Daf Yomi Zevachim Daf 11 by R' Eli Stefansky

[Music] Good morning. [Music] >> Welcome. Welcome to all the guests. We have checking out. We saw him yesterday. What's your name? Sadik >> from where? >> L. >> London. From uh what's the what's the name of the place over there in London? Yeah. Stanford Hillyak. You part of that. You part of a group over there. No, you do your own thing. Knows about you or you're hidden. >> It's a huge you talking about there's 150 people there. No. >> All right. What's uh you you're you're not new. No. What's your name? The Kazak >> from >> Lansman. He's a lman. Who >> from >> Oaksters, New Jersey? >> Hillrest, New Jersey. >> Oakde area. >> Very nice. I like the name. It's name. >> All right. Welcome. >> Oh, Maz. When? Today? >> Uh, no. After >> the whole month. >> All right. Cool. So, we'll see you once in a while. Love it. Oh, [Music] rebell. What is What is Thank you very much. It's the greatest to be used that song to be used in such a holy keep up your amazing >> keep up elevating learning the satur that you have you should have ava you're filled with filled with filled with dash that's what it is you're giving dash you're giving sweetness to people um you're amazing Ellie >> and for me to have a small little little part and uh what's going on there. It's amazing. Ah, it's to do the D. Yes, it is. Sending love. Love you very much. And thank you very much for sharing that with me. It's a tremendous tremendous. These are the two guys that stay by my house. They're they're in action already. And this her boy saying in Oman. I thought I saw him in one of the videos. Look at this. It's a nice crowd. They have their own nice costume. Somebody had to donate the screen and they're going to use the screen next year. This story remembers Milstein. He's a Rebi. You remember him? He's another Rebi that sent us he was also at the shabaton and uh he did this whole good morning our voice once or like a a play remember I think his kids did like a whole >> Yeah. I'm a rebi and I was thinking how to best explain to my class the history behind and then it occurred to me that this year is very easy to bring it to life for many people because of Charlie Kirk's death. What happened? He was he was put in charge of cla for the right after the and then he was assassinated and that was it for like the ran away went to Egypt this that so he's saying it's a martial it's not mish but it's an assassination that hurt cla this the senate and congress both passed a vote to make the date of his death a national day of remembrance house senate passed the national day of remembrance we have Tim gdalia day of remembrance I won't be able to share this thought with my third graders, but I thought it was something you'd enjoy. Thank you. And yes, I did put have you in mind in my tus. A lot of people said it's Let's see. Let's see if it works this year. From the amount of people that told me it, it's not like the wine and the water. Everybody's going to pour the water in. There's wine going in wine this year. I really appreciate it. May you and all of those that are dear to you be blessed with the year of health, spiritual and material blessings. May all may you all see tremendous and all do and enjoy your growth in all areas. May you and your wife see from the whole family. Thank you for all that you your wife your whole family do for the you are very loved and appreciated by the warm regards Elan Gul Montreal. PS next time you're in the New York area if you're willing able to come to Montreal. I'll take upon myself to organize a venue for this year to work hard to market it and draw a crowd. It could be a big push to grow this year in Montreal. Not sponsored by David Solomon. Dedicated memory of anonymous sponsored by Skyber Capital in honor of our friends for devotion to study. Father Jack anonymous co-sponsors monthly anonymous from London business monthly sponsor TCS Israel power talk save Kesler in honor of the marriage of my son and my daughter am I relocated to Eden gardens in Orlando Florida from London also monthly sponsors Yehuda Loshinski in honor of my father six cycle of the daf your big heart and giving to the community is an inspiration for all of us anonymous Benavash Shaa coffee for the month I guess. Rifka and do yeah Rifka and Dr. Aram Epstein pray for a complete and speedy recovery for Dr. Harold Goldmire Rafi Goldmire's father who just lost his wife when like less than a month. No, he's weekly sponsor have a speed anonymous for a year full of anonymous. Thanking fans and the MDY team for making the accessible and enjoyable to many Nancy and Arnon Steinhard Lea Jerry Loy and Lloyd and Gimar to for all Gishi Schwarz rebell you changed my life truly and it's my birthday today anonymous anonymous in honor of the RV for keeping the boys spicy and Making sure the woos are flying. Some inside jokes here. I hope he didn't make me say like something like really spicy in another language. >> Yeah. Okay. >> Boy, here we are. We're starting from not four lines from the bottom of not awesome. We have the P over here. I I have to say that I was just here a few hours ago. I gave three shim in a row last night and there's a nice crowd. We're going into like 1:00 in the morning kind of thing. There's a little mishuga and uh there's no coffee, but it's Kishmak. We're here for Oh, so we'll do forim in I don't know 7 hours. What 12 hours? >> 12 hours. >> No, the first year started at 