Menachos 91

Today's is and we are six lines from the top of being learned as a so we're smack in the middle of a a began with the days that discusses the idea of the So one of the critical parts of a carbon, not all carbonas, but of many many many carbonas was a quote unquote wine libation. So when you think of a carbon, you usually think of the animal. Be it a sheep, a goat, be it a larger animal such as a bull, be it a min and of course the come along with exactly how that offering was brought underrated. together with many of the carbonists. There was a mitzvah to take a certain presubscribed amount of wine, pour it on the misb and it was literally a of the actual it's known loosely as the by the way could be either or almost every single time you hear the concept of you're referring to the one exception to the rule is on sukus where there was a special avoid known as the but the point is that with many carbonas there was this wine libation that had to be brought. Now the para of the where the talks about it in detail is not in but rather it's talked away in it's at the end of parl and I think it's to go through theim again even though seven and a half years ago we went through them a little bit in the end of but really the avoid of today's is going to be after dasha after dasha. In fact, if you count up the amount of dras that we're going to have in today's daf, it's over 20. So there's going to be many many dras all focusing on nuances, grammatical in these that we're going to go through. So I think just to at least have a little bit of a feel a time for what's going on in these and then we'll jump into the d. So the pics says as follows and this is in again when you're gonna come to and you're going to bring a carbon to whether it's a carbon or a carbon whether you're bringing this carbon because he made a nether to bring the carbon or because he made an ada to bring the carbon or you're bringing one of the carbonas that were brought on y lastly And the reason you're bringing this carbon is to make and it doesn't matter whether the carbon is being brought from cattle or whether it's being brought from in any one of these affformentioned situations. And this person brings his carbon the in addition to the buck and he should bring a he should bring a carbon what's known as the ma that's not being brought on its own but rather is an ancillary to a proper carbon. So you should bring a it should be made up of an iso that's an amount of bowl and it should be mixed with the again that's also amount of oil. Additionally, you should bring wine. And this is the punch line of what we need. And the purpose of the wine is to pour on the how much wine should be brought. Now, is this in all situations? So really the end of this is that we just mentioned that's in the event that the car that you're bringing is a sheep for each sheep. Meaning if you're going to bring multiple then you're going to take this number and you're going to multiply it by whatever that multiple is but the bottom line is for each sheep that you're bringing you're supposed to bring that she what's going to bring in the event that you're bringing your not from a but rather from an isle in terms of the nuances between avas and an isle very much featured in today's so in the event that you're bringing aisle well then you're not supposed to bring one of the is a bigger animal as a result it needs a bigger so it's going to be made up of twice the amount of soil it too is going to be mixed with oil but not within but rather that's a little bit more so is 25% of is 33% of again a larger share additionally you're going to bring wine but again more wine how much wine you're going to do this you're going to continues and says what's going to be in the event that was Ben it was cattle it was even a larger animal well then the have to again be increased so it's not one like the it's not like the isle now it's going to be three and it's not a reve Now it's a additionally there's going to be more wine. How much more wine upgraded the same amount says. So based on what we just mentioned, this is the way you should do it. Whether you're bringing a whether you're bringing in and all these situations, do exactly what I told you you're supposed to do. By the way, if that PK seems a little bit superflous is going to dish in every little syllable of that based on the amount that you are going to bring. In other words, are not regardless of how many of them you bring, but for each individual one, that's what you're supposed to do. And then the says even a bigger in the event that a converts going to be living amongst you would have been maybe the par doesn't include the a special in the to teach me that it does the again and even this idea that the parak relates not only to the person that was born but even to the G as well. The bottom line is we just read 16ukim all discussing the same idea the concept of the which tagged along as you see from the many carbon. Now which carbon had and which carbon did not have well that was the Mishna Mishna said whether they are required with the exception. So sounded like all carbonus but then you have to read the not so such fine print with the exception of the the micer the pes the all of these carbonas did not require there is an exception within and where sometimes they do require what is that the and the of the do so at the end of the day even though there's the 16 para of which feels pretty inclusive But at the same time, not all carbon are included. What's the rule? Doesn't matter if it's a carbon or a carbon. It's going to be included with the exception of the pass of the and the with the carve out within a of the mitz and of the then brought a ba a very very long bry that started the top third of the days and went all the way to the bottom of the oven. I think there's a few key points of the bry that we need to over because they're going to be very much naya today's daf. So the began by discussing the PK it's giml the third of these 16 that says when it says the word is a doesn't have when It says the word is meaning had it said only you would have thought maybe is also but that's how I know is not what is that word is coming to be so you would have thought from the word I know that the is going to be included the then said, "Why did the Torah have to mention it's coming to