Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
this Torah class is brought to you by
Torah anytime.com
who has
a
Ben Ben you have the piece the back
up
oh here it is
s
okay okay we
just
thear and
the the says made a name for himself how
did the how did make a name for himself
says
thear now if they would have asked me
not that anyone's asking me but if they
would have asked me how which book in
the tanak did make a name for himself
with
the last book on my totem list would
have been
melester cuz it's the one book The Only
book that hashem's name does not appear
how in the world could kazal say that
how does Reon make a name for himself
through mikill I mean that's probably
the last choice that I could think of
how the ream made a name for himself I
was always bothered by this
question the mar even learns that the
gamar is bothered by this question but
this is an important question question
on
this the opens up his comments on just
interesting just uh an aside know the
when the
begin he says the word ha two times you
ever notice that theama says a ha a few
words and then he says ha again which is
a Pella the R's it's one comment it's
one note it's the only time in the
whole continuously talking and he
says so they say from the that like many
who would like to begin their saer with
the name of
with3 that's the that was R's way of
starting with
the but the's very first comment in is
as
follows
summ I place before me
always with something that we need to do
always
likewise with another thing we have to
do always so in we have these
two just like we have
the we have
two one
is the other is
the one is dependent on the other if you
want to be happy if you want to be
a the way to get to that
madga is
through
the if you see the before you always
the you will reach the M
of and that's what we want to speak
about tonight how did make a name for
himself and where do we see this madga
in the Mig you know it's an interesting
thing you ever notice the tells us that
one of theim that we add
to primarily consists of four you
make you
make you make and you
make they once asked the when he was a
little boy why in that order so very
simple you
know first you
say you drink it
then you smell it then you see it and
then but that's the but then the ra says
we should addim of
yesu and one of the that we add of
course is from and we say every
we say it during the three weeks we say
it during the nine days we say it ER of
P it doesn't matter when the entire year
we invoke the Yeshua of and we
say why did the
of legislate to say this and of all the
we do say we specifically are when it
comes to
but interestingly that's not the only
connection between
and because the wres it's interesting
thing I I I was not familiar with this
it's actually brought at least the this
way when you smell what should be says
the passing this way you should
have in
now say you don't have to you don't have
to because they dry out and if you're
only going to have you're not going to
be able to make a but the agrees it's
better to also have then that's how the
so if you're a you need to have and even
if
you're
to to the why
say but then he says the REM is it
says
so it says the word
and so therefore says the it is
appropriate as you're remembering the
shabis to also have a remembrance for
Hadas and of course we know that PK is
Dar for referring to Esther because that
PK that we started to share
with says is a reference to Esther
it's also interesting the writes
randomly in one of the that when he
looks at the N
of of havdala when he looks at the auka
and it has to consist of two n to him
the two of hav represent and that's what
writes so it's like every every
procedure of havala you're basically
kering over the salvation of PM you know
you're remembering
you're remembering you're saying
the you remember and the
two why every shabus do remember purm
it's not PM it was
shabas someone asked you an interesting
question one of the great G who graced
these
Shores absk I believe was here in
England and he says in the penultimate
ofel
that P is really teaching us how to
approach M because the second to last
the M
reads if you want to know the might and
the
strength you want to know all the
Intrigue you want to know the whole
story you want to know the historical
context wrong book don't look
here go look in the chronicles of Persia
and media ask absk what is the Milla
telling us does Milla want us to go to
the British mum open up the chronicles
of Persia media and read what is called
the rest of the story what is the Milla
telling us says rsky the Milla is
telling us the central principle and how
to approach Mill eser and that is don't
think that there is a sentence or a PK
or a word or a letter that was brought
that is written just to give you a
better picture of the historical context
