Preparing video...
0:00 / 0:00
Daf Yomi Bechoros Daf 51 by R' Eli Stefansky
3,484 views
Thanks for learning with us! -- - Good Morning - Emails - MDYsponsor.com - Questions & Guests - 51A - 51B - Have A Wonderful Day -- Take the Quiz: Kahoot.MDYdaf.com Support the Shiur: MDYsponsor.com Where to Watch & Listen Find us on your favorite platform: https://mdydaf.com/learn#platforms US: 605-562-0066 Israel: 055-DAF-YOMI (055-323-9664) UK: 03-333-661-463 Belgium: 0480-201-272 #DafYomi #EliStefansky #Bechoros #MDY
Chapters
Featuring:Daf Yomi
Categories:Torah/Gemara
Comments
Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
Welcome, welcome to all the guests.
So they opened up a new satellite the
regular satellite locations in America
besides Tom River and a few other places
and
once a month
in Flatbush, but they have
now the satellite location on all
Polaris United Airline flights.
[laughter]
satellite location was totally full this
morning like Toms River. I did manage to
get the last spot in Premium Plus
satellite location.
That's why it goes premium now. It goes
more.
He's back at cabin.
No, I didn't get it. What?
>> He couldn't get into Polaris and he's
stuck in the premium behind.
>> Oh, oh,
[laughter]
Okay. Premium is behind. Look look he's
not a maven. He's already
Yeah, yeah.
I got it. Okay, so let's do it again.
[snorts] The United Polaris satellite
was totally full. I did manage to get
the last spot in premium. Okay, now
Okay.
I don't know what this is exactly. I do
see it like an operating like something
going on here like this in a hospital.
The
don't stop from Avibar.
What is that? No, not this one.
This.
See something going on over there.
Okay, the doesn't stop.
Can't get away from the
[laughter]
Gersh Rose. Okay, so
[laughter]
No, no, no. This is all Torah.
For real. It's all Torah.
[clears throat]
Now, these are
Some are not relevant. See below
The approach.
They're going to why we're not careful
to give a
President today and suggest that's
because lineage is in doubt.
The says that even in earlier times the
did not behave properly. It was not
treated with the full honor.
And today it is even more so.
The
relies on the
and
uses this to be
held captive. The
treats
This is the approach
but they do not eat
Torah level
You ever noticed that don't eat
The
some hold that the today are treated as
definite and bring proof from the
They make
The din that still applies at a doubt.
Even a cannot prove his status must keep
the restriction of marriage and
The I said this last time we learned
this
7 1/2 years ago I brought this
So we get to our
So because
the father should redeem his firstborn
from as many as he can find. No, not
this one. That's not what I said. As he
can find in case one of them is a
definite
He also holds that the should return the
money. This is what I said.
The should return the money. In our days
it's better if the returns the money in
case he's not a and it would be
stealing.
decided that
The itself says the should not routinely
return the money so that other do not
lose out. Hope this helps with Gershi.
Raboysi, listen to this.
Yeah?
What?
>> Verstanding.
>> No, no, no. There's a
something like that.
This is unbelievable. In Stockholm. In
Stockholm there's a
There's a
Anyways, there's going to be a in
Stockholm. If anybody's in Stockholm, I
love
Stockholm
is going strong and we'll arrange a
public
in
J E S C H U R U N
synagogue in Stockholm. Attached is the
invitation if any other would like to
join us. Best, Aaron. Unbelievable.
Um
Oh, hello
I'm watching your now over two months on
WhatsApp. I I personally life love to
criticize. That's me. He loves to
criticize.
I must say you're doing a crazy,
unimaginable job.
The you give when you open the and say,
wow, I have a beautiful ahead and I'm
getting hungry for the entire day to
learn.
Oh, he's on Zoom right now. That's what
they tell me from the booth.
That's what Mark tells me from America.
Maybe you can find him.
who's just about
Reb Dovid
Dovid, you're not worried you're going
to throw you out of Williamsburg over
there? [laughter]
I don't hear you exactly, but okay.
[clears throat]
So you like to criticize. You like to
You like to So do I.
