The Jewish People Principle - Rabbi Avi Geller

today we are learning the Jewish people principal it's a very important principle to understand many important topics in the book of voracious Genesis and answer many very very very powerful questions whenever I start my flesh class I always started with an introduction that's a question what kind of book is the Torah the Torah history book the taurah a law book the taurah story book the taurah all of the above it's the answer all the above right it contains him three you can tell you stories it contains laws let me rephrase the question what's the main point of the Torah this is basically a history book and part of the history is that God gave some laws or is it basically a law book and histories background information for the laws is it this is it a history book that contains laws or a lower box that contains history if you go to the secular schools in Israel they all teach the Tanakh well they tell you the story book right aesop's fables be rabia nice the Bible I once had a professor said the Bible is a very truthful book it's truthful can learn a lot of good things wait it's not true don't take it too seriously look at to inspire right like the lady that sent to Cynthia she because even going out with a non-jew they started getting religious that's enough that's enough don't get too fanatic right but anyone is it tour objectively can't help it seeing it it's basically a law book like what if y'all got wider gog about cyanide ten stories to ten commandments no another one to change the ten suggestions every other Tessa gestures it camis is too heavy like it 10 nice thing to do if you feel like it still at that Commandments I sure you've heard the bad joke about was this go down from the mountain right I got good news I got bad news area that would rather I like the guy comes to his office and his secretary says boss I got good news I got bad news let me are the good news first the Coughlin doctor's office you got three days to live that's the good news what's the bad news they call two days ago I forgot to tell you ok good news got him down to 10 bad news adultery still here that's a bad joke this lady I was when sitting in a hotel lobby then he comes in and says you know I put him in Susa and there's no Ted Commandments inside first of all it's not thanking a mrs. she might as well so you know bite with susie but this is a box i get a bit of mrs. in all right this lady wants promises to a wrapping it was empty what's the matter well the instructions were in Hebrews I throw about the Torah happens to be very poor history book things are not necessarily in chronological order events that happen later I've written before his big gaps in the middle ten generations from Adam until Noah she's listenings he gave her to him he gave her to him he gave her nothing important happened the period of a thousand years right from Noah to Abraham again ten generations listenings we finally help to the star of the show our father Abraham do you know how old Abraham was with the topic is talking about him 75 what happened till then nothing important so we have to be dressed in the trash is the oral tradition which fills in a lot of the gaps but the Torah happens to be a very poor history book and our tradition is that is basically a law book and the story says background information and therefore the conclusion is that every story and every detail of every story is coming to teach us a lesson we must ask well lesson is a competition when you read a novel you don't say why do you think that life is telling a story don't you a lot of details right but if the story in the law book it must be there for a purpose right now right in the beginning of the Torah first Rashi ask a question brings a rabbi yitzhak ask a question since the tour is a law book not a storybook why is it that from creation it's just off from the first law what's the first law on the Torah well there's many first laws the first mitsui give a tad and whisper ravu have children and I've Ramires Mila and Jacob another but the First Minister given to the Jewish people by moshe by God was chapter 12 of the book of Exodus this month shall be the first month we have a lunar calendar and this is the first month right in the letter vision right so rashi says it should start from there doesn't even wouldn't know all the rest why can't we have all the rest in the oral tradition the Midrash will tell us a story of creation in the story of Noah's Ark in the story of the ten plagues and the story of the forefathers like we have that mimic Josh why is that happening in the written law in laws the law book and Rashi answers rather useless says the reason why it's and they're all a law is for the shoes it's for the non-jews he broke or subversive initially or does it say the total shooters began from here co-op mustafa kemal the six lemnoc let's go him it's a verse in Psalms this pettiness transceivers these did he tell the nation's in order to give the inheritance of the nation's right now she says it is gonna come when the non-jews are gonna say you're crooks you came in today the client you stole our land Joshua stall the land from the clan is right and we'll tell them