9:30. Well, it was really quarter to 10 hours. >> Yeah, 10 hours. It sounds better though. >> 10 hours. >> Okay. So, it says in the if you bring Oh, so this kid a 13-year-old kid from Betar. He even has his name here. Printed with 3D Schlammy Rubenstein. So, he he had somebody 3D print this and he gave it to me. He forgot to tell me that these are these are these are spikes that the pigeons don't they also spike your finger when you touch them. So, I'm opening it up and I spiked my fingers. But he gave me a bandage. So if you take the blood and you put it into this which is 200 ft tall >> the the uh carbon becomes possible. >> So you take a katas it's a good katas but somebody puts the blood inside the it automatically turns off the katas it's gone it's a goner. Now the question is is it just the katas or it's other kurbanus as well? Perhaps it's in the asham. Perhaps it's all kurbanus or perhaps it's only the now what does the say only the every single carbon. How do I know it? from the first word of the it says okay allas no no no no we're not darishing any says now we have a third is similar to himself in our Mishna the first Mishna when the Mishna says that if you have the wrong orb you have to destroy the animal it's it's a goner says is similar to in all things in this also that if you to put the blood into the it ruins the li that we had yesterday the says it's similar the are similar they're put together in the same so they have the same he just explained his reasoning we have a heckish discussion What what are they going to do with this? Why do they argue and say no only says it's impossible? Why to say that if you bring the blood inside the itles the actual so what's interesting is the more we learn we're tend into the more we can anticipate and understand what's flying it's the same thing over and over yesterday we had two of these today we have some of them it's the same thing just you put different assets different words in there and but the same it's It's the same thing. It's the same procedure. What do I mean by that? Here is going to try to learn asham from anah. We're going to say that if asham you bring the blood into the kosher is more powerful than asham all thing goes to nobody eats from it. So asham also if you bring the blood into the It should be okay. What doesar say? No. No. Is special. It's actually not more. It's more than it doesn't give a kapara. So, we're going to go to something else. Going to go to the You guys remember from yesterday? Of course, it's the same thing, but for a different it's a it's a it's a it's a flower carbon that you give to and if you bring some of it inside the it doesn't do anything to the so but says yeah but it's not it doesn't have any blood it's not it's not a carbon you don't it so then what do you do in this case you remember what you do when you have these two things so then you go to the but Then you go back to the you're going to circle. So what do you do? You do a common denominator do you take the two of them together. And you say well the two of them together have one thing one thing in common there and if if you bring the blood inside the it's kasha and therefore also and then what happens after that then we make a piran those two things they say no those two are different than ash why there's no there's no set price you can pay as much as you want but ash you have you must pay at least two shekele and you go around in circle and then what happens are you simon >> then you bring a There's gossip. >> Exactly. What? What are you saying? >> There's no dam. >> You don't understand. So we'll see inside here is so powerful that all of it goes and if you bring the blood inside the it remains kosher not like is less than that some of it is eaten by the and certainly if you bring the blood into the it should remain kosher. No but has something that that's the opposite of a it's a it doesn't forgive it doesn't you can't get a forgiveness from if somebody brings a what's a so if somebody did a sin certain certain and he can't afford a carbon he brings a bird and if he can't afford the birds he brings a so that if you were to bring some of it inside the it doesn't ruin it. So too shouldn't ruin it. Says first the digresses for a second. Why did the gumar bring a raya from the min there's something much better that's that's more appropriate for our which is the bird that's one bird is one is the is bird the bird that if somebody has a little bit more money than a real real barber he'll bring the bird and why is that better because it has blood it's a lot it's a lot more similar than jumping all the way to to to flower that doesn't have blood says, "I couldn't use a bird. We're not sure that if you bring the blood of a's bird into the it doesn't ruin the the bird. That we weren't sure about. But we we're certain that if you bring part of the into the it doesn't ruin the and now is is saying within the words that is the is the is the don't you can't bring a from the flower because of flower doesn't have any blood. It's not a it's not a carbon but is a carbon and you bring if you bring the blood into the it doesn't ruin it but so you go to which is but it's not a but is also not you go around in a circle each one has a positive each one has a negative just like in real life but the denominator is that they're and if you bring the blood or the it remains kosher I could learn from them the bottom line is I want to learn you need to pay minimum