teach me that only something that's brought is included in the parish?" But any that can't be brought is going to be excluded. And that's how we know the because these are all that are not brought. When it says the word is that the did require now doesn't it say already which means but once it says you would think that maybe only but you would have thought maybe not the word that that's going to be included as well and then finally the when it says lastly Why did the Torah have to mention and said it was a between and between according to what the Pik is coming to say is that in the event that a person brings you're not going to bring the soil was said that this is actually talking to the very first where the introduces the concept of of person making a to bring a carbon and the says if you want you can bring right the you would have thought that maybe anytime a person says you would have to bring all of the above in the in the beginning of there is no that they're not all attached to each other and that it's not all one grace of par. It's tucked away here invoker this is the one place that the know you can bring that they're not all going to be according to the is not teaching me but it's teaching me a very it's literally a gilli on the opening verses of teaching me exactly how you're supposed to learn the of the and Either way, it was a little bit of a wordy introduction. Very, very necessary. And as we're going to see, this Brya that we just recaped is something that the Gamarra is going to begin with. Number one, the Gamarra is going to explain the BISA. Additionally, the Bryer only was mafarish some of the going on or some of the in the PK, but in terms of this Pain, the Gamar now is going to be Mov. is going to d a lot of the other here in the paren that the Bryce didn't already either way on that note we segue right into this discussion six lines from the top of so the said how do you know that the is included in the parish of again it says we said so again the price said had you Oh, it's because it says the word is a not a that I need a special to be. Now, why would you say? Well, if ze means a is a type of not just that the when it talks about the carbon it says actually refers to the as you don't even need oh should be we know the said that why do I need a special of say the carbon came together with breads. Maybe it shouldn't require the explains because you would think that the breads meaning a carbon needs to come with something. Maybe that's the of the okay usual carbon doesn't come with anything. So therefore you have to bring the but which comes with breads which a regular carbon doesn't come with maybe the should be how could you say that? Why should this be different than the that's the used to bring which came together with we're going to see later it's a that the came together. So you see that even though there were breads there was still I would have thought the breads of the only two here it's four. So maybe two minim still require but four maybe not. That's why I need a special to tell me that the carbon despite the fact that it comes with four types of breads. It's 40 breads by the way but it's four types each one multiplied by 10. We learned the already. So I would have thought that maybe that's why have to write the word. This is already a cash on the price. Why have to say to tell me it says once I know so I know that anything that's included and is broken. So why do I need now still in that mojo? One second. I need to be didn't the B says I could also be from right. I could also be from the fact that it says and could be it says is the first word. So right away I know but I don't need the word to be because I could always be from the same way that I was from. So at the end of the day, why tell me to teach me I know from the following says I'll tell you had it not said in the mean I would have thought that the way you're supposed to read the P is as follows when it says so that's the opening words of this again this gimmel is very much the focus of the first part of the dishe I would have thought as a cloud when it says that's a proud when The says that's what's the rule just like the pride is mafurish that it's not something that's something that's are both not so I would think we're going to be anything but that are not for that reason the say to teach me that not only is the and the but the are as well in other words the saying the reason it said even though in the price it said that the reason was But really you want the real reason that's why you have to learn the beer of the real reason is to be one second because it says and as a result we knew from there to be right that was what the B said that's true only after I already know once I know then I can be more inclusive in terms of what had not said the word I would have been from but I would not have been now what's the methodology and it's not just that what's the methodology if it says it sounds like it has to be brought so what's this business that had not said I would have only as opposed to something that's brought in which is an is not it's like says it has to be brought in which means can't be but it also means it can't be the it's because we know is always from the right whenever you have a cloud the cl situation. So what's the rule? The rule is that even though the told me a prat but the before and the afterwards is that we have to be from the prat anything that's but the point is that whenever you have a claim more it's true if all I had to work with was so then all five of these and would all be excluded but being that I have a cl so I know I have to be mar so I know not only telling me the father right just to bring out the point a little bit better if I had a clown and a so then I would say oh wow everything that's it has to be so that's a now that I have a second cloud now that was now that the last so now I know I have to bet and be mara more so the question is what should I be marba So the more you're going to be included. It's only the things that have no to the that's going to be excluded. So I'm going to be something that's not but and I'm going to be something that's no to something that's not broken. What's the thing that has no because the of the carbon is a different type of carbon. A current that's broken in is not as opposed to which is which we know is