Preparing video...
0:00 / 0:00
There is No Book Called Nehemiah - Rabbi Yitzchak Breitowitz
1,127 views
According to Chazal, there is no book called Nehemiah. Where did the division come from? Rabbi Yitzchak Breitowitz explains. #Hidabroot #Judaism #Tanach #jewishtiktok #jewishthought #jewishshorts #rabbi
Categories:Torah/Tanach
Comments
Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
According to Chazal, Maseches Bava
Basra, which enumerates the books of
Nach,
there is no book called Nehemiah. Just
like, for example,
there is no book of Shmuel Aleph or
Shmuel Bet. There's only a book of
Shmuel.
And there's only a book of Melachim.
Not Aleph and Bet. There's only a book
of Divrei Hayamim.
And there's no book called Ezra Nehemiah
and Ezra and Nehemiah.
There is only a book of Ezra, which
included
what later became the book of Nehemiah.
Okay, so if you ask me, where do Chazal
talk about the book of Nehemiah? The
answer is they don't talk about the book
of Nehemiah, because technically there
is no book of Nehemiah.
The division of Shmuel into two books,
the division of Melachim into two books,
the division of Divrei Hayamim into two
books, and the division of Ezra and
Nehemiah as two books, is not a Jewish
thing at all. It comes from the
conventions of non-Jewish printers,
who were dividing the Bible into
convenient units.