Faltche Frumkeit

I think it's Kadai to uh go back to yesterday's daf which was really a repetition of Z that talked about differenti had taken upon himself. The says besar pigle the says what did mean when he said these things at first glance it sounds like what he's saying is I didn't do the biggest aas in the world is being misspire they didn't do the biggest in the says the mean lovely means which means he didn't eat from what does that mean? I never ate from a any that required a was not a behemoth that I ever ate from. Now the brought this me of and the because of the fact that this brought as the 30 the third how you know that it's really brought it to the next line why bring it because told the story about a tra that It seemingly Ravh held was a problem and Rabbi Abra went ahead and he was make and not only was he even ate from it, right? He bought 13 ai worth of this buser and he ended up eating from it and asked a bunch of cashes on the story but one of the said was that how was he able to eat from it required himself at the end of the day required and if never ate from such an animal so why would he have eaten from such an animal and the gummor came out and the gmorra said that the reason this was different is because understood this is only nea But wasn't just saying right was saying something that he knew what was the sh of his sack was based on and based based on this idea this does uh not come into this in says as follows. He says but the based on is not anywhere is that it's shouldn't eat from it. So it says to that if there's a but the way he came to his was based on why because it doesn't say anyway that it's if you're a you should not eat from this says what is the to this because really this whole comes more from than it does from you see that said that he never ate sar pigle which the garra says means what he never ate from an animal and the qualified what say that's only but if it's not then in that situation this is not going to apply but the bottom line is what do you see from here you see that there's an idea that was not to go ahead and eat from an animal says this is not everybody but it's so if somebody's there's that tells him what he's not supposed to do not eat from aart brings a fascinating said what would be if there's a it's could be or could maybe not be in other words is saying that from we learn that if there's a hat they're based on it's a good thing to be mad makes it into if it's so there's no should because it doesn't raise to that level being that it's that it's based on so you have a higher feeling and sense that this is probably okay and it's for that reason I'm not going to tell you now what if I want to be m what if I want to be so from that then not only do I not eat really ne and tus And not only will I not rely on autism where something is is like which really is based on A MESSIAH I DON'T know I'm still NOT 100% SURE WHAT IF I WANT TO BE even on something that's can I or can I not that I found that this is really a just to read a little if would fall into a so we know that is that a cliche doesn't have the ability to be so what would be if somebody has a situation where was the that you have is the of a of a cliche so cliche is not that means it's not considered hot it doesn't have the ability to impart and plus. So what would be if you have a hat but it's in a cliche or there was that fell into a hat where it was a butish to go ahead and be says of that if somebody wants to go ahead and be you should know he's being unbelievable. So the says he found from that if somebody wants to be even on a this is something that he's allowed to do says if that's the case but it's okay you have to say that stating that says >> [snorts] >> that if somebody wants to go and he wants to be on something that these two examples HE'S BECAUSE HE'S NOT like it says he found that what would be if somebody wants to be on something within you don't have to that's the basal but let's say you want to be can I or can I not the said that of course because anytime there's any little bit of is even if it's in a cliche even if it's a disgusting and if that's the case mitzvah there's no sh in the world is a mitzvah to go ahead and to be in such a situation the brings from the that if somebody wants to be not only is he doing a good thing but to the contrary how can we meet so you have two opinions of how to view something like this and it's literally either it's a mitzvah because you're miracle from something disgusting or it could be it's literally which is which is the most thing that a person can possibly do. I saw Margolus in which is his commentary that he wrote on and this is in so he quotes this who brings from the who said this unbelievable that if somebody wants to be on something that's such as cliche being that maybe it's or not relying onishim It's and he at different places where you find the such an idea that if somebody wants to be not only is it not okay not only is it not but to the contrary there's a of the first example this might be the best known this is in It's talking about the laws of Shia and and you know how you prepare for Shabas which is you know we have it down to a science but it's really in an old world was pretty complex says any person who doesn't believe in and he says I'm not going to eat on Shabas because this is complic you have to be maybe he's a man use that if somebody goes ahead he doesn't