Preparing video...
0:00 / 0:00
Bar Mitzvah Discussion - Ask The Rabbi Live with Rabbi Mintz
135 views
Oorah's founder, Rabbi Chaim Mintz, giving his weekly Tuesday night class at Oorah's Torah Spot in Staten Island. The class is streamed live at http://www.oorah.org/rabbimintzlive each Tuesday night at . "Ask the Rabbi" session begins at . Send your question to be answered by Rabbi Mintz to [email protected] ALL QUESTIONS ARE WELCOME!
Featuring:Bar Mitzvah
Categories:Torah
Comments
Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
i have a question about um who um was
abraham's son um isaac the first child
to um be bar mitzvahed why can't i see
who's asking the question
what
isaac's mom
oh yeah i couldn't see you
yeah okay now so yeah
oh the question i had was um
abraham's son isaac was was that the
first bar mitzvah that ever occurred in
the torah or
the first bar mitzvah yeah
or who who was the first child to ever
be abominable what was my mistake a
party you mean or becoming
by first by mitzvah well i guess like
turning 13 and
becoming obligated to follow jewish law
well there was nobody obligated to file
jewish law at that time because the
torah was not given yet
so they only had the ability to keep the
seven noah was
the great
abrams
to make their earth patrols they kept it
on their own
because they wanted to keep because they
knew it's a good thing
but there's no obligation to keep it
until the term was given to mount sinai
now
you brought up an interesting point
is there such a thing as by mitzvah by a
non-jew
a jewish person we say he was obligated
at 13
by non-jew
most
opinions say
he becomes obligated before 13. 13 is
only a jewish age
but a non-jewish person
once a child becomes
a
person with
able to understand and choose being good
and bad maybe maybe 11
maybe
12 maybe nine it depends on the child
they become obligated to keep the laws
of the seven laws at that age
and by mitts of 13 is only a jewish
age of obligation
but non-jew says that seven laws have to
be kept once a child becomes
smart enough
knowledgeable enough to know what's
going on what right and wrong is what
god is what our law is that he's
obligated at that time
some people have the false impression
they think by mitzvah is like a wedding
a person doesn't have a wedding he's not
married if they don't have a mitzvah
party monopoly are not obligated
they make a mistake
that's a wedding if you don't get
married if you don't have a wife give
her a ring she's not your wife but a
person is 13 he can be in in on mars and
nobody's around there's no
no schnapps to drink and no cake he is
he's 13. he becomes obligated to keep
the torah don't need any ceremony
wedding needs a ceremony but
doesn't need the ceremony
but make people make the mistake if i
didn't have the ceremony bar mitzvah i'm
not bar mitzvah i don't get what i want
that's that's that's a that's a very on
the
un untrue kind of idea people have we
make a ceremony by with to show that
we're very happy that the child has come
to the
point in his life where he's
comes
obligated to keep the laws of the torah
so we make a party to show that we're
very happy about it but that didn't make
him interrupt
didn't make the obligation the age made
the obligation