Daf Yomi Bechoros Daf 48 by R' Eli Stefansky

Good morning. Ah, what a day. Oh, we need some volume here. Let me see if I could do this. But don't worry about it. It's good stuff is the most northern Fore! Foreign! Foreign! from What a kiss from Hashem, says you, the Carmel. I've been doing the D study since without missing a do a a day. Since without missing a day. This happened to me yesterday. Keep in mind this is not my profession or what I do daily. I was simply helping a friend when this happened. And the is dedicated by our third and brand new corporate sponsor dedicated by services and honor. He's he's using already signed up. >> Beautiful. You see, he's already he's already doing business because he's a corporate sponsor. He probably bought the floor because he sponsored the day before. FDY Kensington satellite location. Ah, the only thing they're missing is Cheers. But besides that, [laughter] they have a computer. Everything's galding. >> United, United, our United David Kryberg and Mark Ashkanazi MDY United Polaris satellite location brings us sminking fus to the first flight of new daily 168 to a Viv to Newark. And this of course is in Miami. official Nathan Kamanski Ariel Fishell in honor of our David Pesaki and Naomi Hounder as a host for all our feels to be answered. You see Naomi David Saled me solutions dedicated Dr. travel shar dental services and is sponsored the new corporate sponsor dedicated by Lucid Services in honor of Rebelli Moa Halburn and Ellie St.Arick foundation. Gratitude for all you do for MDY. Plenty gratitude to all of At least he calls himself something different than anonymous. Another three for the complete >> [clears throat] >> The are monthly sponsors of he went for business but every day he knocks on doors and makes a matz of goes to satellite location. >> Where was he last time? >> Cleveland. >> Cleveland. He went to the tower. tower new partners in Cleveland bring him to the family and the Mexico City community at large Marty and Leora Fineberg with gratitude to Hashem for his many gifts including her belly Stan fireman's wife muchem for Stan attending the asad where where is he ah Oh, really? >> So that's it. You're in. >> So this is your to the family. >> Wow. Welcome. [music] Let me I don't want to. We got to do this right. We got to start. Do you want Stan sitting right by your ear every single day? Is this an okay thing? I can put him on the other side. >> He's quiet enough. Do you want coffee? Is he Can I have coffee? >> We got to got to make sure that I don't want to ruin your experience either. I don't want any of you. >> Stan, you got we was later when it's not on in front of 60,000 people. You throw your under the bus like that. the sus family from Mala. If you see Stan sitting in the back of the total opposite corner, there's a reason you where is he here today? He was here and he didn't go in. >> Ah, he came to this yesterday. I recognized him. It took me like 5 minutes. I'm looking at him and this and that and all of a sudden it's [clears throat] younger from Austria. from Benhind my MD wire mayor Ben was nifed last year after tree fell on his car should have an aliyah anonymous in honor of Chief Benny and Mark and all MDY staff for all they do is initiative for the month Ellie Freeman in honor of Mati Freeman. So as you know we did our fourth. I forgot to mention nobody even told me up to today that the second is the same as she did two. And who is she? Mati Bellski sister. >> It's it's unbelievable. It's not it's not a coincidence. Two great minds. He came up with the idea and she's implementing it. Yeah. Friends of the anda in honor of MDY. I didn't see this yet. in the honor of MDY number four and Jacob trapper 27 to 29 year olds this per like this is this was the this was the idea behind it mdy.com >> beautiful is beautiful the whole thing is beautiful art great story [clears throat] turning of the anchor healthare Beautiful. >> Okay. >> Yeah. >> We are starting. >> Yeah. It's a little You know why? Cuz it's only 8 minutes into the D. Like something's something's off here. >> We're holding by the Mishna. I hope. >> But before we start the Mishna, I want to ask you a question. And I asked the Hebrew shear. They got low grades on this question. Very low grades. And I'm I'm going to ask not to say the answer. Don't say it with I know you want to spit it out. Raise your hand. If you say yes, it's the right hand. If you say no, it's the left hand. Then we're going to go one by one here. We're going to have to This is a question that applies on a day-to-day basis and everybody should know it, but there was a confusion. So here's the question. If here's a question. Say, is there anybody in the room that's a Bakar that was born with a ceserian? >> You're a Bakar. You're born with a ceserian. Okay. >> Who? Anybody else? We have two. >> We have a Spanish speaking and English speaking. And your son, Lauren? >> My son. >> Your son also. So, we have four in the room. Maybe you guys shouldn't answer the question. Don't look at their hands going up. But here's the question. You guys that were born with ceserian and you were first born. Do you get two parts of the hal? What do we pass? You get two parts. Raise your hand if you say yes. Let me see. What do you say? You're you're a ceserian. You say no. You say yes. You say yes. But what about you? You're a bakar. You say yes. You think yes. Who else? So we have a no and a yes between the ceserian people. You say yes. Now everybody else. So everybody raise your hand. Yes or no? >> Yes. Yes. Yes. We got a no over there. We got a safet. We got a mus. What are we pasking? What are we ping? Not a >> yes. Says yes. Okay. No, I'm just happy cuz uh I was learning and he says everybody knows this. I said no, they don't know. They don't know that. In fact, they don't know the because the is