Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
The Yeshiva.net
I'd like to introduce Rabbi Jacobson to
talk about this very important topic.
Thank you for coming.
Thank you, everybody.
Thank you for the source.
Thank you for the honor.
Thank you for the privilege
of uh
addressing all of you today.
I know that we have hundreds of people
listening.
And uh many more will probably watch or
listen later.
And I'm really very grateful
for this uh
this privilege and opportunity and to
talk
about something
so important.
And for this organization Avnei Chein
for all of your tireless efforts and
dedication and love
for our brothers and sisters in your
community and across Eretz Yisrael and
all those you impact directly and
indirectly.
And uh
Vihi noam Hashem Elokeinu aleinu u'masei
yadeinu konnena aleinu. As Moshe says,
"Yirat shamayim tishreh shchinah b'masei
yedeichem."
May the shchinah dwell
in the work of your hands so that you
should be able to continue to grow and
be successful
and be ambassadors of true healing
and uh recovery
and hope
and uh love
and uh expansive redemptive
consciousness.
And with arichas yamim v'simchas hadas
u'menuchas hanefesh v'haguf.
So
my topic today
is dealing with the stigmas
of uh
I would say everything connected to
mental and emotional health.
The stigmas in our community, the
stigmas in our homes, our families
individually and collectively.
And
where we stand today, how we can
improve, how can we how we can each
become kinder, more sensitive, more
compassionate
within our own hearts, within our own
homes and families, within our
communities, for ourselves, for our
loved ones.
So, I'm going to
share a few
a few thoughts, a few uh
feelings about this matter.
And I know we're going to have
Soon we're going to open the floor also
to dialogue and questions and answers.
Everybody could uh
I guess you already announced everybody
will share their questions and we'll
address it on a more personal, intimate
level in response to people's questions.
I think
it probably won't be uh
dramatic to say
that
in our generation, in our times
we are seeing something very strange
happening. Maybe it's not so strange,
but
many people call it strange.
Namely
an explosion
in the mental heal health field
based on a mental health crisis.
There's not a day that doesn't go
through that doesn't go by that I myself
don't deal with either many emails,
letters, texts, WhatsApps, conversations
reaching out
for this crisis or that crisis, this
breakdown or that breakdown, this family
or this community
going through a very difficult
situation.
People are wondering, why? What happened
suddenly?
You know, mothers write to me all the
time, "Well, you think my life was so
easy when I grew up? Fathers say, "Well,
what what do what do these kids want?
What do they want? They have more
comfort
than we had, than our than our parents
had, than our grandparents had. We're
not crazy, abusive parents."
There's a lot of confusion.
There's a lot of pain. There's a lot of
anger. There's a lot of frustration.
There's a lot of resentment.
I would say there's also a lot of
ignorance. There's a lot of
judgmentalism.
You know, some are saying
it's all the fault of
the society today and the mental health
professionals and rabbis or spiritual
leaders or activists and who contribute
to the toxicity of encouraging and
reinforcing the mental health crisis.
In other words, what about going back to
good old disciplinarian measures where
we don't take our emotions so seriously
and we just tell our children, learn
from me, be a soldier, put one foot
ahead of another foot and march on to
the promised land and everything will
work out.
Some of you are smiling cuz you're well
familiar with this approach.
And, you know,
I think it's in this area it's so
important to be humble and open.
There is room to discuss. There's a lot
of room to discuss, you know, the the
boundaries that are blurred
between
being empathetic to emotions
and
losing
all definitions of right and wrong,
constructive and destructive,
the need to be able to
be in control of my thoughts and my
words and my actions.
So, there is a lot of room for that.
But, I think I think
that many of us have tried that. We have
tried, you know,
putting down our fist, saying this is
how it is and hoping
that everything will turn out wonderful.
But, it doesn't work that way very
often.
And
I don't think anybody here is on just
for voluntary reasons, cuz you have
nothing to do, and you decide that this
is what you want to think about. I think
Ahavas Chinam was founded, as many other
organizations, because of a real real
situation.
Because of reality. I could try to fight
reality, but at some point I have to
embrace reality, not fight it.
And the reality is
that so many people are struggling.
And many of us don't know what to do
with it.
And I want to discuss a few issues with
this.
The first element has to do with shame,
stigma.
This is a big one.
Shame and stigma is based on the idea
that
we have developed a culture, and I'm
going to be saying this
with God's grace, without any judgment,
because to judgment is on me, just like
anybody else. It's not about judgment.
This is really about identifying,
identifying truth in a compassionate and
humble way.
But, we often grow up in cultures and
communities, and I'm talking about all
different types of communities and all
different types of cultures, even within
the Jewish world, and within the Jewish
Orthodox world, and within the Jewish
ultra-Orthodox world. And I know that
the demographics are very very diverse,
and that's wonderful. So, this is not
about one
community, or one movement, or one
group. This is really about a general
trend that affects us all.
And that is that we we like to feel that
nachas, success, means that we create
perfect families, or at least close to
perfect families.
As I always say, we want to hatch them,
match them, and dispatch them.
Give birth, put them on the conveyor
belt of a Jewish education, right? Three
years later is an upsherinish, a few
years later is a bar mitzvah, bas
mitzvah, a few years later hopefully you
can walk them down to the chuppah and
ask them to give nachas with a new
generation coming and now you become a
zayden and a bubba.
I'm saying this of course a little bit
the tongue in cheek and humor, but you
get the point.
And sometimes it works that way, you
know, those kids who follow the
trajectory of our systems and they do it
well and they do indeed bring us to a
lot of joy and happiness and it's very
special and it's very beautiful. And
just because a child likes the system
and works through the system, we
shouldn't discriminate against them and
not give them all their needs, right? Al
pi shaloisha is oich Yisroel and even a
kid who's not driving you meshuga
deserves all the attention and all the
attachment and all the empathy like
every other child who is driving you a
little crazy. So we have to remember
that. Very, very important not to
neglect that child who's just waking up
in the morning and going to yeshiva and
going to school
just because he or she has not rebelled.
But the fact remains that so many of the
youth
are not in that. They're not following
that path.
And whatever the reason may be,
there may be mental challenges,
emotional challenges, spiritual
challenges, social challenges,
psychological challenges, challenges
within the house, challenges within
themselves.
Challenges that come from their nature,
challenges that come from nurture.
Challenges that are connected with
parenting, challenges that are maybe
connected to epigenetics, things we have
inherited through all generations before
us and maybe a combination of so many
factors.
And it's all coming together now in a
very, very intense and I think an
unpress, at least from what I know,
very unprecedented and certainly in
terms of the quantity and also in terms
of the quality.
And the shame and the stigma becomes so
profound, you know?
You're embarrassing the family and what
are the shadchanim going to say? And
what if I can't get my other daughters
into the right seminary? And what if I
can't get my sons into the right Yeshiva
and generally what are my neighbors
going to think about us?
And what do my parents think about us,
the grandparents and my uncles and aunts
and next week we have a cousin and a
shower and a mitzvah and
is she going to come? Is he going to
come? They're not going to come.
And generally if we start talking about
all these things like you know what was
we have a crazy family like we have
mental illness in our family.
We have depression in our family. We
have psychosis in our family. We have
bipolar in our family. We have
schizophrenia in our family. We have
acute depression in our family.
We have a lot of anxiety in our family.
We have somebody who shalom tried to do
the worst in our family all in our
family.
And I'm like uh
I'm a prominent guy in my community in
Israel, you know. I've been learning in
college I don't know for 23 years. I'm
considered a Thomas Hachem and my wife
is like a decus and you know the biggest
ballas in the whole neighborhood and
I'm just giving one example but there
are millions and millions of examples.
You get the point. And I think there
comes a moment in life
where we all have to look very very
deeply into ourselves
and say goodbye to the ego of shame and
stigma.
Because you have to choose
the safety of your children
the well-being of your loved ones or
the external egotistical validation that
comes from people thinking not knowing
thinking
that we are this most beautiful family.
And I want to say it's not easy.
And I don't judge people who can do it
because it's a hard journey. It's really
really you know I have to tell you this
moment it touched me so deeply.
