Daf Yomi Menachos Daf 25 by R' Eli Stefansky

Good morning, rap boys. Don't look the other way. Don't look the other way. >> No, this there's not saying it and it's looking the the opposite direction. It's a [laughter] like >> like a I do. We're only going to do this for rebels and he's the only one going to answer. You ready? >> Good morning. >> There's another. Okay. From our grandson, listen to this gun. You're going to love this one. >> Good morning. >> This what you can [laughter] say. Good morning. Say ah. >> The first words the kid said. Ah, Sam Schulster. I've never ever been so excited to fly. Thanks to Mo Landi, I now push myself to see how many daff of Khazar can finish on a flight. The best part is knowing my brother Yehuda on a separate trip is also daffing in the sky with Rebelli. Y Valde. Dear Rebelli, kudos to the team, the Kyle, the artist, and you for the fabulous diagrams of yesterday's daff. I don't know how this could have been understood with words alone. The blue island, the comb, the tuma going up the stream of oil. All of it. They really enhanced my understanding of the d and I'm sure for others as well. I'm joining much more than I thought I would. Thank you, Lauren Spiegelman. Rabbi Zachim, good afternoon rebell. A few years ago, my 10th grade class and I decided to join him. The wife is a transformational experience. So upon finishing each parag we'd make a small and be upon finishing Nazer a number of us continued for as well or in Shaon and Sha actually continued to together by the time passed and d a few weeks ago was preparing to go on a winter break for 10 days driving into the yeshiv a few days before the break I heard your interview with Jacob Langanger civily striking this guy's 50,000 people in the shir we had to get back in at the shakers on a whim I told the holy yeshiva that if we had at least These 10 people doing the dive every day would go someplace like Oklahoma. Wow. 14 boys joined. Imagine if you would have said like Florida. [laughter] Every day the boys have to confirm that they learned the DA with MDY and send in voice notes summarizing at least one thing they learned that day in the DA. Often it's an off-topic schmoo. Today we went out to eat to ourel. I'm just thinking the off topic. Ellie said Tanakman like this and like that. We are 11 boys and going strong in the attached video are Ellie Lax Shats mayor Saburov Mayor Weiss David Wellman Yinon Mala Ami Misrai Yav King eron Seam I'm not sure I don't have the video couldn't download it. Maybe uh the editor will throw it in. Not sure how we'll get to Oklahoma but we will definitely make it happen. Thank you for the and inspiration. Always grateful. Moa Zakim Arlo Yeshiva High School, Brooklyn's warmest yeshiva. >> PS our 12th grade plans to come to this week. >> Oh, and hopes to come to the Listen, if they got them to get them to Oklahoma if we can only figure out how to get there. >> His father was [clears throat] his father. [snorts] >> The famous 32. >> Yeah. >> One of the founders of Flappers. >> One minute. Who's a very good friend? Oh my middle. No, isn't he wasn't >> a Greyber first and personal I must thank you many members of our Toronto of yours who find Gishmak and clarity with your I want to share with you an amazing story that I can't stop thinking about. Several weeks ago I traveled to Pico Roberts area of LA for Simhan Shabs met a wonderful local family. The fellow mentioned his dreams as a high school student going to developing and learning which he paralded with his abysmal experience there and how he put away those dreams after the year. I really used to dislike learning was a statement we picked up on the line. I used to dislike learning and asked what what did what did that change? What changed? He said I used to dislike learning now I love it. What brought about the change was a couple years ago someone told me about fans. I tried it and loved it and I'm in I love learning. rebell tears welled up in his eyes and then he said my father's about chuva never learned kimarra I told him to try it out and now he's hooked now we call each other every day to discuss the d as he said this tears were streaming down his face he proceeded to tell how his whole life as a has changed rebellion towards the of every individual everyone just needs to find their way to connect and understand should continue to grant you the ability to teach and uplift not just your not just your doesn't tell me then but the thousands more are waiting to connect with Talo aka Graber Toronto it's a nice one >> what do you just think it's it's a collection of >> not doing anything else he's going to do email >> this one is is a controversial one I always like controversy my guide you inspired me and my friend to start the weird sites with our parents were certainly happy about that but we we have a rebi and Shiva who asked us on what basis we wear it we and and if we have permission from that's all good. He claims that it's considered a change of clothing and just as they didn't change clothing mim then so it is today that line I don't believe it's impossible that said something