Preparing video...
0:00 / 0:00
Contemporary Tevillas Keilim Issues - Rabbi Yakov Zev Smith
197 views
1. The halachic definition of cutlery that require tevila. 2. Should an EZ filter attached to a faucet be toiveled? 3. New: meat thermometer, food scale, cooking probe, measuring cup. 4. Can opener, corkscrew, nutcracker, trivet. 5. Spice grinder, apple corer, peeler, masher, sifter. 6. Sour dough starter container, meat tenderizer. 7. Is a bracha said when toiveling a salt shaker, pot cover or egg yolk brush? 8. Does a אליהו של כוס or a קערה סדר ליל require tevila? 9. Poultry shears, corn-on-cob holder, melon baller, pizza slicer. 10. Cookie cutter, metal ice cube tray, tray of כוס. 11. Spice bottle (i.e. pepper) that has a built-in disposable grinder.
Comments
Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
Shame like to welcome everyone to her
student
contemporary
issues sponsoring a please call
email ist.com
>> this time of the year we prepare for pes
always we about Kum and I was collecting
a few of them and it turned into
[clears throat] really a full shear.
Someone bought a new easy filter become
pes
which typically you screw onto the
faucet and it keeps out the bugs. He
wanted to know if
interesting question someone asked me he
bought a a meat thermometer which I
wasn't familiar what it is but basically
they take they have a thermometer you
stick it into the roast and you can
measure the temperature so it shouldn't
burn it shouldn't dry
someone bought for a new
as we'll soon see not everything is made
in
has to be made by a Jewish company
assuming it's aish company
and before long we had quite a long list
of what we call contemporary questions.
Most of them are new questions that are
not found in
but I want to just before we begin just
to make one point very clear
not every ki is and because it really
depends on the material that it's made
from the of is on the as we know metal
gold silver
or glass a glass
many items items today are really
plastic. So we're saying it once and for
all. We're talking today when when the
material is and wood is from plastic is
so if I say the word strainer I mean a
metal strainer not a gluten plastic. So
to save time we'll say it once and for
all. We're talking about that the
material is the question is the function
is a meat
thermometer is an easy filter. It's the
right material but the question is the
function.
So to make the question
which of
the points out something that's very
important to realize
has nothing to do with a tray for kali
because in mid they first cashed it and
now it's 100% kasha and then they titled
it. So has nothing to do with per se and
therefore
even a new ki you buy a new pot that's
not you have to it
why it's a ki so based on that asked a
question since even a ki is
even a scissors
should also
You should even have to a regular
scissor a regular hammer and for no it
can't be why not this is probably the
most important words for today you look
at the the in the case of mid it was
it was plates and cups and and cutlery
zigmor the only is
it has to be used in conjunction with a
so therefore a scissor a hammer is even
though it's metal.
So this those two words as we will see
is probably the most important words for
today.
Rashi explains that even though
typically you have to cash something
before you ty it but a dafa even a new
but it has to be a suda now our question
is
what about an easy filter what about a
me thermometer is is that considered
so we'll get a good start from the sha
in our sim and today every day is
the sha is the following
>> [clears throat]
>> typically something like a hammer, but
you make a hole in the barrel and that
becomes your spout or you put in a
spout.
This type of hammer, you make hole in
the spout in in the barrel to make a
spout.
Now, the truth is we don't have this
exact thing today. We used to have
something pretty similar. I don't think
I I don't see it around. A regular can
opener today, we picture opening a can
of tuna. You take off the cover. But not
long ago, a can opener had a different
function. You wanted to open a can of
pineapple juice in a can. So you had a
can opener that has sharp edge and you
punctured two holes and then you were
able to pour from that can. So that's
really a
you're making a hole in a can
that is
question is why
it's opening a can of food and someone's
even touched the food. So here we come
to big.
Let's say someone has mischievous
children and they always open the
refrigerator. He wants to get them out.
So he puts on a lock on the
refrigerator. Okay, understandable.
Do you have to to the key that opens the
lock?
Sound like a joke, right? But why not?
You can't get to the food until you have
a key. Terret says
means it prepares the suda. It prepares
the food. The key doesn't prepare the
food. The key gives you access to the
food.