So go I did an interview with Rabbi
Shimon Russell
who wrote the book Raising a Loving
Family a very good book very special
book.
And we did a three-hour interview maybe
some of you have watched it
about you know why my child hates
religion why my child hates Judaism how
to bring out the best in your children,
how to create attachment and safety.
And he shared a very, very personal
experience. It touched me so deeply. He
was in Lakewood. He lived in Lakewood
for more than 30 years, learned in Kyle
and became a therapist there. Classic,
you know, Gateshead graduate, Lakewood
finance, he would say Lithuanian Kyle
bent Torah Thomas Hachem young man
following through, you know, the
Lakewood system, Torah and more Torah
and Yira Shamayim, you know, Torah and
fear of heaven and a Jewish religious
household on the most
the most optimal level.
And Baruch Hashem, God blessed him and
his wife with eight children. And as he
put it, six of them six of them
or seven of them
struggled deeply, deeply with Judaism
and fell out of the system.
And he said one Friday night he was
sitting at the table,
grouchy, angry, upset. None of the
children were following the system. You
know, sit at the table, let's sing
beautiful songs. Mommy made the most
delicious fish and soup and chicken and
dessert, kavod.
Let's share something on the parsha.
Let's share something you learned this
week in Mishnayos. Let's have an
interesting conversation about Torah,
about Yiddishkeit, about life, about the
family. I don't know, maybe about Purim,
about Pesach, whatever it is. And none
of this was happening.
Instead, there was confrontation and
negative energy and darkness
and anger and alienation and no interest
at all in Shabbos and the holiness of
Shabbos and the beauty of Shabbos and
the transcendence of Shabbos. And he was
very, very upset. This was not the
Shabbos table
we imagine, we dream of, we envision, we
anticipate, we hope for.
And he finishes benching
and he's going up to the second floor I
guess to retire.
And he's really upset at his kids. He's
really upset, you know, they're ruining
his life.
And Rabbi Russell said, his daughter
let's put it this way, wasn't dressed,
you know, in the most uh
religious uniform.
And was rebellious.
Turned to him as he's going up and she
passed him in the hallway. She turned to
him and he said, she said words
that changed his life. She said to him,
"Tati
it doesn't look like this Judaism thing
is working out too well for you."
Mhm?
And hit him.
It was like a lightning bolt. Doesn't
look like this Judaism thing is working
out too well for you. You seem so
miserable.
And this was it jolted him.
Because she was honest. She like,
"You're miserable."
You're a miserable person.
And at that moment, he said he had to
make a choice and he transformed his
life.
From being a slave
to the society around him.
You know what happened? He became a
servant of God.
It's a shift that happens deep
in your heart, deep in your soul. Nobody
has to see it.
But you know it and heaven knows it.
It's a very deep shift.
It's ask not
what my children can do for me.
Ask
I ask what I can do for my children.
It's not only what Hashem can do for me,
it's what I can do for Hashem.
It's to quote Mordecai's words to Esther
Hamalka.
Mi yodea
im le'et kazot higat lamalchut.
Esther
was rebelling against Mordecai's
message.
Esther was defiant for good reason.
It's not that she was an always a
defiant person, she was not. I don't
know if she had, you know, oppositional
defiant oppositional disorder.
Or oppositional defiant disorder, ODD.
But Esther said, Mordecai, your
suggestion doesn't make sense.
You want me to go into a king, to my
husband, without permission. He hasn't
been interested in me for 30 days. You
walk in without permission, you come up
with a head shorter. For what? Maybe I
can rescue a people that I am now
estranged from.
I'll remain in the palace. Hopefully,
I'll stay alive. But if I go in,
everybody dies.
There was a very, very deep, deep
resistance in Esther's words. But
Mordecai says something.
And it persuades her to go. And after
everything he says, don't think you're
going to be saved. If you don't do
anything and you're passive, we will be
saved anyway. You and your father's
house will be lost. But then he says,
who knows if this is not the reason you
were chosen as the queen, as the first
lady of the Persian Empire.
What's the meaning? Who knows? Me or
they? Like, maybe. Yeah, maybe not. You
should say, I know. We know.
Divine providence has brought you here
for this moment.
And one of the profound explanations is
Mordecai was answering a very deep
question.
Esther was like, how did I end up in
this mess? I'm a regular Jewish girl,
you know, valedictorian of Bais Yaakov.
Or valedictorian of Bnei Zion, of Bais
Rochel, of Bais Chana, of Bruriah, of
Shulamith, of Neve, or whatever school.
I'm I'm I'm a great girl. I had a future
building a beautiful Jewish home with a
beautiful Shabbos table, with a Yom Tov,
with I'll put him This is before putting
him with a Pesach, with a Shavuos, with
a Sukkos.
How did I end up with this alcoholic,
with this drunkard who killed his first
wife, Vashti? A Persian monarch who's
not Jewish. Why? How? And Mordecai says,
me or they? Some things transcend us.
They transcend knowledge.
Me or they? Unless cuz I say God knows
was not a statement of ambivalence and
doubt. It was a statement of I don't
know.
Some things transcend us. our
intellectual ability to grasp them and
control them.
Your mission in life is beyond what I or
even you can really understand
intellectually. Don't try to
mathematically make sense of oh, it
makes sense based on the trajectory of
my life that I ended up in the palace.
Some things are what we say in the
morning
or my knowing girl Lena. What is girl
Lena? Our lot our girl is a girl. A girl
seems random. Why did you win the girl
and I lost the girl? Why did this goat
get chosen to go here and this goat
there? It's a girl. It's a lot. It's
like a random mistake. But we know it's
not random.
It comes from a place that's higher than
our logic and intellect cuz logic and
intellect are also creations. This is
what Mordecai was telling us to that's
why Purim is called poor. Poor means the
girl a lot just like Yom Kippur. Yom
Kippurim Yom Kippur is like Purim cuz
Purim was also the the lot. Everyone has
a different journey. One goat goes here,
one goat goes there.
How do you know exactly what your
mission is? How do you know what is
right and what's wrong? How do you know
what a perfect family looks like? How do
you know what a perfect job is table or
say there of Pesach looks like? How do
you know what a beautiful home looks
like?
I don't. You know what I do know? I do
know this.
It's not a mistake that these are my
children.
Hashem has given these children to me.
He didn't make a mistake. It means that
these parents
are best equipped to be able to be the
most powerful force of healing for these
children and for themselves. It's not a
mistake. You say yeah, but why am I
dealing with this and why is my neighbor
not dealing with this? And why does my
sister have it so easy? And why does my
brother have it so easy? And why is my
sister making her 14th wedding? I don't
know and within twice.
And I'm still struggling with so much. I
don't know me I day and least cuz I say
get the most but one thing I do know.
And that is I have to stop asking
what everybody is going to do for me to
make me look good.
And say this is really not about my ego.
Now it's time to tune into my soul's
calling, my soul's mission.
Ma Hashem Malach K'Shoyn Yimayimoch.
What does God want from you? And it's
not what he wants from me. It's not what
he wants from you and from you.
Is this something I can always grasp and
understand exactly the meaning and the
purpose and how it's going to work out?
No.
It's a state of me ad d'lo yada. But
this is These are the moments that open
our hearts to infinity. They allow us
not to be stuck in arrogance or
narcissism or shallowness or
superficiality or egotism. This is the
moments when we actually become free. We
are liberated. We become emancipated cuz
I'm not here to impress anybody. I'm not
a people's pleaser anymore. I'm not here
to look good to you or to you or to you.
I'm not about that.
It becomes a moment of authenticity
and therefore becomes a moment of
vulnerability.
My dearest friends, these are choices we
each have to make. Am Are you going to
live from a place of authenticity and
vulnerability? Or am I going to live
from a place of cover-ups
and arrogance?
Not because I'm an arrogant person who
wants to live in cover-ups, but simply
those are my coping mechanisms. Those
are my survival skills. I get it.
I don't want to be vulnerable.
I want to be respected. I want to have a
stand. I want to be chashuv. You want to
be I get it. I understand.
I want my kids to look like they're
playing the part.
They can get dressed up once a year. My
kids are dressed up all year like Purim,
but maybe Purim is the only real day.