like that why because the question is not the question is if this is the real if it's the real and it's a it's a in the so doesn't go in the so the question is is it in the it's not in the or if it is in Tyra, does it apply today? Okay, so I'm just going to say this. At the end of the day, I don't sit and try to convince Bakram to to wearas. That's not my job. The fact that I wear again, I gave a speech in the shred over here. And after the speech, people came over and said, "You were very convincing to to the side that you should wear, how come you don't wear it?" I said, "Okay, I'll wear it." Now, I live in a neighborhood where it's not the most acceptable thing. Most people don't wear And to wear it is not ga it's you get bases for wearing. Most people but I'm the type of person if I feel that I have to do something so I'll get I'll take the bases. There are a lot of people that even if they know 100% it's the right thing to do they won't do it because they're they have a certain that to fit into a certain society. I'm not that type of person. But I'm not going to sit here and try but to to say I don't believe the Rebi said it's impossible that I never ever heard that Tina. I went through the hundred times. Nobody ever said that you're against the in the that you say every day in they have to wear that's not the question is this the real now the reason why I wear it also is because as far as I know you have nothing to lose if it's not if it's fake if the guy tricked us nothing lose okay I the briskar did a whole thing about the he doesn't mention that that fine of course you have an excuse I thought I'd ask you maybe have an answer also Joseph Reich. Oh, he says it's not we explained to him that the rebell spoke about it and he said that even if it's not a mitzvah, it's not an a. And as is we follow in his footsteps, we're actually going in a week and a week. It's two weeks the of we're going to be doing in the factory and hopefully we have some more answers. Once again, there's a guy here that used to give out free to everybody. It's also very expensive. So that's another reason why they say, and you'll be surprised. There's more people that wear than you aware of. They wear it inside. And mark my word, in 10 years from now, things will be very different. >> MDY coffee corner. Yes. Listen, I'm not here to say this 100%. on this on the sad if you believe in archaeology and they found millions and millions of these uh shells and it's it's pretty obvious that this they used to use this shell this type of thing for dying back in the day now there's a big problem because the regime came out with it and that that that was found to be a mistake so y'all that's Corner official edition MDY shots sponsored by the Iranian and leaving families. The peronymous bas sponsors Elanichi was my grandfather January 25th 2000. Listen to this one. Elanidovich Davidi Lelish my grandmother that was Lilian's grandfather on this is his grandmother who onvat in 2008 I don't know if it's the same if they were a couple or maybe from different with gratitude to the New Jersey state police Jewish troopers association daily sponsors Joel Misrai Mazov engagement of Suli Pariser to Shifra forash and In honor of Indy White Sadikim Meyer, Mayor Swimmer in honor of Penny and Lozi Lozi for making sure everyone and Jackson 21 finishes the daff daily. Jackson 21 what? >> They wore a couple. >> They wore a couple and they were both and they were nif on the same day. Incredible. >> Wow. Jacob, it really I mean it's kind of I hate to say this, but it's kind of convenient. You only go to the basic forest once a year. You get have to get a million together once a year. It's very nice of them >> Jakob in memory of Natima Bat. Now if they buried them in different basic forests that would be a problem [laughter] they have to like fly from troll back to New York. It's like in memory of Natima Bachel and Lulu 17th of the sponsor David Solomon dedicated memory I'm doing this once a week David Salom dedicated memory of Could you ask Markaz if you could put in the the monthly the turning of the D sponsors? I didn't see it in here. He might have Oh. Thank you sponsor Jackie family. We are so proud of you. Sponsored by Send Gross and Family Cam Ireland UK in honor of Rebell who changed my meaning of life. Plenty and old Simon monthly sponsors Jimmy Aula Miriam Landy anonymous in memory of mazal and multi that's good and open and revealed way forbud as for everyone in need of aid. Anonymous for the merit of success and blessing in all areas of life anonymous for the merit of helping with pop anywhere worldwide and art for the I haven't seen in a while. I think I messed up. Uh, somebody wrote an email to me and I I wrote it down a number of times that I didn't mention the big sponsors of the event at the Shabbaton. Does that make sense? >> I don't I I know that I put it in my speech, but maybe I just shifted. I messed up. I mean, how the whole this thing [laughter] >> that I don't know. Wow, that would be a big Okay, Omar, we're holding smack in the middle of the base. [clears throat] Here we go. We have the the one