very much a dividing factor in kachen. You can take allas and can divide them amongst these two groups. There's that were brought al and the carbonas that were not. But the bottom line is if all I had was the cloud it's true I would have known but I would have also thought. So the reason the Tyra went and the Tyra wrote the word is and at the end of the day it's for that reason only that the Tyra said the word again didn't tell me to be I know that from didn't say oh which is what the bra said it said for because I could have been from it said to teach me Now that it says so what then do I do with the cloud in other words you just told me very that in this parish there's a cloud which means that we have to be more than a I also know that you can't be knocked that out. So what is the clat being married? I mean, at the end of the day, it seems like the way we're tighting up this is it's a it's meaning something that's brought. Yeah. Something that's not brought. No, but the didn't make it a and didn't put that second for nothing. The put it there for right. So the question is what exactly are we being it's not that that's not included. So the question is what then are we says when other things just like the pride is that these are things that the person wasn't obligated to bring right it's by definition you warn to bring it so to anytime a person brings a carbon that he's not to bring it's going to involve what's coming to so let's say somebody has a carbon that was brought and then that carbon had a baby or Or someone had a carbon that's broken and you made a of that carbon or what about the carbon that was sometimes there was extra or there was leftover of a carbon and they used to bring from it that was brought with or anytime you have a where if it was a it would have been one of the by the used to give it to the past they would give it to the shepherd he would let it roam and graze in the field wait until it got a moment when it got a did and they would buy with it. Wow. The first if a person brings a carbon with the exception of if it's but it's going to be as what? It's going to be brought as a situations where a person has a carbon that's technically as a carbon but you never made a da to bring this carbon. Right? person made a to bring an not the baby that came from it right can't have a baby but the schlam could have a baby or the you are the or you didn't make a nether on that carbon that was brought to or the or the kids but at the same time they are right and as a result as a result declared there should be so is the or is there not based on the if it I would have said no. But now that it's now it's the again the without the cloud you would touch the has to be something that I literally made to bring. Now that I have the color we tight up the a little bit differently. we tie up the prat in a more liberal way that it's and anything else I could be but that's also it has to be something that's bro and that's why all the five that are not are going to be excluded but it doesn't have to be something that was as long as that in itself is going to be oh okay now that we said that the word in this is now where did we say that the word is so if you twice. Number one, we said so we dash in the word additionally the end of the last according to why did say it's to be that if somebody says you bring or you bring you bring even though from the beginning of it's a little bit unclear. So we dash the word oi once I'll leave it to everybody twice I'll leave it to it says the now that we just said that the word is there's more o mentioned over here pun intended in this and really in this entire par of so we're going to have to figure out what do we do with all these other says so what are we going to do to be household. So like I mean I would have thought I would have thought that if somebody says as a nether you don't bring if somebody says as you don't bring it's when you bring a and that's when you have no it's right. That's why said the word would like to teach you that each one individually is enough of a reason for you to bring this is all good. So who's this? It's actually not this we mentioned although it did come up in the on the top of that and that is a that whenever it says in the two things so it means all according to unless the says according to wherever it says two things so it always means the two things together according to unless it says the word I always assume that it means so according to where if it says two things even if it doesn't say I always assume that it means both so I need but that says that unless it says the word it means anyways so why do I have to say the word I would have thought we just a little bit differently I would have thought that because even though it doesn't say I know it's because it didn't say but at the same time I would have also thought that I that if you broke maybe one would work for the two together. Oh that maybe that's the that's not the way it is. So according to I need the word to tell me that and you don't have to bring both according to a little differently very much but it's a different punch line and that is according to I needed to tell me that if I'm bringing a and I bring two I don't bring one said also what do I do with the word now But what do I do with the word? And I would have thought I would think that the only time you're going to bring for and that's maybe if you're bringing or you're bringing what would be in the event that somebody brought an and so he brought a nether and a nether or he brought both binava. So I would have thought that over there maybe we look at the two as one and the two has one and maybe one. So that really belongs like in the it's like it would have said because there's another there's another that we need to learn from there. Now this is already so there too the says so why have to say the word over the it's all the same things when is it that you bring at the very least different but let's bring two You're bring then know that even though they're both listen they're both schlams it's going to be this is very similar to the what we learned out from the right before this from right before this we said there would have been here it's which segus into this last one oim When the says that's in that same what do I need that for I would have thought what is it that it's