You know, other days of the year we
think those are the normal days. Purim
is like, you know, the strange day, ad
d'lo yada. Right? The other days of the
year we know who everybody is. I know
who you are, you know who I am. I have
control, I have a schedule, everything
is planned. And Purim is the day, you
know, where chaos reigns.
Maybe it's the other way around.
All the other days we're dressing up,
trying to make believe we know who
everybody is and that we're in control.
Purim is the authentic day. Adloyada,
give it up. Let it go.
The freedom of letting go, letting go,
letting go for real. I don't have to
control anybody. I could relinquish
control. I don't have to play God. I'm
not God. I'm a channel for Hashem.
When you let go of the need to be God
and you can be a channel for God, you're
a free person. You know why? Cuz you
have all the power without all the
responsibility. Listen to what I'm
telling you. You have all the power
without all the responsibility. You have
all the power cuz you're Hashem's
shliach.
The messenger carries and possesses the
properties of the one who sent him.
You're a shliach of Hashem
for these people. You are their father,
you are their mother, you're a brother,
you're a sister, you're a relative,
you're a friend, you're a therapist,
you're a teacher, you're a mentor,
you're a guide, you're a rebbe, whatever
it is.
And you are a shliach for yourself, for
your own soul.
And as a result of that, I have the
divine power that I need to be able to
show up.
But I don't have to take responsibility.
It's not personal. It's not personal.
And that's how we let go of stigmas. We
need open conversations.
Let me Let me Let me try to be honest
with you. I think I'm trying to be
honest the whole time.
You know, I feel that sometimes so many
of our conversations in our communities
are so
saturated with cover-ups, with
inauthenticity. People are sick of it.
You will have to choose which
which team you're going to be in. Are
you going to be those Are you going to
be from those who help us find a
solution?
Or those who continue to wallow
kvetching and sighing about how terrible
all of our youth are and how spoiled we
are and narcissistic and confused and
all these parents who are enabling these
meshugana kids to go crazy. They
themselves are just
completely confused. You're going to be
part of the problem or you're going to
be part of the solution.
We want authentic conversation.
We want real conversation. There's
nothing as liberating as being authentic
and vulnerable. You know why? I don't
have to carry the burden of trying to
protect my vulnerability, trying to
protect my humaness, trying to be what I
am not. And our kids are so sensitive
today to truth. They are done with
cover-ups.
They are done with religion that feeds
toxicity. Religion that has so much
corruption and politics, so many ego
games,
so many cover-ups. They're done with it.
They don't want a God that is toxic.
They don't want a God that is based on
lies. They don't want a religion that
can't deal with real authenticity and
creates these models of perfection that
are maybe realistic for some people but
completely alienating for others.
This requires a conversation where we
could be truly open and real and
vulnerable. And one day I'm going to
tell this to you.
You will look at those children
who made you struggle most and thank
them.
Cuz you will say El Hanar
has his polarity.
Till you don't reach that point, know
that there's still a lot of work.
And still you're looking for another
child. Couldn't you be like your
brother? Couldn't you be like your
cousin? Couldn't you be like me? You're
not in the game. You're disconnected.
And I say this without judgment, trust
me.
With a lot of compassion, but you're not
you're not connected.
Only when like Hannah, you could look at
your child and say
he's pal LT.
It's for this child that I prayed.
I can't thank you enough, and I can't
thank Hashem enough for giving you to
me.
You are my pride. You are my joy. When I
see you, my heart swells with love.
Now you guys are thinking, "Rabbi, why
why which planet are you living in?"
Do you know my child?
Do I get an applause for that? Which
planet are you living in?
And I say to you, "I'm living on planet
Earth, and I know the struggle.
We're all in the same boat. But this is
our work.
Very often, our work with our children
is not work with them. It's work with
ourselves.
How godly are you?
How well am I dealing with my trauma,
with my coping mechanisms?
How much am I connected to my own true
self?
And this is where I come to another, I
think, very very important point.
And this has to do
with inner work. Inner work.
When
we are watching in our communities, in
our children, in ourselves,
you may be you may be
you may be listening, and you're going
through these struggles.
What is the most difficult thing that
happens? The most difficult thing that
happens is
that it's very very easy to project our
problems on others,
to blame others,
or to get very angry and resentful and
lose the plot.
And this is where we need to learn how
to regulate ourselves.
The real work
of being there for people who are
struggling
is do we know
how
to truly truly be aligned in ourselves?
Because all I can give you is me.
I can't give you anything else.
All I can give you is my authenticity,
my blood, my heart, my soul, my truth,
my light. I can't give you anything
else. I can't control you. I don't want
to control you.
I can't manipulate you. I don't want to
manipulate you. I can't exploit you. I
could, but I don't want to.
I also can't at the end of the day let's
come back to want me, but I I I don't
want to.
What I want to give you is I want to
give you my truth. I want to give you my
neshama. I want to give you my soul. For
this I have to have a relationship with
my soul.
So, let's talk about parents and
children for a moment or teachers and
and students.
Educators and and disciples.
Whatever the relationship, parents and
children are obviously the most intense
and intimate relationship in terms of
connection, but this is true of all
relationships, husbands and wives.
When my child is behaving a certain way
or going down a certain path and I'm
being very very triggered
and I'm now living in a place of despair
or guilt or shame or fear
or a lot of anger and resentment
or so much anxiety.
The real work here is not to change my
child. The real work here is to change
me, to change myself.
This is where I and you, we all I need
to develop tools, find tools to be able
to make our soul our best friend.
To be able to find calmness inside of
ourselves. To be able to deal with our
own mental challenges, our own inner
struggles. And here's the truth.
We all develop coping mechanisms at a
very, very young age, and those coping
mechanisms help us survive.
But many of those coping mechanisms
become terrible distractions
as we get older. They may undermine our
marriages. They may undermine our
relationships with our children. Most
importantly, they undermine our
relationships with our own truth.
I don't know my own truth cuz I'm living
with a coping mechanism, and it proved
successful for many years, 50 years.
Maybe I disassociated emotionally, and
it did well for me cuz I couldn't deal
with my emotions. Maybe I became very
aggressive. Maybe I became very meek and
passive. Maybe I became the ultimate
people pleaser. Maybe I'm dealing with
constant anxiety, constant guilt,
constant shame, constant anger, constant
resentment. These are things I need to
be able to work on, deal with.
Am I ready for my other way out? Am I
ready to let go of my coping mechanisms,
of my egotistical structures, and
develop new neural pathways that are
based on mystery, infinity. Can I open
Can I open myself up every single day
to my inner divine soul, which is a
chelek elokai mima'l?
It's a derivative of infinite
consciousness. It's a fragment of the
divine.
It transcends abuse. It transcends
illness. It transcends
any flaw.
The soul is always filled with
confidence and joy and oneness and
promise. It's full of curiosity
and compassion, creativity and courage,
love and connection. It's a derivative
of the divine. It's infinite.
It's not afraid.
It's not afraid of authenticity. It's
not afraid of vulnerability. That is its
staple. It is authentic because it's
divine. Hashem Elokeinu emes. And it's
full of joy and strength. Oiz vechedva
bemkomo. it says in tell them we say it
every morning. There was confidence and
joy in his space. In that space of mine.
I am a derivative of Elokus, of
godliness, of Ein Sof. I am a
manifestation of Hashem in this world.
Or to put it in very deep, deep
spiritual, Kabbalistic, and Hasidic
terms, basically
This is a famous expression of one of
the great masters. An neshama is Elokus
nasa nivra.
A soul is the way Hashem, Hashem's
infinite light becomes embodied
in you and in me.
When I go to that place, there is so
much love.
There is so much truth. There is so much
connection. But I have other voices.
Those are the coping mechanisms. We call
it my animal consciousness, my animal
soul. The voices of my body trying to
survive and my nervous system may not
have regulation.
The more we, you and I, work on this,
the more we become the most honest
people, the best version of ourselves,
the more we learn
how
to regulate our nervous system, the more
we create a link between the mind and
the body.
Because the language that connects the
mind to the body is the nervous system.
