction. He has an affliction
of tas. He's waiting. He can't wait
until he has a tass because then when he
has tas he'll become tar. How is it
possible such a thing?
>> It's worth 100,000 points. Such a such a
question.
>> All white
>> when what do you mean all white? But
that then how does it help him? He
doesn't. Right now he's clean and if he
gets
>> No. No.
>> Right. Right now Right now he doesn't
have tarass. He doesn't have tarass. And
he could he if he gets harass he'll
become tar.
It doesn't have any tas now. Zero.
>> No. Zero.
>> So we shall see when we get there. We'll
understand the answer.
>> Right.
>> Right. That's the answer. Very good,
Arie. Very good. If a person cut off his
So right now he doesn't have TAS. So you
won't become until he has another a new
one
>> and it goes
>> because you know that the first one is
>> you haven't dealt with the person
>> right
>> okay
>> very good we had yesterday twoim over
here
the one was
and the other one was
we have a
if an animal has The mum.
What kind of mum are we discussing? So
Rashi says the worst mum possible is
this animal is about to die any minute.
If you don't do blood letting, he's
going to die. It's too much blood,
whatever it is. So that's a mum. And
then you poke a hole to get the blood
out. So now you created a second mum on
a balm. And the question is if you
create a second m on an existing m.
Well, it depends how you learn the if
you learn the
So if he only if he doesn't have a mo
then it's but if he has a m already then
it's not he's not a so he can poke a
hole that's
reor brings the
of
the word tells us that even if you add a
second additional you're
so thear says two lines from the bottom
What? Okay, they say we have that you're
only when it's completely when it's
unblenmished and you poke a hole. But
this animal who's blemished, who's about
to die because there's no blood letting.
So
what do you do with the of it seems like
you're not allowed to add a second
like says no the is coming to say
what have you caused you didn't you
didn't poke the hole but you caused
something else to poke the hole how
that you shouldn't physically take a
punch hole and punch to hole through
this animal's ear.
If you thought there's no video,
I am starving. I can't believe I didn't
pack enough food for the trip.
He's
aar. You can't eat him. He doesn't have
mum. Oh. So, what do you do in order to
have a mom?
>> There we go. A little shmear for the
ear.
>> I'll be right back.
>> Little chocolate.
Your ear. What a shame. Now we can't
bring you as a corbone. So we'll just
have to be pde you and eat you in the
morning.
Good night.
>> Play to you in the morning. Very good.
the technology today. We had this video
like a few months ago. So I told Yoshi,
"We got to fix it. We got to, you know,
the wording, the way he spoke and the
the punchline, fix it." He said, "It's
not good to fix. Let me just do the
whole thing from the whole thing. Every
part is brand new. It's unbelievable."
>> Huh?
>> No. You make it a Yeah. Pidge. Not
pigon.
says
please
we learn from the word
not that you're if you put a second
moment to the animal but means all types
of m you're not a cause don't be the
cause to the m don't put the chocolate
on the ear don't put a on their ear the
picture from our garra is a not simpler.
This is on the air. Put some like a
piece of dough that will have the dog uh
cut it. Okay.
Says we actually have a
very short three lines of names.
What do we have yesterday?
is if there's a barrel of wine that's
truma and you don't know whether or not
it's tummy. You don't know if somebody
whose tummy touched it.
So take a look at this. This is very
simple. We have it throughout.
We did something new today for this.
We have a to protect to be the true we
have to make sure that it doesn't come.
But how do we read it? Look at the word
there's a there's a dot on top of the me
that makes it plural
two. But if you take off the nudas and
you just read it as is
it could be it could be singular. So
that that's the famous concept in shame
or does it go by the way we read it
mikra we
we read it or is it misarious the way we
write it two different things the way we
write it is without nudas it means one
one true you have to watch or is it two
trumas they have to watch so here goes
mikra is the way we we say it the way
the b reads it with the nudus messiah is
without the nudas
Trumai as if there's a VV there that's
ribbar and therefore it means two trumas
one is the regular trum you have to
watch and the other one is the one that
we discussed the suffix suffic you have
to still watch it uncovered cover it
make sure a rat doesn't fall into it you
have or the the messiah is without a
vasi trumi that'su which would mean you
only have to watch and protect one truma
the truma that's val truma Okay, very
simple. The problem is that over here is
on the right. He holds that we go by the
way you read it. In a second, we're
going to show that he holds that you go
by the way you write it, not read. He's
going to be on the left.