Yeah, it's in the but you can't You HAVE
NOTHING TO CRITICIZE
There's a lot of little stuff that you
could criticize.
Let's go.
It's your chance right now. I'm mute.
Can't hear a word you're saying.
Maybe we can hear him. I'd love to hear
his voice from Williamsburg.
>> Still to come.
Oh,
[laughter]
I miss the capital. We don't SEE THE
CAPITAL.
OH.
[laughter]
SO SO
THE doesn't give you a hard time in
Williamsburg that you do this year?
There's a lot of people in Williamsburg
do it.
No, I don't hear.
All right.
Ah, he's in No, he's not.
He doesn't want to wake up his wife.
It's late at night over there.
All right.
Okay.
This is a Hebrew
um where is it? In Hollywood, I think.
Where did they say it was? Not
Hollywood? I see Goldstein there, so
that's somewhere in
Oh, Aventura. That's right, Aventura.
E Copy Solutions is
sponsoring over there and
Okay, so the other one of Aventura
coming soon.
[clears throat]
David Salem dedicated
in memory of
The
sponsored dedicated by Dr. Nick Sabo.
Sheridan Dental Services dedicated by
Lucida Services in honor of
and Ellie Steimitz.
They say that Lucida is the number one
flooring company in the world.
I'm joking. I have to look it up.
The family foundation in gratitude
for all you do for
Plenty in gratitude to all those
If they're not the largest, they will be
the largest
bringing to the family and the Mexico
City community at large.
>> Arthur Berkowitz in memory of
Herzberg.
Look at Ethan Herzberg's
ninth birthday in his ninth month
learning
every day.
Herzberg family Ethan Herzberg's ninth
birthday. Wow.
He's 9 years old and he's learning for 9
months.
Daily sponsors
Wow.
He followed share.
Manchester used to do the
on his 45th
and all good things for his
great-grandson.
Okay, I got it. All good things for his
great-grandson.
Friends of the
Colin honor of
number four.
They donated I think like $1,300
to cover the costs of
of
I made a We do 100
we'll make like $100,000 if everybody
gives $1,000.
And we'll be in a small hole, not a
large hole.
and Jacob Trapper
[clears throat]
Here we go.
>> today.
>> Where?
>> In
>> Who?
Oh, you made a
>> Great I didn't make a great-grandson.
>> Also, who do we have on the screen here?
>> First time Levine.
>> First time Levine
And and that's the same place?
Two different angles. Beautiful. Wow.
What time is it in uh New York?
12 25 Okay,
You're going to love today's daf.
I have a question. Huh?
[laughter]
You like that one?
>> Yeah.
>> I signed it that.
>> [laughter]
>> Thanks for the uh There's a request for
a video. Let's see if it comes up in the
sugya again. We don't just show videos
here. What are we? Is this Netflix?
[laughter]
It says at the end of the video when you
watch the
Your daf yid.
But thanks thanks for the uh
Look [clears throat] at this.
Yeah? [laughter]
We got to send them around the world.
I live for these videos. Yes?
You want to see
Okay,
we'll do it like once we'll have a new
thing.
Request request. [laughter]
No
Rebbi, can I see the one
It gets better and better. Listen, I
have a question for you. I have a
question for Rabbi Michael Harbater, the
pilot who just made a for a great
grandson. Unbelievable.
Question for the
What if I have
a bunch of friends? I have Rabbi
Schoenberg and I have Donnie Fine.
I have a
What do I do? I want to I want to be
Can I give one sela
to each kohen and say, hey, you guys,
together I gave five
today. Does it work or have to give it
to one kohen? Let's let's ask the
grandfather. What the great grandfather,
what do you say?
What do you say? What's your guess? You
can guess. There's no wrong or right
here. You can guess.
>> I would qualify, but say you have to use
the one kind.
>> I would say the same thing. Nu, what
would you say?
>> No, I would say one is good.
>> You can give five
Now you lost a little bit of your
with that request. You know what I'm
saying?
So I don't know if I can be you. Anybody
else want to jump in there?
>> You're a little controversial.
>> [laughter]
>> Yeah, you're controversial. Nu? Anybody?
What do you say?
>> No.