somebody brings two but let's say a person would bring here's the or the same thing with and here's the point where you have so where it's literally it's the same and it's the same type of carbon so I would have thought in that situation disclaimer for sure one should be enough that's why I need oi and oi and oi to tell me in every single situation anytime you bring a it doesn't matter if it's the same type of carbon it No matter what kind of perputation you're going to be able to come up with in all situations, this is the way it's going to be. We're always between the nether and the says the according to raia. So who's again is from the original said that what do we learn from? Those are the last words of the Bri has been. Okay. So to me, but why do I need the for explained a little bit better that it's a beginning of so the whole punch line is really the it's you know from the beginning of you know from the beginning of but I could think so the word is but according to I don't need that word I and now that we just dion all these So you have to as well. So again, we never had a mention in this because we already knew that from yesterday's but what do we do with the word says I'll tell you I would have thought maybe even though we said in all situations were always right every single situation we had three extra to to work this all out but I would have thought that the only time is betray at the end of the day it's two different animals But if it's one animal then maybe the animals and even maybe the mid that's that creates one that makes it a singular that's the punch line that's what we do with this says the ly this is already impos the We gave a little shout out to this Pik when we were introducing the right we said this is a pretty obvious Pik that we're going to have to get back to that it's a pro right everything that you have over here is for each individual said many times like then you have this one general what do we do with this says I'll tell you there's a thought when is it true based on all these o that you bring a separate set for each animal. Maybe that's only if the animals were being brought as if maybe they're one maybe that would be now what does it mean is very interesting means where the was and he brought them so it sounds like both things you made them usually you don't care when you made it hectish a little but you were and you're bringing them so maybe that in of itself That is the final on this topic that even that not so the shame nether not the shame not even the shame nether and the shame not the min is not and even if the original hectish and the are happening at the same time even that's not that's why the in so many ways went to tell me no for each individual animal that you bring you have to bring a separate set of the bottom line is is that Really we started this part of the daff with recapping the bryer the bry if we were going to do the recap now. So at this point now we know a lot more about this uh bryer right it has a a whole different punet right there was so many little pieces that were added number one in beer of the bryer additionally places that the bryer was matzer which at the end of the day we see now that we have to be right let's just take a quick stab at it says that's a we'll hold that thought for a second but that's a so the bra said is in addition to teaching me it's also But really what we saw is that from the word that's how I know it didn't just say it said so what do I do with the o that was one of the o that theor used to flesh out this idea and that is that I'm sorry was that's the prat in this uh P which ultimately is it's also with the G of the now it said so that was one of the O that was that each individual carbon and it doesn't matter if it it's the same type of carbonim same type of nether doesn't matter if it's the same man. And it doesn't matter if the and even the hectish was done. In all situations, there's this theme of oi that's going to go ahead and and be that was also one of those but they're not being brought they're going to be included. The last that was the second right what we from the cloud isn't it only things that are brought right what we anything that you're not such as or right that's being brought to kids or with the exception of the of the and then finally when it says so according is coming to what is the that's one of the and according to no the is really not even teaching me it's more of a g how you supposed to learn the in the beginning of that if a person says it's only from that there's a lot of various you could have thought that maybe it's one big over that it's really not one big para. Either way, there's a whole another part of the sun that we have to do. So, we just uh recap part one exhaled for a moment and literally let's go with part two. So the Mishna said so in as much as the don't require but there's one notable exception when it comes to the of the are going to yes require. Now why does the not need and it says and even though we have a cloud cloud but the end of the day that for sure is that's definitely not going to make the cut. Okay. So if the of the is and they were already excluded. So we're going to have to have some sort of to that's the of this next is going to introduce what's we learned in a so it says in the par of this is not this is actually it says so together with the carbonus that the brought he also had to bring so we know that the of the is from the or esoteric paras in the not even a question but as it relates to the carbonus that he brought he brought he brought an asham and he brought an now the says in addition to that he had to bring he also had to bring a says the when you're 90 into what kind of was this meaning it's a as opposed to what maybe it's just a fourth carbon meaning This is this a this is the that was brought with certain or you bring you bring you also have to bring a so I'll tell you a regular they used to put the and the between and regular so the B wants to know that you mention three carbon you mention what kind of is the B I'll tell you what it is it's a Maybe it's just the fourth carbon. You're bringing three. Might as well bring four. I'll tell you when it says and that's again in the parish of the talking specifically about his. So it says he should bring the and the why do you put the together with the have you