So the is going to go away from this. So
that's not the
name again
>> from
>> Baltimore.
Oh, you're part of the there. You get
together once in a while.
>> Part of the remotely.
We need we need
once in a while. Once in a while I know
once in a while.
All right. You you got to get more
people more people involved. If you have
a
guide grow it's a way to grow it.
Everybody could be a trailblazer.
Everybody even in Baltimore even like
this guy got 386 people. You in
Baltimore can get 386 if you put your
mind to it.
>> Spiegelman. You hear this one?
>> Do Spiegelman. There you go. Number one
here. Start start from here. If you ever
need help, let me know. I'll I'll shout
out whatever you need over there.
On the right, he holds that it's a
plural
even one that we have a suffic. And
therefore yesterday we learned he holds
you have to cover uncovered
truma
or you have to protect it. He's on the
leftum
it's singular only one. Which one? The
one the true obviously it's you only
have to protect one truma. Which one are
you protecting? The one they know for
sure that's true. But the one that's you
don't have to protect
you're telling me that goes in with the
way we read it and not the way it's
written.
So now we're talking about
a person sells his daughter. Now you
could read the word so that
the owner could be he could he could
marry her. At what age?
up to 12. In other words, she's really
young. There's the avalan
came to and said, "We have a sh of the
shabas in who should we give the aliyah
the the m to? Should we give it to the
barit boy or should we give it to the
which one comes first?" He says,
"Depends who's older."
We talking about she's 11 years old.
Yeah.
So what is this word? What is avdi? You
can read it like us most Americans would
know what a begg is means uh um a talis
he it's a lotion of marrying her with a
with a begged. Oh we actually it's
pretty it's pretty cool what he did
here. I like it. But you know, bda here,
take a look what is according if the way
you read it. Take a look. He has a begot
over there. It's on the bottom
or
only Israelis who know this word. Not
only butad.
Bagad means
>> to rebel. A traitor.
>> To rebel.
>> Who rebelled? Everybody say, "Who
rebelled?" The father. What business is
this? Selling off a daughter. That's a
That's a rebellion. That's the worst
thing that a person can do really. Yeah.
I always try to f for him. He's trying
to he's he cares about his daughter. He
needs, you know, she's starving. I get
it. At the end of the day, he sold her
off and shipped her off to
to sleep away. Uh whatever. Okay.
Bye-bye. See you. See you later. I'll
come for the bris. So,
so to learn it one way is a beg. And
once once he he uh marries her, so to
speak, then the father doesn't have a
right to sell her. You can't sell her
after she was married.
All
>> even if she got divorced,
>> right? Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Of course. She
gets divor. He's told her she gets
married to the owner, divorced. You
can't sell her again. I know she's 11
years old and you want to make another
deal here. It doesn't work anymore.
That's it. One time. But all of a
sudden, he's on the left side. He goes
with he says it's not. It's the way it's
written. It means the rebellion that
what? Once you sell, you can't sell
again. Not once you get married, you
can't sell again. There's no selling
after selling.
Once he sells her, that's it. You're out
of the picture. There's a rashy here.
Let me see. Did I finish showing over
here? Yeah, he sold her. Sold. You get
the money. Okay. You can't sell her
again. Just a
there's no
you don't sell after you sell.
But after after marrying you could okay
fine I go upon him. What's the point
there? The point is that you see holds
it's not he's on the left not on the
right. He goes by the way you read it.
You write it not you read it. And we
said he goes by the way you write it.
when it comes to
plural says
just to go back to the here's the on the
screen
I gave to you
have to protect and watch you what I
gave to you what did I give to you a
true nobody could eat why why can no one
eat it because it's suffic tummy. A rat
might have touched it. So the kite can't
eat it. You can't eat it. So it's not.
It's for the garbage. Burn it.
>> You don't have you don't have to watch
such a thing.
What's
because at the end of the day
I always
going to come today. So I have to
believe he's coming. He's going to tell
me what the hell what's what's the
what's the status of this truma? Is it
Tommy or not?
This is good. I didn't This is something
symbol I didn't do in the Hebrew.
But here's the Mishna that tells us in
the
you have an animal that's dying. It
needs a blood letting. The doctor says
you got to let the blood, but you're
going to poke a hole. Says
and what's we said in the what's anybody
remember?
always says that if you don't have
intent to damage, your intent was the
intent to save. He's a paramedic. He
comes in with the with the needle p
saves the life. Oh, but there's a
outcome. There's a hole in there. Okay.