That's [clears throat] why a can open a
his type of can opener is
it doesn't prepare the food. The food
has an obstruction. It removes the
obstruction. That's not
so this is basically the the important
sh a can opener. to my knowledge all
is not
now the
we find that
if you look at the lion in English at
least can opener
it's not a food opener it it's mish can
I'm not bringing a big ria but that's
the a can opener is mish the can not the
food now I must mention that the shak
himself points out the in the hogim
of says that we do toal can openers.
Okay, I looked it up. There's not much
of a but I imagine the is found
says this and he says holds any
the actual preparation anything that
facilitates is also
so although we don't pass like but at
least we see an insight
is not we pass like
What is what prepares the food
I saw both and that even if sometimes
the can opener does touch the food but
it's still not a it's still not a suda
it's still not preparing the food so
that's in fact some say that can't open
it even
you don't have to it because can't open
it typically doesn't touch the food okay
a nutcracker
is fundamentally different because
[clears throat] the nut consists of two
parts, the shell and the nut. So, you're
really cracking the food itself. You're
not cracking a a can. Again, again, I'm
not bringing right from English, but
nutcracker
sounds like it's cracking the nut. The
nut is the food. So, nutcracker, you do
can't open a nut. Apple kora takes out
the center of the apple. Again, it's
touching the food. It prepares the food.
It makes it usable. And that's why a
nutcracker does an apple kora does need.
Now, I'm leaving out peer because there
are two types which we have to go for a
different time. But basically, it has to
be audible
for now. People have a metal even a nice
shabistic trivet. You can't put the pot
the hot pot onto the onto the table. So
you put a trivet a piece of metal on the
bottom and it looks nice and you put the
pot on top of it. That's not
because it's not mish
is fine. It's basically protecting the
tablecloth. I it's used in conjunction
with the suda but that's not the
criterion. It has to be something that
prepares the food.
Someone asked me, I wasn't familiar what
it is, but it's it's called a spoon
rest. Basically, if you have different
spoons being used by the table and you
don't you don't want to put it down on
the table because it gets dirty. So, you
put the spoon spoon on the spoon rest.
It's like a parking for the spoon.
So, again, this is not a cle suda. It's
a protected tablecloth. Even though it's
metal or glass makes no
[clears throat] you look in the gor I
should mention this that
it's cooking utensil
flasks bottles
see it's not cooking but it's preparing
but a spoon rest is not at all
preparing. preparing the food. Now
before we apply this more specifically,
we have to learn one more very big.
Imagine a is starting off his profession
and he buys a new
knife. Now we're talking about it was
made by a guy. Okay, if you made by fine
you I'm talking about made by a guy. The
question is does he have to the knife?
So you're wondering what's the shil if
you have a uh electric knife for example
and a metal blade.
So the metal blade I you cut this the
the the roast not by the table that's
not nice. You cut it before you before
shabas you slice it and you never see
that
that that meat slice or that that
electric
slicer.
So why ter say what do what do you mean
why it's preparing the food you can't
serve a big roast you don't do it at the
table who said that's the deciding
factor so we see no doubt about it a
very sharp knife electric knife is
because it's a it's
so now the question is so why should a a
be different than any other night that
you cut the roast and indeed the tajit's
cut and one of
says
that you use for
you must before you use it makes a lot
of sense big knife small knife what's
the
however the
actually the first page
of
does not require
Why?
Why? And one of the reason he says is
cuz even after the you can't eat that
can't eat a raw behemoth. It's full of
blood.
So the morai is using the word suda in a
very very important way that aita knife
even though it checks the the animal but
it can't the meat can't be eaten after
the preparation that's not aud
And this a new expression of
the
also says that a
does not require.
So we have two examples that
the can opener and now the second.
Now I the question you might ask is so
if that's the case why
pots also cooks raw food that's that's
foolish because it makes from raw to
cooked but a
does not make it cooked it just makes it
kasha and that's the of the that's from
not even now the is the cotton
And the
says that according to this
it
so you have two extremes
but what's makes this much more
important for us the
continues there are other examples that
you
and one example is the needle that you
sew the chicken see they they used to
make stuffing kal
They would actually sew the chicken up.