>> No. You say no. Good. Why?
>> It belongs to cannot belong to three or
four
>> Oh. He's saying good. He says you try to
get your son back. So are you going to
split him up into five pieces?
Do you one and you redeem the leg, the
other you redeem the hand? Anybody else
what do you think?
>> I say no.
>> You say no.
I love it. I love the American crowd
because the Hebrew crowd there's of
course, of course. I was very
disappointed. I said I I I gave a riddle
that nobody got it wrong. Everybody got
it right. Over here
some of you got it wrong.
[laughter]
You're doing good today.
The answer is you could give it to five
You could give it to five
In fact,
you can even give it to different in
different days.
That's [clears throat]
Okay. Fine. So as long as we learn one
Sholom, what's your name? What's the guy
What's your name?
>> John
>> From where?
>> Westchester
>> Oh, we had somebody last night I think
from Westchester. No?
>> He was in my class in high school.
>> No way. It's a small little world there.
From California to
>> Chicago, Kishinev.
>> Oh, in Chicago. I got it. Okay. Very
nice. Welcome.
We're holding
on the top.
Right where we want to be.
And we have another guest.
Oh, for the
from Cleveland. Yeah? What's your name?
>> Yitzchok Kluger
>> You've been doing the for how long? With
me?
First day? Is your first day?
>> Couple years.
>> Couple years with me? Really?
Very nice.
>> 6:00 in the morning every every morning,
almost every morning.
>> From Cleveland, right?
>> Yes.
>> Cool. Very nice.
I just remembered I'm going to ask Mark
now because there was a guy on Zoom
a whole with him. He lived out of
Cleveland. He was like a Remember you
guys remember tattoos or something?
[clears throat] I haven't seen him in a
long time. He's still on Zoom?
He still write emails and stuff. Okay.
It says in the that all these things if
you if you if a person kills his his ox,
kills his slave, you have to give a
with
The special
Okay, he's around.
Um
what else?
The 50
We already said this in the beginning of
the we said
Says the
I think it's fascinating if you think
about it.
This idea of being
to say something bad about somebody
to to give somebody a bad name
is worse than the actual You hear this,
man? The actual
Somebody's somebody, 50.
Wow.
is the worst.
Huh?
It's worst. The says it's it's terrible
stuff. You pay double, 100.
It doesn't say
you learn one from another
and
we learn
from the
So everything in the
you could use
Besides the actual
that we bring
to the
that has to be the real deal. It can't
be a chair, it can't be a a computer, a
bike. It has to be money.
Another two things we're going to add to
the list.
Which is
And when you bring the money for the
carbon
every time you come to the
you bring with you a carbon.
You also bring
You bring
to when you see the
So that has to be
with real money, minted money.
Now we're going to just go through it.
What a gift. Sugar gift.
>> When you come on
>> Yeah, yeah.
So
we have here two coins. They weighed the
exact amount. They're both 1 oz. This is
gold, this is silver.
How much is this gold worth more than
this silver? How many silvers go into
this gold? Anybody want to take a guess?
>> No.
>> Today, yeah. Today.
Huh?
80. 80 something.
This is 80 of these. So imagine you're
in a city.
You're in let say or I don't know where.
You're in New York and everybody sends
the
I think it's from also.
Everybody sends a
And they send it with one Now
everybody's going to go to the to bring
it.
How's the guy going to thousands of
these. It's very heavy.
So you're allowed to trade it into one
of these gold coins that has a that's
minted. It has a depiction on it.
It's a minted coin.
Why?
Because it's very heavy.
But you don't What you don't do is you
don't take all the and put it into a bar
of gold. Just a solid piece of gold. No,
no, no, no, no. It has to be
It has to be
That's the over here. There's three
things that you could only change it
into
not just a a minted currency that's not
just the value of gold, a piece of gold,
a necklace, let's say, a gold necklace
like they do in
It has to be a coin. That's the
Maaser
right?
So when do we give Maaser what years?
Oh, everybody knows 1 2 4 5. Now we know
why? Because Maaser on years
three and six because that's the
smallest
three and six. Easy to remember. 1 2 4
5.
is minted minted money
So you have a lot of fruit and you don't
want to schlep hundreds of pounds of of
fruit up to the up to Jerusalem. It's
too heavy.