But that's not that wasn't his intent.
That's what saying the
bottom lines
says not only are you permitted to to to
poke the hole in the ear but then you
say you know what by mistake he has a so
I'm going to now have steak that's
another so so he says over here which
one what did he mean that is scaven or
that I'm allowed to eat this animal
based on the hole I poked in in his in
his ear because I try to save its life.
Two different
one is the header to eat it and one is
the to do it.
Which one are you talking about?
There's no in that we know throughout
says
And argues with the rabbi says so we
already know throughout that holds so
what are you telling me that
and it just continues this is the same
exact thing just it's not with
it's directly saying it
bottom line is we know
or not so what are you telling me oh
Hello
coming to say is we pass it that if
shows up for blood letting and they
don't have a mind to to make a hole or
even that the the owner himself the
owner himself yeah maybe in the back of
his mind subconsciously he realizes that
he's going to be able to eat steak soon
but lice is coming to save this animal
so he pokes a hole in his ear he creates
a mum the next day he could check this
animal that's he could check the animal
need it.
and he says
he sticks in the word not the but the
bottom thing the give me that
>> I don't I don't know you know that I'm
confused now cuz he said in the back you
don't you're not he confused me
>> the m you get to eat it not right there
but I don't remember the word p I don't
remember pa in the video they had a I
don't know. So I don't I don't want to
argue on Yoshi in the video,
>> right? But that's that's a regular car.
Maybe slightly I don't know. I don't
know. Right now I'm I'm drawing a blank.
We probably learned it yesterday. I
don't remember.
>> So you're saying that it's not?
>> No, the the the video.
>> Yeah.
>> And Bryson that we learned in the
beginning. Oh, the video is absolutely
not a
>> Uhhuh. Maybe the video is not a but I
hear I hear. Okay. So, you don't have to
the You don't have to. Okay.
>> Okay. This is our picture of a of a
person creating a m on purpose in the
ear. He he figures nobody's watching. So
cut his ear. He cuts his ear. He's he's
permitted to
to eat to to this animal.
We punish him. We punish him that
forever and ever. It's a forever even.
Oh, what does it mean forever? Yeah, of
course not. No. Even if he develops a
real mis his his leg gets chopped off
and he has a real m can't eat him.
>> Can't eat him.
>> You have to starve him. No.
>> No. No, no, that's the starving is only
in me. This one you can't take care of
it. Here took a video.
This brought up a lot of I mean in the
Hebrew she
>> the was very emotional very emotional
people like I was looking around and
after he says such a um mira
because of this video and the next one
there's a follow-up to this video too. I
hope to
>> open your kamashim.
>> Where's your
>> I I I forgot it.
>> Oh, you forgot.
>> NOW YOU'LL REMEMBER TO BRING IT NEXT
TIME.
>> Please take care of him, Rebby. He's my
bor.
>> Don't worry. Don't worry. I'll take very
good care of him. We used to call it
that little thing that every has one of
those. I don't know why.
>> That's also a classic.
>> I'm stepping out for a few minutes.
Salt.
>> Salt.
over here means
come here. Come, come. Don't be afraid.
>> So you'll remember.
>> Ow ow ow ow.
>> So sellers.
No, now you're a balm.
>> But Reb Ellie said if you tear a bor's
ear, you can never shuck it. Never.
>> All right. If you want to know what
happened, let me just show you this. Uh
>> okay.
All right.
I I forgot when to show the next part.
This is part two. It's coming up.
Okay, we can we're not going to allow
you to with this M that you just created
with your own hands. But if there's
another M that developed on he sent him
to Kev Land and over there he developed
the M You're allowed to chef because of
that
says that he's that you can never eat
this animal because he did a deliberate
we have something similar
this
he had an infliction of teras on his on
his skin looks let's say something
like This just a white a white a white
thing. We're going to talk about a gris
in a second.
If by mistake you were I don't know what
a knife came and chopped it off by
mistake.
Your was by mistake
but he chopped it off on purpose.
If he'll develop another
then he'll become tired from the first
one.
So if you now read it yourself
when he'll develop another
become from the first one at what point
does it become from the first one? The
moment he gets a second one or after he
goes through the process of the of the
second one
>> these
>> you're right. It's a good qu your
question
is the the exact words in the garra but
it's a good question.