made out of one is a flower that was divided in two. and one of them got lost. So instead of the one, let's say the one on the right got lost. So you went and you put another half of your son in there. What happens every single time when you do something like that, you find the one that gets lost. Right after you mish the other one, you find it. I don't know. uh when the three of us were in Italy and there was a a very of a couple from nebra I don't even remember the story so I just remember that it was it's traumatic for us we we went somewhere we went on a boat no we went >> the first day >> the first day we're on a bus with a bunch of from people and there was a elderly couple from Benra and the woman said she wants to go on the boat she doesn't want to go on the boat I remember exactly the whole thing and her husband said I do said they split up but when we got back. We couldn't find the wife and she we found out later that she she wasn't aware of a lot of stuff that was going on and we had to look for her for how long? >> A very long over an hour. We walked in all directions. We split up and finally think I found her in the police station or something. >> The whole bus was waiting for us. >> The whole the whole bus was uh waiting went to police station spoke to some people and kids are they had her in a police station. It's very very sad. Misa no bamis. It's like a lost person for over a yid in a [snorts] a random Italian city >> and she didn't speak any English only Hebrew and they're talk she's trying to communicate with the police and they have no idea what the she they're telling you what's your name who are you nothing garish standing in a >> why did you just remember that >> cuz got lost >> what do you mean it's a clear connection you talking >> this is one of the clearest you're going to [laughter] You found the third person instead. Now we keep >> listen of the story. She did grab on to you and she started walking with you. So we have a picture like and this is part of it like the this new this new this new person the how do we view the third person the third. So oh oh oh oh oh oh oh oh oh oh oh oh oh oh oh oh oh oh oh oh oh oh oh oh oh oh oh oh oh oh oh oh oh oh oh. So now we're here. Now I do want to say this. Remember yesterday we said that if a tulian touches one piece touches this what happens it automatically goes to the other why because they the two are connected because they're from the same so the cle is able to be mire of them and connect them but what happens if we bring in the third piece from another place it's not mama others yeah even though it's the same and the cleans It's not. Why? Cuz that guy, the third guy is separate from the other two. It's not the same. It's not from the same. So if we know that, then what happens over here? Now we have three pieces. >> That's not why I mean we said also if you bring in if you bring in one piece of the two that's tame [snorts] into the >> That's what that's what I showed. Hello. Hello. Right over here at the same time. >> You you bring in this >> right cuz it was at the same time. >> No. No. No. That's something else. That's something else. >> That's a different thing. >> That's a different thing. I'm just saying I'm just saying I'm I'm saying what is the hello what is the something that belongs to you something that doesn't belong it's not that idea if they were both in the bowl and not and touches one the second one becomes only provided that it's connected to him they're married to each other they're from the same but if you introduce another wife another piece piece from somewhere else. They're not connected. There's no connection. Or maybe sometimes one is connected to the other. And that's our suga. It's a it's a quick sug. He's the original piece. You have the guy that got lost, the guy on the left, he's a he got lost, but he's connected to the first one. And then you have the mu, he's the new guy. The guy all the way on the on the right is the new guy. So let's see. If a dead mouse, this mouse is very dead, touches the [clears throat] lost one. Who's connected to the lost one? voice and out of the three who's connected to the what? >> The rich one. The first one. So only the first one becomes tame because the bowl is only what is connected to it. The mush is not t. Oops. What just happened? Oh, he threw it in there. I got it. Now if the mush becomes tame, who is the mush connected to? >> Rish only the rish. He's not connected to the lost guy. So once again, now what happens if the rish gets tame? Both of them are connected to him. But the problem is you you can't eat any of them. Why? >> Because he he can only be connected to one. He can't be connected to two. So let's see inside. And you found the first one. All three of them are inside the same bowl. If the lost guy got so he is he has a connection to the first to the first and therefore the first one becomes a but the the other guy that you that you brought in afterwards he's not part of them. But what if the new guy became The one that never was lost, the one with the white beard, the original. He's a partner with the one that