So you trade it in your city for a coin
that has
a minted coin and you bring those coins
up to Jerusalem and then you do the
trade back. You buy fruit with that
those coins.
And the
We don't want you to bring inferior
silver
So you you bring
pure silver coins.
Says the
Pay attention here that we're 50 50
That means that in about 10 days we're
starting a new
And it's going to be one of the last
opportunities before the final
which is
is a great
to bring people. So start getting ready
to bring people.
I'm not going to make such a big push
the two after that.
But
is a good time to bring people.
Easy. Very very
So
what are you shaking your head a little
bit like that?
>> It's mostly well, every is mostly easy.
[laughter]
Talking from an editor's standpoint.
Okay, so start getting your ideas ready
for your videos, for your status, for
your things. We're going to have to make
a big push.
This would be so interesting. Come to a
and the father of the son
shows up with a slave,
brings a slave, puts him in a box,
and gives the a slave.
Instead of my son, I want to give you
another human being. Human being for a
human being, that doesn't work.
I also can't give the
a nice apartment in
on the beach in
somewhere. Can't do that either. Ah,
it's worth more than five No, can't do
it.
So
today, a simple would be a check. I
can't give him a check.
Especially those checks that bounce.
But a check in general check is not a
good. Now,
we discussed it yesterday, but some of
you weren't here.
Is a $100 bill
It's not enough even, but let's say 250
200 $300 is that a check? Is that
considered a
So it's a big
Especially today in America where
there's no real
gold in the safes anymore. They just
print money
It does have you could buy whatever you
want with it. You go to any store and
buy and it's not a big deal. So is it
it's considered
if not is it considered What is it
exactly? Okay.
says it's fine. Others argue.
So it's not a good idea to use $100
bills at a
not with real estate.
Now, the simple meaning in the
you can take a
let's say you
an animal. You said this animal should
be a
You can't take an
and redeem your son with it. Of course
you can't take an redeem your son with
it. It's not yours. It's the
So what else could it be? Um
somebody donated a laptop to the
So you can't take the laptop and give it
to the Well, it's not yours to give.
The says no, no, no. It's completely
It's it's not even talking about that.
It's talking how do you redeem
[clears throat] When there's a laptop in
There's a laptop. You want a laptop and
and then you're going to buy it off the
yard sale. You cannot use real estate to
buy that that laptop. You can't use a
slave to buy that laptop.
That's what the
But we're not there yet. What?
The tells us a very interesting case.
We had a here who said he did 10
And he told us about
a that he did for a and that kid was
killed in in the war last year.
He redeemed him 30 years ago.
And then he's sitting next to
and said he never did a
ever. And then uh
uh what's his name?
Benjamin Bornstein did two. So some How
many did you do, Rabbi Schoenberg?
>> Three, four.
It's not so common for a
So let's say let say we have a little
bit of a fight here. You know, Danny
comes to me and says, listen, I would
love to do a you know, like before I was
a the first time I like had this
this urge like it's such a thing. I want
to do it.
So Danny I don't Danny, you ever did a
You did once. Okay. So let's say he
comes he comes to the to the to the
father of the kid. He says, listen,
it would mean a lot to me if you if you
made if I did it, I'll even give you the
money back. Just
So the guy says no problem here.
I, Eli Stefansky,
owe you the five shekel of of the
I'm going to I'm going to use you. You
write a I I I promise Danny fine, I'm
going to use him as my Cohen at the
thing.
Says the Mishna,
you can't do that. And if you do it, you
have to pay Danny fine five sela.
And then to start all over again.
Nothing to do this has nothing to do
with the
Why? We don't want people to get
confused. People are going to say that
the
is what did it. And we know is no good
for
You wrote a a document saying I am going
to give you the five sela of the
He must give him the five sela.
So let me ask you a question. What if
Danny fine is a nice guy, Danny? He
says, listen, I know the Mishna says you
have to give me the five sela.
Don't worry.
Does that work?
What are the next words?
What does that mean?
It means to say that he cannot say I
Danny fine cannot be It's not up to him.