But if I never learned how to regulate
it, if I never learned how to listen to
the language of the body, you can be
inspired and hear a great speech today
by Rabbi YY Jacobson and by our great
psychiatrists and therapists and
psychologists and life coaches and
pedagogues and brilliant orators and
guides. And it's great and you go home
or you're already home probably. And you
say, "You know what? Tonight I'm going
to respond differently."
Tomorrow morning I'm going to respond
differently. I know what to do. And let
me tell you friends,
doesn't work. You know why? Because she
comes into the kitchen, he comes into
the kitchen, they say something and
you're triggered. My your body feels
unsafe. Your body feels unsafe.
And there is a reason for it. Because
it's triggering something inside of you
that is very very deep and it's not
about your child, it's about you.
Those of us who realize that are on the
way of tremendous tremendous healing and
redemption.
Because now I can take responsibility.
This doesn't mean what my child is doing
is right or wrong. We're not talking
about that. It's we're talking about our
reactions, our triggers. Can I identify
the triggers inside my own soul and work
on them?
Because when I can show up with my
divinity, with my godliness to my child,
to the struggles of my child, everything
is different. My child won't feel my
anger. My child won't feel my judgment.
My child won't feel the need for me to
control their life. What my child will
feel is unconditional love.
Unconditional attachment. Unconditional
connection.
And then that will allow them to heal.
Because when I believe in them, they'll
be able to believe in them. But I can
only believe in them is if I have a
relationship with me, if I believe in
me.
And I'm not talking now philosophy.
This is not another lecture that Rabbi
YY is giving. I'm now talking about the
visceral knowledge and experience.
When you feel that, when you connect
with that, you radiate it. And when you
radiate it, the people around you also
change.
There's an insight I once shared. I saw
it somewhere and it touched me so
deeply. You know, at Pesach, we have
this custom
that we take the afikoman and we hide
it. It's called yachatz. We break the
matzah and then we hide the matzah and
who finds it? Our children go and find
it. And they are the ones who may hide
it and then they'll retrieve it and
reveal it to us and then they want an
afikoman prize.
And sometimes parents get really upset,
you know, why did you steal my afikoman?
Bring it to me.
And they negotiate and then when your
children are satisfied, they will give
you the afikoman. Mazel tov, we can
continue the seder.
And there's a deep message here. The
deep message is what we hide, our
children are going to reveal. We all
have our afikomans. They're called
safun. Safun means it's hidden. What we
hide, our children are going to expose.
They're going to reveal. Now, I have may
I may have hidden it for 50 years very
successfully. I may have suppressed it
or repressed it to a point that it was
completely below the surface and I had
no knowledge of what is going on. I was
so detached and so disconnected. So,
even though I was living in active
active active trauma, I have no
awareness of anything and I'm just
following things by rote.
And those of us who are successful
people know that our trauma can create a
story of success, but we are living in a
survival state. We are living with
coping mechanisms that paralyze us and
debilitate us and take away our emotions
and our bliss of life. Life was not
supposed to be made to live in misery
and agony. You weren't supposed to be
fighting with your kids and fighting
with your spouse and hating God and
hating the world. That's not how life
was supposed to
be designed. I know we're living in
galas. We're living in exile. There's a
lot a lot of pain.
But now we want to prepare for a
redemption. We want to prepare for a
transformed state. And the
transformation begins inside of me. So,
things that I hide, my children bring to
the fore. It's called afikoman.
And when my child holds up that afikoman
and says, "Hey tati, look. Look." And
suddenly I get to see some of my demons.
Some of my coping mechanisms, some of my
skeletons, some of my ghosts, some of my
most painful things. My instincts say,
"Run away. Run away. Run away. Run
away." Just smile and make believe
nothing is happening, but I am angry.
And others have this voice, "Fight.
Attack. Scream at your kids. This is
chutzpah. This is disrespectful.
Everything I did to you, how dare you
speak to me this way?"
Sorry, you were triggered. Now, I am the
three-year-old. My child is nine and I'm
three. My child is 16, and I'm two.
Or you could do something else. You
could look at the afikoman.
You can hug your child and say, "Thank
you.
Thank you for this gift."
Come, let's continue the seder, and now
we could both say together, "L'shana
haba'ah
b'Yerushalayim."
Next year, this year in Jerusalem. In
other words, we can together go
and celebrate our redemption because I I
didn't run away from my afikoman.
I embraced my afikoman.
And let me just tell you, it's not
always easy. There are voices in our
animal consciousness and our body that
are very, very scared.
Remember,
and here is a truth about life.
It says in Sefarim that marriage is a
second birth, meaning the soul comes
into the body once,
and then when we get married, it's like
the soul rebirth reborn again in this
relationship with your spouse.
The other day in a shiur, I explained
what that means, at least one of the
aspects of what I think it means.
And that is every neshama comes down to
this world with a special mission, with
a special tikkun. Mi ya'idiam laze kaze
I say got l'malkhus. Everyone has a
light to bring to the world.
Every one of us. The Mishna says,
"Everyone is supposed to say, 'For me,
the world was created.'" Hayav adam
l'omar bishvili nivra olam. It's not a
narcissistic statement. It's the supreme
Jewish perspective on life. There is
something at stake in the universe that
only you and you and you and you and me
can fix and repair. And no one else
before you or living after you will ever
be able to do this. This is your mission
that is exclusive to you. Bishvili nivra
olam.
And every single one of us has that. And
that includes fixing things and
repairing things and confronting things
and subduing darkness and transforming
darkness. And it's based on your mission
that you have your parents and your
circumstances and your mental
challenges.
This is not a mistake. It's not a
tragedy. It's a journey. Me, I day, I
don't understand it. You don't
understand it. We don't have to
understand it.
We Let me tell you something. The
deepest things in life
we can't understand, we don't have to
understand, we don't want to understand.
I'm going to say it again cuz this is
precious.
I heard it from the Rebbe. The deepest
things in life
we can't understand, we don't have to
understand, we don't want to understand.
Are you going to do reduce the
relationship between a mother and a baby
and a child to an intellectual
mathematical game?
Oh, yeah, you know, that I'm responsible
for the baby cuz legally there's no
other guardian and I'm the guardian and
if I'm responsible that if I'm going to
nurse you in the middle of the night.
It's true, but it's much beyond that.
The deepest truths about ourselves are
intrinsic in our DNA beyond my hand,
beyond logic.
Our mission is rooted in Adonai Adonai.
The less logical we are about it, the
more we could be open to it.
And therefore everyone has a mission and
we sometimes have to fix things. And if
I don't fix things, when I get married,
it's my soul coming down again because
my wife
will probably challenge me and bring up
those stuff
to give me an opportunity to heal what I
didn't heal yet. And your husband the
same thing.
This doesn't mean every marriage you
should stick through. Sometimes it's too
abusive, it's too unbearable. He's not
ready to be fixed or she's not ready to
be fixed. But if you're both ready,
what I didn't do before my marriage, I
have an opportunity now in my marriage
to heal through my relationship with my
spouse. Because what happens very often
in marriages,
his trauma triggers her trauma. Her
trauma triggers his trauma. If they both
get entangled in their own trauma, they
start killing each other because they're
meant for each other and their traumas
are killing each other. But,
if her trauma
triggers his empathy
and his trauma triggers her empathy,
now their souls connect and together
they can help each other confront their
own traumas. That's an incredible
opportunity. This is what makes
marriages blissful, my friends. Now,
sometimes we don't do it in our
marriages, so God gives us a third
opportunity. It's called our children.
Our children will trigger all of our
traumas, I guarantee you. I got an
applause for that, too, by the way. Our
children will trigger all of our
traumas. If not number one, number two.
If not number two, number three. Usually
each one will trigger another trauma.
Each one will trigger another one. If
you have Baruch Hashem seven children,
you probably have seven serious traumas
to deal.
If you have 12 children, okay, good
luck. But we're all dealing with
something and when we can confront our
Af Kayin and embrace it, it's
incredible.
It's incredible.
I'm going to tell you something else, my
friends. I have another 10 minutes and
I'm going to go to questions.
I'm going to I want to I want to tell
you really two things. One is a personal
experience
that gives me a lot of strength.