two shekele for the carbon a and the don't have that. So if there's a certain there's a certain minimum that means it's more I can't learn from the other two yesterday I believe it was a little confusing cuz I gave a then I went back and gave a and people that were they came they heard the and like but wait a minute it's this and that like start asking me questions from no that that's tomorrow's oh Yeah. Yeah. Okay. So, I think I think it was yesterday's where we had the same thing, same for today. We'll get to it. I I I don't remember what >> yesterday was yesterday. Okay, good. I'm saying it's it becomes very predictable. It it's the same. It just keeps on going. Bring it right from this. No, this has a bring from this. This has to both them together. And then there's a final p on the bottom and then that doesn't work. And then we have we bring apostle. Literally I have here three of these exact same thing for three different [Music] it says in this I just showed you from its blood but its blood only's blood and not asham's blood. It's a me and says that asham does if you bring the blood of into the it ruins it. What is he going to do with the word? It seems like there's a meal only only the if you brought a piece of meat into the that doesn't ruin the only blood. He's I agree with it. Everybody agrees that how does he know that? because it says dma instead of d. So now I'm learning two first of all dma means it only it only the and also the reason why we we said instead of d is another way to learn and doesn't learn two drases from one word in this case very similar what's going on here there's two when it comes to there's a that's possible. We're going to see the in a second if you say is no good and asham is good. So now I have a case and therefore I could say that a is like a like asham. One is kasher one is puzle. But if I say that both and are the same and they are both possible. So how can I say that a min is like a they don't come out that both both are both possible. But that's not what I'm trying to get to. I'm trying to say that one is kosher and one is possible. So that works beautifully like because they say is possible and asham is kosher. And aka is like a like asham. One is kosher, one is possible. But according to that both and are possible. So what am I saying? A is like a and therefore what they're both possible. No, I'm trying to come to the situation where one is kosher and one is puzzle. Let's see inside you'll understand more. I have a that's and I have that's when you do that's why the says in a second we'll see the [Music] that we we compare a what's a it's a carbon made out of flour we compare it to the that When you bring your first sin, it makes a lot of sense. It's similar to is also brought for a sin. So if you're you do a and you bring a and you have the wrong what happens to the you thought that it's aim you got to destroy it come. If you do, you go like this and you think to yourself, I'm doing this not for but I'm doing this for you ruined it. And made out of flour. He can't afford an animal. So im she's a poor person. He goes and he asks his wife to make him like a to give some flour and he brings it to Hashem. That's like an if he did the without without the it's kosher. Now I just want to show you this rash. Yeah, we'll show it later. It's not for this. So yeah, that's great. According to that one is one is according to where both and are both possible if you have the wrong intent. So then what does it mean? What how's the comparing to one not right? There's another limo learned. Do we put it in at the end Dave? It was up there. No, we didn't put it in. Okay. You all know that there's a clear is full of flour. It's a golden cle has the cle you put it into the cle becomes kadesh. Then the client sticks his hand in like this and he folds his fingers three fingers top bottom and whatever is whatever remains in this what does he do with it? What does he do with this hand, >> right? He puts it on his but before he puts on the he puts it inside of another he dumps it in the clichus. Then that cleles you could maybe go like this to misbeh also but you put in the cliches. So this is the rash I wanted to show you. I think it's a super important rash. It gives us more ideas in says the is saying that he forgot to put it in the he didn't put it in the part he didn't make the the with thears it's possible says an amazing thing that a is similar to a carbon there's four what are the four by a regular carbon So too by we have what's the and then you have to do well it's not spraying blood so you take it and you put it into that's the what's you walk it to the and what's the putting it on the that's the now we here a new thing we just learned now who is connected putting in it's like you walk to the and throwing it is like doing so if you don't do you didn't you you're missing one of the four one of the four essential is doing you forgot to do that's so we're going to learn a new according to it's okay Right. This is learning that it's like says that if you you have a choice you want to hold the in your hand and go like this to the great just make sure you do with your right hand. Somebody told me a mis I don't know it's interesting story I could understand I I hear the story from beginning to end maybe not the end the beginning part mish I could relate to gave m to one of his and the was taken back by the m and he smacked the rebba right in the face and he