Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
[Music]
Okay, let's begin with a chapter of
Tahillim as always and welcome
everybody. Thank you for coming.
Yes, sure. Absolutely. Absolutely.
Okay, we'll
say which is
123 123.
And the next
is
124, the one right
after.
forch.
Say and one more 125. The next one 125
[Music]
Shalom Al
is okay.
[Music]
Okay. Okay. I'm sorry for the delay. the
electricity went down so uh the system
had to be
rebooted. Okay, welcome everybody. Thank
you for gracing us. You have one source
sheet. They're always posted on the
yeshiva.net where the classes are also
posted. So you can always retrieve them
from there. So you heard the
announcement. Next
week we make our move to 84 Viola. We'll
be a little more uh private and
exclusive and thus a little more
organized in terms of entrance and
exit. If you've never been there before,
just drive slowly because you have to
see the address and go into a uh long
driveway. As you're going down Viola, uh
I think you pass Spook Rock, right? you
pack spook and you go on the second
section of Ayola and then on the right
there'll be a sign 84 and you go
in. Okay, we look forward to welcome
everybody there and
uh with Hashem's grace and I want to
thank Mrs. Miriam Klene for
initiating and
yes and the leadership of the Schul on
84 Viola who have graced us uh with
their permission and help and blazer and
Heather Shiner and uh the entire
leadership of this shim for their
invaluable assistance as well as freed
and Silva for all of the technology
development and uh thank you very very
much to everybody. it wasn't uh these
types of moves uh require some
logistical planning. So thank you to all
who were
involved. When I was a bak yeshiva they
used to tell a story I never knew if it
was true or not that uh the principal of
our school when he was a getting
married. So the day of his wedding, he
came to yeshiva to learn and in the
afternoon he asked permission from the
principal if he can go to his wedding
because he was so involved in his
learning that he felt he's a ber and he
needed permission and when he got
permission to go to the wedding that's
when he went. This was the legend that
they used to tell us in yeshiva. I
didn't know if it was true or not. I I
don't think I ever asked him. But then a
few years ago, um I was giving here a
shir from men. Every morning uh five
most mornings 5:30 in the morning, we
would learn uh you don't have to be
jealous. No, we were we were learning uh
and
uh there was a a baker who was coming
every day. His name is Yehuda Nad. And
he was getting married. And the day of
his wedding, he came 5:30 in the
morning. He showed up like every day. So
I started off this year by saying, "Oh,
now that story may also be true if
you're actually coming on the day of the
wedding." And I gave him official
permission to uh to go to his wedding
and I even attended the wedding. So the
permission was really verified. But
today we have another treat and that is
there's a kala here who is in the middle
of her shabraus and uh she comes every
week to the shia this is nimra who just
got married and she came last week on
the day of her wedding literally and she
told me I'm getting married tonight and
I'm like and you came to a class the day
of your wedding she's like yeah and I'm
coming next week in middle of my bra so
I want to welcome her and her
mother and wish you a and an amazing
life and everything should
be and you should have a home filled
with health, happiness, joy, prosperity
and all of
the maz. It's an honor to have a queen
with us uh in addition to all of the
queens but a special queen with us at
this at this year. So thank you and
maz and mazov to the mother as well.
Thank you eta
ya.
So as we know this week we finished
safer the last par of safer pud. Very
often vayak and pud are connected. But
some years like this year they're
disconnected. They're disjointed. So
vayak was read last week and pud is
going to be read this shabas and it
becomes the final chap the final uh para
that culminates and completes the entire
safer or as in English it's called the
book of exodus following which we go
into the third book of the vayikra also
known as Leviticus. So this is basically
the grand finale. It's the concluding
portion of safer and it's titled an
interesting title which is purude. The
word pud means an
accounting lif means to count and the
word pud is to make an accounting to
make a count. And the reason it's called
that way is because it's the opening
words. If you see in the first the first
uh verse in the first of the source
sheets that's Exodus 38 21 the beginning
of
says so the word is here twice in this
verse basically this is the accounting
of the Mishkan the Mishkan the dwelling
place which was a testimony for God's
presence among the Jewish people which
was counted pukad again the same word
based on the mouth instructions of
Mosa and it was the work of the Levites
especially in the hand of Isar who was
the son of Aaron Hakayen. So basically
what happens now is in the continuing
verses the continuing mishabenu presents
a detailed account of the many many many
donations contributed to the
construction of the tabernacle of the
Mishkim. Not a single coin remains
unaccounted for. Mosher Rabenu goes
through literally anyone, a man, a
woman, a child because children also
donated to the Mishkan. The men and the
women donated. The Tory says the women
came before the men and they slept the
men. It said last week, but it says in
that even children gave whatever they
had, whatever they wanted to give. So
every single coin that anybody gave
whether it was from gold, whether it was
from silver, whe whether it was from
copper,
moherenu counts, has them count every
single one and exactly the weight of
what they received and then gives an
account what it was used for very very
specifically. And Mosha reports to the
people how many pounds of gold, how many
pounds of silver, how many pounds of
copper he received, and how exactly they
were used, where were they used in the
structure. Every piece of jewelry and
metal that came into his hands, there is
an
accountish. Now, why was this so
relevant? One interpretation, I
mentioned this last week in the class,
was that there were a few people, rabble
rousers, who started to spread rumors
that Mosher Rabenu packed away some of
the cash maybe to go buy real estate in
Saudi Arabia or to purchase a private
yacht on the Mediterranean or whatever
accusations they had there. But the
Medri says that there were people, a few
people who were accusing him. What did
he do with all of this this money?