He can't be a nice guy. He must take the
money from the
If he wants, he can give him a gift
right back.
But you cannot do
taking the that he wrote me here and I'm
ripping it up. Why? Because this is all
the I want. want you to pay up and lose
your money. So you should never do such
a thing again.
>> What if he owed the Cohen the money
Okay, that's something else. But in
terms of
But if you be we're talking about
there's a going on here and it's obvious
that he did this for the
then it's no good.
You set aside five sela for the and it
got lost. That's your problem, not the
not the the Cohen's problem.
We saw when it comes to
this doesn't work like that. That if you
put it on the side, it's okay.
I want you to remember this because it's
very important for later on in the
right before everybody's ready to get up
and run out the door.
Over there we're going to be talking
about
that the Gemara introduces. And Rav Papa
is going to ask what do you mean? It
says
What are you looking for more
when the Mishnah gives us the over here?
Okay.
So it says in the Mishnah you cannot
redeem
with three things. What are the three
things?
and
Instead of three things on his list
he only brings one.
I told yesterday, I'm going to say it
again, when I was learning this on
Shabbos
it seemed to me like from the easiest
for me personally one of the easiest to
prepare.
Why?
And once you learn it once in
and you get it down it's the same exact
thing over and over and over. It's the
same thing.
And then when she did the to me after
she goes this was the easiest of all the
So what's a
Is is the video in there?
So we have something special
because we have Dave.
[laughter]
Mark did it?
Is that the Oh, it's not it's not the
video itself. Okay, I got it.
I thought it was going to show that
video that he wanted the request.
He wants the video of Israel dueling it
out.
I didn't prepare this. I I Question.
The You think Israel knows the
difference between a
and a
You do think so? Israel, do you know the
difference?
Light. Say it nice and loud. Let's hear
I did not prepare this. I did not ask
Israel if he knows it. Let's see if he
knows it.
I'm going on a limb over here. Could be
embarrassing for this year. No, it's not
going to be embarrassing. Even if you
don't know, everything is good. Cuz how
old are you? 10 years old.
What what's the difference between?
What's a
What's the difference, you know?
>> It's when there's [music] something
like
let's say a bunch of animals
>> Yeah.
>> and a prat is like it takes out some of
them
and a cloud adds like a few more
>> Very good. So that's a cloud prat. And
what are
What's the difference?
If you do the same thing but a
is it different?
No?
[laughter]
Okay, so I'll tell you the difference.
The difference is
That is very good. [applause]
[cheering]
There is a difference. It's almost the
same thing. It's the same words. We're
using the same exact words. We're just
calling it a different name. We say
cloud is a generalization. The
generalizes in a lot of things. Let's
say
You can do with everything in the world.
All any anything, even slaves and and
real estate, everything. Then the says,
no.
It has to be
Then the says again, it generalizes.
So that we call cloud
You could call that those exact words
Whoever does cloud
does it for the whole
Or if you're in the the camp that says
that you do
you do that in the whole You don't pick
and choose.
Okay. But what is the difference? A very
small difference. Small but large.
When you do a cloud
The prat
describes what the cloud is, what the
generalization is. So it has to be
similar
to the prat.
But we're going to take off a bunch of
stuff.
In our case, we're going to take off
three things. What do we take off?
Slaves,
But if you do a
you only take off one thing. That's the
whole difference. Do you take off one
thing or you take off many things?
It's not only three. Sometimes it's 20.
Sometimes it's two.
But a means I'm going to take off one
thing. The thing that's the less the
most
the furthest away from the
generalization. What's the furthest
thing away
from something that's worth money?
A note.
A
It has zero value. You You can't even
blow your nose on it, you know, because
it has ink all over it. You can't even
do that. What are you going to do with
it? There's nothing.
Uh a slave has value. Uh real estate has
value. So the thing that I'm going to
take out I'm only going to take out one
thing.
So what the says
Rebbe argues on the The says you can't
do with three things and Rebbe says you
can you can't do with one thing. The
Cuz Rebbe holds
He only takes off one thing.
in the hold
You take off three things.
So let's see inside.
In other words, you could redeem your
son with a slave and with real estate.