ran away and of course the ran after they caught him >> which >> I don't know there's too many >> there's like a thousand >> okay >> the smart one the smart one, the smarter one. Listen to this. >> He had more than one. >> So they bring the to him and the is, you know, trembling and the Reb says, "I have a big T on you." A yid when he does something, what is a yid? Why do you smack with your left hand? >> And he broke the ice. The They both started laughing and the guy nine months later was the biggest ever. He was >> I had a story like that myself. You made me fit when I was a buffer. Yeah. >> I went there for he says he says to me I said what you stick out your right hand. >> What he said in English >> stick out your right in English. I don't understand what you're saying. I I know you. I don't understand what you're saying. Finally he says to me in English. Just stick out your right hand. I put my left hand. No. >> Very. Right. Right. Everything's now he decides to do with the vessel with the small. Don't get confused there. If anybody got confused, Rashi explains right away. You could do with your left. You don't have to do it with your left. like I we just learned from this that if you don't do the pass it says says no the main comes to say that we just said that if you do if you do it with your hand make sure you do it with your right hand if you do with the cle you could use the the left this of of of I I'll get another source If you don't have the right, it's another positive. This is we had yesterday. The word he who is what shows us that you have to have you know what is the same word he according to what do they do? Why is compared to what do they learn from this? This is one of these I think that's like under the table kind of thing. It goes in still when they ask you on a test. This is where they get you good. What do you learn from and learn that this you have to lean your body weight on a just like you do for what does say that if you take a carbon pes that if you take any carbon or let's see inside the not only if you take a carbon p and say that it's you ruined it forever you have to destroy it but even if you take aim on and you say this ones is a carbon pes you also ruined it you have to destroy also says the same thing. No, no, they argue if you take other carbonas and you have a mind for that's where the ex is this you have a carbon pes that's too old became a old man it's already over a year old you can't use it anymore for carbon pes and you take this 2-year-old carbon honor say this should be a carbon pes If you take on that's it says the same that we just read in the what if you take another not only if you take a carbon pes and say that it's aim of not only honor pes the six-hour window that we have to sh if a guy messes up and he says This is not a current p this isim. What happens? Take that animal and destroy it says and so says that if you take aim the reverse you take a schlam say this is a carbon pes not only say carbon pes this is a schlam but even say this is a carbon pes destroy it says so now we have these back and forths these it's also the same style that we had before these these to prove it and it goes till the bottom of the so if you don't like these you can take a little break now for 4 minutes if you take a a carbon pes and you try to sh the carbon p what happens garnished but if you take other carbonas and you try to make it a carbon pes it's kosher becomes that that is because only ones is a problem itself this is this is the logic that doesn't like so if you take and after it's good for so certainly if you take and say that it's on it should be kosher says your logic off. I could take the same logic and use it against you. If I take a carbon, it's not going to be a carbon p I cannot check the carbon. But if I take the carbon on say it's good, listen what's going to come out according to your logic. I'm using your logic come out that if oh so certainly on the carbon and it is good and so certainly I should be able to take the carbon pes and make it aim and that everybody knows is not okay. You're really going to look at me in the eye and tell me that's the case. I'm just using your logic and your logic doesn't work. And now the Gar says the interesting thing here and another question. He says it has to go it's a two-way street. So if in if in the entire year I take other animals other and I take aim and I say it's a carbon pes what happens? It's kasha. And therefore if I take a current PES and I say that it's aim it's so throughout the year on I could go both directions. I could take aim and make it a PE take a P make it both kosher. So is saying on Arab it should go both ways also to make it ple. If I take a carbon pes and make it aim it's possible. So if I take aim and make it a car should also be puzzle. The two-way street should work both directions in both situations. Again, if during the year I have a two-way street, if I take a schlam and make it a pes, it's okay. And if I take a pes, make it a it's okay. So pes, which we know for a fact that if you take a carbon pes and make it aim, it's not okay. Logic should dictate that it goes the opposite way also that if I take aim and make it a carbon p, it should also be no good. What you just did is prove to me that is more severe than a carbon. Why? Because if becomes ple on pes that means it's becoming a carbon p becomes ple yet a carbon pes on is kosher. So you see that is more severe than