you do not get two portions of it's a kdish. It's a big kesh. So if you went home with this, that's it. But the thing is that we're going to have a lot a lot of more kush from today as usual. And I think it's a big big that people don't know it's yusha today tells me that it's in in the that he gets the two parts. I said, "No, no, bark is going to hear this tomorrow." He says, "I only have one brother. I'm going to fight him out on it. You knew this. I saved you. You owe me." What's going to happen is there's going to be like family feuds now. Like give me back that apartment you took. The guy that took the already last year, he's going to have to give back. Going to have that's anyway. So let's see this inside. [snorts] Now listen to this question. Y'all, you missed a good one. You missed a good one. A B that's born with a ceserian. Y is born in ceserian. Does he get two portions or one portion like his brothers? Ceserian. He gets two. That's why he came late and you missed the he gets one. See what's I'm saying. You never know what you're going to miss. That one minute. That one minute I saved you. But listen to this. Uh I'm aar and I was not born ceserian. So I get two portions and my father actually did a pigeon ben and I did a pab I got two pions. So let's look at the Mishna. What kind of do you have to do a bend like I did and also get two portions. What do you mean? Every normal isar that's not born gets these two things. And the Mishna continues in a case where the mother miscarried mal some sort of sack full of water with. So the answer is the mission. You're right. Of course there's a normal bkar. We're not talking about that. I'm talking about in a case where she had some sort of miscarriage beforehand. Where does it remain of a 100% and there's no issues with his and his that's even in the case where there's a miscarriage of how dug we searched high and low high and low what does it mean she gives birth to something that looks like a grasshopper look YouTube and I found something that's really appropriate for Knock himself just holding. [laughter] Oh god. Anyway, that's that's the best I was able to find on YouTube. So, that's not considered a birth. So everything after that is a full-fledged for and for and a woman who gives birth or or miscarries before the 40th day since conception. So I heard a misa here in the neighborhood. Somebody came to Rob and said that his wife had a miscarriage in in in the 80th day and I think either he came with it or he told him that it was 7 mm. The whole thing was 7 millime. She said if it's I don't know what what [laughter] he told him. He says 7 mill they they measure it 7 mill. So he says 7 milliliters is not is not it's impossible that was 80 days by that point it's already I don't let's call it 20 15 20 he says when you come with seven that means it's less than 40 days it's automatic less than 40 days just based on the size. So ask your local rabbi I'm just throwing it out there. He said this what happened was she miscarried before 40. The lea was at day 80. You're right. The lady was a it's two different and based on that he said that the next kid is 100% thear with the with everything all these things if she gives birth she miscarries some sort of sack with fluid in it water blood whatever it is I'm sorry the next kit coming up is 100% the bkar for all purposes for the uh here for both yusha and forben for both things. So this is this is what we're discussing and if you look there's a hay over here and that that hay indicates that's a kid born by and the following kid the first one is also not a the first one doesn't get two portions and the first one certainly doesn't get a why does he get a because he's born ceserian but he doesn't what do What are you asking? You looking it up? >> No, I'm sending it to my kids. >> Ah, good for you. You just made him. He's like, "Wow, >> his stock just went down >> big time." >> Is pointed out if it's in the it's a different story. >> Yeah. Yeah. I I said that I told that to last night also. If you want to go away from Allah in your this that. You're basing it on maybe if you're right. I'm not a but uh Uhhuh. >> Well, what does it say in there? No. >> Tiny part, >> right? Yeah. Yeah. What we do is we give a tiny part for the mitzvah. But in this case, you don't give a tiny part for the mitzvah. You don't give a tiny part to show that that's not the mitzvah. And either way it's not. >> Ah, you're saying that a lot of people they take the second part out of the and they just they just do a sim they do how do you say in >> token >> like a token. Huh? >> Nominal just to show that they're Yeah. >> also gift [cough] to give to give a to give a girl Yusha. A lot of people give the daughters Yusha. That's also that's >> yeah we it's what we learned. Oh now this is super interesting as well has a that's hard to understand says that this person actually had two the first one that was born in 19 97 is a barl and the second one that was born in 2026 he's a bkar he's also bar there's a you know quite a difference years between them born to the same mother but they're both because each one accomplished something else. One was born by ceserian but he's the first so he gets two parts of the yusha according to the second one was a pet. So the second one has to do why not why do we say that the one that was born by ceserian does not receive two portions of the the Are you going to see if you did here this morning? Yeah. >> Tell him about what happened here, but tell him that in Hebrew is much worse. So I told him, I said, you not you you're coming with a different perspective. You're coming with this perspective that everybody knows these that you know, and I'm telling you that he couldn't believe it. He couldn't believe it. Vald delay he brings up it's not it's not it's voy by the way I didn't know it