and the times no every detail every P
every Prat is written for one reason and
one reason
only and if you think that there's a
that's just there so you have a better
appreciation for the times you're making
a mistake if you want to know about the
history of the story
look in the chronicles of Persia
media and it's so interesting because
the next p in the mill excuse me the PK
right before that seems to be
random how does perak
begin taxes the
people really that's great great to know
I'm so happy I know that that imagine
that's how the Milla
ends taxes the people who cares that's
the climax of The Miracle per that's the
summit of the story you know what not
only were the Jews not killed not only
did we kill the amim but taxes the
people that's
that's too much
information it seems like useless
information why is this included in the
story this is the question of none other
than the brisker of
wants to know why does Milla include
this information that taxed the
people we would like to present a novel
approach to this question that in fact
this p is the Highlight is the summit
and the highest point of theh of the
story
of so H's coming to give a advice he's
listening to his wife Z
Zar says go to the king tell the king
that you made this Gallows 50 tall and
we're going to hang M so just then
couldn't sleep and he's tossing and
turning and says who's in the courtyard
and H was coming to tell the king says
on what Al on the
tree literally that prepared for him
who's the
him simp understood that hon prepared
for M but the gar is bothered obviously
he prepared for Mor should just
say why does it have to
say so
the H thought he's preparing it for Mori
but in truth H Was preparing it for ham
he was preparing it for
himself and in these three
lines and these three
words here in lies the central principle
of
Mester
not this is the of
meler we say
in
you didn't just foil his plan you didn't
just sever his plan you didn't just stop
his plan
you what does that mean
you look on
the that level of is such that we would
think that if you have some
anti-semite
who's in office and they're plotting and
they're scheming and they have
machinations so we think the comes and
knocks them off and kills them and
removes them from office and makes sure
their plan do not carried out no that is
not all the does he takes it a step
further he's not
only
he's what
does
mean says you know in America we have an
expression you know play
ball says to the Russia I don't need to
kill you I don't need to knock you off
you tell me what your scheme is how you
plan on harming CLA Israel and I will
co-opt hijack harness your plan to kill
you I will kill you with your plan
that's and that is
the
thear sanen gives it another name thear
sanin says there was a man by the name
of
oada now aadya had very
interesting aada came from Edomite
converts and by the way what's amazing
is who's saying this lesson
raer I once saw in the writings of the
barbanel why is RoR perking up when it
comes to a teaching
onada because nobody knew about Edom and
as and Edomite converts better than rer
because we know rer descended from Nero
Kar Nero Kar was an Edomite convert R
was the expert on the ad so in this gar
the says like this there's a man by the
name of aadya aadya is not a long safer
it's an easy safer to learn it's one
peric long
I think it's something like
and prophesied about the downfall of Ed
and the gar wants to know why did O
prophesy about the downfall of adim and
the gamar says because oad was a convert
from Edam and he grw up grew up among
rash and he didn't learn from their bad
ways so he's going to prophesy about the
downfall of ad about who grew up among
sadik he didn't learn from their good
ways and then RoR gives the final
cracker says RoR you know what you call
this from the forest itself comes the
handle for the
axe you have a Forester he's chopping
down tree after tree after tree after
tree that's right the tree after tree
and we ask him you know R Forester the
the hatchet that you're using where did
the wooden handle come from and he says
it came from this Forest itself from the
forest itself comes the handle for the
axe from Ed himself came the who propes
the downfall
of this is a principle
in that has such control over events
doesn't have to take someone out knock
someone off he says I'm going to play
ball with your plan you pick the plan
I'll use your plan to get back at you so
the stier stier gives a few examples of
this a few classic examples you have a
guy by the name of Paro par makes a
decree that every Jewish boy who's going
to be born is going to be thrown into
the river and the reason parro made that
decree is because he saw in the
astrological signs that the m is will be
born py says I can't let the the Jewish
savior be born I know he's going to be
born today so we're going to knock off