a than carbon pes you hear the it's interesting >> and we know that carbon pes is more severe than everything else the tells us is more severe so that can't be okay that's the hard part for today soar takes it back says okay let me let me come from a different angle if you have leftover carbon what do you do you bring it as certainly you cannot take that's the first you can't take another carbon and make it into well that's his leftover do not become a carbon not the first so now he's starting with the by the way this is this is going to end very soon this back and forth you could later convert to aim. So, but but nevertheless, if I even though I can convert it later on in the year, I could convert it to but I never if I try converting a pes to what happens I have to destroy it. So carbon that never becomes you can never convert into a carbon that's if you try to take aim and make it should be possible I'm going to take your logic and ruin it for you. Why? I'm going to take the same logic and say let's do the same trick with I could convert leftover into how do I have a leftover only one way >> because if no no no no that's that would not work. >> No no no that's also one of the five that's one of the five that die. >> That's one of the five that dies. So the only way to make a converted into is if I buy two and say one is going to be how you say in English backup. >> A backup. A backup. Okay. Backup is a good is good. Uh we'll use that. In Hebrew they said they said what else? >> Reserve. >> Pinchitter. >> A pinch hitter. Is a pinchitter or reserve? That's what it was. No. >> Okay. >> No, >> a little different. >> I could use a good gishmaka drink now. >> Okay. So, so if you have leftover Oh, so what do you do if you have if you brought two and one as a backup and you actually ended up using one, what do you do with the second one? the second one. It's not like one got lost and you replaced it completely and you checked the number two and then you found number one. That's not what happened there. You brought two and you said if if I'm not going to use one, something happens to me, I'm going to use two. Then you take that one and you make it. But never do you have leftover that that converts into. And therefore, I'm going to use your logic and you're going to see that doesn't work. that could turn convert into we know that's the first if you take and try to switch it you have to you must destroy it where there is no converting to never convert into so if you take an with with Of course, it should be possible. Now, we know that that's not the case. You know why that's not the case? Because all year round 365, I don't know, 365, but all year round. But only has six hours a year. And therefore what sometimes sometimes the the isle when when you do it. So therefore it makes more sense that other others that are that for a current P should also be possible. Fine done new easy. So you know turning of the dire global specialist in international financial services anonymous anonymous in support of that all tests should come back 100% healthy for me and my family imagine this person going through Russ has some tests going on and he's waiting for results maybe he lives in cuz results take some time here it's a it's a different rash scary good news whatever it is I hope it's Uh maybe it's something else. Maybe it's a maybe it's SAT a driving test also takes nine or 10 times healthy driving test. >> Yeah. Yeah. Healthy a healthy driving test. >> Okay. Fine. >> Yeah. It should be healthy. >> Healthy for me and my family. Well, family also has tests. Okay. Whatever. Oh, for him. If he's healthy, then it's good for his family. Oh, that what I'll remind this is here. Oh, here's the remember this list. We have the on the right. We have the column on the left. Great. So Shimaria, we said there in the Mishna, why is he called? Because he is he was supported by Zarya. So he's always named after his brother Shimaria. It says like this that if if you take uh a higher up on the list from the count list is higher up in the list. So it's it's more than the one on the bottom, the micer. So if you go that that that route, it'll make it puzzle. But if you go the opposite route, if you go from micer, you take the say I want to go is more then it's kosher. And not only that, he says, and if you go from the list on the left and say take a say it should be an you're increasing the good. But if you go the opposite say should be a no good. We actually have a video here. This should explain the whole in one second. Corbonus elevator. I don't know where these guys come up with these ideas. Sluming him. You go up. You go up. You got a slum. [Music] It's red. No good. It's going down to the carmizer. [Applause] [Music] Okay. >> Okay. You cannot go from the top floor from Schlum down to the mice on the bottom floor. There will be Oh, that's the mice of me in Northfor, Virginia. M is this my favorite mice. I said it 10 times. For the new guys. For the new guys. As soon as I start saying it, you say, "Oh, yeah." >> When I brought my brother, my my brother, when I brought my son, my aram to Norfick, Virginia, the Jordan Stones Shiva over there, and they asked all the parents to leave cuz they want to give a first shir for the new guys. So, I went and I went to Walmart or whatever to buy him a bike cuz the dorm and the yeshiva are very far away from each other. Everybody had a bike. You had to go bought him a bike, come back