look in the touristy they didn't have they didn't have access to the oral law but the written Torah the overhead went when they cross the Jordan River they wrote in running that all the languages everybody knew the written law right the tour begins with God created the world right the world is God's he's the boss in Adamson he was exiles from the Garden of Eden and keynesian he was exiled then the generation the flood they were destroyed generated Tower of Babel they were exiled then came Abraham and God shows apron why didn't God choose Abraham cuz Abraham chose God famous anti-semitic saying how odd of God to choose Jews right I said our answer is not so odd the Jews chose God right and that's RT to the land that did it ever happen the types of Joshua at the came to Joshua said you stole away and he said says the Torah this land is mine God gave the Phantom maybe it did but we have no record of it we have no record of it right but in 1948 in 1948 when ben gurion who was not an orthodox jew by the way came to the League of Nations and asked for a state of Jewish state in Palestine what argument to the use it didn't really have a choice what else could he have said we were here two thousand years ago that's what so pick an archaeology in this country right is that a good reason to throw the Arabs out if the American engineers come to throw all the white side up in hatton highly we were here first but they are with 1300 years right that's not a good reason we had a Holocaust we need a homeland that's not the researchers worked on mine are their land cuz we got how they didn't do it some beer for all right the only thing would say was your Christians and your Moslems you believe in the Bible it says in the Bible this land is ours so mr. Ben Gurion you don't believe in the Bible if you're right you gotta be consistent right right right so you say mr. Ben Gurion is that the only thing he says in the Bible how about shabbat how about kosher how about feelin what do you say about somebody who's a kosher is it just gives cultural videos asha purchased a truly lives or zionist right it's a package deal goes together right right right and now comes my second introduction to the Torah that's the question I say what when a person writes the book what they write about things that interest them and things that don't interest there what do you say things that interest them right if it's poured science whatever it is right we claim this his book that the almighty wrote that God wrote let's try to figure out what kind of things interest God all right the book begins in the beginning I created the heaven and the earth the heaven billions of stars galaxies endless space and the earth you'd ever see a picture of planet Earth space expect doesn't go together like someone saying I went to Paris I saw the Eiffel Tower a Miami hotel rooms little dog house and don't go together alright the next verse begins and the earth was and from that point on the total talks about the earth and not about the heavens conclusion what address god they have another earth yes then we have the six days of creation right the Sun the Moon the Stars the trees the grass the birds the fish the animals the insects The Beatles you know the Beatles are right that he creates one man can what is one man compared to entire planet Earth aspect it's the rest of the Torah does not talk about the birds or the fish or the trees or the grass it talks about man conclusion why don't you rest god man okay Adam was a great man he was given a test and he blew it right right in the beginning of the Torah we have the basic fundamental principles the concept of creation the concept of free will the kinds of a reward and punishment just in parenthesis you know what was the sin of Adam yet from the tree of knowledge of good and evil I guess a question what's wrong with knowledge of good and evil don't you think it's a positive thing to know just been good at bat why is he the sin leave the tree from the tree boughs good so you think God said don't eat it okay but why what's the logic behind that why isn't it shouldn't you know that is it good and bad I think the answers obvious good and bad good and evil it's very subjective right it was a good lunch it was a bad lunch it was a good class was a bad fast i was told me was a great class what'd he say I don't know who's begging thank you go through that the great day a great class could some other criteria one could base a decision on which is more objective than good and bad what would it be what would be more objective how about true or false right something could be objectively true and subjectively bad for example smoking is dangerous to your health that's objectively true for a smoker is bad I heard about a smoker that read that smoking is dangerous to herself you know what he did he gave up reading you go smoke right oh the other way around uh something to be objectively false and subject Lee good a drug addict it's on a trip and he's floating and never ever them that's objectively fantasy but famous good so for Adam ate from the tree his decision-making process was true or false let the chips fall where they may if it's true I do it if it's false at all once the ate