the Jewish savior we're going to throw
the Jewish savior into the water so is
looking down and says you pick the plan
yeah you're going to stop the Jewish
savior from being born because you're
going to throw them into the water
listen up
par Y is going to throw baby mosa into
the water your daughter basa is going to
pick him up she's going to bring him
into the palace he's gonna cry at night
and B say Daddy I'm so tired would you
mind rocking this little baby that I
found in the river and you're gonna say
okay fine and Par is you know rocking
mha to sleep at night par is feeding mha
bottles Bas says you know Dad I need
your credit card I need to go buy
formula I need to go buy clothing I need
to pay for his tuition parro paid for
Mosa's tuition parro raised mosa par
woke up middle of the night parro you
think you're going to stop M Isel you're
going to create m is you think you're
going to terminate him you're going to
raise him you're going to pay for his
rent and
board we can add another interesting
nuda you knowz asks that why did hash
have it that MOS has to be has to grow
up in the house of
Parra says if mha would have grown up
with the rest of the Jewish people they
were a they had a low morale they had a
slave mentality you can't take a guy who
has no confidence and a Slave
slave moral slave mentality and make him
the leader of he can't be a king was
a who's going to teach M the protocols
of royalty and Leadership
the
par par trained M Ru to be the leader
of you know we have many important
people in our history you know Abraham y
how
about you know without doesn't get his
just deserts you know how much credit
par not for Paro we never would have
left M we wouldn't have a toyra today
the only reason we have a to is because
parro trained mha to be the leader of
the Jewish people Ezra says parro you
think you're going to terminate m is
your Gaz is going to
produce everything that you know
leadership you're going to give over to
this kid you're trying to kill this is
the principle
of what we see what happened to
is and there are a few amazing examples
in the
Milla so first of all you know Zares
tells ham that you need to build a
Gallows 50 amamos tall why 50 amamos
tall Now isn't that absurd according to
K then this Gallows was like you know
100 feet tall thear says a person
doesn't even look above 20 who in the
what kind of insanity is it to build a
Gallows 100 fet to you can't you need
binoculars what kind of a is
that so Zar was very smart Zarah said
you know if you make any if you make any
other plan then a might have second
thoughts about it he may revisit it he
may ask somebody's advice what should I
do to you know um might not make an
instant decision but if you have this
100 Gallow tall uh tree staring in
parro's face staring in's face then the
moment you tell you know we need to kill
Mori he's going to make this instant
decision he's not going to think about
it he's going to be very sudden and he's
going to say just hang him so go tell
make the Gallow 50 tall cuz Zar figured
this way will make a rash
decision which is exactly how H was
hanged when when uh Zar tells you
know so if a would have been in any
other other
circumstance would have thought about it
he might have asked advice he may have
looked into it but because that Gallows
was steering him straight in the face he
just said okay oh there it is hang him
so hamon basically dug his own grave the
whole of Zar was so that should agree to
hang immediately which is ultimately why
H was
hanged now this is very interesting you
know in the beginning of the
story a has a problem with his wife he
doesn't know what to do with
vashi so who does he
call
the king is asking
advice why is the king asking advice I
mean if you're the king of the
world the last thing you need to do is
when your wife doesn't listen to you you
have to ask the advice of some
legislation I mean can't you give the
guy what what did it mean he was a you
know he ruled the whole universe why is
he asking the advice of
the so the gro explains the Milla is
about to tell us
why
[Music]
cuz the law in the land was as follows
that a could always make a unilateral
decision he could always make a call
about anything all by himself but when
it's to him when it's relevant to him
then anytime there is a judgment there
was a question that was relevant
specifically
to needed to ask the advice of the uh
of his legislation says the that's the
meaning of
the however if that's the case I have a
question in the end of the story so a
guy by the name
of so ham takes the misstep with Esther
and says oh here's the Gallows so what
does
say him wait a second I thought the rule
in the land was I thought the law in the
land was that whenever a case whenever a
sha is relevant to the
king the king cannot P himself he has to