either that's why I guess that other people won't know and and I gave shir on this I watched my shir last night to to see a certain thing I get like I know I gave she on this but I still don't remember one you would ask me what he gets two portions >> I was thinking the same thing we were all sitting there we also all heard it last time >> yeah we all learned this together actually all four of us well I don't were you yet? >> Yeah. >> I don't remember when you came. Oh, from Yeah. Quite a time. Yeah. Yeah. Sorry. >> Yeah. Yeah. That's why you got to do his handwriting underline that one thing on the whole page there, you know. Okay. I get developed. >> Um, and here, this is me in this that chair. I just I sent this picture to Kobe. I said, "Make me a slide that looks like this." Like this idea. Yoshi's off for a few days taking vacation. I think he's coming back. When is he coming back? Today. >> Tonight. I just said >> I I I gave that chair. It's here. Anyway, so shout out to Kobe. Yeah. Why Why does the first one not get anything? Because it says for the It has to be a birth. That's not a birth. That's a Why is no opinion? We know this. It has to be a And why is the second kid? Why doesn't he get in your case Shia? Why doesn't he get two two portions? Well, not Shia. Is it Shia or >> he's the second? You know what a father cries the same way about his Bkar son. He doesn't care whether he was born a sazir, not sazer. He's going to miss him. He's going to have the same pain. The racial the pain of losing the bkar that's what causes double but this bkar wasn't born normally he's born by cesarian he doesn't get it >> no the second one >> the second sorry you're right you're right you're right you're right the fir the father is going to cry about the first one that's why the second one doesn't get it still here you know how come the second one doesn't get the five this is what everybody understands that you can't be you can't have two bkaris in one family. The first one if the first one was born first he's thear but he's not the so that's it enough but the second one what are you going to say he he wasn't born first but he's not a racial but he was born naturally and that's why he should have doesn't work like that you have to have both things going you have to be born naturally you have to be the first one that the father cries over Omar tailored the he has another that tells me that even if it was you get two parts why it says tailored any way you give birth to why I find that very interesting but that's what he says that you can be aar even for one aspect and that whatever it is even if you weren't born first the fact that you were the forces your father to do a ben So on today's daff we're going to see many things that we already learned going to sound very familiar and the reason is because we learned many of these when it comes to animals >> now we're applying it what >> exactly that's why I was looking back we the same issue about before and after we learned about >> what which issue that we're coming up right now >> we just did >> oh also raised before Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Exactly. So, here comes even more. A woman who never gave birth and she gives birth to twins and they're both male. But what's the case? What is the case? You don't know which one came out first. There's a mixup. No. Does the father have to give a five? Does the father have to do? Yes. He has he doesn't know on which one, but he has to do it. claim the coin. >> You said your father told you on you. >> Oh, we're going to see. There is right now he has no he the is on the father at this point. First 30 days. >> No, no, no. He has there's no right or not. He does he have a 100%. >> We don't know on who. We don't know on who. >> Said the kids have. You told me >> that's something else. When you grow up, when you get older and you But right now on the first month, it's a baby. You don't have a thing. So on the father if the father never did it >> when my father's claiming that he might have not done it because he doesn't owe and I just actually just saw where I see going to get to something else that we are suffer what they said you have to do something the have to do something because they're only forgot where I just saw like two days ago anyway >> fight What? >> Why don't we do so? We don't give we don't know the burning, >> right? Maybe they have to do it. Okay. But if one of the two dies, then all of a sudden you have an issue. Why? Because maybe the one that died is the f is the firstborn. And there's no we could say maybe the one that died is is not it. If the father died now we have to understand when did he die exactly. The Gar is going to discuss did he die before the 30 days and there's no yet or he died after the makes a big enough on whether his property was has a lean already to the to the if it happened if he died before 30 days there's no lean there's no for him to pay the if it happened afterwards there's already a lean so the two sons are around so now there is like you were saying there's on them to be part of themselves If they gave the money before they divided the that's it. In other words, there would be to give now also forget about they didn't do so. So they didn't split it. So they would have to give the kite. So it stays by the kite. If they didn't give the money to the kay before they divided up. Why? Because now they divide it up and then the kite is going to go to this one say give me give me your money. And the kid is going to say I'm not thear go to my my brother. He looks a little older. He's going to go to his brother and the brother say I'm not the go to him get sir and once again we have the same question that a lot of people are thinking in their head how could the come and demand money it's the whole sh of khan the best I saw really is