>> How would you become
>> it says over here?
He becomes immediately from it. That's
how I can read it.
Let's just do the sponsors for a second
global experts in international
financial services.
Thank you. Rebelli Steven Schwarz was my
parents million J Schwarz. I I do want
to show you this meant a lot to me
personally.
This is a new satellite location in Alon
Habashan. I noticed it this morning
actually in the in the Tyra Alone. I
think that the word was brought down in
so here they are sitting into that
community and uh I take a lot of a lot
of a lot of from it. What?
>> The point of is
>> it's the northeest point of Israel. Very
very north. Yeah.
>> Huh?
>> That's it.
>> Oh yeah. This is equal to me as 500
people like each has a special
Israel. So
says the
you can get out of this if you develop a
tarass on your entire body which
basically means it cannot never happen.
But if it does, then that little teras
that you chopped off is included in your
whole body. And and because it's in your
whole body anyway, your your
boy say pay attention over here because
it's tricky. Not tricky like wow hard,
but it doesn't read in the words.
So that was the picture I showed you.
Here's a gris. Let's say some sort of
lentil. When it becomes less than the
lentil, then becomes when when did it
become? When you read the garra, it
seems like later on it becomes less than
a lentil. But guess what? You chopped it
off. What do you mean it becomes less
than a lentil? It's in the garbage can.
Before you cut it off, before you cut it
off,
>> it got small. But before if it got that
small, it's not even. So the point is
you're almost never out of this problem
according to so is going to point out
over here hold basically that you get a
forever where before it's in the Mishna
by when you chop a ear off it's says you
can't use this animal forever say don't
worry about it when you get another you
could and over here they're the ones
that are super m they're the ones that
say oh no only if you get a develop a
tass in the whole body or if when you
cut it off it wasn't even this year
which is not important says
not it's not oh so we have a
contradiction here again what's the
contradiction our mission says that we
punish this guy forever and ever you try
to circumvent the the the
or the you cut the gu the this animal's
ear and pretended that he has a m and
then you want to shed we caught you
you're never going to eat this animal
and over here says, "Not a problem. You
try to circumvent the Tyra. You chopped
off your own your own uh tarass." Wait,
if in two months from now you get
another tarass, you're good to go. No,
but says punish him forever. And all of
a sudden, you don't punish him forever.
Says answer,
it's not a contradiction.
They gave you a can when it has to do
with the monetary stuff like not on your
own body. What's the difference?
Think about it. I need to punish him
because he's he's very smart. He's going
to chop. He's going to cut the animal's
ear. He has nothing to lose.
If they don't catch me, I get to eat it
today. If they do catch me, I didn't
lose anything. I'll just wait for it to
develop a m which I was waiting anyway.
I lost patience. He's I'm going to send
him to Kev Land tomorrow. He's going to
develop a m whatever. He's going to I'm
I'm going to wait. If not, I'll just
chop his ear now. So, either I'll eat
him now or I'll eat him tomorrow when he
gets a but I have zero to lose.
>> But on it's a win-win. It's a shak win.
But on your own behind
life with no bars.
>> So he's very worried. It doesn't pay for
him to do it. Doesn't pay then. Then we
don't have to make any over here.
>> By the way, now we're gumar is like I
wasn't read the lion over there. I just
I whatever. Wasn't so happy with that
one.
I'm just saying this for, you know, for
our goods. Oh,
he might do it. He might try because he
has nothing to lose.
Why would he do it? He might lose. He
might be a mur for the rest of his life.
You ask me a contradiction. Our mission
says that you punish him forever. And
over here it says that you don't say and
what about over here? pointed it out
which is not 100% clear but over here it
seems like we're going to punish him
forever. Oh, wait until you get a tarass
in your whole body. No new when is that
going to happen. In other words, they're
more mach and in our Mishna by the said
if you if you cut a hole in his ear
you could get out of it. You just wait
until he develops a moment you get out
of it easy. So says
we just explained that there's
difference between monetary
and your own body. Your own body you
might be stuck with your harass forever
and
he he'll develop another easy and he has
nothing to lose.
So that's not a but what about
we punish him in what he did. In other
words,
he tried to get out of it by by cutting
his ear.
>> In my mind, I have this picture, I don't
know why, of like a belt, you know, the
belt hole maker.
>> You know what I'm talking about? Boom.