from the tree is it good is it bad this is fun does it fit in with my lifestyle do I enjoy it right once or vehicle Weinberg's I saw was giving a lecture to college professors after five minutes one that said rabbi I want you to stop talking right now why because you keep on talking I'm gonna have to change my lifestyle and I like my lifestyle ever walked out you walked up to Adam Wright was a great man after Adams a list of names he gave birth in make a pro team you know if you look on page 53 in the artscroll you have a chronology from Adam until Jacob right in order to make this chronology after how many years they live the Torah tells us how many years we live but no more details it's fast forward this is not interests till we get to the second portion of the total how does that begin these are the offspring of Noah Noah was a righteous man chapter 6 right in the book of chapter verse verse 9 the book of Exodus Genesis right Noah was a righteous man and we have an entire portion dealing with Noah conclusion what kind of manager is God righteous man right and after Noah again the list of names till we get to Abraham Isaac Jacob Moses and from that point on the TOA talks exclusively about who the Jewish people Jewish people right what interest got in this world the Jewish people doesn't mean that it doesn't care about the non-jews of course God's father of all mankind right but the Jewish people are exclusive and we see the non-jews are obsessed with the Jewish people right now how big is the State of Israel about the size of New Hampshire New Jersey right how open it is real information York Times almost every day right however this new hampshire new jersey not very often they're obsessed with us right so we have a principle called the Jewish people principle and that explains many many many many questions and the stories in the book of Genesis so the point is basically that the forefathers and the matriarch the patriarchs of the matrix the mothers were aware of the fact that they're not private citizens that they have a mission to create a Jewish people and God told Abram this offer out right right right in Chapter 12 left looks alright I will make you a great nation now will bless you right you should be a blessing all the families of the other she'll bless themselves by you then we have the Brisbane of us are in the convent in between the parts that's an also impartial f'lessan we're God tells him that you have a chili girl who be slaves in Egypt right but you're often should be like the Stars right and he tells it very clearly right that they will inherit the land right and there'll be a holy nation he knew that it was aware of that this explains many very very difficult parts of the book of Genesis so let's begin let's begin alright first example is the aqeedah you have the story of the exit of the sacrifice of Isaac God appears to a prayer he tells him take your son two sons your only son both all these songs to their mother oh you love I love them both and bring him up for a burnt offering let's consider the paramount sacrifice in history that a bruh was able to sacrifice his son now we know throughout Jewish history teachers have given their lives and their children's lives which is a lot harder for God and they weren't as great as Abraham and they were command the directory by God as Abraham was so what's a big thing of course abram did it good he was so great a guy committed of course what was the big thing why was it such a big test why was it such a big test was he did it so the simple answer of course is that it put him out of business see what was I params what was his job his profession we call it outreach professional he was teaching the world about God the whole world was steeped in idolatry idolatry includes human sacrifice if we go to South America during the times of the stech some incas right what a grain would you do think of a fair maiden Flint life cut out our heart and sacrifice it to the rain god what else is needed should they felt very bad for the poor remaining what can you do we need right all right ah from since you guys got it all wrong God doesn't want you in sacrifice you have to appease God he wants hospitality he wants it he wants kindly that's what he wants by the way I firmwares he's on his um I sacrifice it was a total contradiction to everything he was preaching right I put him out of business right but much more than that much more than that Abram was aware that Isaac is going to be the future Jewish people right that's what made it so difficult right God promised him he's gonna have a nation that's gonna teach the world about God it is no Isaac there's no Jacob there's no Moses there's no my modalities there's no Rabbi Geller / nothing right right right so he gets up early in the morning right you want to cook his son at least let it obviously have to wake him up at nets in sunrise right all right and he travels for three days you know how hot that is you know think about it for three days you tell a Buddhist you know jump into the fire and then you jumped into the fire tell him wait three days and jump to the fire it's a lot harder maybe you'll become a Christian all right then it comes to the place and he ties