Put the stuff in the center and sew it
up. The needle that you sew is not.
He says why? Because it's not aud
making a it depends how you identify it.
And then is adds in in the next pi and
this is probably most important for
today that anything that you can't eat
after you prepare it after you do that
that shim is not
for example he says the you skin the
animals with a with a knife
and then he adds and this is the most
important thing I think for today.
We call it a rad. The person in the
matzah bakery takes a he's a and he runs
it over the raw dough to make holes in
it. So mata should not expand too much.
This rad is not
why not there. It's very positive
because after you raid something it's
still not edible. So a rad is very
similar to a sakita
beautiful. He gives a few other
examples. A a a
k you cut the raw dough in the matzah
bakery or you make crepl.
The point is if it's still raw it's not
audish
it makes no difference. That's a
beautiful word. I'll give you an
example. [clears throat]
We we we know that the
isashm.
How about the plastic over these?
That's not that's all the that's already
a watered down version of kadusha.
So he's saying that the is using that
word for our the
is only step one but it's something. So
why can't it be that's
what did the hold? Obviously the held it
has to be something that prepares the
food. It's not totally in the tash. It's
totally inuda. If after you can't yet
eat it, that's not cle
how do we so I'm going to take the
liberty of reading the because it's
extremely important to hear this point
the holds
period not even
there are more
so needs
so far so
Then there
[clears throat] if you have the
you don't have to the anything that
seems wrong with this
I'll tell you what's wrong
[clears throat]
says a second shell obviously
is so why is the ratal
And this is the question that's probably
the most important for today that
impacts the most
and it's sort of a
if I could use that term
holds that even
anything that is even
but you know what he did he gave each
their chance because the the sage
then we saw
okay. So then Ram says behold
but the the was not found in in the or
the earlier that was the
so that goes separate that first you do
the
and then you add your comment and then
he quoted the rad but there are more
felt you would understand just like I
argue on the sit told it's
so basically nothing changed
just like
however there is a sh the has the same
kasha and I imagine he felt that the was
a bit of a he says he quotes he all
quotes and really but the shak makes a
very important distinction
>> [clears throat]
>> Look again at a shita and a rad and
you'll see the skillet a sackita
is tak only for but it's a knife. It
conceivably could be considered an a
suda
but a rad no one ever brought a rad to
his table or used it and anything but
matzah zak a rad that's not used in any
other scenario is not a suda and that's
why it's so in the is saying
it's because it's a big small but
But radius
which reads very nicely when you learn.
So these are these are two shas
again I think the is the word
now
the sh sounds familiar I mentioned
earlier that's really what the the the
isa says he says a pin a needle that you
sew a chicken that's not auda
I see you're sewing it but it's too far
removed from the concept of
so now we have the following
The holds
and that's going to affect many there
are more it's
but the question is who do you pass like
excellent question a number of poison go
with the taz that means anything that
touches food is a number of poison go
with the so in we would say since there
are he's not even arguing he says
he's not saying
So maybe we could say
you go with the
something
or a a sewing need
but the minute seems to be this you look
around that's the minute anything that
touches the food and prepares the food
should be in other words
is
and something similar to that as
>> [clears throat]
>> But
so now to apply this to the numerous
shas let's see how much you can gain
from one simple
[clears throat] someone asked me I don't
I don't see the shila but I'll mention
it.
He buys these very elegant uh napkin
holders napkin rings. It's a metal ring.
You put the napkin in it. It looks nice
on the table. We have to table that. So
it's metal but has no shify touda. It
might be on the table and the nap might
be important and elegant but has no shy
to suda. Okay, more of a question.
Someone has a sterno. Sterno there's a
little bottom that makes the fire. You
have a pan with water that cooks the
water and the the the steam of the water
cooks the food. You have to tell people
the sterno pan a regular metal pan. tell
that's stern no pan. [clears throat]
So you might say, "Why not? You're
cooking water." But it's not true.
You're cooking. You're not drinking the
water. The water steam cooks the food.