got lost. Hey, he's not a partner over here. But what if the They're both connect. They're both They're both forget what I said before. They're both says this applies in all three cases. In other words, if the lost piece got then look what happens the become why they're all part of the same house. They all belong to the same family. It's not like the case that we had yesterday where you bring a third piece from outside. It belongs to another over here. They all belong to the same. The reason why you made a mu the reason why you brought in another half was to complete the reish. So he's part of the also the is certainly part of the he's the original. So they're all part of the same house and they're all says the same idea would apply with if you have three three parts one of them got you started out with two parts one got lost. It's the same half got lost but picked the h sorry take a look what happened there you did a now from that part you took a little bit of flour out of him so the leftover of the again who's the who's the lost guy's partner the first guy so he's able to do the the for him but the and the new guy have no connection so therefore Or you cannot eat from the mush. If these two are are partners, great. Now if we take from the mush guy, [clears throat] you have to wait like 3 seconds. Now you'll see his head. Okay? You see it has flour. So now the muh and the are partners and therefore you can eat from those two and the last one is not included. Here's the what I've said before from the first one because now they have a connection and now we don't know where the belongs to since he since he's the first guy the guy with the white beard is connected to both the muh and the so it is a good kamita but the problem is we don't know where the kamita goes to we don't go it goes to the more it goes to the to the to the so therefore you can't eat them says it doesn't matter if you did a from any of the three you can't eat any of them because they're all connected to each other they're I view it almost like sarus like a husband married to two wives you know like they're they're all connected to that husband that reish guy [clears throat] No, I think if it's possible, I don't think so. Why would you do that? What are you gaining? >> The actual correct we don't >> here. Look, let's see. Let's go on because this there's a big problem with this kamita. It seems like it seems like that the that when you take a from one at least that one that you took the from you put it on the back and you could eat it. You could eat the rest of the it would seem like the there's a sixth of the that cannot be put on the in other words a third. Let's let's view it as a third. If you think about it as a third, I just brought this for I don't know if he's going to help. Somebody gave this to me at the Shabbaton and I was scared to. Let's say you have three pieces. It's not a good idea, but you know, it's not coming apart. It's like it's called sensory sand or something. Anybody have sensory issues here? >> Here. So, now I'm going to do kamita. I do kamita with this. >> This is my kit. Right. So, a third goes for this guy. We'll put it over here. A third for this guy and a third for this guy. Now, one of these guys is is no good. One of these guys, let's say this guy is uh is the new guy that you put in. So, this third, when I did a kamitza, a third of my kam was for him. Third was for him, third is for him. It's really a third. You want to cut it in half and and and give another six to each one. So, call it a sixth. The point is it's a third. this third of my kima which belongs half to him and half to him calls it a six for a second but we could call it a third just to understand it it's really a third a third belongs to this guy this guy right over here is no good and when you put this part on the misbak it's a it's not a good kamita now you have a a half you have a a third missing from this is your kamita now this third over here is is terrible. It really belongs to a no good guy. And now the same question. How in the world do you put this on the when onethird belongs to to something that doesn't that's not supposed to be on the calls it a third not a sixashm says different question yeah >> no it's a different question what >> yeah it's a different it's a different question. >> One is how do you get to eat it? Look, th this this this kam the one question is it's the same idea. M the same idea. One is you're asking a question on the shim. How do you eat the shirim when you didn't you didn't take a full kamita from it? >> One this third this third is from here. Look >> the kamita. Look this kamita this part of the kamita belongs to this guy. So you didn't take a full You're missing a sixth from here. A six from here, a six from here. Because if you spread this out, a six goes over here. A piece, one little piece, a sixth is missing from this guy and from this guy that they're missing. So the shir is not edible. This shim can't eat. >> Now it's two sides of the same question. Now, how do you put this on the Mak if a third of it, it's [clears throat] not a six, it's a third is belongs