And this personal experience
I think is a prelude to perspective.
And the personal experience happened
when I was a child.
I was a child.
I grew up in Brooklyn, New York. You
could probably hear from my accent.
I didn't grow up in Mississippi. I
didn't grow up in Atlanta. I grew up in
Brooklyn, New York.
In a neighborhood called the Crown
Heights section of Brooklyn,
where we always worked on integration
between different types of communities.
One year it was Arab Pesach it was
Pesach at night.
First night of Pesach.
The Lubavitcher Rebbe
who lived in the neighborhood would give
matzah after my gift to a few people.
His secretaries,
people who worked in his office, people
who worked in his home, helped out with
his helped out in the house.
People who helped out his
brother-in-law.
Just people close in the office, you
know, in the Chabad headquarters.
My father
had a interesting relationship with the
Rebbe. So he was also invited to get
matzah.
And the Rebbe after my gift before going
home to the seder
would give all these people a piece of
matzah.
The adults he would give a whole matzah.
Their children he would give a broken
piece of the matzah.
It's usually not hard to open a pound of
matzah shmurah matzah and most of it is
broken. So he didn't have a problem
finding broken pieces and then the
adults he would give a whole matzah and
wish everybody a kosher and freilichen
Pesach.
As a kid I went with my father every
year the first night of Pesach to get
matzah from the Rebbe. It was a very
special privilege. The Rebbe's face I
remember he was standing at the door was
shining like a malach Elokim.
And I walked by.
I was a little kid.
And the Rebbe took
turned around to the pound of matzah to
the you know the brown box with the
matzah and there's no broken piece.
Usually he would find a broken piece and
give it to me because I was a kid.
So he started to lift the matzah to look
for a broken piece and he lifted the
second one the third one fourth. He
lifted up every matzah in the box. I
don't know some miracle there were no
broken matzahs in that box. I never saw
that before after. Usually it's full of
broken matzahs. It's hard to find a
whole matzah.
And he finished and I was standing there
waiting.
And there was no broken matzah. So the
Rebbe I remember he took he took both of
his hands one on top of the matzahs one
on bottom. He held them you know with
with with
you know with with subtlety and then he
turned over the whole pile of matzah
upside down and again he started to look
through. So it was literally from bottom
up now cuz he turned it around and
started to look through again looking
for a broken piece. At this point, I
have to be honest and confess I was
thinking to myself, "Lubavitcher Rebbe,
nothing will happen if you give me a
whole matzah. I promise you. If you
don't tell, I don't tell. Just give me a
whole matzah. Let's call it a night."
I'm waiting there it looked like
eternity. It was very special to be in
his holy presence but like it was like
getting a little like just give me a
whole matzah. What's going to happen? A
kid is going to get a whole matzah. What
do you think I'm going to do, you know?
I'll sell it on eBay?
I didn't say anything. I was just
standing. The Rebbe finished the pile
again. There was no broken matzah. I saw
that he was hesitating to break the
matzah. I understood he didn't want to
break a matzah. I get it. It's not the
afikoman. He didn't.
And he started to walk away to go look
for another box of matzah to find a
broken piece of matzah to get me. And on
the way as he started to step away I saw
I don't know what he was thinking but it
looked like he decided not to and he
came back.
And I think a little begrudgingly or so
it seemed to me uh
eyes of a little kid
he took the matzah, I think the second
one
and he broke it
and he gave me the broken piece and he
said a kosher and a freilichen Pesach.
I didn't think about the story. I didn't
even remember it.
Years and years later
the story came back to me.
I was sitting in dealing one night an
email came to me such a broken
situation, such brokenness. Such
suffering, such anguish.
And a part of me
I guess felt so overwhelmed
and so distraught and so confused. I I
didn't understand what is happening, why
is this happening and how am I falling
into this parsha? Like what am I
supposed to do here?
Do I have any knowledge or wisdom?
That that can really help the situation.
It was just very very painful and very
difficult to deal with.
And one story and another story I get a
get quite a few letters from quite many
letters from people of all demographics
with horrendous stories.
Horrendous stories of of abuse
of
dysfunctionality
of
difficult challenges and situations,
especially in the field of mental
health. And it's hard.
And the story came to me.
And I had this vision visual feeling.
Why would the Rebbe not give me a whole
matzah?
What's the big deal? I was a kid, okay.
So one part of me said maybe this was a
blessing
to find my second half.
And to know that I'm not a whole, I
still have to find my second half. And
it was a special blessing cuz indeed God
has blessed me with a second half that
is beyond what anyone can ask for.
L'shana tovah u'metukah.
But then I thought there's also also
something else.
Maybe the Rebbe felt that part of my
journey would be
talking
and meeting people with a lot of
brokenness.
And in his own inimitable way
he was telling me, "Yosef Yitzchak,
don't be afraid of brokenness.
Don't be afraid of the broken matzahs
around you.
Don't be afraid.
Don't duck.
Don't shrink. Don't evade your gaze.
Don't close your eyes.
Don't become apathetic and indifferent.
Don't become cynical and cold. Don't
become detached and judgmental.
Instead, when you learn to embrace the
broken matzah in your own heart,
you'll be able to embrace broken matzahs
in other hearts.
Here is a broken matzah, and remember
that Yachatz
the ultimate mitzvah of matzah we do on
the broken matzah, on the prusa lechem
oni.
Because redemption happens
when we are ready to face all of our
broken places.
Redemption happens when you and I could
look at adversity, steer at adversity in
the eyes,
and not be afraid.
Where I could look at my adversity and
instead of experiencing the shame and
the guilt and the overwhelming anxiety,
I can hear all those voices of guilt and
shame and fear with compassion,
but not back off
from looking at my adversity as dark as
the devil may seem, and it may feel like
it's swallowing me up alive, and I want
to run to China, I want to run to
Antarctica.
I want to disassociate. There's a lion
in the room, I cannot confront all these
lions. There's more than one lion
sometimes. And the Rebbe said, "Don't be
afraid of the broken matzah.
Behind your brokenness, you will find
your wholeness.
Under the brokenness, you will always
find infinite light. It is such intense
light that it couldn't be revealed in
any other form, but only through this
brokenness.
And if you can hold on to this broken
matzah,
and show other people how they can hold
on to the broken matzah, we'll be able
to say l'shana haba'ah b'Yerushalayim.
And this is what I've tried
to be This is what I try to do. I try to
do it with myself. It's not always easy.
And I try to do this with loved ones and
try to do it with people I come into
contact. And it's what I'm sharing with
you today.
There's a lot of brokenness. There's a
lot of pain. But let me tell you
something.
Behind every broken matzah,
there is the promise of redemption.
And there's a reason for this. Nothing
in the world, not nature and not
nurture,
not genetics and not even what happens
in the uterus, not epigenetics,
and not all of the circumstances and
events and experiences we go through in
life, even when we're talking about
bullying, even when we're talking about
sexual abuse, even when we're talking
about emotional neglect, even when we're
talking about all forms of emotional
pain and anguish.
Things I'm articulating and things I'm
not articulating because either I can't
or because I don't know.
But deeper than all of this stands the
soul of every single one of our children
and every single one of our brothers and
sisters and us ourselves, you and you
and you, which is a chelek elokei'
mima'al mamash. It's a derivative of
divine infinite consciousness. We are
ultimately infinite consciousness having
a finite experience. Yes, I can get
swallowed up into that finite and
sometimes painful experience.
But our work is with compassion and
empathy and support
to always find the avnei chein.
To always find
those cherished gems, those pearls,
those diamonds, glittering divine
diamonds at the core of every single
heart that are always always intact.
Nothing can destroy them. Nothing can
even tarnish them and compromise them. I
am in awe
when I watch people
who have been through
so much in their lives
including
such abuse that is unfathomable and that
I happen to have intimate knowledge
about. And then I look at them and I'm
expecting to see a broken, devastated
vessel that is hopeless.
For a good reason. After everything you
have been through, look at you. You
should be broken and yet
I see a light.
I see a soul that experiences the pain.