That what?
Let's just see it inside.
This is the right?
So
is a
So really what we have here is
It's not a
It's two in a row,
and afterwards a
Which the is going to deal with all the
way in the bottom.
>> In in the
explains that concept in the in the
English.
>> Oh yeah?
>> The concept of
>> The difference The difference between
them. Very nice.
I want to show you something that didn't
explain so Okay.
What do we have on the table? We have a
slave all the way on the right. We have
a below the slave. We have MDY socks,
and we have a thing of real estate
all the way on the left. Trees spinning
around over there, and we have money.
I think I just I just noticed my face
over here.
Fine.
So now I'm going to do a
I'm going to take everything off.
But then because I have a
So I put everything back besides one
thing. What am I going to take off? The
thing that's least similar to
everything. And that is a that has zero
value as of itself.
It's just a piece of paper. But the
paper itself you can't do anything with.
I'm going to add everything. My rabbi
every single thing I could redeem my son
with or my but I take out one thing only
because it has zero value. And that's
why Rebbe took out one because he holds
We're going to do the same exact thing
all over again, but the outcome is
different.
[clears throat]
So
The
Everything that you put back has to be
similar to the
but I could take out many things, many
items.
Why? Because I go it has to be similar
to the and if it's not similar to the
you could be 10 things, 20 things, 100
things.
It has to be something movable. Real
estate is not movable.
has to have inherent value.
doesn't have any value. Therefore I take
off
and a
What about a slave? New slave in the
whole
slaves are similar to
>> So, therefore, you cannot redeem your
son with real estate because it's not
movable, and you can't redeem your son
with a slave because a slave has a
Even though they are movable,
they don't have any value themselves.
Simple question.
Since
if you go with a certain line in
you go with
you can't switch one day to
It doesn't work like that. You are a
Rebbe is a
cloud person. So, how all of a sudden
you telling me that Rebbe holds
and he only took off a
He's a
person. Since he's a
individual, he has to
and take off three things.
Guess what? Another simple Why is it
simple? Because it was less than two
weeks ago we had this entire
When you have
a Jew that stole
Rabbi Halberstam, this is instead of
your
This is going to be a very nice video.
Very nice.
You're going to love it. Not as great as
as real. I know. I know.
But when you have a Jewish person who
stole and he has no money to repay,
so you sell him as a slave up to 6
years. What happens when he doesn't want
to leave because he has a child, he has
a wife, he this, he doesn't want to
leave?
He works until
You You You take his ear, you put on the
door post, and you puncture it with a
Oh, with a
The [clears throat] did a great job on
this in the picture here. Let me show
you.
It's one of these.
Anyone else says, how do you know all
these different items? Mine is
literally like the on the side over
there, on the right.
Here we go.
Look, the the the placement of these
tools are is not in the right place. It
has to be in the soft spot. But okay.
said, but we needed some room over here.
A
like a like
auger, like
a bit, drill bit. And then you have a
stylist. Okay.
So how do you know?
Let's just see the video now.
Here we go.
So this is
a Jew that stole money and cannot
repay.
>> Thief!
Thief!
>> How much is he worth? The Trump sell him
as a slave.
[music]
He has a child.
He doesn't want to
He says he doesn't want to leave.
Look at all the guys.
He has this kid that looks just like
him.
Okay.
Not bad.
You like it?
No, no, he doesn't.
Oh, you want to see Dr. Factor?
That I can That I can do. That I can do.
Here we go.
Just the difference in technology.
[screaming]
There's no talking that is
Okay, that was then.
You know what technology that was then?
Wow, the ability to move pieces is
unbelievable.
Must have taken them two days to make
that.
With the With the front of the building,
the whole thing. Okay.
So says the Gemara.
And
He says no.
Anything that's made out of metal, but
you can't use You can't use
like
No
How do you say like
Like a chemical. You can't use a
chemical. There's no chemical.
What's the
[cough] So
you see
that
person. [cough]
[clears throat] But over here
it's different. Why?
Sorry.
But
We're talking about
the that a fish has that it's kosher.
It says
So So going over here?
Because
similar to what we have by us.