to him and he's not he's not even part of the says I'll tell you why when the went like this and he made a kam >> when he when he took a from whatever it is his mind is that should be only on the good stuff. So never you know he doesn't have in his h his hand any bad any bad comments he's only thinking about the two parts that are good the fully sorry says the Mishna now I can go like this how much is left over here not that much it's very interesting >> wow do you I could I could remove this so you have more room for your okay what's your name >> let me read from >> Edison, New Jersey. >> Who else do we have? Any other guests? >> JJ, >> he's a new one. >> He's one of your sons. >> A third son. What's his name? >> Came to the JJ. >> Oh, of course. >> Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. >> Not long ago. >> I know. I remember. It's It's a special name. That somebody blocking. >> Is that one of our guys? >> It doesn't look like our guys. [clears throat] >> Is there a black Mercedes? Perhaps that that's blocking the the gate. >> Oh, it's a mench. Got up. Some people bush. They don't get up. says the mission Ellie don't tell me part of MDYM. [laughter] If the kamo became tame yeah the kimo a dead mouse touched the kamit and you put it on to the mak. We have a very special P in the Tyra that tells us that even though it's okay we ignore it. Why? Because there's something called that the kind wears on his forehead. It says not exactly like it says it over here. It might one is above the other might be kids are something like this. And this has special powers like m like uh it has powers supernatural powers that could overcome even tum. How do we know? Because the says that the tits could forgive an aa but it doesn't say what a is. It could be the a could be one of these things. There's so many aas. One of them is that the Mishna says that that's what the but it could be also if it goes outside of it's also if you do the with your left hand instead of the right hand maybe that sits forgives that who told you that it's going to forgive the maybe you put an animal that has a so that's what is all about to prove that it's the If you recall invim we had an interesting thing that the gives a it forgives a certain thing. Does anybody remember it's worth 100,000 points if you weren't here and you didn't hear it last night? [snorts] >> Huh? >> Close. Nozzer [clears throat] says that the Mishna talks about him >> and then it says David >> exactly. How do you know this? You know by heart. So he says the is because only when the bish is exists do we have it sits that can be on the pim of of >> one of the reasons was destroyed the say okay he's saying that another says oh if you took the outside of the oh we have a galda video for this if you have a that's take a look it's This k is putting a on the on the so what happens is the k as it sits and has superpowers and it makes the it makes the that's what it does but if he went outside of the mdash and came back in then the doesn't work why and here's the the has powers against doesn't help for going out or the mix is going out. >> The kit. >> Yeah. >> Doesn't matter how. Maybe threw it. Maybe this. Maybe a bird took it out. >> Let's say it went out of the bush. It came back in under his bath. He put it in a drone. Exactly. So now we have to do a process of elimination. We have we have all these ais that it could forgive and we have to know why it doesn't forgive in these things. What is the talking about? What area are we talking about? Now the entire we learned that pigle means yet thera calls pigle the gar over here is using that for for whatever reason calls this it doesn't matter really the point is he had a bad thought while he was performing the he's thinking about eating it outside of the md in certain situations it's outside of but that already says there's no There's nothing you can do about it. Here had a thought while he's doing the he's thinking of it's bad. [panting] The the the the is not going to help you. Why? It's trying to work. The says it's gone. It's finished. So doesn't work in this case. Now over here interesting is considered calls it has a whole discussion how to learn it. Also we go with Rashi. Rashi says means regardless it doesn't matter what the Gar uses the ter what term the Gar is using. The point is there's a over here that's no good. Maybe that's what the comes to help Ellie. Do you tell them you're part of MDY or you said no I'm just cleaning something over there. You have to move. Oh, now if it's about it says yeah five so it must be if it can't be these two so the comes to forgive but why I'll tell you why if you have one of the three it makes more sense to say that is talking about tum why we know that occasionally if there's tum and the only way to bring the the the carbon or carbon pes rashi says carbon is when this tum so it's m for the for the community for the community so you see that the t is is lenient when it comes to the the is more make the t is never make on pigle never sometimes go on. So if it's such a it's a lighter kind of a so the tits is going to be the Rashi says