ask the advice of his legislation how is
the king allowed to just unilaterally
decide to kill hamon says the go you
have to go back to the beginning of the
story what do tell by the way who's M
everybody knows m is H so M tells
there's one
thing bad law bad rule that's ridiculous
that you're the king of the world and
you can't make your own decision Visions
from now on even if a situation is
relevant to you do not ask anyone's
advice you should have the only scepter
you're going to make your own calls
you're going to make your own judgments
why should you ask
anybody who new legislation Want It That
should be able to make his own
call of now why did ham make that
legislation that the the more power has
the easier it's going to be to kill
Mori thank you hamon for your suicidal
legislation cuz hamon just knocked off
himself had hamon not changed the law of
Persia he'd still be walking around he
could have gone to he could have said
you know you can't tell you can't say I
should be hung you know you need to
speak to legislation of Persian media no
once issued the
law
now was able to
say and the rest was
history there's another very interesting
grow if you look at number
23 in par gimmel gim the says this is
the decree
of we're going to send out books in the
hands of the
runners so what does the document say
the document says that the Jews are
going to be
annihilated but then
says what was the text of the
document
be ready for this day you know like
Beware of the eyes of March beware of
that day and and what's going to happen
on that day it doesn't say so you have
twoim and they're talking about two
documents and the document says
specifically what's going to happen and
the document says absolutely nothing it
just says beware of that day well says
the grow very simply H is a very smart
man he knew that if the official
document said that on that this and this
day the enemies of the Jews will
annihilate them the Jews will call up
the local Congress person the Jews will
you know call up their politician give a
little shad and we'll get out of it like
we always do so H needed to keep the
threat of annihilation secret
therefore the the sign on the wall and
all the communities just said Beware of
the eyes of March be ready for this day
but it didn't say what was going to
happen but hon told all the runners by
the way let me tell you you know FYI
some uh some highly classified
information we're going to be killing
the Jews on this
day says the gr it's a good thing hamon
did it this way hamon thought by writing
the documents this way he'd be able to
get this plan to be executed without us
being able to defend ourselves but
ultimately when Esther petitions the
king and Esther says somebody wants to
kill us and we got a problem because
K will never resend the document says I
don't know what I'm going to do if I
signed that the Jews could be
annihilated on that day we have a
problem so looks at the document and
guess what the document said officially
nothing it just said Beware of that day
Sav says great we're just going to turn
the tables and we don't even have to
finagle the document we don't have to
make new legislation and now the Yen
will kill theim and that is ultimately
part of the Salvation
of so time and time again we see that
every idea every notion every
machination every scheme of hon of Zares
wasn't foiled it wasn't
stopped took it hijacked it co-opted it
and used used it against them hamon
thought he was going to be able to kill
Mori by changing the law in Persia that
the king could take the law into his own
hands that's how he killed himself H
thought by making a Gallow is 50 amamos
tall it will be easier to kill Mori
that's how he killed himself H thought
he'd be able to get us so that by us not
knowing what would happen on that day
that's how the tables were
turned by the way this is the principle
of
why does do this why couldn't he just
you know have lightning come and hit H
that would have also solved the
problem why could the just knock down
the tree why does he have to make it
that every plan of H and zes should
backfire on
them soar has
a the author of
The writes in
his
that you see the perm story is very
tricky God's name is not in the Milla
which means we don't see any open
Miracles so how are we going to
recognize a
KES so we would tend to think well we
don't see any open Miracles but the
random collection of seemingly
coincidental things strung together it
could not be a coincidence clearly it's
the Y hasem over here I mean that that
should refuse and Esther should become
the queen and that should overhear the
plot to kill the king and Esther should
invite onto the party I mean it's got to
be the hand of God but says
the person may make an error and say you
know what it's a coincidence maybe it's
a
mikra says b when there's no bik and