with the bike, and come to the yeshiva and front door is locked. What do you do? I don't know if they had cell phones then. Not a thing. I'm sure there were cell phones, but not him. Not so I'm knocking, knocking, nothing. I'm sitting outside. Let me check the back. Go to the back door. Aby, you look at me like you never heard the story. >> You don't remember the story. >> A million times. >> Get sir. I have to make sure I don't mess up the story. I say it exactly the way I always do. >> Go to the back back of the I'm saying. Go to the back of the building. the the door locked. So there's a there's like a fire escape. So I start climbing the fire escape. Locked. Get to the third floor. Oh, there's a little bit of hope. The door is slightly It's not opening completely, but a little bit. I figure if I give it a big push, I could get in. So I back up and with my back, I get a zest. And in fact, it it opened up. But the pro I come tumbling in like this and in slow motion slow motion and these alarms these lights like you see and are very loud for the the the lights are for the for the deaf the the sounds are for people that are not deaf become deaf just from the sounds. And as I gather myself and I turn around, it's my son's new class, the Shir and the Machir. And the whole class is looking at me and my son is horrified. This this this face of I can't believe you just did this in front of my new yeshiva in front of all my new friends. I'm like, "Hi, I'm Alisansky. See you guys later." And I walk out the bush of Okay. And ever since then our relationship has not been the same. >> Says I have a lot of from these days says oh so where did he get this from? They could go up a little bit and it's okay. You go down you get the alarm. Did I ever say this ben in the Hebrew? I didn't you got to remind me say it one day. So it says in the now typically means to separate but we're going to use it like in Hebrew to go up to go upwards. If you go from down to above then it's a good carbon. So if the guy looks at a micer and he says it's aim then it's a good car. If you go downwards every ruins it is needed for something completely different. How do you know if somebody eats food that you didn't take to get the death penalty a heavenly death penalty? It's very means in the future but right now there was no truma taken it's in the future okay so I need the whole forum that is from the different way of writing it I can learn the two I learn that if you eat you eat food that you didn't take from you get the I also learn that I could go upwards in a carbon and it's okay. Now, let me show you this. It's super simple, but if you look in the gar, it could be slightly complicated. It's really simple. What say in the Mishna? If we do this, it'll be easier saying that if I mess up on a carbon, the the carbon, he thinks himself instead of thinking that it's a he thinks that it's aim, forget the no, that's not a good example. Instead of he says it's the first the first what's but what >> huh >> very good I have to bring another one what is that called kosher and not miratza does it matter if according to doesn't it matter that I went upwards I went from a micer to aim no even in case of going from tolam they say it's no good it's but and if I go from downwards to same exact they're consistent that will never change all besides if I if I think of different I don't care what direction from the top of the list to the bottom of the list it's I have to bring another carbon. Now let's think what does say now? Now we're going to understand him in a slightly different way at least for me. What does he say? He says that if you go upwards it's kosher. If you go downwards it's possible. So he's for sure arguing on the downwards because say if you go downwards it's still kosher. But he says you go down. The question is how many arguments does he have? One or two the way we see right now how many arguments are there? >> Only one because if he says if you go upwards it's kosher and so there's no argument over there. The only argument is if I go from down let's say to according to it would be possible according to that's one way of looking at it. But maybe said not that it's mirata, it's kosher and mirata. And what say and not they don't come out too. Check it out. If you go upwards, he says not only is it kosher but I don't have to bring another carbon. That's in disagreement to say you have to bring another carbon. That's argument number one. If I go upwards, if I go upwards is kosher and say argument number one. Argument number two would be if I go down is the same thing as we said before down according to it's possible and according to on the right side nothing ever changes with them. The question is what did say do you say or and that would be enough if he argues on one thing or two things. Yes, we're good. >> Yeah. I think like in this for hours only this hour only this hour get confused. >> I don't know if that works. So you brought think about it. You just came from it took you three and a half days to get here with your donkey. You had tremendous isurum. You finally get to the base of this and tell you well it's not 4:00. Got to wait. That's like we're closed today. Just wait around. You know what? I need to get I need to get home. >> No, you come in. You just go in out. You started making hours. >> Bring you bring you have to make two trips. >> Yeah. What if you bring two? What if you have you have to sit there all day