that we say shanim when when there's a father about to do a pen so no particular kay could come over and say cuz he has the he has the to give to whoever he wants but when is denying it. When he denies it, then a can come and grab it from him. Sort of that's okay. But that's not the point of the point is is there not says even if there's no even if there was a sorry, even if there was the vision and you got 50%, he got 50%. The can demand his five. Why? Because the the the um the state Oh, that's a good word. The estate has to pay the kite. Not the kids. The state has to pay. On that is going to ask what do you mean the state has to pay? Could you demand money from any of the children? You didn't make a demand. So how do you go directed to the state without going to the children? You have to first go to the children and you can't go to the children. Why? Cuz this one's going to tell you go f. So we have a problem. How do you go directly to the state? That's question on this. But what if a woman gives birth to twins that are both one of each? Again, these are we saw in this when it comes to an animal. If the can't prove which one is the firstborn, it might have been a female. So there's nothing he can't get anything. [clears throat] Says he went right away. When did the father die? He died after 30 days. Why would there be any whatsoever? Hold on a second. I got to say to some of the guests who are the guests here. Oh, what's your name? Sadic at the end of the table. >> Ronnie. >> From Manchester. >> Oh, where you from? >> I live in Ireland. >> In Ireland. >> You You got to go on my board. Where's that board? [laughter] >> Yeah. You said there's an idea, but it's not up here. >> It's a good idea. No good idea. Oh, he watched this year. You're constantly How long you doing this year? >> Centurius. >> Really? >> Wow. >> Thanks to him. >> You brought him in. >> Who's this guy? What do you know from my student? >> Bis. Wow. So, what what's a There's a There's a whole minion. There's a whole thing over there. >> Minion of house. [laughter] So anyways, this is this is the Judaism. This is your English guy basically. He's holding you together kind of thing. >> Wow. Wow. What's your name again? >> Ronnie what? >> Ronnie Gorowitz. And you live in Ireland with a bunch of cows. I love it. Ah, it's great. Okay. Thanks for coming. Thanks for joining us. >> Who else? That guy. >> Who do we have? >> Who? >> Oh. >> Yeah, I saw you. >> Yeah. Yeah. >> Cleveland. >> Laser from Cleveland. >> Yeah. We were here. We're here visiting my my son had a little baby girl. >> Maz. Maz. First. >> Wow. Number four. >> And four girls. Okay. Yeah. >> Very nice. Mazletov. Mazletov. Okay. Anybody else want to say hello? I like this Ronnie guy. Ronnie, get over here. Get over here. We got to I got to meet Are you a shepherd? What are you see? GET OVER HERE. COME HERE for a second. Get over here. This is crazy. Ronnie from Ireland. This is not This is not a joke. [applause] Maybe Nakman Ster has to interview you. You have to share. This is not a joke. And he actually looks like your son, by the way. He has a resemblance to your son. >> Just the glasses. >> No, no, no. It's the smile. The smile. >> The smile. Okay. >> What's going on here? >> Well, where did you You were born No, you were born in Manchester. >> Yeah. >> And you made it out to Ireland. Why? You drink a lot of whiskey or something. [laughter] >> What are you sitting down? I need you to sit next to me. Sit down. But I'm worried about >> No, [laughter] sit down next to me. >> Get a coffee. I guess I haven't had a coffee already. [snorts] >> Um, >> what's going on, Sadic? [laughter] >> Tell me what's going on in Ireland. >> What are you doing there? What are you working? >> I live on a farm. So, >> EMS. Yeah, that's why I said the cows. I wasn't trying to be >> Wow. You know, anybody else on the farm besides you? >> Yeah. Yeah. We're about 10 people. See, >> just you're hurting cows. >> Not the whole day. Do other things as well? >> I'm assuming they're all like nice f boys over there. >> Yeah. >> Any any of them Jewish? [laughter] >> Look, just you. >> No, no, no, no. It's not. >> There's another guy that's Jewish over there. >> There's another Jewish woman. Oh, you >> So, it's good. So, you're doing the da in Ireland on the farm. farm. >> And what do these guys think while you doing the D on the farm? >> It's a great idea. >> It's crazy. You're going to make them all gay. Maybe. [laughter] >> Wow, this is crazy. >> Every now and then they come have a look. >> Okay, have a seat over here. I need you to sit next to me. This is nuts. This is Muga. >> I was already sitting there. >> Okay. Okay, you can go back if you This is okay. Next to Mati. Thanks for being here. Wow. It's unbelievable. >> Wow. Okay. >> Said Mati said it never changed his life. >> What? Oh, the daff. Yeah, but someone else's life. >> OH, I DON'T KNOW IF IT changed his life, Ronnie. Did it change your life? >> Added to my life. >> It added to your life. Okay. So, it added as a change, by the way. Just it's it's you're fighting with the fact added. You were at 90, now you're at 91. So, it changed to 91 and then addition. Okay. Great. Mi, did it add anything to your life? Let's not. No. Love [laughter] it. Love it. You're to bring to this year. That's to me that's an addition. >> That's addition to for you, NOT FOR ME [laughter] >> FOR YOU. YOU'RE NOT you're not you're haba guru. You don't have this. >> Ask me when I'm in. >> I don't have to ask. I know now. I can tell you right now. That's this is our argument. I guess that's our argument. Okay. I won then. You just don't know. There's something you don't know about. Fine. Ronnie, let me know when the is I want to be Madakushian on a farm. [laughter] I'm not gonna be I don't want to be there. It's going to be crazy in Ireland. The guy's