So how would you look at the sterno pan?
It's something like a great maybe
something like the fire, but it's not
the food. So although you need that
water, but you can't say that the pan is
considered the cle. Now I want to add a
little more to this. I think it's it's
it's a it's a right way of looking at
it. the place can discuss what's called
an immersion heater. You don't see it
that that often, but it's good for a
traveler. Basically, it's a metal like a
it looks like a round
coil. Very good. You plug it in and it
boils water in a cup. You don't need a a
urn or something. So, the question only
is it only works with electricity and it
does not a kali. But no one says you're
put because
the you're cooking water because you're
cooking water.
So if you see that immersion heater like
many because you're cooking water so why
is a sterno pan pot you're cooking water
it's very positive in the immersion he
want to use the water but here the water
is so it seems that a sterno even that
the even the pan itself is pot. Next
question is a beautiful uh contemporary
question that brings us to the in the
most perfect way [clears throat] and
that's what's called the proper name is
a meat tenderizer
but the way the Hamish way of calling it
is a schnitle hammer sounds pretty
different meat tenderizer schnitle
hammer but what's it different the mis
some people have this it looks like a
small hammer and you bang on the
schnitle it's supposed to flatten it out
so it tastes better and whatever
whatever Whatever the reason is and
again do you have to title that metal
meat tenderizer.
So this is mish
nothing nothing uh more perfect than
that because it's only used for raw
number one. Number two it's not used for
anything else. I mean even a judge might
use it but it's too small tiny little
thing. So
and that's why the say the minist
but that's the minute the
a poultry shear again that's proper
English we call it a chicken scissors
but the word chicken scissors is in I'll
explain to you in a moment poultry shear
actually is a scissor that cuts raw
chicken. Poultry is raw. Does that need
that's like
the so the would say yes.
The question is is would the
agree to that? The answer is yes. You
know why? Because people have a poultry
she that they use for cook for cutting
cooked chicken. So it's it's it's also
understandable that we consider
so that's why a poultry should be
a corkcrew which basically is a metal ki
that takes out the cork sounds like a
real
but has no whatsoever. It doesn't make
the wine. It doesn't make the barrel.
It's probably less of a than the case of
the of the of the madak
at least is making
a a spout. It's touching a little bit of
the wine. A cork screw to my knowledge
all agree is the less you know it's just
taking out his cork. A cookie cutter, a
metal cookie cutter. So it cuts shapes
to make into cookies. So that's the
same.
The only question here is no one use a
cookie cutter
for for any other purpose but for raw
dough. If you tell me you use it to cut
baked cake, no then you
if you only use it for raw dough, it's
once again the meaning is like the to
a metal rolling pin. you have to to that
he's starting to make or pizza whatever
you he wants to a metal not wood. So
again this is the same idea it's used in
conjunction with raw dough inedible it's
and if there's no other purpose then
just just rolling it you're not suda the
sh would hold it the taz holds it and
the minute is to be for the taz today
it's very popular the sour dough so
what's called a sour dough starter
basically you put in the ingredients you
put it into a glass or plastic container
we're talking about a glass container
You close it, you keep it until you're
ready to use it. So whole different not
for today.
You storage is
but this might be even less of a why is
less of a
because it's not even like you're
stoaging um um fruits or vegetables.
This this sour dough is inedible. So
even if it would be a cle for a sour
dough
this is so this would be even less than
a regular cle if there's no use other
than for sour dough we do have the sh
that holds it would be
someone asked me a good question that
was better than it sounds a metal ice
cube tray again typically that plastic
I'm talking about a metal ice cube tray
or an ice crew Ice ice cream maker.
So what's the shila? You're making ice
cubes. That's also an important food.
But
the question [clears throat] is
in the
we don't find in the puk in the gum they
had ice cube. They didn't make they
didn't have it. Maybe it's only in
conjunction with cooking. Who said an
ice cube tray is considered?