eat you think he's now you learn this what do you think of you think of the right you think of the of fame right that's what comes to mind but after you see this the word min is a a digger way of describing somebody that wants to be said it's and you're allowed to eat and if you're going to go ahead and not eat because of that it's okay to eat and you know just follow the script there's an English and this is a chuva from the rottenber it's invites as follows You heard you heard about me that I have that after I eat after I eat cheese I don't eat meaning not never but he waits considerable amount of time but I'm when it comes to so says let me explain to you the rumor that you heard when I was younger I used to know people that took on this and I used to Cuz when I used to see those people, I thought they were until one time I ate cheese and then by the next meal I found a little bit of cheese in between my teeth and I made a cuz I had such that I'm going to be the same form. And I thought about it afterwards. I realized that even though at first glance I thought this was minus cuz you're going connected to but really not and this is not really one said that I'm compared to my father like vinegar is compared to wine which is not much of a comparison when it comes to the my father when he would eat he wait a full day until he ate And I only What do you see from here? is you have to say he said you see from the of that even TO GO MORE THAN SIX hours and to be more if you're holding by it that's a very so if you could be to go 24 hours not going to eat meat until tomorrow cuz I had a coffee today or cuz he had gina today. So why can't I be Makm and say that when it comes to if I'm going to in the reverse to go ahead and be [laughter] so it's for that reason I came around but what was his says because I used to look at it someone that's I used to look at as being Minos brings It's the last This is says the even though a person is allowed to be. So if somebody makes a and he wants to make this is something that you're allowed to do and there's no in this you're allowed to do it. And if there's someone who walks around thinking it's not so but the bottom line is the he talks about someone who's and says it's allowed to do it. In fact, now it's fascinating that he uses again the now really if you looked at this Rama in a vacuum. I'll tell you where my mind went. I would think of the raid that we spoke about how the minimizing about and there was a minus that very much related to so the person that doesn't want to be it's what the means but at the end of the day I have who brings from the name of the that if somebody is And so it's on it's of and if somebody's not says in the end of there's an element of minus and said that I used to think that somebody that was like a person like that is is I came around and this is not something that's as bad as I thought it was And says in regarding so again you have it in the sug of you have it in the of you have it in the of and you have it in the of we there's an element that it's not so to be because if somebody's going to be in a situation like this there's an element of meanness. So what's the I think for sure we could all that raid from et [laughter] and if you're going to go ahead and you're going to be you're being there's an element of meanness that means you don't trust kazal 100% kazal said cliche is not oh the terret is why because you did an experiment and you saw clichi is kazal said it's now what the cliche mash it's it's it's a legitimate question but AT THE SAME TIME SAID that and it's for that reason this is something that we need to be mab 100% and if a person is not mab 100% on some level he's undermining margles in that piece he says there's another element to this and really that element is a classic it's in two places in the first it's in the second this is famous we mentioned it this says this falls very short. So he once went to was in when he was there he met the southerner who was from the southern part of he saw was and this is what he said and his were so of etc. So says that when heard what said he goes running into and he goes to first and he tells you heard they were they were heard that he ate shakim said perfect. He took a little bit of shakim, dipped the sour dough into it and he ate it like but Rav when he heard the same exact thing he didn't want to eat. He said I'm so went to he told I want you to eat the law cuz if you're not going to eat I'm going to say about you that you're not being of the we didn't see my Rav told one second one you're going a little too fast he said you know I used to be init so Rav said when I was init this role. I know you're the man. I knew about this Indian. I know this to you. You're very impressed. I know. Listen to me. I'm not from his from what he says. I'm not what you think is saying this on his own. He said, "So I would agree with you. If this is I'm not saying you have to jump but he said over there says the end kept on badgering Raph until finally Rav who was much older than but Rav ended up somehow conceding and he ended up eating from the but you see from this year anotheruda and that is that if an Adam god an Adam god somebody that people look up to if he is going to go ahead and he is going to go ka He's being and he's not doing it in a he's not doing it in the context of a but at the same time seeing a gay irregular guy but a regular