in Ireland on a farm. I don't know if you what just happened there. You don't you don't even what the the state already owes this the five. How can you be there's a there's a famous story about a that was on a train in Europe and all of [clears throat] a sudden he sees bear bark bear. So he walks over to thinking in his mind this is in yeshiva we're already going through the sug of shud for a whole month and we're binding is she considered a half a or a half a or this or that the kids are he's like this is my opportunity the most guy I could find he he walks over to him he says what's she or it's a he looks at him he says is and then it's passible I don't know for a fact he went back to yeshiva and he told the am that a sh is a she and the yeshiva worked on those words for another two months what does it mean a she is a she the point is it's a sh how do you say she in English [laughter] >> like the >> [laughter] >> There's a lean. There's a lean. Lean is a good word. There's a lean on the property. You had no right to divide it and give it up between the children. There's five slime that must go to the kay. So, you must say that the father died within 30 days. So then what difference does it make if they made a division of the state? Once you go to one boy, you say, "Hey, give me the five slime." He'll tell you, "I don't know what you're talking about. I'll go to my brother and each brother that he goes to, they're going to push him off to the other guy. So even if there was no there's it should be the same thing. What's the difference? Each brother in all situations will push off and not pay. So here comes we're going to hear two and it goes like this. Boy say think about it. If you're in in Williamsburg or you're in your let's say and you you get you lend money to a guy, you ask him what's his name? He says, "My name is Nakman Ben FGO." Chances are that there's another Ben FGO or maybe another two thou 10,000 of them in just like this. Yo, Ben, whatever the names are in and then there's there's in Crown Heights a lot of men and Vishn and they all have this and then the mothers they go by the mother also they take the rebbit. So you lend money to this guy and you come to him and you tell him hey give me back my million dollars and he tells you what are you talking about? You have to go to Naka that lives next door and he goes next door and he says it's not me it's the guy over here but kids here sir what do you do? So listen to this unbelievable kadesh. Let's say there's only two Ronnie uh I forgot his last name in Ireland. >> Gurwitz. Wow. That's a name. >> Yes. >> I [clears throat] I didn't I didn't think about that that when he said I didn't put it together. Now I'm starting to put it together. >> I [laughter] was like he lives in Ireland. Gurwitz. We're not we're not even going to go there. That's why he didn't want to say his last name. Okay. Now there's a little hesitation there. Okay. Ronnie, do you have connection to Rabi Gurwitz? Okay. >> Okay. So, no, I'm saying he's I know Rasheed is looking down now. He's happy. >> Oh, I meant his father. >> Yeah, I meant the grandfather. Anyways, fine. >> That's your father. >> See, it's not his father. It's not Rabbi Guru. Okay, fine. He's related. So, he says, "Listen, we're in Ireland. There's only two burits, is there? Two Ronnies. Two Ronnies. Okay, great. So listen to this. You can't go. You can't collect from one because each one says it's not me, it's the other one. But then the two Ronnies, these they decided to buy a farm farm with a bunch of cows. So they buy a farm and each one owns owns 50% of this farm. Now the lender comes and grabs half of the farm. Why? Because half of the farm is his 100%. He has a half a farm here because between the two of them, half of it is his. And then he tells the two of them, "Go break your heads together. Which one owns the other half? It's not my problem. In this farm, I have half. I'm going to grab half." You hear what's going on here? It's a beautiful kesh because there's a guy here that's really getting messed up. He has no nothing. He He never knew he was alone. And today they're taking away and he has to fight in courts. Which half is his? So, let's see inside. There's two people with the same exact name and obviously you have to say the first part. There was a loan and the guy didn't want to pay and he blamed it. It's it's not me, it's the other guy. >> Yeah. They bought a field in a partnership. The the lender could take up to half. Not the whole thing. up to half because half is for sure is because he says if I'm going after you I'm taking your part of the land if I'm going after your friend. The half that I'm grabbing now is either yours or your friends. The rest is not my problem. The the property the state of a person is an arav. What is an arv? Here's an arrival that in their disproport you can borrow money. They'll give you money interest free. >> I need shekels for a minivan. The family keeps growing. >> No problem. Bring me an arv. >> What's an arv? >> An arv is like insurance. If you don't pay, he pays. [music] Will you be the arv? >> Yes. >> You understand? If he doesn't pay, you pay, right? >> Yes. [music] Thank you. Slowly, slowly I say this every time. I'm going to say it's a public service announcement. There's a big mitzvah to be an ARV, but there's no mitzvah to be a shaita. And when you're an Arab, you have to think about what you're doing. If you could afford to lose that money, then it's a big mitzvah. But I was saying out of experience, I didn't I wasn't hurt. But when I was younger, somebody asked me to be an Arav. I didn't think twice. He said, "What's the He's gonna pay back." And there's another guy also. And I went like this without even think. And like years, what what were you doing? Like cuz I know people and you know the same people that I know