It's not true because
cups and pitchers are also
if something is used to either make food
or eat food or serve food, it's this
this ice cube tray is made to make ice
cubes. And he's convinced that even with
even though it's a new phenomena they
didn't have freezing but what's the
points out that even though there's no
problem of ble of tus in ice cube ice
cube tray but so what that's not the
criterion it has to be a suda and this
would be a suda you don't eat the ice
>> what's the difference you put into water
what's the difference it's it's it's an
edible food okay another question a
Beautiful question is an easy filter. So
to remind you a number of years ago
there was a discovery that there's bugs
in the water. So the easy filter people
will not drink water if it's not
filtered. So the easy filter is
definitely
the prepares the water [clears throat]
is on a strainer a calendar is
if it's a metal calendar used to
separate the luxion from the water and
the luxion is fully cooked
it in fact some pois
it's a suda others maybe feel that it's
not a complete tick
The luxion is made. It just gets out of
water. But definitely a strainer that
strains edible food.
If you have a strainer that you use for
uh your barley that you soak in water or
beans soak in water for the chant,
that's different because there that's
raw. But if it's edible, the food that
you strain is edible.
So it should come out that a new easy
filter should be and maybe if you never
titled yours till now you should to it
[clears throat] and the truth is
it's correct an easy filter should need
but here we come to a different angle so
[clears throat]
I see people have these big yo sharel
that are attached to their home or their
business and they don't them I it's a a
real it cooks water a real
that is attached to the ground attached
to the house
is no longer audi
lo in many other areas of so therefore
this
is not a suda because it's not a cle
it's not a cle it can't be a cleuda
Now he's talking about a big vat. But
the
in in
he has a different con and he wonders
why we don't to a faucet. The water
comes out in your kitchen in a faucet.
Now it doesn't sound right but why is he
why is it? So he says a very simple. He
says that why do you have to tell about
the pipes
the piping is besides the piping is
bringing the water it's not a suda it's
piping the water from the reservoir so
the faucet is part of the piping system
not
according to this there would be a good
reason to say that he's built is
but as we said if it's
that is enough of reason to and tak saw
who says that if it's not usable as it
is in other words an easy filter is not
a strainer can't use it on your just
hold in your hand it you have to have it
part of the sink so an easy filter
although in its function is a cle suda
but if it's not a cle it's not a cle
suda
so I'm going to add this sha He bought a
pot. He toyled the pot. That was the
good news. He forgot to to the cover. So
now he has a cover, a metal cover to a
metal pot. He didn't toy it. Does he
have to to it? Number one. And number
two, you make a br on the cover.
So the is that the
inabas we know putting a pot cover on
the pot is
it's bish in a very big way. It keeps
the heat in and it hastens the cooking
process. That's an indication of what
the pot cover is.
It should also be for that reason. But
it's another and typically especially a
ch but many foods if you cook it and it
boils so the food bubbles up or this or
the vapor bubbles up and hits
[clears throat] the pot cover. So not
only is it part of the cooking process
but even touching the food and that's
really part of a different that touching
the food is a very important criterion
in
so therefore the assume that a
is
interesting the ra in the same that we
learned we began with about the and the
ra says
is
but a you put on top of the bread that's
baking is not
because the pass that doesn't touch the
food
and therefore the says this
says this that if a touches the food a
and a
Even with a
question is sometimes you have a pot
that the food doesn't bubble up and
touch the but it seems
that the fact that it's part of the
bishial process it keeps the heat within
that's enough on a cover even if it
doesn't touch the food. [clears throat]
So a pot cover is and even with the brah
of course we should tell together one
braha goes for both [clears throat] how
you have a pot cover say a cover that it
doesn't help for bishop is no bish it
just keeps the food inside of it clean
and sterile for example
a honey dish a glass honey dish is
do you have to the honey dish cover.
No, if it doesn't if it's not cooking in
it and doesn't touch the food at any
time is
there's a very nice cha in the
test. He discussed the whole concept of
of
and he says
a kiso that doesn't touch the food. It's
just there as a haga that no dirt or
debris should fall into it is not in.
So here you have a case of a honey dish.
The dish is but the cover is not
[clears throat]
a beautiful question.
[clears throat] Is a salt shaker number
one? So typically many salt shakers the
bottom is glass and the cap is metal. So
you have two [clears throat] good is a
salt
is a salt dish a glass salt dish you dip
this the into it.