his son down he takes survive he's arrested right round to slaughter his son and the angel appears and says you passed the test and client colorist don't do it let me just make a little cottage always serious no nothing all right then the Torah says he sees a ram that was caught and the thornbush the rabbi say this ram was waiting for this moment since the six days of creation and it came running towards him the satan put a thornbush it make it more difficult right one horn was sinai one horn is the machine and everything the seniors were used for King David's harp right so the question is question is it after we saw as a ram what does it mean he slaughtered a ram instead of his son any sense what eyes that make any sense right you just gave me a million dollars cash thank you so much for the height how can I show my appreciation you know I just I just had the Bobby put on the floor I just found the bobby pin on the floor right you just take the bar been around for instead of your million dollars that make any sense that make any sense right I chantels of slaughter his son his who's bored him at the age of 100 the future Jewish people all right rare slaughter him don't slaughter thank you so much god you know I just have to ram here I don't even buy it just sounded over here please take this ram instead of my son that make any sense and after he slowness the ram the angel appears a second time and gives him a tremendous blessing rye rye second time from heaven I verse 15 in chapter 22 in Genesis you have done this thing you hold back your son your only son also bless you crease you toss me like the stars of heaven like the sand of the sea your aura Jimmy inherit their enemies right the make sure the liberal shall bless themselves by your offspring cuz you listen to my voice hold on one minute went he passed the test when he was ready to slaughter his son or when he slaughtered the RAM forget about the rim st. it was no random it has a test God didn't say slaughter me said brilliant okay that's the answer in the end but but when did he pass the test when he was ready to slaughter his son or when he saw the RAM right say there was no ram did he pass a test yes so why did he only get the blessing God says he he's read his letters on you pass the test now he's floors around instead of his son whatever that means and then he gets the big blessing why do you get the blessing only after the rain and the commentaries explained when Avril took that ram and his mind's eye it was a sunny look and he cried bitter tears how can I do this to my only son the future Jewish people and he overcame his emotions and said it's the will of God no questions asked and he slaughtered the RAM and said thank you God for taking the ram instead of my son then he took the blood of the RAM right in his mind's eye was the blood of Isaac he cried bitter tears how can I do this and he overcame his emotions the will of God sprinkle of blood on the altar every act he did the rim in his mind's eye was as if he was doing it to his son and it was considered by goddess if he actually saw he's florham instead of his son literally and that's why I got that blessing right and that's when the Jew can to Jerusalem Temple times he brought an animal for a sacrifice right now they don't the conservative movement took out of their prayer book every mention of sacrifices when I do that again when I got back to that sacrifice call you know and our prayer book it says Moo stuff that's the additional pray we saying on Shabbat and holidays were sold as we say we really supposed to make a sacrifice but we don't have a temple rebuild example so we can bring it they took that out we're not doing that anymore all right I've never seen a conservative I got of Passover because they have a problem the hold on god of Passover is based on giving their base of a car roof build the temple so we can bring the Passover sacrifice you know when do we say this shanna hababam schlein next year in Jerusalem whether we say that you know pass over after the Seder and your Kippur after yom kippur right no other time why only those two times what's the common denominator we pass over and you're Kippur because all the other holidays you can have without a temple we can have a sucker we can have a chauffeur we can have a little of right but the main point of view Kippur was the high priest going into the holy of holies on your Kippur we don't have that today next year when usual I'm we can have it the main point of Passover is the pastor of a sacrifice but you don't have today next year when usual I'm you want to have the sacrifice right when a jew came to Jerusalem and brought an animal here we put his weight on the animal and say this animal should be instead of me and when he saw the blood of the animal being slaughtered that should be my blood and the fact that should be my fat it made a tremendous emotional impact you were a changed person after bring the sacrifice right that was the idea instead of young so Abraham knew that he had to make that he had to make a great nation and that was a test the test was do God's will let's carry on another example Jacob right he's running away from his brother Esau and his father tells