cuz some of them are in this room that they lost their house because they signed ARV. They had to pay to the very last penny of an ARV for another front person who he couldn't pay back. So you can't pay back. They come after you and they make your life miserable until you pay them. And it's you have to pay them. You can't get out of it. So I want you to be but you have to think beforehand and are you willing to lose this amount etc. et just think about it before you do it. The the the state is only a guarantor and acts like is there something in this world that you cannot go to the original borrower? you could go to the second guy but now we learned I'm the apartment we learned if you lend money and there was a guarantor there's a said something I I you know again go to your r look it up see if actually but there was a case where guys played a game on somebody they made him sign a guarantee and they went straight to they went they they got the money let's say they got a million dollars and then they had no intention of paying it back they said this guy's a you know he's a millionaire let him pay it back. They told the whatever we're not paying. And they went to that guy. The guy went to says, "You're not an arav because you weren't an arav on a loan. You were on a scheme on aa and that's not you don't have to pay." That's what he said. Look it up. A doesn't like it cuz they had no no intent to [clears throat] pay when everyone the whole thing was bottle. Say who has to pay. Exactly. Fine. I hear What does it mean? It means don't you not to go to the first he's easy easygoing guy. Go collect. No, first you go to the you go to him. How in our case when you can't go to any son. Why can't you go to the son? Because each one is going to deny it. [clears throat] Oh, I didn't do this. We already had right. Excuse me. Ysef Ben Shimon. >> Uh, yes. >> No. No. Me. I'm Ysef Benjamon. >> What? You two? >> No way. >> Wow. High five. >> You go up yourself. >> No. No. You go up yourself. >> For you. Anything. Go up. >> Same name. Why not the same house? >> My brother. >> Name? Ysef Benjimon. Not me. Him there. Not me. Him. Quick. Quick. Quick. Got to run. Got to run. >> One of you owes. So half the house is ours. Work it out between you. >> Bye-bye. >> You're a crook. Amar [snorts] rea it's only A [laughter] he took his house on a okay's fine great [laughter] amina over okay so there with We said the father died after 30 days. So it goes like this. It's very very cool. What I I told uh Kobe to do this and he did this. It's very nice what he did. Let me show you. It's actually like four steps over here. Very very easy. But we're learning new concepts and that's what's great over here. And we're building up the concepts one on top of the other. And then we come out with the with the outcome. Raises holds that when you divide uh yusha property half of it is yusha half of it you act as as a purchaser. What does it mean? Because I'm not going to get into the whole thing. I'll say it really fast. There's a concept of yesesh bra that retroactively we see that this is what was meant and destined. So is the yusha when you get the Ferrari and he gets the apartment in Miami. is that that's how it was and that's how Hashem said it should be. So that's bra and that is a yusha or there was a deal that went on between the two brothers. I get the silver, you get the this. So that's more of a deal. That's more of a since we don't know how to pass in we're going to do 50/50. Half of it is half of it is now as a side note. In other words, when the tells you you have to pay the five, then it's not as if it this is a verbal agreement. Okay? We're not going to discuss that that much. What we're going to discuss is the third thing on this chart here. When there's a mil val like the five slim, you could only um >> collect. Thank you. You could only collect from the yusha part from the 50% that is and not from the 50% that's the so now that you have five you have five 25 50% of it is a yusha 50% of it is a mech. Here's a deal. The Cayenne cannot go and get his his the whole five slime. He could only get two and a half of the slime. Let's say the whole consisted of five slime. The client is not allowed to ask for the part because that's a deal that happened. It's already too late. He could ask for the part. And then this fourth step that's not here is can a collect 50% of his of his uh of his money or only the whole full five slime. Yeah. Is that clear? I think it's very simple. It's very cool. These four steps we'll see them inside. It goes like this. Here we go. We have a question who the bkar is. And the father after 30 days takes a little trip goes bye-bye and he left a beautiful of >> five sl no no two. >> Yeah. Yeah. We're talking about one and a quarter. That's exactly what we're talking about. One and a quarter. This is what they divided. 2 and 1/2 and 2 and 1/2 and now it comes out that each one got one and a quarter and one and a quarter as you can see on this picture over here. So mea since it's in the they have to pay a ken. So that's ale. That's considered a a loan. Uh yeah, the loan is a verbal loan. It's not in a in a in a document. Since it's not in the document, the client could only take half the yusha part and not the part. And then we have a is whether or not [clears throat] whether or not a coin can take says the coin can't take two and a half. Either takes the whole thing, the entire thing or nothing. Don't take half says that's why he's potter says that's why let's see inside [snorts] four lines from the bottom the father died after the 30 you were asking if the father died after 30 then there's a lean you're right there is a lean if if he left him a lot of money will come in there and take his five slime you know what's the case he only got he only left him over and everybody's going to hold