And the third question is a
pepper shaker you want me that's the
difference. So that's that's the of this
question
a salt shaker should be
because
salt is anal you make a salt to eat a
plane okay people don't need a plane but
you make a it's a regular so why should
you need a on a salt shaker and indeed
in fact I saw a bigish if you have a
salt crusher let's say you have hardened
salt you have a special crusher that
that grinds the salt. It's also
because salt is edible.
But here's the catch.
The
end of says a salt shaker is definitely
like a regular cle.
But the question is how about if you
have a pepper grinder
pepper in a pepperc corn for the raw
form you grind that peppercorn. So this
the pin discuss maybe it's not really an
because pepper there is no e plain but
the you use it in foods. So that's a big
discussion if a pepper grinder is some
hold. Yes, but there are but it has no
sh to our sh cuz let's say you have a a
pepper shake which means you put in
ground pepper into the shaker
you take it to the table you add pepper
why is that a if you want to say a a
pepper grind is part no I or not I can
understand because you you don't eat raw
pepper but in the pepper shaker you
poured it into the soup whatever you
want to do. So, it's a food and there's
a cle and taka. There would be no
difference between a salt shaker and a
pepper shaker. Both require
they started selling I I didn't check up
recently, but I know they for a number
of years they had a sp a jar of spice
and a built-in
grinder. Mameish. [clears throat] A
built-in grinder.
Do you have to table that
grinder? So maybe the the glass if it's
glass the glass container is pa because
it's not really a kali. It's basically
like a shell like a container for the
food. We don't the wine bottle the grape
juice bottle because it's considered a
shell but the but but a grade is a
grater. [clears throat] So this was very
challenging to me because I had to know
the mats. I found a beautiful safer on
has a number of volumes on David
page 73. So he did very good research
and he says to his knowledge at this
point maybe a few years ago all of the
disposable grade disposable graders are
made from plastic. Believe it or not
truth is unfortunately we know from 9/11
that a sharp plastic could be very
dangerous can be very sharp. But his
research is that all of these
disposable grers on the top of a spice
jar are made from plastic.
No plastic and [clears throat]
so if you have to keep up to date of
course but if they started making it
with metal that would be a problem at
least the top should be in.
Another beautiful question
[clears throat] someone has a coffee
grinder. He takes coffee beans raw
coffee beans and he grinds them. Does he
have to make does he have to to that and
if yes with a [clears throat] so you're
wonder what's the we spoke about pepper
grinders so why is coffee different
so there's one obvious because pepper
after it's ground is used in its raw
state
coffee grinder that grinds raw beans
even after it's ground it can't be used
it has to be cooked
So how do you look at a coffee grinder?
You think about it. This is another
example of
and who says this besides you
[clears throat]
on the page on
but
so as I told you that
gives us a lot of mileage in the sug.
the
end of
he assumes that a coffee grind is with
that's the way it's understood. So
says why
is [clears throat] very surprising
he says
that's all he says. [clears throat] Now
why is that true? Why coin does the does
the say the
>> oh so some say it's a printing error it
should say taz but they have all the new
no one says that so that's probably the
right answer that since the you could
use this grind for other foods very good
that's why it's even like the mean say
and like certainly it's
an [clears throat] egg yolk brush that
puts a raw egg yolk onto a kala. So if
it's made of the material and
then there's a reason to it but it's
more likely it's in because this no one
used for anything else like the like the
you' be a question that I thought was a
joke but it wasn't a joke.
If you have an Estster box, Estri
pushka, and you're planning on using
your SR after sukus to make estri jelly,
does it need before sukus? That sounds
strange cuz the ma the on suk is not an
the is a very expensive fruit. $500 a
pound is pretty expensive, right? So,
how could you say
it's an but not now? Right now it's a
not aud
but I did see the
sim
he says if you know in advance that
every year you make estric jelly you
have to t the box so if you like fine to
us it seems that it's not a cle
>> it's no
>> not a cle it's only storage it's not a
it's a cle for a mitzvah
next question and this is taka another
Beautiful question. [clears throat] We
spoke about rashana the honey honey dish
suk is now is pes turn [clears throat]
think about this objectively
he bought a new kura do you have to the
the k use on pes so I'm talking about it
was not made by yid that it's metal or
silver whatever it is but it's
the material the question is is that
true
so the truth is there are different
hogs. Some people just put the food on
the kaira and keep it there. They don't
touch it. So why
it's not audly
onto the kra and take it off and and eat
that whatever it is the whatever it is.