Hashem is hidden and we don't
see and the the shame is not apparent
what is the single greatest
demonstration
that when the says you pick the poison
and we'll use it on you this is the most
open demonstration of the Y hasem in
theas this is the side of
M so
that it has to be
then that if the Milla is ending then is
taxing the
people this can't just be a way of being
mag the miracle but it has to be in
this um method and this procedure as
well so I had an opportunity I was
giving a sheer once a week in Queens in
New York we were learning say for
Ezra and we're learning about the
rebuilding of the second B mikdash you
know there's this guy
dares and the Jews they don't have they
don't have money they don't have money
to build the second temple they're
running out of goods they don't have
animals to bring carbonis they don't
have salt they don't have oil they don't
have uh cash they can't Finance the
project and this man by the name of Dar
yaves by the way he's a he's a yish guy
he's a Jew he has a mother who's one of
the sh EST
the father was a little bit of a nut job
but that's beside of the point
dares dares calls in
Ezra and dar says you don't have money
you need support you need financial
assistance no
problem you take a look in number 43
44 the decree is issued
tells his officers you need to cooperate
with the Jews to rebuild a
temple where is it going to come from
the Royal
Estate from my tax
money and whatever you
need inas whatever you're missing you
need Bulls you need Rams you need cows
you need oil you need salt you need
wheat I will supply the fin es and the
and the resources to rebuild the second
temple wow nice guy
dares I'm assuming it it cost money to
rebuild the second base of M it was
quite an edifice and he's paying all
this money from his Royal treasury of
the tax Treasury and how could you not
help but think where in the world did
Dar yish get all these tax this tax
money from to rebuild the
second you know how the Milla ends Milla
ends with what would might seem to
appear as random information that a tax
the people no this is not random
information this is the summit of the PM
story because while the Milla begins
that is having a sud celebrating the
fact that the
prophesied that in 70 years the temple
will be rebuilt and it wasn't being
rebuilt so says the temple will never
ever ever be rebuilt and brings out the
Cale of the mikdash to
celebrate and was looking down from Shay
you're celebrating the temple will never
be
rebuilt this party that you think is
celebrating that the temple will never
be rebuilt you're going to kill your
queen and you're going to have to bring
in a new Queen named Esther and you're
going to have a Jewish child and his
name is going to be dares and then after
you tax the people he's going to give
all the money to rebuild the second
temple so you think this suda is
celebrating this suda was the Saba of
the
B so while Milla opens up in the party
that was
celebrating reine the Milla Ends by the
end of the story friends a has become
the chief fundraiser for the second B
mikdash now there are who
learn that H actually gave all that
silver to annihilate the
Jews and if you look in the N Ezra dares
takes a k 10 Kikar 100 Kar of
CF and he gives it to the yiden to re
build a second M mikdash where did he
get all the silver from thank you H H
also is number two in other words if you
had you know the like in every show they
write the builders and the founders and
so if you would go to the second B
mikdash the the gold page the main
builder of bayi thank you very much
number two the Platinum builder of the
second
mdash that's the climax of the
story
says ran the story is not finished the
ran writes that after daes took out all
the money and the tax money and the
cattle and the sheep and the salt he
gave back the of
the learns supplied the C that had
defiled at the in the beginning of the
PM
story but we're not
finished cuz now there's a man by the
name of neya and neya he looks depressed
he's all sad and he goes to the king and
the King says why are you so upset and
says you know the walls of Y lay in
Ruins King what should we do about it
you think you could help us rebuild the
walls
of and the PK
says there was a sh sitting next
to dares and the gar says the Shel was
maybe a dog
the malum says no you know who the sheal
is the sheal was Esther Esther dar's
mother was sitting next to him at the
time that NE petitioned to rebuild the
walls of and she's giving him a kick
under the table say yes do it do it
Finance rebuilding of the walls of
Y so it's
half the Milla begins takes out the
of the mikdash and he's celebrating that
the B mikdash will never be Reb
built that very suda was the siba that
vashi should die and he should marry
Esther and he should have a and should
take all the money