like now I just want to point out that at the end of the we could say not everybody holds like I can make the is here any way I want I can say not we don't hold like or we don't hold like papa when we have these these uh the whole only works if you do all these steps if you knock out one of the steps you say no a yish is is uh is not a half yish and a half he's a complete yurish then the will grab Everything is there or I could say that we hold that everybody holds the the card can take two and a half not it doesn't have to take the whole five or I could say that milv you could collect even from the part there's different ways to play with this there's too many steps there to say that everybody agrees to everything so in other words he only gets one and a quarter each one gets one and a quarter I said what? Where are you? >> I don't know. Oh, I mean there's no real. It's only a verbal lean or loan to the kids. and everybody holds what does say since 50% of the 50% is says that in such a case where the is a verbal agreement like in our case with the you can only collect from the part and not from the part so what is then okay so there's two and a half left give it to the question is could a collect less than the full amount It's all or nothing. You could collect if that's the case. Did everybody get it? I think it was simple enough if you paid attention. Why does say that there's a lean on the property? You know what? Also agrees there's a lean on the property. Everybody agrees that the war was the question here. The question is whether or not the client has to pay it. Does he have to pay the two and a half? Does he have to pay half? That was the question. If there's 10, okay, 10 not to be confused just means two and a half. There's five and there's two and a half. If if there's each one got two and a half then they have to pay. Now what does it mean? You're talking about in total their whole entire which consists of 50% 50% and that whole is two and a half for the for and two and a half for and you can pay the even half you're paying the less than the full then pay him then even if it's less than than why you come up with 10 No. So obviously we're talking about a case where there's a full amount. So there's a full amount. Why why did why did each kid get the full amount? Because the only way the coin could collect is if he takes the whole amount and not half an amount. So there's no in that. Oh, so there's no whether or not the can take half or not half. He has to take the full amount or nothing. So then what is here? Oh. as I mentioned before you could have another either in step one or in step three either I agree with say no it's not it's fully yours or I say no you could you could collect from anything you want I don't have to say that the is whether or not you could if the co collect the whole thing or even less than the whole thing no everybody agrees the coin could only collect the whole but then I have another is here Right. Turning to the daff sponsored by anchor healthcare global going global to bring more people to the daff thank you rebellious my parents million jwart now we have the whole again but this time we're going to come out with another not the before said that if two people with the same name own one field then the lender could go and grab half listen to this this is what's going to come out from here If the guy with the f the same name, Yois bin Shiman buys the whole farm. Ronnie buys the whole farm and then Ronnie sells the farm sells it off to another Ronnie Gorwitz. Then what's going to happen? Then the lender could go and grab that field. Why? Cuz he's going to say either I lent the money to Ronnie number one and it was mine or I lent it to you and it's mine. Either way it's mine. So it's another not that the first time was that they own it together now and he could take half and now we're saying no he could take it from the second buyer because the second buyer bought it from the first buyer and they both have the same name. So let's see it inside V the master laa and some say this whole shakario which the step by step >> why do they need to have the same name on the second buyer isn't he just a secured creditor and can get it from the second >> no no cuz then he doesn't know it's a secure credit I I know I know for a fact that I bought that I lend money you asking I lend it to him I don't know that this field is secure to him it's only because it's the same name that what reviewer says that even after the the the brothers divided up their the state they have to pay the why because he says that the state had a lean on it. So, so we're doing the same thing again. When did the father die? If he died after 30 days, you're telling me that that argues in this he's say there's a lean on the on the property. He died before there was a lean. Why does he say any why does why did the boys have to pay? Each boy should push him off. So before that there was there was no kaluca there was no division. So it's as if they bought it together. It's as if the muscle of before was they're holding on to the field together. They have a partnership in the field and that's why the guy could come and but over here we're talking about that they already made a division. So it's it's similar more similar to this case that one sold it to the other one sold the field to another. The guy could come and demand the money the the the lender could could grab the field. If you're the one I lent the money to. So I'm taking your portion and if I lent money to the other one. So I had a lean on the field. He had no right to sell it to you. Omar says and in fact the the property of a person is is a guarantor. And now we're just going to go and and finish off the suga. In other words, says you don't have to finish it off. You going to say that we're talking about the same case as