ever so for sure just the reading of the just from the that this is a no. So if the is meaning you see one of the so it's on all the but we need the next part of the idea I still don't know does it require wine says in the now where's this is back in parl this is hey so Again, the dr we had so far were gimmel. We dashed a little bit. If you're keeping score, this is you bring it for each individual, right? It was a different shape for the for the and the bambar. But as relates to the how much wine was reve this is a little wordy that I can live with but I mean how many times does to tell me it's for so this thing's going on over here so says the when it says over here these words so as follows it's coming to me something you know which even when it says you want to know what's coming to teach And when it says the word is also coming to it's coming to me. So you want to know what the is I know it from this tucked away no mention of the but at the same time the extra it's coming to me something. So let's assume that it's coming to me says why do I need to be the from the word and the only why can't I be inside the from the word didn't we learn how do I know the now the context over there says it's talking about the of the carbon theor says that the carbon Nazer had a unique that they would cook the and in the fire that was the would take the here of the and he would burn it. This is one of the mitzvah that had to be done. The sh is what would be if the hear of the nazu was not fab underneath the it was fab of the so we learn from the word zeb extra word in the parish of the rabbis it could be from the and the of the as well but what do you see from it we just need one point we're not learning the now what we need is is that the word zebra two not just one and so why do I need And how do we leave that stuff over there over there? There's no difference between the and the of the both go and accomplish the same thing the but where the and the are doing two different things. The is coming to be and the the and the have the same when it comes to the actually doing two different things. The is being the and it's beingcome again the is being but it's and as a result this person now needs so when the two are accomplishing the same thing one word but when one is coming to do one thing and the other something else they're fundamentally different so then already you need to the bottom line is that's why I need the tube sukim over here. But the bottom line is this. Bottom line is the Mishna said that and are excluded from the with the exception of the of the and the of the what's the is this extra and there's something extra over here from I learn is the is the now it doesn't say one word about so there's No proactive mafurish mik to say that this has been marb obviously I know it based on process of elimination it's going to be marba something and I don't know what it should be so we assume oh probably the soar now is not going to take this line down here could be that's what it is but some that's what it is and thear is going to run through other possibilities knock them all out and then by process of elimination we'll know there'll be an enami in the garbar really of this next several lines of the iss but at first glance it doesn't seem or maybe it is that's the it says maybe from the word that they require right you would say not says and it says only Maybe zak is coming to be marba the kas and the asham of the now notice it sounds like from the word zak we want to be marba the kas and the asham I thought could only be one it can't be too so means right and the real terra said already then in the one word and the are doing the same THING IT'S AFTER IT'S OVER THERE. SO SAYS MAYBE THE word is coming to me. Why? So it says this is with regards to the carbon of the it says which by the way is a giloy is a giloy that the nazer used to bring ms. All right before but stating that's talking specifically about the it says now this is tricky is but it's in the par of it says so here too the mentions and it's talking specifically about the says the word was what does it mean? We know already from previous that the Naz was an idle. So why does the have to say you want to tell me and that you need to tell me but the fact that the is the if you look two three earlier again it's very helpful to know of but if you look a few earlier you'll see that the already told me that the is the and this is the and this is the sole wants to teach me something is something that's so too the only times the carbonus of the Naz is going to require that's such as the which is and the as opposed to the or the right just to be clear every single used to bring when did a nazer bring an asham that's the nazer to when he's becoming t that's when he used to bring his asham but the bottom line is any type of carbon of a naz Be it the or the not at the same time but be the or the is he would not bring this we said how do I know that even means maybe now by the way why would I even need a to be why do you need a to be mar it's Because even though it's but right now it's being brought I know but isn't it anyways what's the answer if you hold so you see no it's not true when it's being brought you need for it so maybe here too you need a re as well but the bottom line is now said that you want to know why is not because is excluded it's included wouldn't mention the mission if it was excluded it's included but the reason is is because I know from the end of that kind of says when it says in the end of the same exact that's coming to me this is this is the 11th animal of which is brought as so what's this case so this is we used to call this the guy who was drinking on the job right so somebody was counting his mahima he's counting 1 2 three and then when he came to number 10 so he by mistake when he came to number nine right when he came to number nine he by mistake said I'm not drinking on the jaw when he came to number nine he by mistake said 10 and then he oops I said 10 for number nine so then by 10 he said nine now really he was supposed to say nine by nine but he knew he had to say nine so he said nine for the next one and if he said when he said nine for the 10th. He ended up saying 10 by the 11th. So they all have some level of kadusha. The first one cuz he called it the 10th. The second one because it is