And I say to them, don't you realize all
the pain you're experiencing is because
your soul was intact and your soul saw
it all happen and your soul is a
witness. And your soul knows that it
should protest all the lies and all the
stupidity and all the atrocities and all
the cover-ups. And that's why I know
you're intact. It's the greatest proof
of the divine core at the heart of each
and every one of us. If we were really
just random mutations susceptible to
forces outside of us, then those of us
who experienced hardship and abuse
should be broken, hopeless vessels. But
because at the core we are divine, so
we're invincible. No one can snuff out
the flight of your soul. Nobody can
extinguish, nobody can dampen, nobody
can eclipse, nobody can compromise the
infinite
expansiveness of your soul
embodied in you. What we need help is
access. We need help to access that
inner soul to be able to communicate
with our brain, with our nervous system,
with our body, to be able to embody our
light. But never doubt that light. Never
ever doubt that core. That is why you
have pain. That is why
you know what happened. That is why you
know how wrong it is what happened. That
is the sign that that sense of
truthfulness inside of you nobody can
ever take away.
Believe in it. Hold on to it. Embrace it
because it's much more powerful than
everything that's broken in us. And
don't be afraid
of the broken places inside of you and
inside of others. Let's support each
other.
Let's hold each other's hands. Let's cry
on each other's shoulders because then
we'll also be able to laugh on each
other's shoulders and dance to the end
of love. Thank you.
Mhm.
Thank you so much, Rabbi Jacobson, for
the
absolutely inspiring and really powerful
reflections and talk about the concepts
of mental health and concepts of mental
health challenges
and
switching the way we can greet that
experience. It was really
um so powerful and so appreciated. So,
thank you again.
Thank you for this question.
Baruch Hashem.
So, we have a couple of questions um and
I'm going to combine a couple of them
because they
they cover a similar theme.
So, the first question that I'm going
that was raised um through some of the
people who are participating here
is
how do we find shidduchim for adult
children with mental health diagnoses on
medications? Most medical shidduchim
groups are not accepting mental health
patients and concurrently
there was an individual um themselves
that said that they are um single and
have a diagnosis of bipolar and would
like to get married very much and are
really struggling with navigating the
uh shidduch the shidduch system.
And when do you bring this up and how do
you navigate this?
Love to hear your thoughts on it. Yeah.
And this is a question for me, right?
Yes. Cuz I know you have someone else
answering questions. That's why I'm
asking.
Yes, but I think this is something from
a rabbinical point of view. Yeah, yeah.
Okay, wow. This is this is
this is a painful but very very real
question and there's a few parts. So,
let me just uh say what I think.
The first element is uh
You know, when we speak about mental
illness, it's important to understand
that uh
there are those of us who struggle
mentally.
If we identify the problem
and we identify
our challenge with honesty and without
covering it up and without running away,
I just want to say this at the outset.
There are so There are so many healing
opportunities today to enhance our life
significantly.
I know personally many individuals and
I'm and I'm not I'm not a mental health
professional, not a medical
professional. So, I'm saying this, you
know, with a lot of humility and without
any conclusive uh authoritative
scientific facts, but just from
conversations with quite many
professionals and patients.
It's just so important to know that
people who are ready to take
responsibility for their challenges
today, there is an unbelievable
opportunity today that God has given our
generation for healing modalities. Um
I've done interviews with really,
really, you know, serious doctors in the
mental health field who even said
that today there is a huge literature
suggesting that there are profound links
between mental illness and trauma.
Unlike we always thought about mental
illness that it's basically you just
have a chemical imbalance, you know, a
boy is born with a hole in the heart or
with diabetes and you have a mental
illness. But, if it's associated and
connected to trauma, this means that
it's so much connected to our emotional
well-being and our attachment and
connection. So, it's just important to
understand this and there are even those
professionals who are suggesting
different models of healing today
outside of the regular medication route,
which may may not, but may prove very,
very an unbelievably helpful for trauma
healing and therefore perhaps for
different issues connected with what we
call mental illness. And especially the
area of plant medicines, vitamins,
vitamin somatic therapy, exercising,
uh daily schedules that are consistent
with a lifestyle of mental health and
alignment. I'm just throwing this out
because I think it's important for
people to realize how much hope and how
much potentiality there is today for
incredible healing even in those areas
that we thought it's just this is the
decree and this is how it's supposed to
be and this is how you're going to die.
The best is you can just manage it to be
the avid but there's a lot more today.
Number one. Number two, in terms of a
shidduch, I think this is where we
really need to reach a very deep place
of trust in ourselves.
In other words,
and I'm not a superstitious type of guy
so I don't want this to sound
superstitious but I'll tell you what I
mean. What I mean is is this.
If I am comfortable with my mental
challenges and my mental shlichus, my me
idea, then ultimately I will attract
that. People will be more comfortable
with me.
And therefore, I will find the I
hopefully
I can hope much more to find the right
person for me. In other words, if you
can really accept yourself,
other people will accept you as well.
Obviously, you have to find the right
shidduch.
Obviously, we all know that just like
there are many boys struggling, there
are many girls struggling and I think
that we don't we're not looking for the
perfect person. We're looking for a
person who's confronting their own
things and they're they're ready to
create space for another person
confronting their things and if there's
willpower, real willpower,
what do I mean willpower? I mean there's
goodwill and courage on both sides to be
able each of us to deal with our issues
and sometimes these can be the most
powerful marriages. Now, we don't want
to be deceptive in any way or form or
fashion. I was at a Nefesh conference.
Nefesh is like a group of religious
psychologists and Reb Dovid Cohen
shlita, he was one of the prominent
rabbonim in America. Reb Dovid Cohen was
there and they asked him this question
and he said that he feels that at the
fourth date,
third, fourth, if around the fourth
date,
that's when people should be having
these conversations about serious mental
challenges cuz he feels sometimes the
first three times it wouldn't be fair
because there's no
there's no
chemistry at all. It's just like you
have a problem. Okay, next.
And afterwards it's not fair cuz
sometimes people invest a lot and then
you may not be ready for this. But he
felt that after a few dates where
there's
where there's enough connection that you
really see the qualities of this person,
then a person should say, you know, this
is what I'm dealing with. This is what
I'm struggling with. And then the other
person could make a decision. But I'm
going to say again, I think the real
deepest issue is there has to be a lot
of trust. If God made me
and he's invested in me
and he gave me my soul and he gave me my
body, my challenges are not a source of
shame.
My challenges are a source
of pride because this is my mission.
Esther wasn't ashamed that she was busy
with a non-Jew
in the palace doing what he wanted
because me and they are this was her
mission. Each of us was sent down a
certain path. If this is my path, I'm
not ashamed of it. I will accept it. I
will embrace it. I'm not going to deal
with stigmas. And you know what? You're
going to attract people who are
like-minded. You're going to attract
people who are also honest and also
authentic. Let's remember a lot of
people in our community are struggling.
Shh. Shh shh shh shh shh shh. Not our
family, but it's all a joke. It's a lie.
Everybody's struggling. There's mental
illness everywhere.
There are serious challenges every year.
Trust me. Yeah, I know what's going on a
little bit because I have I have a
little access and people are open with
me because they don't have to sign their
names and their emails. We're all
struggling. We're all challenged. So
when you're comfortable with it, you
will attract people who are authentic
and honest and with a lot of faith and a
lot of trust and a lot of inner
self-love and acceptance
with God's grace you'll find the right
person.
And it's And if we're both committed to
the path of healing, you can have an
unbelievable relationship. But you have
to take responsibility for your
challenges and not throw it under the
rug.
Thank you so much.
Uh
next question is for Dr. Ari Woll.
And the question is this, how does
society view mental and physical health
differently?
And do you think the two should be
addressed in the same manner? Why or why
not?
And the second part of the question is
should there be any caution when sharing
that information with an employer the
same way you would maybe share physical
information?
That's an excellent question.
Um you know
mental health and physical health
are very similar.
Um but also very different.
So you know I think you know that in
many ways you can look at mental health
like physical difficulties. If a person
is ill
you know you often say it's like if
someone has a flu often it's hard to to
do things and to to function well.
Uh people with mental illness often find
themselves in the same position where
it's difficult to manage and to
function.