>> Huh?
>> A leather puncher.
>> A leather puncher. Yeah, that's what I
have in my mind. The guy has a leather
punch. He goes to to his animals there.
I mean, that's probably what the farmers
have today. punch a hole and they put a
a plastic uh tab tag and show you that's
a mum. That's a mas has a special
leather puncher.
So he tried he punched a hole in in the
ear with that m he wanted to eat this
carbon.
So he said okay you cannot eat because
you have this mum
and I'm not going to allow you to use
this mum forever. Okay if he develops
another mum you could eat. Oh, but what
about a person? Also, the same thing.
We're going to punish you with this mum,
but here's the thing. The mum is gone.
You took the tarass off. Where is it? I
don't know. It's gone. It's in the
garbage. Now, we're going to pretend
it's here. So, now he's stuck forever.
This mum is is back and it has to be t
but you can't make it dark cuz you don't
see it. So, that's it. He's a for the
rest of his life.
You try to use this cutting off the the
teras and get out by it.
Let's just show I don't I forgot where
to show the second part part two of the
emotional video
over here means I don't know what he's
eating over there.
>> Dear Reb Ally, you saved my life.
We're going with the same logic as
before.
>> I got up from Shiva for my father today
and now I'm your Reba.
>> Rebby, do you teach like your father or
like Reb Elli?
>> Like Reb Elli. First the den, then the
demonstration.
The father was fined, but the son not
fined. And now the demonstration.
That's the next guy. I messed up.
>> No. Kindle luck.
Dear Rebelli,
you saved my life.
All right. So, we'll have to get to that
sug.
So I pointed this question out before
and the did not have in the Hebrew we
had both sides going very very over here
we only had one side
what what does it say all the way in the
top of the it's when there's a there's a
one m there's one uh one saras and you
cut it off you wait until the second
saras develops and it says
he becomes tred from it does it mean on
the spot
or do you wait a week you have to go
through the process
And the gar actually ends up with a
believe it or not it's a
doesn't mean that you have to wait until
the second one is completely tamino
and that's what Lauren asked
at the end of the day you have to wait
for something to become anyway the
second so you taught me in this position
you taugh no there's a
there's that But if a developed aas
during his
we give him the free we don't even deal
with him go go to the rabbi after same
thing on yont wait until after is over
then you go what happened over here our
case sees a harass
pictures
you got a chop chop chop with a big a
white blemish takes a razor cuts it off
then He develops a second one
during.
So if you say he has a freebie, he has
to wait until then. So it depends if he
becomes t immediately when you see a
second one. So you start the whole he's
t cuz the second one came and you don't
have to be m the second one. He becomes
tired from the first one that he removed
and everything is good. But if you have
to wait until you do the whole process.
So now he's going to have to wait until
after go to the rv do all but until he
goes to the r and everything is tummy.
No, no, no.
>> You have a You have a That's harassed.
Time out. That's harass. He chopped it
off. He's Tommy. He's Tommy before he
chopped it off. He's Tommy. He cut it
off for pictures. He's still
is that if he gets a second Saras, he
becomes Tar when So if he gets the Saras
on day one of the second one, and we say
that he becomes Tar immediately. So he's
tar during.
But if you have to wait until the end of
the process,
>> so now he's not even you can't even look
at him. You can't even do anything. He
has to
>> from the first one.
>> So he's coming from the first one.
>> You can't say that because the second
one wasn't declared yet.
>> That's
>> that's the whole point.
>> That's the whole point.
>> Call it You can't call it a second one.
It isn't. It isn't until it is.
>> I hear. But it is.
>> But you're saying you need you say you
need a coin to declare it. I hear I
hear.
>> Imming cautious today.
Even if you see the neg on on a garment,
nothing
also you find it on his foot. I'm just
joking.
You find it on
you give it all
the
says that he becomes
right away.
You can't you don't do anything with the
second one. So Lauren is asking, but
it's not a real one until you go to
here.
What does he all say? Hold on. If you're
right over here, then you have to come
every day. You can't. There's no You're
stuck.
If the is that you wait for the second
one,
okay? So you don't declare it. You don't
you don't do anything. But he still
taught me from the first one my
but he's asking how do you become t on
the first one from the second one the
second one is not a second one until you
go to you don't go to because brothers
take there must be a good answer if you
did he'll tell you in a second
very simple question this is what we saw
in the video if this is what happened
that that's the video the rebi The first
one, the father
caused a deliberate m in a bkar and then
he died. Does the son get punished? Does
the punishment continue to the son? Now
the brings two cases where he
answers.