So it's a regular
some people keep the food in a glass
dish and that on that they put that on
the so then the glass dish is and the
kra is it never touch the food that's
the right approach for this
so the only point that someone asked me
is but does it make sense it's not
really a food it's a mitzvah but I
didn't find if you eat the if you eat
this. If you eat the the bea, why isn't
it a food? Because it's a mitzvah. No
one says that's in fact the car that
holds the matzah.
You have a special plate for the matzah.
Why?
So that's basically the aora that that
is made by a should have le a really
challenging question.
So you think about it, it's not so it's
a little intriguing because we don't
have anything like this the rest of the
year. [clears throat]
Some people have the minute they fill up
the
before the before the that time of the
after they pour the wine back into the
decanter never use it. So why is it feel
it's a cup made by a but it's not
being drunk. It's not being consumed.
Oh, wait, wait, wait. I'm talking about
those that put it right back. So, it's
So, someone said, "Yeah, but it's clea.
It's storage the wine." That's not true.
The wine was very comfortable in the
bottle. You put it in the for the
mitzvah,
not it's not storage. So, I think it
makes sense. The
that is not used at all. You put it
back. There's no saw say this. If you
use
the wine the kdish the next morning like
some do and I must mention you have to
cover the k you leave wine overnight not
because of giloy because it's it's
inferior quality wine so if you use the
wine the next morning then you have to
it because it's a regular kit it's
preparing for the next morning
[clears throat] the question is some
people have the meaning that they pour
from the kio into all the kais for the
fourth kais
Then the is like a pitcher. It's like
like a pes picture and for that reason
it should be. So again everything has to
with the original
another question that that is not funny
cuz all the po discussed [clears throat]
and that is for those that have dentures
false teeth does that require? So we're
talking about that the material is of
course the metal base of it or and or
the glass content in the teeth itself.
So the truth is for those that need it
grinds the food, it crushes the food. It
it makes eating possible.
But the only issue here is that can we
call it a cleuda? And I'll give you an
aidless empisor for on chabas. You're
not to make
but you could eat food crushing the
food. You're making
the terret is in the food in the mouth.
That's not a
it's called. So just like with one's own
teeth there's no of course but the
dentures are not a suda it's part of a
person and if he could use his teeth to
brush something he could use dentures
in
has another really interesting and he
says there's no kali in the world that
you can't share with others like
dentures
>> kay
>> oh that's what he says if you can't
share with others is not a some say also
another that
this is a very lish
he points to a
test if you walk into the house carrying
a ring a bag so the item tell me right
away but if you're wearing it
it's bottled to the person has a
different
bottle to the g or separate He says if
you wear if you're wearing dentures it's
not a cle it's ble to the person. So
there are few good that it's
not it's not a ki you can't lend it to
someone and also in
it doesn't have a shem
or so too in
the next question is also unprecedented
but and for us it's a it's a very sh to
look to and that is a meat thermometer.
So they didn't have meat thermometers in
those day that's for sure. But the
question is is a meat thermometer that
you put into the meat is
so it sounds pretty much of because it
touches the food and it's there when the
meat is being cooked or baked.
However, think about it closely. It
doesn't make sense because the meat
thermometer is doing nothing in the
preparation of the food. The food is
cooking very well. Ah, it tells you when
to close the fire. So very good. Does
that mean that if you buy a timer that
after 30 minutes it rings to close their
oven, you have to to the timer. If
someone uses a clock to know when to
close the the the roast, you have to the
clock. It's basically a mea in a very
real way.
So it's touching the food. That's true,
but [clears throat] it's not being in
any given way. It's one big me it's
avoiding being dried or burnt.