them go find a wife go to her on and marry the daughters of love one on his way to go to his father's the rabbi's tell us is a 14 year gap in the Catholic calculations he went to study in the Shiva of shame and a ver shame was the son of Noah and they were a ver with a grandson they had a tradition even though he was world tour was given by the a tradition handed down from Adam no all right and he studied Torah for 14 years he didn't lie down in bed for days yay fell asleep on her when you lie down what they had the dream of the other of the latter is first time I lie down to 14 why is he going 14 years to study has thrown up Mary's and 60s already right then he comes to lava he's already some of these right right seven years of work for Rachel yogurt that was in seven second year seven years was love his idea but the first of it why seven years ago chamara ready I'm answer is the answer is he knew he was making the first totally Jewish family Abraham had a leash wall that was no good you suck had an ace of Jacob's gonna have 12 tribes and he felt he wasn't ready he was preparing himself for 14 years of Torah study to be able to do that job the responsibility of making Jewish people he needed you know when you Shepherd you have a lot of free time when they wouldn't when they when the sheep are grazing you couldn't study in Reverse he wanted to review the seven years the 14 years have you studied right he Matthew West man that explains another question it says the fourth 27 years and he worked for Rachel was like a few days out of his love for her that's what the verse says that doesn't make any sense yeah when you're anticipating an event to come up here a wedding right a vacation right how does time fly faster slow when you're is very slow what are they gonna be ready where are they gonna be very very slow all right Sokka wins the seven years like a few days it should be like in 10 years like a like a hundred years right but when you waiting for it exam and exams coming up how does time fast fly there even the exams next week oh no it's tomorrow oh no what's today all right he these seven years he was preparing himself to make the Jewish people the Jewish people principle that's why you went like a few days right and then he gets married as four wives in this competition over how many babies and how many babies right right and rachel says I don't have a baby I'm dead is that a way to talk you know you kind of children that there were great people that has ownage didn't have any children suroosh enero the founder of the base yeah can we didn't have any children you can still accomplish a lot without children right but I want to be part of the Jewish people right right so she gave him her maidservant her child is subservient to me off at your part right and Leia has four children she is amazin true chance for children ready every child is a tribe of Israel right they were aware of that that was a competition who's gonna have a greater portion and then make chills on her deathbed right and the Midwife has don't worry Rachel you ever saw me don't worry she's dying I mean don't worry because the most important thing was I want to be part of the Jewish people another tribe of Israel see that that's just that's the principle over here right what is the principle the Jews people principle that they were aware of the fact that they were private citizens that they were making a Jewish people Abraham knew if he slores Isaac there's no more Jewish people right Jay Jacob was preparing yourself to make a Jewish people the mothers were where every baby that's born is a tribe of Israel let's continue we have the story of Tom Moore and you right so you who marries his two sons and they both died and Tom Margie he's afraid to give her a third son and she disguised herself as a prostitute right and she gets pregnant from her father-in-law this was considered bibim he was never right marriage today we left right marriage the Torah says for only a brother but before the Torah was given it was performed by any relative including the father all right but what was the motivation what did tammeh do this for she wanted to be part of the Jewish people she knew that having a child from you to be part of the Jewish people that was a motivation and that's why the Torah Justin poses this story right on top of the story of Joseph and the wife of put t far and then obviously what was the wife of 40 bro what was her motivation right she wanted me part of the Jewish people too she saw on the star that she's gonna marry Joseph and be part of the Jewish people right for stargazing is very hazy prophecy is crystal clear right like for example the star cases told Pharaoh that the Savior the truth being born and his downfall will be with water so they drowned all the babies of the river right right right his downfall was he hit the rock that was didn't see clearly right Jeane Dixon I can predict things very easily very vaguely but I clearly right right what she really saw was that her daughter estas some say she threw adopted daughter Mary Joseph later on but what was the motivation again she wanted to be part of the Jewish people what I was that way that's why those two things again the Jewish