Um
but I think it's important to realize
that
um
mental health often looks like it's like
it's more like it's deeper than physical
difficulties. For example, people often
think that there's something wrong with
them because they have a mental illness.
Something wrong with them because they
have depression.
Getting back to what Rabbi Jacobson was
referring to about shidduchim
you know I think it's important that
people don't define themselves by their
illness. People don't define themselves
by their mental
health crisis or diagnosis.
Um when someone has a broken leg they
don't say how am I going to find a
shidduch because I broke my leg.
You know you know people
are who they are. People are
personalities. People are very special
in many ways.
And a person that has a mental illness,
who has depression or anxiety, for
example,
doesn't make them different. Doesn't
make them not a special person. And I
think it's very important that people
realize that when getting into
shidduchim, thinking about shidduchim,
thinking about
um functioning in life, and doing things
in their life.
Uh so I think that's a very important
just concept of how to of how to view
um of how to view mental illness. Um
Um the second question
Um I forgot the second question. Do you
want to remind me of the question?
Sorry.
Second question is just similarly how
one may disclose to an employer because
there might be time needed to take off
because of a physical ailment, how does
that apply to a mental illness?
You know, it it it's Yeah, I don't know
Yeah, I think it's important to
understand that employers
don't have to know everything about you.
Um and I think although, you know,
people have all kinds of different
struggles. Uh people have physical
struggles, people have bad days, people
have all kinds of struggles, and I don't
think employers need to understand um
uh details about why a person can't show
up for work or have some difficulties. I
think the important thing is that people
try their best, uh people try to do
what's right, um and um
and people have to be as honest as they
need to be, but not you know, people
don't have to divulge things that are
very personal and and
and
very very personal to them.
Thank you so much, Dr. Wall.
Um Rabbi Jacobson, if I
could ask you a further question,
and I'm going to also take two questions
that are
uh uh, could be extrapolated one from
the next.
Um, is there a truth self?
An authentic self? If one feels that his
authentic self is counter to Torah, how
do we manage that? Do we encourage the
person's perception of their truth self?
And I think this really goes into the
second question of somebody's
mentioning, how do we deal with fearing
the choices our children are making,
especially when it's against our values
and what we believe in?
Wow, both brilliant questions. Excellent
questions.
Um,
Okay, let me address the first question
first. Uh,
what if my authentic self is completely
contrary to the Torah way of life, to
Torah's values? My authentic self is
telling me things that are exact
opposite everything Yiddishkeit or
somethings Yiddishkeit says. Which one
do I embrace? Do I suppress Do I repress
myself and embrace Torah, or do I say to
the Torah, "Bye-bye.
You can go somewhere else. This is not
for me."
Excellent question.
Let me tell you how I see what Torah is.
The very famous expression in the
Medrish
that when, uh,
when, uh, God, God created the world, he
used a blueprint, like every good, uh,
contractor. You know, there's a
blueprint that you follow that the
architect has drawn. And the blueprint
was Torah.
The Zohar says, "Kudsha Brichu istakal
b'Oraisa u'bara ol'ma." He looked into
the Torah and created the world. What's
the meaning of that? Well, he needs a
blueprint? He didn't know what to do?
He's like the contractor I have here in
the house. Like, what?
Even today's contractors barely use
blueprints. That's why our houses look
the way they do. So, God had to use a
blueprint? The answer, of course, is
that
what this is really saying is that the
design of the human brain and the design
of the universe is a reflection of
Torah.
So, if I'm finding an inherent
contradiction between my authenticity
and the Torah,
Either I'm not being honest enough with
myself
or the Torah that has been fed to me is
a very, very distorted Torah.
In other words, when we find our I think
this is one of the most important,
important core ideas of the Jewish
mystical tradition of Kabbalah and
Hasidus.
Like there's a whole safer Tanya that's
based on this core. If you know your
authentic self,
your authentic self is a reflection of
the ultimate divine consciousness, which
means in simple words,
that the authentic self is filled with
infinite love and attachment and
connection.
The the the the core of the self is full
of of holiness and authenticity.
And all of Torah is basically trying to
cultivate a life of auth- authenticity
and love and holiness and attachment. I
may be living with a distorted version
of Judaism. That's true. And you know
what? I may need to be able to detox.
One of the most devastating things I
heard from a young man was he told me he
can't keep Shabbos
because he was sexually abused in shul
every Friday night because on Shabbos
the shul was empty.
Everybody went home. And that's when the
predator pred- predator used
the unique energy of Shabbos to do the
unthinkable. So he says, "For me Shabbos
is is is Gehenna. It's It's abuse."
So, yeah. For him Shabbos equals
devastation, emotional murder.
And we have to respect that with
compassion. We must respect that with
compassion. But is that what Shabbos is?
The whole idea of Shabbos is the exact
opposite. Shabbos is the time
that we detox from technology
and we bond with our spouses and our
children and ourselves in the most
intimate way for 26 hours. That That is
Shabbos. So I think it's extremely
important to understand this. If Judaism
is in defiance with your authentic self,
I will maintain, at least this is my
deep conviction,
and I think with quite
with some life experience as well, and
and a feeling for what pain looks like,
I would say
patience and compassion. Find out more
about who you really are, and find out
more about what Judaism
really, really is. And now, I'm not
saying that there's no mitzvah that may
be difficult for me at the moment, but
ultimately every mitzvah in Judaism
is here to flex
the muscles of our soul,
never to destroy our authenticity. If
you could find me a mitzvah that
destroys people's authenticity,
I will tell you, either you don't
understand the mitzvah, you don't
understand yourself. And if we're
teaching such mitzvahs,
then we need a lot of help.
And we're distorting Judaism. This
brings us to the second question. Your
children may be making choices that are
very, very painful for you.
And there is a need to grieve and to
cry.
But here is the deal.
Very often, very often, much of these
choices, their drifting away from their
parents, has to do with a very, very
deep pain and trauma inside themselves.
Okay? I'm just going to give one very
simple example that doesn't approve true
about every case, but just one example
and illustration that is very authentic
for many situations. If my child, or me,
I went through 10 years in school,
and I was not a success story. I saw
myself as a loser. Not because the
teachers or principals were abusive,
they were not.
But because, you know, I looked at
myself, I compared myself with the five
top kids in the class, and I felt like a
loser. So, for 10 years,
this relationship with my school has
caused me intense pain and an intense
feeling that I am not good enough. I am
worthless. When I get older,
I may want to disassociate from this
source of pain, and anything connected
with school, with Torah,
with God who put me into this system
causes me a tremendous sense of inner
inner anguish.
The worst thing my parents can do is
scream at me, rebuke me, shame me
further, which only means I will go
further away from your dish guide.
They're intensifying the trauma that
Judaism caused me. And this is not
blaming anybody. This is just
understanding diagnosing the pain. What
the parents can do best for this child
is become closer.
Become more attached. This starts
healing the wounds of the child. The
child says, "Mhm, my from father
is not on the team that's causing me so
much pain. He's actually causing me
delight. So I have a problem. My from
father puts on to fill in. He davens. He
learns. Hey, I thought Judaism is the
source of trauma and abuse. So now this
cognitive dissonance. My father is so
loving. My mother is so loving. What's
going on here?"
And you know what? This is the beginning
of healing. So when your children are
making bad choices
and destructive choices, be very very
careful not to damage the attachment,
not to damage the relationship. It's the
relationship that is usually the remedy.
The relationship is the tool for
healing.
That connection is more powerful than
anything else. Don't let go of that
connection. Don't.
Abandoning that connection is abandoning
the future of your child, God forbid.
It's painful. You need a support system.
You need to get rid of your ego.
You need to have a good marriage.
And you need to be able to have
compassion for all the voices inside of
you that have been struggling. But
find your courage in your soul. Remember
you're a servant of God and connect
deeper with your child. Don't run away.
Thank you so much.
And think it's
you really touched on a point that's so
sensitive and
very applicable to so many people.
And
It's hard.
Because we think if we scream at them
and we just tell them, "You don't do
this in this house. You In this house
you wear a keeper. In this house you get
dressed with sneez." You think your
17-year-old daughter doesn't know how
you dress in your house.