Look at this. It's a
But if you look at it, look at the
It says
and then it says
So it's a
and a
and only afterwards you have a It's not
It's
So that makes a difference. In that
case, when you have two
together
and afterwards you have a
and that says that's a
Then you go with the
And it's a
No, but in
they say look
It says
You're right. It does say it like that.
But what do we do in
We do this.
We do a switcheroo. We put the the
in as if it's in between the two
To get a regular typical
But argues you don't do you don't do a
trick. You just leave it. So by us also.
What do we have by us? We have a
and a
or a
and a
It's not a
prat
it's a
Oh.
So the question is do we do that trick?
will say we do this.
And says no, this is a
[clears throat]
When it comes to
You can't you can't use a
or something like that to redeem your
son at a
It's It's not your personal property.
So I was not happy with our
I mean it explains it, but I didn't
think it did enough of a job. What do
you say?
>> Agree.
>> You agree?
>> I agree it did not do enough.
>> You agree it didn't do Well, say what
does say about us?
No, no, I'm saying no. I'm trying to
bring out here is
when it's a little bit of a complicated
answer like that then not a average
person doesn't really get it on the
first shot. One more line would have
done a great job. What?
No, he what does he say over here?
No, that's the he says that also. I'm
just saying to to make it that we're not
just to emphasize we're not talking
about using the
to redeem something. We're talking about
you redeeming It should just be another
few more words. I think it would be
easier to understand. Anyway,
but we did a great job in explaining
Okay, great.
No, what what happened look I'm I tell
the staff the whole time I said we want
it
precise. We want a very very very So it
gets in their head very
but sometimes it's on the
of understanding the
easy and clear and going. Like yeah it's
a it's a
>> Fine line.
>> It's a fine line. You have to decide on
your own when is the what is the time
when not.
Adar Global going global to bring more
people to the
Thank you
Steven Schwartz
my parents Million J Schwartz. The new
is a step up. The the new
is completely different in terms of the
way it's laid out. So the the pictures
are much smaller in the in the it's I
think it's beautiful. It's really really
good, no?
So the artists are not happy.
All the artists are not are upset about
it because it doesn't it's smaller.
Yeah, but I think it's much
You loved it. I think people are going
to love it also.
[snorts]
Look, we're talking about our
So again,
I tell I tell I'm going to pay you five
30 days. You don't worry about it. I'm
not going to take Rabbi Shomberg. Have
no fear. So the is I have to give the
and I'm I'm I have to start all over
again.
It's a good
>> People are not going to realize what
happened there. They know I gave
30 days ago. They're going to think
that's what caused
And we don't want people to think that
you can use because that for sure
according to everybody, even according
to Rebbe, the one thing that's no good
is a
He says, oh, when you pay up the you're
good.
These are people that said things
without
that said
as is.
We don't pass
You give a
I owe you five
No good.
We learned
I think it's a fascinating
I would have not known this. I would
have guessed like the people that
guessed that it's no good.
Like he was even saying
what you're redeeming one child,
you need to redeem it to one person. No.
The is I could take five
put it in front of 10 run away. Say, you
guys deal with it. You guys split it the
way you want to do it.
by putting it down.
So Rashi says over here,
talking about to one you just give one
one coin after another coin.
So timeout.
But
as I mentioned before, even if you give
it to different
one after another different days, you're
also
[clears throat]
If
you give it to the
and the gives it back, it's good.
It works.
Like it's brought down from the
He says that in our days it's even
better for the
to give it back.
Okay? Now that we found out that it's
worth about $50,000 in the community, I
don't know if it's such a great idea to
give it back.
50 grand.
I don't know. It has it has value.
Don't forget was a tremendous
tremendous. So it could be, okay, he
gave it back.
He used to give it back.
He received it.
He gave it back.
That's it. only did one in his whole
life.
Even this
So What's the
What?
No, we'll see because
first of all the
good. It's a good thing you bring it up.
There's a problem here of
And that is you're not allowed to help a
anticipating that he's going to give you
you're going to help him out in the in
the threshing floor over there and then
he eventually who's he going to give the
He's going to give to you.