the 10th and the third one also because he called it the 10th. But the bottom line is that 11th one which has a little bit of kadusha. Why does it have a little bit of kadusha? Because of the fact that you called it the so is from the word not the it's the first of the next set. It's the 11th. That one is going to be included and it's going to be now to the laws of because it has a and it's being brought. Now why do I need a for that? So the price says because really what's the whole of the 11 it's it's to the 10 and the doesn't it's right it's one of the five exclusions. So you would have thought that how could it be more at the end of the day this is going to be but the bottom line is you want to know why from not because we already from bottom line is if you make a for let's just finish said you know you have a lot of good cashes over here we said Maybe is maybe is referring to the or just alone is referring to the Nazer because I have nothing to DO WITH IT. I'LL SHOW YOU THINGS to do with it. So no, we said reasons. You can't tell me the carbonus of the because it's excluded from the extra aisle in the par of the and you can't tell me the because it's from the next word says the you don't have to back into it even though didn't say the word but if you had a real you'll know that really this is what it means. How do you know that? Because the way you like a set it's a set of three and this set of three is coming to talk about one para that's going to be three different uh carbonas what's the only thing that has three the only thing that has three is the and that's how I know to be mar the three the bottom line is what's the is the mitz is the mitzv is the regardless of how you get there by process elimination or not process elimination it's all the same is coming to is coming to be that farmer who by mistake referred to the 11th as the 10th that carbon 2 even though it's really a tough to doesn't But it is going to have either way. So we've been dinging all these. So let's continue along. Why did say really in just in the segue of the last that we mentioned were the next words in the right goes through individually more than once what you bring for the Kev, what you bring for the what you bring for the bamber. Right? So the feels that all these mentions are a little bit extra and the sh is what do you do with these words? So we were now what do we do with the word isle that used to bring there was a specialisle that used to bring and that is what we're coming to. Isn't that just a a carbon and all the yonas were ready? Maybe the carbon is also my is like a lion rabbit. So maybe it's only the carbon but as it relates to own personal maybe not. What are you going to tell me? There's a between when it comes to we just from the word. So maybe I would have thought maybe that's only maybe the so it's a little bit more than a so maybe that even though it's a that's something you could be as opposed to the which is number one it's a maybe not And it's also so it's not so I would have thought that should not be is coming to me to tell me that yet. So from the from the says so we dash in a lot of in today's what about the we know what to do with but what about so the says lari says aalus it's coming to be the infamous palus so what's a palus rashi says apalgus this is very interesting a palgus is an animal that's finished his first year of life but didn't start a second year. Where does that mean? Right? He's like in a time capsule like by definition, right? Can't hit the pause button on time. We'd love to, but in the meantime, we haven't figured out how to do that. So, the bottom line is what does it mean? It's what is this concept? What is that? What's this concept? So the beer is is that uh a sheep during the first year of its life is referred to as a caves. Once it's 13 months and older, it's referred to as an aisle the zar that 13th month. So it finished the first year. It's not a kev anymore, but it's not already after the 13th month. It's not in the 14th month of his life. That one month that's when the animal is known as a palgus. says the you want to know what is coming to teach me it's the it's as it relates to are like the so you have to upgrade it right it's the bigger as opposed to the which is the smallest says really this is this is all good who holds the palgus is a it's own creature it's not avas it's not What's the martus? It's a cre we're talking about somebody that went and was made a nether that he's going to bring a palus. So the question is like what do you bring now? So the Mishna says that if you went ahead so you bring the nisim of a you bring the of an isle. Actually, Rashi says the case is the other way. Rashi says the case is where a person made a Nether to bring an isle or a Kev and you ended up bringing Apus, right? Six of one, half a dozen of another, but the other way just to read Rashi. So, a person made a Nether to bring a a Kev or an aisle and you went and you brought a a palus. So it says the Mishna that what you're supposed to do is you bring the of the but at the same time you're not going to satisfy your meaning you're going to have to go bring depending on what exactly your nether was said how do you know that the of the is the you want to know what do we had a different shot. He said that the person is supposed to bring the of the but at the same time he's supposed to make a and the reason supposed to make a because supposed so what's the is like this if the palus is an then it's all being brought to do and if it's really a second or the additional then I'm bringing difference between the re and the that's being brought to But the bottom line is according to there's no that the of the palgus is supposed to be like the it's according to me you have to make the and if that's the case it can't be is coming to be why because it's I need a positive to tell me what you're doing a mat of sophic everyone knows what you're doing a mat of sophic t is filled with hus and dus you know exactly what you're supposed to do I would be needed to tell me that apologist Even though it's a suffic but in it's an but in the world of that it's not an it's only suffic that you're bringing the of the so says you're 100% right don't have an but we very much do have an again those four words is the is The 11th of the Oi is the palgus and is coming to teach