carbon and Shamshi sent me this story I saw a bunch of times I don't think I ever said it in cheer it's a famous story I said it anyway that's son said that his father told him a number of times that when learned in luma inik he's roommates with salvage once went out the the to bring people to the to to the yeshivas. He came back 4:00 in the morning and he had a sedime said this over. So he opens up the gar at 4:00 in the morning and the question that they ask is why was up? Okay, he had his own say and he starts learning. Now I don't know if you ever try to learn at 4:00 in the morning but it usually goes something like this and that's what it was. was falling asleep learning two words falling asleep asked him he says did you retain it did you gain anything from your learning he said no so why did you do it why just go to sleep he said I did it for the next 100 days the doing this every single day so I came it came into a point where I didn't do the daf that day and and not to break that that streak that I did it now it didn't do anything I didn't learn anything but it didn't break the streak that. Yeah. So the is always that if you come to a situation where it's 4 in the morning, you literally can't keep your eyes open. So at least open up the gamarra for a minute, 5 minutes, at least you you don't break your streak. They say that when it comes to exercise also you're not in the mood to do. So just get on the treadmill for a minute, just lift weights one time, do one rep. At least you're not breaking your streak. >> No. No. Okay. >> You do only the email. Does it count? [laughter] voice. I >> This is This is Benny's official first day on the job. Like he he sold his business yesterday and he already that was [applause] I don't know what you're clapping for. He already got fired. He asked if you only do emails, does that count for the one minute one minute of emails? Does it count for the D? I hear it could be the sh >> I told him to say it. >> You must from other people. >> Okay. Doesn't matter. >> I didn't say it. He said it. Fine. >> Why does it have to give extra reason by elimination? We know that it's >> you saying because the P already says lay it off. It doesn't work. >> Okay. >> I [clears throat] don't know. And it's a good cash because the next cash is only based on this on this line. >> It's a good mascul. We have more on the list. Of taking out a carbon outside going like this. just walking outside of B mikdash immediately turns red he's outside mikdash why it does not now you're gonna tell me that well if you have the two you're going to go with tum why because tum has a lighter because sometimes it's I'll tell you so the same thing with bama if you take certain times and periods in we had bas in the backyard and we would check animals in the backyard so You see that sometimes it's just like sometimes sometimes Obama's mother this comes to forgive something that happened that sits forgives something happened in front of that the soul could happen could happen in front of the could happen in front of but the is when you're not in front of when you leave the maybe it's coming to refer of doing with the left hand instead of the right hand. Why should take a look at this beautiful for today special the holds with his right hand the heavy coals we want him to hold with the right hand even though he should really be holding what is he holding in the left the should be the opposite is dyus he should be holding with the right hand but the coals are dangerous and heavy so he put it in his main in his in his dominant hand but you see that you can use your left And for the Tyrus I am so and I push it off. I said you know this today but not not today. There was that same tumor was a tuma yesterday. Today even though it's it looks like it's not this is the way to do it. This is the way I commanded you to do it. Today it's not just it's how you do it. You're asking me perhaps he's coming to say if a did it with his left hand it's okay that's in the we're talking about an that's in the is in the not in the that's what put on and the and this is an ofi the son of the son of raidi told raashi and some say ber raashi Raashi had a son. His name were and they had a discussion father and sonashi. The son asked his father. We have one more on the list and that is if an animal has a blemish. That's the last one on the list. You know how to put on the but it's not similar to once in a while. No, this also birds don't have a there's no such things about animal. If if an animal has a broken if a bird has a broken leg, you can put on the vap. There's no such thing as a male female by birds and he overheard one of the guys telling a worker, he says, "If we we ran out of the the the males, just put the females." Nobody's going to know the difference. So he's like he's shooken up and then the guy saw the heard it. So he tells him, "No, no, it says in a time of zakas." So anytime is by birds in the mikda certainly not by kaparus shouldn't be enough in kaparas but I wasn't sure about that because you know maybe chickens is so obvious pigeons you know you don't really see you can't