person you know is you have to be a mad to be a you need to meet a lot of qualifications if you remember [laughter] but the bottom line is someone on of the ilk of rah who's on this level if he's going to go ahead he's going to be m This is a well-known what's not so well known says I have one more. This is the last one. I have one more and this is a this is fascinating. So this is if you want to look it up it's towards the end it's dash. So he's writing to someone who doesn't want to do chuva over something very bad that he did regarding an right sounds like he's going to be making an where people don't want him to make an but if you're holding with the flow of the d it's actually be just the opposite I already wrote to you about the I already said that it's the that if you have a that's 101 and it's going to be okay and you said for that it's going to be awesome and you told me by this IS INCREDIBLE I TOLD you the Russ is talking I warned you I warned you. I said you better make an I was told this is so important because right all the pro famous where it's based on the fact you're being right remember the says I should eat by someone who lives in that doesn't have an because if there's no ultimately you're going to be on two weeks after you see this and if you're not going to listen to I'm going to put you in I want you to know if you were around in the times of give you cuz you go and connect the SENSE THROUGH WORKS AND YOU CAN'T BE MORE than there's a postcript to this. It's test dash base. He's writing this to the not to be confused with this >> [laughter] >> was the rush talking. He says, "The letter that I wrote to that person who I want you to know that if he's not going to be I'm warning him that's the entire right. So this is what the rush is writing. because otherwise every is going to come up with and [laughter] he's and I want you to know if he's still not going to the rush gave him a lot of chances. It's pretty clear. So the rush again you have to go back to the world of history. is outside my lane to appreciate the the protective that had amongst the kings and he said I'm going to make sure that he's going to have to pay some sort of fine say that the rush said he should pay $1,000 or whatever the number is and if that's not going to help I want you to repeat every I want you to keep me informed keep me posted And there's a mitzvah to put him in the and you we should even try to find a way to kill him. Now the rest of the story is right they bring here on the bottom this we spoke about one of these rushes once with but the bottom line is the rush was not so opposed to capital punishment this is a whole sheet of rush that's way beyond the scope of this I love because this was obviously printed after his but here's another example where the was so upset about somebody that was being he was going connected this by foolish and he was invoking the quote but he means the it's he means that just like told obviously was he was someone that had the ear of the people and he said if you're going to be and you're going to go blatantly connected this is the bottom line is we have a fascinating idea usually when you think of you think of it's but you see it's not so posit you have to be this with at the same time realizing and appreciating that sometimes if a person is well this is an element of minos AND IF A PERSON'S ABOUT THERE could be a dimension over here of which is of not just but was given not just any mis was given and it's one of the four times that it says in the it's one of the four times that had it be done by when all the because it undermines the it underlines undermines the because if someone's going to go ahead and he's going to go ahead and go connect the so just think about what it is that it's doing and that's this of not being allowed to go and be it's not something that's okay but here's the usually when you think of the you think of it in terms of or you think in terms of you're going to be but you see it goes the other way as well you let it be and just think about it we had the with regards to you want to be I want to say I want TO BE I DON'T WANT TO THAT FALLS INTO a but who would want to eat a ch like that but I want to be my this is something that something I'm not okay I'm not eat that maybe there's a little bit of an element but I used to believe in my heart of hearts I used to think that if somebody in it's of the says that if somebody is has a little bit of in the is also a of didn't want to eat was something that was awesome. He heard a rumor that Ra felt didn't have so much credibility. We didn't see it WAS SAYS I'M JUST NOT GOING TO EAT IT. BUT I have to eat if I don't I'll buy KOSHER OIL. YOU BETTER EAT IT BECAUSE OTHERWISE it's gonna be a of and this became and he doesn't want to make an foolish that means a hard stuff right with this of everyone knows to be is terrible thing and if it's connect there's no other way to describe a one word description this is his whole uh brief Russia but the truth is it goes in the reverse as And for a person to go ahead and be is not so the question is how do you really reconcile this? It's it's a little bit hard. I mean this is how we're walking away from this. But is that true? So it's never okay to be on something that's what right? Shouldn't that fall in a little bit to the equation? It's a good question and is this question and a mahalak will be the topic of tomorrow's