memor that it says in this par and this is this is mish at first glance. I mean after you tell me the of what you do with the and the and the and the and you tell me in the next I know it's for each individual one and there's a thousand already that were for each one you bring a separate so why do I need the to tell me this is going to be the topic of the last part of today's says the what's this all versus you find between the right is the as opposed to the I would have thought I would have thought that when it comes to the Benbak it be the same thing. So the Ael is when it's in its first year the par is when it's in its second year. So I would have thought just like there's between the first year and the second year when it comes to this the so maybe it should be the same thing for the when it comes to the it's one doesn't matter how old how young it's always going to be the same why did the say over here says you see this between the first year and the second year when it comes to the campus in the so maybe when it comes to the second and the third year it should be the same thing that says one is once you're an isle you're never going to be anymore so the is the male right so you find by the male the first year and the second year so you would have thought maybe when it comes to the female it's the same thing the is the first year and the is the second year again to be all to each other. It makes no when it comes to sit in a cave. And finally, why is this in this case? Just like this in the first year and the second year when it comes to the sheep. See, he would have thought when it comes to the goats, it's the same thing. The and the maybe should be different. So, which is which? So, Rashi tells us and the isu. Okay. So you would have thought it should be the same thing to tell me it's all the same. This is a little bit of a test at the end of today's said once he said he said how many how much was brought with the so again what's the is the female sheep when it's like the isles age it's already two years what was the right he wanted to know is it like the or not in the doesn't say anything about the just says by the so you want to know what about the he asked a good way and we were able to be from a and this is a perishim the background to the Mishna is is that when a person would bring the together with his carbon so you didn't have to arrive in the B mikdash with the oil and the the wine and everything you could show up with money as long as you had a credit card that in of itself was enough and what you would do is you would and you would meet with one of the right you have all the so you meet with the on the and you would tell him what carbon you're bringing and he would tell you exactly what you're going to need how much it's going to cost you swipe your card he gives you in return a card this little ticket and the ticket basically was a simmon like a receipt of how much money you paid and exactly what you're going to need you take your ticket you bring it to the vendor on campus and now you're going to get whatever it is you need to be able to go and bring you a carbon either way. So the scholum says that one of the tickets would said that's what it says. You know what it worked for? It was if it said so you it worked regardless of whether you needed to bring a male or a female or whether it was a had to have its own thing. What's the is the is because then of the sheep of a the only difference was was the says is going to be between the versus the ones are and the other ones are but as relates to any other combination you can come up with it's the same in other words the ks under all included together with each other it's all one and the same and it's for that reason it's for that reason we're able to be from the bottom line is we did a few short recaps along the way. If you want to recap this properly, you can just now of and go through all these different and not just learn the hopefully they have meaning and at this point even either way just to conclude with two. The first story is so the topic of today's d was very very much hopefully this is not news the together with carbonis not all carbonis but together with many many many carbonis there was a wine libation that had to be brought there were by the way just to bring out in our own mind what a big deal the was the whole of all those that we learned together is a a person a very bad person who's going and he's pouring wine for his gatka for his deity for his pagan. The point is is that was a very very basic form of aoid and there was a that although wasn't primary in the mikdash but it was secondary and it was something that came along with many of the carbonas. Now why was brought together with carbonus? You take a look at the right here in parl. So he has a whole on the and then he concludes as follows. He says the whole idea of bringing a carbon in this way where you have the animal and then you have the came along with it and then the it was because once upon a time where there were kings and if you had that were going to bring some sort of gift to their king. So and they would bring bread they would bring flesh and they would bring oil to make the food that they're bringing good and they always bring a a little bit of wine says when aid brings a carbon he's bringing he's bringing food for but by the obviously The way you is by being but says it's the way the used to bring he would bring he would bring he would bring a little bit of she and he would bring and that's the of the way we're supposed to go ahead and we're supposed to bring our gifts of course the of what is saying is that we spoke about very much in the and that is that on the most simple level what the mikdash was what The mishk was is like the ram says right in the beginning of bias it was a bias for and talks about this throughout his in these parish and really all the say this idea and that is the was a bias for and the was living in the miktan says that's why para came immediately after mai because mid arena was the law. Well, if we're the nation who's the mel, the mel needs to live amongst the nation. That's always the way it is. And as a result, we have to build a bias. You build a bias and you're spiritually fit is going to come. and that was the that's what is butas has a when you go to a bias to greet the king you