people principal right and then we get to the story of Joseph hi story of Joseph and the brothers you know plotting to murder their brother god forbid you know part of being Jewish you know our ancestors wanted to kill their brother that's not a very nice thing to do right god forbid they they they convened the court of law right and they decided Josie was trying to get us right his dreams are in prophecies that's what he's thinking about all day he's thinking about us bow down to him all day right he's telling the father bad things about us and the father should curse us you know the curse of Jacob was very lethal he cursed Rachel not know not knowing that she stole that I and she died because of that right right he wants the father should Chris us you know Abraham adderall and yes got a sub get rid of the brothers Abraham Isaac Jacob Jones that's what the brothers thought was Joseph's goal before they wanted to get him right and Jacob is crying for 22 years he refuses to be consoled you know is that the Jewish way we supposed to you know in the non-jewish world when somebody closed eyes it's usually one of two reactions one reaction is take your trip to Bermuda don't think about Duff death it's too bored with right right the other reaction is I'll never forget it for the rest of my life and the Torah says they both wrong when someone closed eyes you have to sit Shiva sit in the floor you tear your garment you know where shoes and you cry for a week and you deal with it then for three more weeks you limit your activities for a parent an entire year you don't go to weddings listen to music right and gradually get it out of your system then once a year is he your site you remember that person what's his wife at 22 years he refused to be comforted and the answer is Jacob wasn't crying only about a son he had a mission to make a Jewish people with 12 tribes and he knew that and one is missing that means I missed the ball that means I did not accomplish my mission this world for that he could never be consoled and then when he finds out that Joseph still alive right well as he say now I'm ready to die you didn't die for another 17 years after that right I'm ready that cuz now I know I fulfilled my mission the fact that the forefathers and the mothers were aware of the fact right that they have to make a Jewish people and Jewish people have to make it impact in the world you can't have a world without the Jewish people can't have world without the Jewish people that's the problem all right and then the game note that I know that that's what it's obsessed about us because they know the Jewish people we're a nation and supposed to teach the world about God by example by example all right right that's supposed to make a Giada give her everybody Judaism that's not our goal by example imagine if there was no crime in the state of israel there were no drugs instead of israel right oh the nation would say learn a lesson right look in the religious neighborhoods right give it to me a shower room you know it's a poverty neighborhood right they live with 10 kids in two rooms sometimes all right what's compared to any poverty neighbor in the world right what's the violent crime wave what's the drug use wife abuse tribe over my main I mean I'm saying it's perfectly sure they've never used to lock the doors there until people came outside start stealing right but this is a the Jewish people have to be a light unto the nations we have to teach the world by example right right and we have taught the world right right if we proud of being Jewish it back for a minute be proud of being Jewish right we taught the world morals and ethics right right right right Roman soldier is about to enter a city to pillage to rape to murder to loot you stop hold on buddy one minute when that's going question what right do you have philosophically speaking right to go into that City pillage rape murder Lou what would you say before you chop your head off any Romans philosophy or do you say very simple I'm stronger might makes right and if might makes right and you have the might then right or wrong you're always right right that's what they believe yo every sin Camelot it might makes right and you have the right there I don't who took the world that might does not make right right that right makes might what if the Romans was it the grease whether the Persians it was to choose we taught the world morals and ethics right and the Western were all the slogans right love your neighbor as yourself proclaim Liberty throughout the land our Torah our profits right all men a great equalizer Jewish concept you know they even give us credit what's in a while you know the United Nations not known to be very pro-israel that's the understatement of the year right Debbie r of the Isaiah wall you know they say a Wallace United Nations walls called the essay will they will beat their stores that the Ploughshares no more war our boys are profits are we taught the world morals and ethics our biggest competitors are imitators the Christian missionaries go around the world that God loves yoga who talk around the world we taught them that right we taught the world's they have to be proud of being Jewish am i