You think your son doesn't know what
your values are. They've been in your
house for 15 years. They know
everything. They've heard this lecture
20,000 times. They know everything. This
is not an issue of knowledge.
This is an issue of inner inner pain.
And the greatest remedy for pain is
attachment. Now, I know this is hard.
This is hard. It's difficult, especially
with other kids.
This is one of those me ideas. What's my
mission? But everyone is dealing with
this today. I mean, I can't say
everyone, but an enormous amount of
families, perfect families, beautiful
families, BEST FAMILIES IN ISRAEL, best
families in Be Shemesh, Beit Shemesh,
Beit Tali Leed, and Bnei Brak, and Mea
Shearim, even Mea Shearim, and even
Batei Ungarin.
And Monsey, and Lakewood, and Boro Park,
and Williamsburg, and Monsey, and Crown
Heights, and Golders Green, and Stamford
Hill, and everywhere else in the world.
So, welcome to the club. And now it's
time to open our hearts and not to make
decisions from anger and resentment and
ego or insecurity, but make decisions
based on really, really what these
children need more than anything else.
And I'm also going to say get advice
from people who are experienced with
these children. Do not get advice from
people who don't have a lot of
experience with these children cuz they
might mean well, but they might give you
horrific advice.
I really appreciate that perspective
because very often what in crisis people
are really looking in every direction
and whatever sometimes the most
accessible and available might not be
the most effective. And as you're
saying, could even be destructive. Um I
have one quick question. If we could
just really this would be a 1 to 2
minute answer, cuz we need to wrap up,
but I think it really touches on the
core of Avne Cain's mission, because
Avne Cain, when we work with families,
it's not only for the individual who is
going through the mental health crisis,
we really look at the whole family and
whole family system. And the whole
family that nobody exists in a vacuum.
And so the final question for Rabbi
Jacobson would be, what else can or
should our communities be doing to help
those who are suffering with mental
health challenges or even their
families? What could we do more and
better as a community to
create a cohesive support system?
Excellent.
I would say three things that we can all
do immediately.
First of all, it's teachers, parents,
educators, principals
educating themselves about this.
Educating themselves in a very, very
serious way, understanding the struggles
of what of what people go through.
If I'm a parent today or a teacher, a
rebbe, a rosh yeshiva, a menahel,
menaheles, mechanech, mechaneches,
whatever is, mashgiach, mashpia, any
age, and I am not keenly aware
of the inner state of a child,
and how important emotional attunement
is and attachment and connection and
safety is, I'm not allowed to parent and
I'm not allowed to educate. I will make
horrible mistakes, not because I'm a bad
guy, but simply because I'm clueless. We
all are We have a duty to educate
ourselves, especially if you're in the
field of education. The first I was
talking to a principal of a huge mesivta
in Chicago. You know, he's there for
more than a few decades, and he he he
told me an epiphany that he had and I I
was grateful to hear this epiphany, but
this is such a foundation.
Every boy who walks into your classroom,
every girl who walks into your classroom
and walks into your house, the
prerequisite is safety, safety, safety,
safety.
Are they feeling safe? If they feel safe
emotionally and physically,
they can be regulated. If they could be
regulated, they can absorb things with
their prefrontal cortex, not with their
amygdala. If they can absorb things with
their prefrontal cortex, they can grow
to become healthy human beings and
beautiful people and Jews. If they are
sitting in my shul, in my base medrish,
in my seminary, in my school, in my
cheder, in my Talmud Torah, in my bet
sefer, my tichon, whatever it is, and
they're not feeling safety, they're
feeling judged, they're defensive,
the principal is about to punish them,
the teacher is angry today, there's no
education. Old education is skin-deep
and superficial. So, we all need we all
we owe it to ourselves, just like I have
to know the curriculum,
just like I have to prepare the Gemara
I'm teaching, the Chumash I'm teaching,
the Mishnayos I'm teaching, the grammar,
the math, the biology, the science,
whatever it is I'm teaching,
before all that, prepare something else.
Will every kid feel safe in my
classroom?
Will every child feel safe in my house?
That is a different skill set. That's
not IQ,
that's EQ.
But it's equally important and between
you and me, it's much more important
than academics. Much more important. I
mean, academics are important, we we
cherish academics, we're the people of
the book, but emotional safety is more
important. If you give me a choice, my
kid could go through eight years of
elementary school and feel emotionally
safe, even if the learning, you know,
won't be in the highest level, or the
learning will be on the highest level,
they will be emotionally unsafe. I know
what I'm going to choose. Of course, I
want both. I'm a Jew. I want the cake. I
want to eat it, too. But, we all know
what we have. I think that's number one.
I think number two is
Number two, this is very, very
important, is our ability to have
conversations in a free and open way, to
create support systems.
Parents shouldn't feel alone. Parents
feel so alone. There's nobody to talk
to. Who am I going to talk to another
person who's going to think, "Oh, this
is the crazy family. Oh, I wonder what
meshugas is happening over there. Why
are their kids so sick?" This If that's
happening, there's no support. We need
all need to get rid of the stigma.
Everyone, trust me, everybody is dealing
with something today.
I'm laughing. I'm not It's not funny. My
point is we're all struggling. I'm
struggling. You're struggling. We need
to be vulnerable and authentic. If we
could talk about it, create an
environment of safety. Mothers can talk
to each other. Fathers can talk to each
other. Siblings can talk. I think
creating support systems other is it you
have, you know. We have support systems
for cancer patients.
We have support systems for for other
physical illnesses. And it's amazing all
the bigger items when it comes to mental
illness. There's so much silence.
There's so much stigma. And I understand
why. I'm not judging it. There's a lot a
lot of shame here. A lot a lot of
embarrassment. But, so many people are
struggling. We don't have to be
embarrassed from each other.
So, let's create those groups. Every
community should have such groups.
Groups where people could meet. They
could be Zoom. They could be WhatsApps.
They could be conversations. Those
should be references. You know,
professionals. I found an amazing doctor
in England. I found somebody who
microdoses with an amazing I'm just
saying with an amazing remedy or a
vitamin or it's it's helpful also to
have the pressure on one person to find
all the help in the world. And they get
that one doctor who's an encyclopedia.
It's very rare. It's very, very rare.
But, with a support system, you know,
you can also get different perspectives.
It would be so, so helpful to people.
The third thing I think we can do, and
this has to do with uh I think very much
of us, you know, I think with what we do
individually. I think what we can each
do with ourselves is
be able to reach a deeper place of
acceptance.
A deeper place of acceptance is stop
fighting
the
your child. Stop fighting the state of
being of your child. Embrace it.
Because the more we fight it, I think,
the more we don't allow healing to
happen.
It's like I'm going to make my kid
normal. I'm going to make you fit in.
You don't fit in. You don't fit in.
There is neurodiversity. You're
neurodivergent. I'm also neurodivergent.
If you haven't realized. You're
neurodivergent. The question is what we
do with our diversity.
Can we make space for it? Can we trust
it? Can we believe that God has a
mission for us, or we're just the losers
of society, the dregs of society? The
more I can accept other people with real
dignity and grace, I can make a space of
safety for them. When I create a space
of safety for them, there is much more
opportunity for healing. I would say
even that many mental challenges at the
core is a lack of safety. It's a trauma
that caused me to go crazy in order to
be able to survive.
If you me, your father, your mother,
your therapist, your friend
cannot be afraid of your outbursts
and stay there with you
in that space
without judgment and without me going
crazy,
we can sometimes recreate those same
initial challenges that caused the
trauma and help the person confront them
with more ease and dignity.
That's why our sages say that real
teshuvah is going back to the same
place, the same time, the same woman, I
say Malcolm, I say man, I say Isha and
redoing it differently. Kabbalah
Kabbalah I can take you back to that
space of chaos
and show you we can be here with you and
hold hands. That is so healing. So, this
has to do with a very internal work that
I think we are we are challenged today
to do.
And that is really go to a place of a
very, very deep calm
acceptance that comes from empowerment
and strength.
This class is brought to you by the
yeshiva.net.
Please help us continue the classes.
Make even a small contribution at
www.theyeshiva.net/donate.