Preparing video...
0:00 / 0:00
Israel Palestine and Groupthink
7,262 views
Comments
Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
I've noticed this interesting pattern,
this cycle that's taken place over the
last almost a decade now. And it follows
the same pattern in trying to assess
who's generally on the right side of an
issue and who's generally on the wrong
side of an issue. And a lot of it comes
down to group think,
being emotionally charged or activated
by an issue, losing all sense of
critical thinking capacity and
rationality, and joining a sort of mob
mentality. We can trace this all the way
back to Trump, right? Remember when
Trump was on the rise back in 2016? And
in the peak of woke leftism in the
culture, it became impossible to discuss
Trump rationally.
His flaws, his virtues, the good things
he was saying, the problematic things he
was saying, that didn't matter. You
couldn't discuss it rationally because
the people opposed to him were so
activated, so emotional, so irrational.
that to say anything that was off from
the group think about him, you were
considered a monster. Years later, with
Trump getting elected for a second term,
looking back on it, it seemed like
rational minds prevailed. We realized we
had made some mistakes. Collectively,
same thing happened during co remember
it became unacceptable to not accept the
dogma that was co had to accept
lockdowns. You had to accept the
narrative that was coming from the
government. You couldn't discuss the
origins of the disease without being
called a racist. You couldn't discuss
alternative treatments without being
considered harmful to society. You had
to accept everything. And that was the
emotional group think. Years later,
looking back on CO, it seems like
rational minds have prevailed. were able
to discuss more rationally vaccines, the
co origins, all of these emotionally
charged issues, trans issues, BLM, they
all had this element of group think, and
everyone had to suspend their
rationality, hold back on expressing
doubt or skepticism or honest
conversation. Fast forward to today,
Israel Palestine. We're almost 2 years
since October 7th. Ask yourself
honestly,
where is the group think? On which side
of this conflict does there exist a mob
mentality of people getting on board,
not using critical thinking or
rationality, but looking at images,
looking at headlines, and just becoming
emotionally charged and to become
completely hostile
to the other side, to demonize the other
side. I come from the pro-Israel side.
I'm a Zionist. I'm a Jew. And I can tell
you that a lot of people on my side are
very engaged with this issue, are fairly
educated on this issue. We've been to
Israel many times. We have family
members and friends that live in Israel,
and we have formed our opinions about
this issue based on both education and
experience in talking to people
firsthand in seeing things firsthand.
Contrast that with the pro Palestinian
side. Ask yourself, have a lot of these
people formed their opinions based on
education and experience, or have they
formed these opinions because of things
that have been repeated to them in the
same way many people formed opinions
about Trump because of things that were
repeated to them or they formed opinions
about co because of things that were
repeated to them. So too, many people
are forming opinions about Israel,
Palestine, and the Middle East because
of things that are repeated to them.
What it means to be rational is to look
at a situation and not just simply be
emotionally activated by it. Not just
look at images or headlines, but
actually try to evaluate what's going on
beneath the surface and not be
manipulated by propaganda. When you look
at the other side, I see group think. I
see a mob mentality. I see people
burning flags, destroying property, and
when you ask them why, they can't tell
you. They just use the same buzzwords,
the same kind of buzzwords they threw at
Trump that proved to be false or they
used during COVID that proved to be
false. And I think when it comes to this
issue of Israel Palestine, while my side
might feel like we're increasingly
lonely and isolated, in a few years
time, we're going to look back and
recognize where the group think, where
the brain rot, where the irrationality
truly was. Just like during Trump or CO
or any of these highly charged issues on
Israel Palestine, ask yourself, who's
doing the group think? Who's a part of
the mob mentality? Which side is being
manipulated by propaganda? The people
talk about public opinion turning on
Israel. Well, ask yourself in the last
decade, has public opinion been right?
Was public opinion right about Trump?
Was public opinion right about COVID? Is
public opinion right about Israel,
Palestine?