long >> and listen to the full day outside? >> It's not like it happens. Just like with the hyest who says it ever happens. What if it happens? You should know it's possible. How could it be if it's the wrong >> how could they be according to what this viol >> Oh. Oh. So let's see. Let's see. We're going to discuss a little bit about what you're saying. That might be a little bit of what the is in the >> Oh, sorry. I just No, no, no. Wait, wait, wait. Oh, there does it mean does say that you have to bring another carbon then he's only arguing one thing on the the when it goes downwards that it's possible and they say it's perhaps he said the two things he says and it's a perfect carbon two What's aar your first born is it is it coming to forgive anything? No. What's it's all your new all your babies over there? You take one out of 10 and you it's not coming to forapar for anything and you take that. [Music] If you go downwards from top to bottom if he meant that it's meaning it's doesn't come for that's basically what is asking so you must say that when it comes to there's no so all cases what he means by by ration this is this is the ratio when I go from the right column to the left column that's the ratio and and this would be the the safa schlum to messer because in all cases there's no why because if in this case micer there's no kapara because doesn't come to give a kapara so too when I should say asham and whatever all these cases are not for kapara says classic line who said this if there's no in theap so why does it talk about what do I gain from that from this this thing right over here uh no this one what do I gain from this case right over here if there's no and there's no note that there's I'm telling you that even on the left column There's a there's a higher up there's hierarchy. There's a there's a and there's less here. I I could learn that from this case right over here. If I go from so this this higher and this lower no from the right column to the left column what is what is I think that to do one of these to take from the left column and flip it into it doesn't they're all the same they're all that's I also know from a different place it says what if you come to you're holding holding aim and he's holding a bkar the client looks at both of you what do you got I got what do you have akar what is he first he first so you see that is higher up even though it's they're on the same list of but is more than and explains why it's not because the different type is you have to do all four walls you have to lean on it you have to bring wine with it you have to wave the the breast into the thigh. I thought for me at least the Arab Mishna that there's a that there's a what's the what's the lion that it goes in >> hierarchy but there's a better >> priority >> priority oh priority baby there's a priority on the list there's the the there's the top there's a bottom oh there's gold you see I see the gold guys like in uh you know when you fly you have a priority >> status status comes first they get in first. So no, so by us that's where we learn the one the over there where it says that that's you learned that. Should we do the Mishna? lesson. Oh, so let's think about this for a second. We know if you the carbon pes in the 6-hour window, in other words, from until the night, and you think to yourself, it's not a carbon pes, it's carbon, destroy it. after then it's before. What if you in the morning before time when you're supposed to shed it in the afternoon? You did it in the morning. Is it does it ruin the carbon or doesn't ruin the carbon? It didn't. It's not time yet. What do I do? Nonchalantly Greeman is taking videos of me like I don't see the short. Was he brother? Don't tell me he's over there. >> Oh my >> he is. Wow. You done seeing with me? No. I'm saying because he was taking this old man that came in and he took care of him, putting the whole thing. So he's doing he he heed before the time of heed it in mind. But what's the difference in the morning is the same thing as doing it on the 13th and the 12th of of of it's before the time the is going to start off saying that maybe hold that the whole day is kosher even in the morning that's why he says that it's possible he says it's possible interesting I got I got a tradition from 72 it doesn't say scan it says zakmor is going to discuss why it says zak in other words all 72 said the same exact thing the famous story that they they got they got rid of who's and they put in there yeah the famous story basically this is coming to argue on what we learned on the in the first mishna of what do we learn in the first mission that there's two carbon that if you mess up you have to destroy the carbon and now he adds another one more's nephew >> yes I think so because that's what he said over there he have no this is >> uncle his uncle >> yeah that's >> because of this of supporting all animals that you could that are edible that are edible. He says that you had the wrong intent for the but you have to bring another one. They're continue bringing them but you have to the owner has to bring another one. So what did he just add? We already know he had another one. One more third one is not edible. If you mess up on the on the you got to destroy it also on the have a meaningful fast. Have a wonderful day for coming. [Music] >> Merit these of spreading Torah throughout the world. Sponsor Ashir today. mdysponsor.com or sponsor at mdy.com.