tell it's impossible to tell okay I don't know but is not happy with that very nice it's a good nice Try it on. You cannot bring a balom. There is no sit that's going to be when the says straight out don't bring it. If you bring it, it's not going to work. Blood that became and was thrown. The blood became here. You have a not a big video. Damn. I just like the the mouse over here. It's mouse. Here you have blood in the maze. This is the cle. It's a very cute mouse. And a Remy. Oh, >> I just wrote about a Rey's father. Remy when Ay's father saw him on the video like there's another he got all excited he jumped out and said that's my son that's my son all that >> those who don't know know it's an interesting story that Remy tried to convince his father to do the daf he hasn't learned in a while do the daf and he push him and push him so one day he told he told me I I was there I was there at the satellite location in Terry and I did it so says I'm in charge of the cameras [laughter] what are you what are you talking about he said okay you got me and The next day he went and he went every single day and he loved it and the whole thing is okay. So the blood became a dead mouse a touched it and he did with it. It works. Why? Because you have tum over here and it sits. So it works. Just what if you do it deliberately? Why? What is that called? It's a penalty. It should work. It's good to remember this because we're going to be talking about penalties. Try to compare it to something else that has a penalty. There's no such thing as a penalty to the to the community. So even if they do it deliberately, it works because it works. It should work by also. We punish the I like this one because there's a guy there's a Yid I don't know if you here in you don't you're not in Chicago there's a neighborhood right next to where I lived that they didn't allow Jews all the years eventually like just recently they broke in there and they they start but no Jews they wouldn't sell a house to a Jew and the golf course also you can't get in there if you're Jewish the whole thing so there's a Jew What what's the name of that neighborhood? Right next to Mish next to Dan and Devon. You know where the giant churches. There's a giant church there. The the lawn is mushar. Anyway, so there's a a y that wanted to get into this golf course. So he practiced he practiced a lot. So they he comes there and he said they said they asked him what his name is and he said uh my name exactly. It's like you do the my name is John. What's your Smith? Okay. Okay. And what's your wife's name? Christina. And your kid, Billy. And where do you go to school? Yale. The whole thing. And uh what do you eat? Where? What restaurant? The whole thing. What's your religion? I'm a [laughter] >> What? >> What did you think of those boys? The guy said me too. Doesn't matter how he did it. The guy doesn't get a story. But here's the here's the problem. We just said that an individual doesn't get a kapara if he uses blood that's tame if he does it on purpose. But over here it says over here means the the parts that we put on the look at this even if it's on purpose here it says even it is here it is I just want to point out a very quick thing before yeah I see okay I'll say the turning of the dar globe mobile your onestop shop for all your financial needs and Isaac Castle in honor of all MDY doctors in South Florida we should all be anonymous in memory of Mosha Paris first yard just uh which always bothers me throughout but Rashi here addresses it says means by mistake Mason means on purpose, deliberate. Ous means you were forced. Rotten means you did it on purpose. So in fact, me and Rotten are identical. There's no reason to to say the word rotten. >> So Rashi says, "You're right." But because the opposite of is maze, the opposite of is. But the maze and rat are the same. And are very different. Means I didn't say I didn't know that you're not allowed to do it. Means somebody put a gun to your head. You were forced to do it. So and are very different and it are very different. The one out of the four is tak is really extra doesn't belong but to be symmetric to oh okay just throwing it out there. So this is today's maybe even a little bit of tomorrow if we we're not successful in finishing today's what do we have here? We have two bryas and there's a contradiction in the bry number one says whoa. >> It didn't upload. >> Yeah. I'm just going to show this and finished because the word yak is missing and it was over here. Somebody I don't know how it popped out. That's so weird. Okay. Ra number one says is not when an individual does it on purpose. that sis does not work if you do it on purpose for individual says the exact opposite sis does work for individual that does it on purpose answer number one it goes according to two different shittas the the says no good goes according to the bride says yes good go according to what we're going to do right now it's going to take us uh about okay let's just do it for let's start it now I'll tell you what we're going to do [snorts] simple stuff though four lines Bryson number two is