of and rebuild the second mik and
rebuild the walls
of and this is the ultimate
demonstration
of is not random it's not historical
detail it's not to give you
context this is literally the
sh the summit the greatest demonstration
of in the M you
know we see this
great and this could definitely help us
reach madga of
sh to recognize is always in front of us
but the highest madga I don't think
is to put Hashem in front of you always
you know there's a big Kasha in the
Milla the re's name is not in the Milla
how did hasem make a name for himself
with mikra
Milla could you
say that you know we have this book in
tanak where there's another name that
doesn't appear you know who else doesn't
appear in Mester not only does Hashem
not appear
is doesn't appear how many times does it
say is in the Mig how many times does it
say in the Miga how many times do it say
Bob in there is no mention of the Jewish
people in Milla sester isn't that odd we
have a new name in millas sester you
know what our name is in
Miller
yehud
yehudim what kind of name is
yehudim KES right look at the name
Yehuda and you will
see the name Yehuda is the
sh plus
the the represents how is the of
the but the chair is about to to and
is the name Y is the
ultimate of the sh and
the perhaps through the story of P we
reach the
MGA where it wasn't
just that we place the in front of us
always but an even higher M
than is that the the awareness of the is
part and paral of who we are where the
shame is
nrau and in that case there is no safer
in the entire tanak where the Reon is
more found than Migel but where's his
name his name isn't there his name isn't
there it's in us it's
us we were elevated that the allowed his
name to be called upon us that's the
highest M of the awareness
of
that's
beond who says the
RAV Who quotes
RAV bra
ofas Sheilas are you going to name your
kid Sheilas what kind of name is Sheilas
I mean for real you're going to name
your kid Sheila what kind of name is
that Hungarian name what kind of
Sheilas it's a boy
Sheilas
that re writes Rao writes and if you're
someone who lives
with what do you think you're going to
name your
kid of course you name kid Yehuda that's
the of the of is not that is here and
I'm here is that you should live with is
part of you
and then if you do that you'll
be that's the greatest the greatest is
if you live
with you
reach when you
reach you
have and this is what we achieved
through the miracle of par
perm is the greatest
day chabas is a pretty good
day but chabus is very
tough
there's that women don't drink from the
of and there's a question why not and
women take this a little too
far if a woman's by herself and she
needs to make abdah she makes havah and
she drinks the wine that's the best
option but all thing if she has a
husband there she has someone to make
abdala she doesn't drink that's a Min
why in
the there's a there's a from he says
women don't drink from abdah because
women like to emulate s who's on the
Madre of shabus throughout the week in
the tent of s the bread stayed fresh
throughout the chabas the N was do uh do
the whole week the was always over so
therefore women don't drink from the
narab
they can't bring themselves to be M from
shabas they're on such a
m but we don't have a choice we have to
be mdil from shabas we have no
alternative can chabas comes and chabas
goes we have to be
mdil you know but the gar says that
originally if you look at the the way PM
was legislated it was
legislated and then later on it
says
and you ever notice that the M discusses
how at first tried to legislate Y and cl
did not want to accept it as a y I mean
are you kidding me if somebody offered
you a free yam that's a day off of work
who wouldn't accept the yam why wouldn't
we accept the yam so hner quotes the
MS that he heard not in the in one of
these you know one A different
from that says the reason why we didn't
accept p as a yam is because if P would
have been a yam we would have to be M
from p and a can never be
from so
every it's such a sad
time we have to be M from
shabas we have to
say we cannot be connected to shabas
anymore soaz say don't sweat it because
there's one day that you never have to
be MD from
you never have
to you smell the you remember Esther you
look at the narrow you
rememberer and you recognize that P
is per is a day where we live with the
awareness that it doesn't matter what
thee against us Hashem doesn't have to
abolish it he could manipulate it and
hijack it and co-opt it and if we feel
that then we reach the
M PM is not only one day a year we carry
it with us throughout the year it's uh
it's through PM we recognize how is
constantly with us and thereby we're
to thanks so much thank you brandise for
arranging uh my comment and until next
time you've just experienced another
Torah class brought to you by Torah
anytime.com