When you know that Rabbi Shomberg is
that kind of
that he gives back
But
is the type of that he likes to keep it
for and different reasons. So you are
going to use Rabbi Shomberg. It's it's
better for you.
So isn't that ruining it? brings up the
point over here and
He has a question. It should be
for him.
You're destroying
He they're going to they have a monopoly
now on all the Nobody's going to use
another Here's a guy that gives back 250
bucks every time.
This is more of a for the Israeli but I
can tell you also that
sometimes you go to a hotel and it's a
little bit of a I I people in hotel in
our hotel speaking, oh, these Jews, they
don't tip us, and
you know, the porter that brings the
suitcases in,
actually, some of them only work on
tips.
They don't They don't even make a
salary. They only work on on the few
dollars that people give them to bring
the suitcases in.
So, community
public service announcement that's for
our especially because we
and
and we don't want to make a especially
in our thing. So, there's certain things
that you give tips to You don't have to,
but it's accepted that
that you give also
the cleaning
the What is it? The
the the people that clean your room
the What is it called? Housekeeping.
Thank you. Housekeeping. They also
expect tips. So, you put a few dollars
by your bed on the on the table over
there.
But sometimes you come to a place, the
guy brings your suitcases, right? And
you you're not so experienced.
So, he puts the suitcases down and then
he doesn't leave. Then he starts looking
at the ceiling
and he starts doing one of these. He
walks this way and you're like
And the guy is not going anywhere and
you don't know why.
You don't know why cuz he's
You know? You know these guys? You know
these guys? So,
[clears throat]
so
that's what happened there in the
like this.
He would take the five but give it back
to the
He sees a guy
The guy is walking back, forth. What
does he want? What's What's going on? He
starts clearing his throat.
He just received the
from the father of the son
and the father of the son starts making
around this table.
I don't understand. You didn't give it
to me 100%. Would you expect me to give
it back to you?
You did a terrible thing, he tells him.
You weren't because you thought I'm
going to give it back to you, then you
didn't give me a real
I was testing you to see.
There's a the famous myself the rabbi
every after every
he would put his keys on the table and
say I had enough of this. I'm too old
for this. It's so hard. It's so hard.
And the whole kilo would come no no
please just one more year one more year
every year every year. So one one year
some guy got sick and tired of it so he
slept the keys but it was tied to his
pants. [laughter]
Yeah.
It reminds me of just just this week I I
don't want to get into names so there's
a certain
politician that said I am done. I'M
DONE. I'M OUT of here. He was out but
then
begging him begging HIM TO STAY. SO OKAY
OKAY FINE fine fine I'll stay I'll stay
just one more
for this thing I'll stay. I'm not going
to go into any names. So anyway
but we do have we do have a
>> Huh?
>> Every year on you say like
to eat eat eat come and join me.
>> Oh, but you don't really mean it?
Here we go. Hold on.
>> [music]
[music]
[laughter]
>> If you set aside money for the got lost,
you have to replace the money yourself.
You know a lot of times at the end of
the they start hinting to you.
A person says
his value I'm going to give to
and you set aside the money and then it
gets lost, you have to you have to bring
more money.
So as I told you then, I just I'm going
to show you again. Oh no, do we even
have a better one here? This was in the
I need a
I already brought a
If you lose the money, how do I know you
have to pay again?
It's in the
What are you bringing?
I learned in
Beautiful. It's a good thing you caught
on.
This stays. This stays. How do I know I
have to replace the money? Because
there's a
of
So why did I bring all these
What's going on here?
Oh.
It's brought for something else, for a
different we learned a few days ago.
If
the son, the kid dies, I'm sorry, the
father dies after 30 days and now we
don't have anybody to redeem the kid.
Even though he didn't give somebody
should give
Sorry, the kid died.
The kid, but now the kid and the father
died both. No, nobody's there.
So by also if the the person, the
redeemer, the the one that has the and
the one that the value or the person
that said I'll do it,
either one if they die, you have to
continue giving it.
The the inheritors are
So too by
to give
have a wonderful day.
>> Merit the of spreading Torah throughout
the world. Sponsor a share today.
mdy sponsor dot com or sponsor at mdy
daf dot com.