this because it says you now take if a person has let's say 100 apples he has to give two of them to a cayenne so he's a he's a wise guy he takes the two apples that the dead mouse touched and he gives them to the kayen no good why because he just hurt the kayen the ken really he can't eat it and what he's gonna do he's gonna sell it for really cheap so you hurt the kayen the he went ahead and he did it anyways This is very similar to how you shouldn't do it. But if you did it on purpose, if you did it on purpose, doesn't work. Again, why doesn't the work here by trauma? Because it's a penalty. It does work with. So if he did it by mistake, the truma is a truma. And if you did it on purpose, not a truma. Truma. literally mimics our right over here that what that if you have if you did it on purpose you do get a kapara even if you did it on purpose you do the truma does work even though you shouldn't have given it and it's you shouldn't have done it like that it works one thing it's one thing to say you don't get a penalty but to say that that sits is so powerful that you could get you could eat it you go that's already farfetched to say that the tits is so powerful that you could actually eat it it's one thing to say that there's no but to say that you could go ahead and eat it but it's more than that it says is the one that says that is powerful you could even actually eat it and who we're talking about it it literally doesn't work. Where is that? Here. Look at this thing right over here. The typical We do this all the time. The one on the left goes. You just told me is the one that says there's no penalty. There's no problem. That this is great. So what do you do? So it's very simple what you do. You flip it around. Is the one that says that is okay. So that's a little bit of a You got to do a switcher rule. So now the is going to do 25 lines. I counted 25 lines to prove that you can't flip it that cannot say it's actually that says so just to get to the it's you have to just remember what are we trying to achieve here. We're trying to achieve one thing to prove the it lines up like this. Not you're trying to do aeroo a very nice try but it doesn't work. How could you flip it around? You have meat that became and you ate it before the what's before allows the kite to eat the meat. If it was before, you weren't allowed to eat it then. Maybe you should get your should get carus for eating it. You don't get cars for that. Why? Because it's not edible. There's no yet. when you get car. If it's okay for a to eat it, then if you're a that's you ate it, then you get cars. But if it's a meat that was never able to be eaten by anyone, why? Because there's no yet great. Okay, so that's one thing says maybe it's coming to say that somebody else doesn't get cars. Maybe you should get cars. perhaps it's coming to exclude meat that was left overnight and meat that went out of the mdash that a person in other words if a t person eats it he'll be potter it's extrab that you're if you eat it maybe if somebody who eats pigle and he should be and and and the Gmorra just pauses for a second, goes off track just to fix this sentence. What do you mean? We just spoke about and we said now you're telling me maybe but we just discussed and are the same. You're right. Okay, fine. People should be like we're going back into line now. The says if you're if you eat pigle and you're don't get cars. Why did you decide you have you have two things in front of you? You have that we said you get cars. You have pigle you say you don't get cars. Maybe do a switch. Who told you? Maybe pigle you should get you shouldn't say because it's logic because at the end of the day said one is and one is not now let's think let's think what makes more sense and were once upon a time good 5 hours into their lives somebody took it out of the bd it became 5 hours into their life it went overnight but for 5 hours it was Pigle happened during that not for one moment of its lifetime. Was it kosher? This case that we had that the meat became tommy even before bomb question. How can you give him it never had? You hear the question we just said something that never never the moment it was born was already bad. You don't get car new. So this piece of meat that he ate when he was t before it was never okay to eat. So never had a how could it be how could you get cars for it? Because the gives you an out over here. The makes it as if it's completely kosher. So it comes out that if it becomes you do get and if it goes outside before you not you don't get oh finally here we get to the it's look at the chart again we have to go back it's that lines up with and And finally says let's just do one. Okay. So in fact it is so instead of saying so what was our problem? The problem is we have a contradiction. The bis not a contradiction. The says that since it's not goes according to the says it is goes according to >> not we got rid of it's a whole another terrace not there's 25 lines to prove it's not have a wonderful day merit the of spreading Torah throughout the world sponsor a shir today mdysponsor.com or sponsor atmop.com