before. The what the father died after 30 days and there's only five and there's a there's either and so each one got one and a quarter, they got two and a half or one and a quarter and etc. So we just finish off the like that says the Mishna. This is the whole Mishna. We have to finish the Mishna and we have four minutes and it's fine cuz everything is very very simple in this Mishna and if you do it together with me you'll see what I mean. It's it's stuff that we learned already. If two women married to one man they never had a child before and each one gave birth to a male. What's the father has to do what? Two. What's the question? What? if you miss any videos. >> Oh, I don't know. You said that I missed the video. >> Oh, this is a very good video. I like this video a lot. I like this video because of our artists interpretation of reality and how he comes up with these ideas. This is art of Rabbi. >> Yep, that's me. You're probably wondering how I got here. It's Friday. >> You might recognize me. Staff 30, Rebelli Shear, my big break, [music] and I fell in love with the DAFF. Every season, every episode, all 2,711. After that, the offers [music] poured in and I took the best one. Lucky goose to Captain Goldtooth. One of the crew borrowed gold. His friend signed as the RF. Then we stopped for coconuts. >> Nobody noticed he was missing except me. >> Ye signed for him, so you pay me. >> And then I remembered yesterday's shear. >> [music] >> Lucky goose, your luck just ran out. >> Supposed to go to the fortress. >> And that's how Rebelli changed my life. [laughter] What's going on here? You guys started out from a pot. Austa came. Okay. If one of the two boys that were born to the same father but from different mothers, he's married to two women and one of them died. So again, now what happened was that the father was very nervous. He his two wives gave birth and he realizes it's going to happen. They need a new shaitan for the bris. They're going shopping soon. It's a problem. So what does he do? He takes 10 lime and he walks over to Kai. He says, "Listen, hold on to these 10 slime. I'm going to need them in in 30 days. I'm going to have to do two PA bends. I don't want to be stuck without any cash. It's not yours right now. Just hold on to it." Now, one of the kids died. So, the has to return some money because it's only one. He should return half. But what if he did this deal with two separate? He can't prove to which to either which one of his sons died and which one the money went to. What if the two wives one gave birth to a male and one gave birth to a female? Or he has one son for sure has to have opinion. There's one daughter, one son or two sons and one daughter. But one wife gave birth to a firstborn to give sorry where they say but what about but if there's three kids and two females it's possible two females and two girls were born first and there's no opinion or two males and two females. Once again, it's possible that the first birth is females. No, the doesn't get anything. What if it's two? He had two wives, but one already had children. So, one of them is for sure. One of them is for sure not. Once again, simple stuff. You give the one but now becomes complicated because these two boys we one of them is a one of them is not. I don't know which one is what and one died. So that's also easy to answer. What's you don't have to do? What if the father died? Similar to what we had in the first Mishna, the father died and the kids are around. If they gave the money to before they divided because then they could just push him off and say I'm not the one that's not true. There's a lean on the property and they have to pay up or there's one woman who gave birth. >> No, two. One gave birth to Z or one gave birth to Nika. One I'm sorry, one gave birth before. Yeah. One already had had a child and one didn't. So it's not that the the Z that's born now is why? Because maybe the zak that's born now, his mother is a woman who already gave birth. The other woman who didn't give birth, maybe she gave birth to a so therefore the doesn't get anything. Two women that belong. Should we stop here? No, it's two separate husbands. Two wives and two separate husbands. They never gave birth and they gave birth to two males. Of course, each one is because it doesn't matter if you don't know who the kid is. You know that your wife never gave birth and she gave birth to a boy. You have to pay. I don't care if you know if you can recognize him or not. That's the but what if one of them died if they gave the money over to the he has to give back to both of them five cuz he doesn't deserve 10 he only deserve five one of them is dead but if they gave to two different they can't take the money out because the is going to say no the other guy's son died not yours two women that are not married to the same man they're married to two different people and they never had children Before one gave birth to a male, one gave birth a female. Now we don't know who gave birth to what. It's possible that I have the girl, you have the boy, so I don't have to pay for the but here you hear this. There is eventually on the son when he gets older to redeem himself. But if there's two females here, it's possible there's no at all. It's possible there's no at all. The doesn't get anything. Two women belonging to two different men. And one gave birth before, one didn't give birth. Since [clears throat] there's two males, you for sure have to give. Why? Because your wife gave birth to male. Now, you don't recognize him, but it's too bad. You have to pay for the But if it's possible your wife, who never gave birth before, she gave birth to the The coin doesn't get anything. Have a wonderful day. [music] Merry this close of spreading Torah throughout the world. Sponsor Ashir today. mdysponsor.com or sponsor at mdy.com.