>> He does. He asked the question. What
does he say?
>> Mhm.
>> Okay. Basically what I was saying to him
>> sir because he's a so even though he
didn't declare it it becomes a thing you
hear Lauren
>> since he's and even though they didn't
declare it we we let him we use that as
a thing okay I hear it's a good the is
better than the answer probably
okay so
the father deliberately caused the
injury to thear eat it and then he dies
at the saying you see he deserve to die
cuz he poked the hole thing I'm telling
you. So now could the son eat it?
We have something similar. We have two
cases. We could go either way to the
right and to the left. If you if a if a
father sells a non-Jewish slave eani
which actually is mitzvah and that's the
whole problem here. He sells his his
slave to a non-Jew which would not allow
the slave to keep mitzvah anymore. So we
punish him that he has to pay tremendous
amount of money to get the the slave
out.
We do punish the son too.
Every single day is not keeping mitzvah
and it's not good for the father. So we
make the son get get rid of take him
out. But on the other hand,
right, we always speak about this that
until I gave I used to think that is a
great time to go on trips and you know
basically you just wait for y to come.
You have yont you have the two days of y
in America or in you have the two days
at the end it's a but in between it's uh
like a break you just this is when you
go on trips to to we used to go to the
amusement parks and everything. My
father obviously used to stay at home
and learn and it was it was just a great
time to everybody has to go on trips and
the fact is no it's yont if you don't
wear yontiff clothing it's a big rashish
talks you know thing it's yont just it's
a lighter we allow you to do some
so you cannot go shopping
is because there's a there's a sale
I'm just saying this is what people say
in the hotel wow the bus loads of going
shopping we're going to look for a
double oven of it. Great. You know what
I'm saying? His mom is like that.
>> So
>> once in a lifetime sale.
>> Yeah.
>> So
this guy, what what do he do today?
>> What did he do? He he has a vineyard. He
has a vineyard. And he thinks himself,
why should I waste my I have to build a
suka and buy a nest and everything. I'm
going to do the whole everything I have
to do on I have free free days. I'm not
I'm not going to work. I might as well
that's but when is this or when he
actually cuts his stuff then then he
says if I don't do it now it's going
it's going to go into the garbage. I got
to do and then he dies before he had a
chance. Why? Because Hashem struck him
down because he deserves to die because
he thought of this thing.
And this is
over there. We don't give the son a
punishment. Why?
The father never did. He never he wanted
to. He thought about being
but he didn't.
But what about by us in our case
the the maybe we give to the father the
rebi the old rebi but he's gone. So you
don't do it to the to the son.
Hold on.
Maybe they put the on the animal and the
animals still alive. We learned that
you have a field that you cleared it out
from the thorns.
It's not such a big a to clear the
thorn. is not a big you could you could
uh plow it and and uh see use it on on
maza
but if you did you fertilized it nidyro
here we have a great video almost a
great video nidra means that you take
these animals and you fertilize the
field with animals here you just put
them in a pen and you constantly move
the the you pull it with a tractor
wherever they do it here he's showing
you the all the fertilization that they
do I didn't realize he talks about flies
developing. I guess there's a whole
process with the flies go to the manure
and that actually activates it
there. He's moving it with the just keep
on fertilizing. That's in the diary.
Now that's already a big job that you
did there. That's already helping out
the field. You're not allowed to use it.
What if the guy did all this work and
then he dies?
You don't punish the son.
We don't punish the son. We could
actually do we have we have a minute.
Let's just do this until the mission. So
we start with Mishna.
Very simple.
So we had this video. I hope I could do
it within here. It's just A FEW SECONDS.
WHAT IF you take and you very special?
>> He's going crazy because he's making a
lot of noise. take a dead sheriff puts
it in the water. Now the water becomes
and she uh 150 lb
and she ruins the fruit. She bakes to on
the fruit but the thing is it's not
visible to is not visible. So
you don't punish her children because of
what she did. Why?
Because it's not discernible. You can't
see it. It's not considered
gave you a day. That goes to the person
that did it. Comes it doesn't go to the
kids.
Have a wonderful day.
Merit disclose of spreading Torah
throughout the world. Sponsor Ashir
today. mdysponsor.com or sponsor at
mdy.com.