right this is the Jewish people principle right so the book of Exodus the forefathers and the mothers they planted the seed for the future Jewish people right thrombosis is the famous very important principle throughout the book of Genesis master of awesome on the bonham the deeds of the forefathers is a symbol it's a sign for the future right for example Jacob is a Brazilian of Israel and there's a famine he goes down to Egypt the Egyptians making trouble they take his wife to God big plagues on Pharaoh when he leaves he chipped with a lot of money that sounds familiar all right what happened later on in the times of Jacob there's a famine and goes out to Egypt you just make us slaves God brings plagues we go out with a lot of money right whatever the forefathers were doing with your deeds they were planting the seed for the future Jewish people that's the fundamental principle of the book of Genesis we come to the book of Mouse the seed grows starting off I slaves in Egypt right who's the first one the course as a nation you know first one Pharaoh the nation the children which is a family we're a nation right right the ten plagues is pleading the Red Sea and the pinnacle is the revelation on Sinai we become a nation and we're supposed to be a light into the world were the whole mankind that's the Jewish people principle any questions cuz i'm so going back to the cicada thing so i've heard people do so don't go to synagogue that off and what they do go and everything us to do and they go to the akkade and they read this story about Abraham sacrificing Isaac and they say this is what we stand for that some guy blindly goes and is gonna sacrifice his son this is my my ideal that I need to leave that I need to live up to this is crazy this guy's hearing voices and so the questions that we asked was that throughout history shoes have given their lives for God right where they get it from you know they got it from it's in the genes from Abraham I'll tell you a story tell you a story in one of the concentration camps one of the Commandant decided that too many of the boys were lying about their age they were saying they were 18 when they really weren't she put a sticker certain height and all the boys in the camp go into that stick wherever it didn't reach it was gonna be killed stepped on tiptoes we shot on the spot they had about a hundred boys locked up in the room the next day was rosh hashanah we're going to kill him all the next day now the Nazis he can't bribe but the couple was the police of the camp believes right people had smuggled in dollars and gold and silver you could bribe them get your son out but before they will let your son out the first thing they took the first boy they found and put them in they have the right number of them they'd be in trouble right Hungarian Jew close to the rap it was when rabbi in the camera buying my entire family was killed I have one son left and he's in that room and I my relatives gave me money I can ride them get them out but I know they're gonna take it innocent boy in this place what does it tell us say am I allowed to take one guess seem to save my only son and the rabbi said what you're asking me a question of life and death when I'm starving to death in the concentration camp I have no books to consult I have no college to consult I can't answer your question do whatever you want when the minister's rap are you the only rabbi here I have to know am I allowed to say my son or not he was essentially an entire year our entire hour he's begging the rabbi entire era the rabbi's matuszak do whatever you want at the end of the heiress's rabbi if it would have been permitted you would have told me right I understand when you reply that it's not permitted I'm not gonna do it father Abraham you were commanded to sacrifices on the end you didn't sacrifice him I'm ready to give my son the next day was rosh hashanah and the boys wanted to hear the chauffeur blom before they died right and they smuggled in a chauffeur and the rabbi went in and they said if you take they come and you're gonna go with them and they heard the show when they were all killed the rabbi tells the story after the war that's the situation if someone's coming to kill you you kill him first someone tells you to kill an innocent person or I'll kill you you have no right to who says you're plus more read it is maybe his blood is war read the yours by right throughout our history Jews have given their lives for God inquisitions the Crusades a with commit suicide they would rather than have their children before some the converted to Christianity right right where'd that come from where'd that come from it came from the genes of our father Abraham he started it off right fact that is most myself so so all the generations it was a personal thing right the Jewish people will survive I might die my children my diet but the Jewish people will survive right I'm ready to give my life for God right but with Abraham it was much more difficult because Isaac was the Jewish people right killing Isaac means killing everyone right that's what we detest so enormous and he was able to stand that's why that is a merit for all generations okay okay thank you very much