bring him food and that's what the but the point says that when you understand that in the simplest level that's what a carbon is so of course you have to have and who would ever feed somebody a meal without a little bit of wine and it's for that reason you're coming to feed it's that you would have to give a little bit of there's another very basic elementary point that we need to mention as relates to and that is why mentioned in in why is it not in not in not in now there's mentions of prior to parl but the para of which carbon is all the drious that we saw in today's daf they're in parl from all places why would they not be why would they not be in the paras of so really the giveaway is right in the beginning of the par in other words it seems a little bit from the that even though there was a mitzvah of but the wasn't until the came all the of the mentioned in these when he gave Mishka at the time that were in the midbar but this is already from the and as a result this is in a separate par and it's mentioned in getting closer to preparing to go to so it's over here it's in this context it's over here that we mentioned the truth is all quot that discusses whether the midbar or they were in the midbar on some level for sure the were it's then and only then that you're supposed to go ahead and bring the so it seems like that's the reason that this was singled out but it's and the reason is because the location location of where the mentions the parish of the is flabbergasting is right where does it say it's in parl you know where in parl right after the parish of the miracle the mentions the parish of the mira right if you look at the right before this the last that's the story of the that's a story of all that but the bottom line is is where did the mention the par of it's right after immediately following the story of the maraglin and all the asked the kasha why in the world would the terra feel that the right place to mention the is over here I saw this says and it's the for those holding in the says that to bring a carbon when the is an add-on to the carbon had the not sinned with the maraglin they wouldn't have needed that add-on they could have been by bringing the carbon and that in and of itself would have been enough Now they needed their carbon to be in order for their carbon to be they were going to have to do more. And that's why it's after the parish of the said now we're ready. You can't just be with the now you're going to have to go ahead and do more. Why is this the if you remember holds that the was a result of the he learns like that the paras and it was because of the that they needed aka in fact the says if you look at the right after says right don't make it fancy you could do whatever you want wherever you don't need temples that the Egyptians used to have. Anything is going to be fine. Then all of a sudden, what's going on over here? In a perfect world not with it would have been you don't have to make all these fancy IN HIS OWN HEART can have we don't need temples to connect to but the problem is sinned. There was and once it was we fell and now we're ready. We need to do a little bit more. This is this NEXT which is the next. Now again we needed to pick our game up a little bit. We already have a mishk. We have all the carbonas. Now is the was as a result of the just like the of the wasadesh in the world of the as a result of the mish right here of an art in this par but the that's brought down in the is a little bit of a different says maybe the reason was with Theion of the right now was it was to give the and to give them because they were very sad. They were they were giving up had just sinned with the mira said that because you cried it's going to be and you're going to be in the midbra for 40 years and no one from this generation with the exception is even going to go in and it's going to be your children your grandchildren they're the ones that going to ultimately go ahead and they're going to inherit the land. But the yidden looked at themselves and the yidden realized we just lost on what we were promised. Imagine, you know, when you think of it in the context we just finished, right? We're still holding PES. When you think of it coming out of Pes and we did it all the was to go and the was for and then everything got lost. It's like an incredible postcript when you when you internalize it in a very simple way. Everything was the the deflation was and they were told but the are going to go okay okay okay you could live vicariously through your children that's that's a very noble thing that's very but they were saying themselves that in 40 YEARS MAYBE OUR CHILDREN ARE ALSO going to sin I don't even know if we're going to make s and he saw they were in a state of he saw they had given up so he wanted to go ahead and he wanted to be them wanted to give them And he gave them the how he gave them the he told them the parish of the and the pars he gave them a mitzvah that's and when they heard that there was a mitzvah in the words of the was a that they were going to enter the land at some point. So the reason it's placed over here, it was an it was a it was to give them a little bit of hope that despite the fact despite the fact that in their minds right now, who knows if we're going to be to be able to enter the land said no you're going to be able to enter the land. We mentioned in the past that this used to say over in the name of his father who said over in the name of who used to say so it comes out the whole parish of the was a parish of but why this parish there so many different parishes in the maybe so many he said because the says wine was created to be that's the of wine it's to give somebody a pickme That's why the created one coming off of Yontiff. But that's the whole Indian of what is all about said. He said wanted to be like Ramban said. How was the he was them with because that is the is the that's exactly what wine does when says really the pour is also like said that we're giving there was a certain of whereas was morning and And the of what we do in a it's all with wine. We're supposed to be but the bottom line is it was through the par of that is the rest of the story. That's why the para that immediately follows the par of is the para of the wine. We'll save the second raid bite for tomorrow. A wheel stoper.