So that's
but there's a big kash on this because
we find inpace I mentioned earlier
who says if you have a scale
that you weigh foods
and as a has a metal tray you have to
the scale tray because the food goes on
it. What do we see?
That's something that you measuring food
is
this is a glass measuring cup or metal
measuring cup. Why do you have to title
it? Because if goes into it. So now you
could ask so if a measuring cup and a
scale is so why the
but think about it's very posit because
the measuring cup the food goes into it
and you measure it. You take off or add
and then you pour it into the pot.
That's part of the the scale also you
add to it to make the right amount. You
take off and it goes right into the buta
in his ina
says this very distinction that
does not apply to
it does apply to a scale and a measuring
cup. Now someone asked me but but the
misa the another reason it should be is
because the meat is still raw but that's
not a that's not a because it's getting
cooked. Now another point about this me
the
says in Zion this is interesting a
funnel for example you have a big jug of
of olive oil you want to put it into a
small container so the funnel
helps pour from a big jar to a smaller
jar so the mahaba says the says a funnel
that's of the right material
so what do you see
that a funnel like this
I is not doing anything but it's helping
in in in the transfer. So what about a
me thermometer but makes makes has not a
diminion at all. A funnel touches the
food on both sides and it helps using
the food right now. It doesn't spill on
the floor but a meter does nothing in
the preparation of the food. It's just
basically to avoid burning. And last but
not least I'll leave you with an
interesting shila pis of shabas. I
noticed in our house we have a a chik
like many people have a tea bag. You put
a tea bag in or two you add hot water
and it basically gets hot and you put
onto the black and it keeps it warm.
Is a chic a new chinic made metal of
course
because the end of the day after you
make the tea bags in the chic you don't
drink plain tea essence. It's not edible
as it is. You have to add water. So
maybe we'll say that the chinik is
something like raw meat like the raw
meat and is not at least
cuz no one drinks plaines.
So that sounds intimidating but it's
wrong and I'll tell you why because
pepper grind
says pepper grind
I you don't eat it after it's ground.
The terret is
here. The criterion is if it's
completely
processed, if you did what you're
supposed to do, the pepper is supposed
to be ground in the pepper grind. Fine.
No one uses plain tea. I understand. But
is the tea bag completely cooked? Is it
the way it's supposed to be? Yes. That's
why it's and the biggest is
why is a why is a why is
no one drinks plain water hot water but
it's a back says kum is
if this ki makes the full preparation
that's so t essence is a so to a kettle
that's the final preparation I couldn't
talk to you all
Uhoh.
>> Why do
Why do you have to perculate?
sponsor
8651 ist.com
might
Okay, everybody say there's some salad
that's going to prepare in the back.
It's on these aluminum pans that don't
need
>> temp one use single use only pans.
>> Okay, just that's what we learned today.
First of all is
based on the that's why a scissor is but
using heat even a cup even a pitcher is
a [clears throat] can opener is from
nutcracker should be apple should be a
trivet a spoon rest are not suda they
are cle
not
the
is
the shak and
argue about a rad if it's because you
don't use a rad any other context but
the minimum is like the taz that if
indeed it's a touch of the food and does
some type of paratia like a rad should
be toy a napkin holder a sterno pan a
it's not a suda a meat tenderizer
poultry shear should be toyled
a cork screw is it's it's opening a cork
but not the bottle and not the wine. A
blade of electric knife should be toy. A
rolling pin should be ice cube tray ice
cube maker should be toybled even with a
braha. Easy filter does not require pot
cover if it's the right material should
be toled with a braha. Just to keep
clean honey dish cover does not need cuz
it's not max the food anyway. Salt and
pepper shaker if it's the right material
should be toled disposable the
disposable
spice dish that have a a grater ace at
almost all of them are plastic you
should know the matas a coffee grind
eska I don't think it should be to kaira
glass dish
you have to if you touch the food touch
it the actual kaira and you eat from it
then even the kyra itself should be
toyled
yo probably is better to to it because
you might end up using it. Dentures
Dominique is not to it. A meat
thermometer is not
measuring cup and a scale does need a
tinik, a kettle, an urn since it does
the final preparation of the water etc.
That does need filler.