That's what we spoke about last week.
Now it's true this hasn't a so it's true
and even if Misha felt compelled to give
an accounting and as the med says there
were some nudnik who demanded one it's
interesting though that the terra feels
the need to record it not every story is
recorded so if there were a few people
who didn't trust him and he said okay
let me show it to you but the records it
and it's its own parish and it occupies
quite a lot of space because goes
through a detailed accounting after all
it's not a story that's going to repeat
itself. What's the point of knowing the
details of each contribution? Now, some
of the authorities say something very
interesting. They say the Bach writes
this
in that the is giving us a lesson and
that is that even trusted leaders need
to be able to be transparent with all of
the money and funds that they collect.
And this is a very very valuable lesson.
In other words, not even because
somebody is suspected of doing the wrong
thing. Even if a person like Mishaben
knew that 99% of Jews obviously knew
that you're talking about a person of
impeccable honesty and impeccable
flawless purity and authenticity,
loyalty and dedication to man and to
God.
Nonetheless, it behooves even such
people, never mind people not on that
level, to be able to be completely
completely meaning truly truly honest
and not just about huge amounts of
money, even about a coin that was
received and that's a tremendous lesson
teaching us transparency. That's true.
But the Toyota could have then just done
it done very simple and say Rabenu gave
an accounting of everything that he
received the gold and the copper that
was contributed to the project. The toy
doesn't only do that. The actually goes
through exactly what he did and what he
said exactly the weights which doesn't
seem relevant because it's not like a
story repeating itself. It's not going
to happen in another generation. The
Mishkan was built once and it wasn't
built
again. Another very interesting thing is
the name. The
name means count which means that this
is really the theme. The theme of the
para is the count of the detailed
account of every single every single
coin and detail. So why does the feel
significant to feel it's so significant
to get into the specifics of this
element? I mean it's interesting to see
exactly exactly we know how many pounds
of silver they collected. We know
exactly. We know exactly how many pounds
of gold. We know exactly how many pounds
of copper. Literally everything. We even
know that which he could put into larger
numbers, what's known as kikar, tons of
silver or gold. And that was left over
that which was left over like
1,750 extra shekel of silver that didn't
go into the kikar. I mean that's how
detailed it is. It would be like you
know somebody would say I collected uh
$20 million and you know 23 cents. Like
that's how specific Mishraenu is. It's
so interesting. He doesn't give general
numbers. He could have given general
numbers. You know, we collected 5
million, we collected 1 million. No,
he's going to be it's like $8.30 in the
equivalent of the currencies that they
used then in the
desert. The answer to this
question is profoundly profoundly
important. And here we're going to
explore a major theme that comes to the
culmination in and this is right at the
beginning of the portion. And then we'll
see the other theme that gets
articulated mamish at the end of the
portion where all of
ends there's a principle in one of the
oldest cabalistic works. know
it's which means the beginning is etched
in the end. The end is always etched in
the beginning. We say
in the final product was there first in
thought. You know when you plan a house
the initial thought of the house is what
it's going to look like at the end. Now
that may take 35 years depends on your
contractor. We hope it takes much much
faster. But what you're thinking when
you plan that house or that company or
that organization or whatever it is,
you're planning the final final product
to get to that takes some time.
But so that's always a rule that the
last is always etched in the beginning.
And this is true with everything. That's
why when they make us see on a track,
they they connect the end and the
beginning even though they're the
furthest away, but the fact that they're
the furthest away meaning means that in
many ways they're the most the most
connected. the beginning of we just
discussed the accounting. Now let's go
to the last verses of after which the
congregation always
exclaims ven what are the last ones so
if you look in your two last source
sheets the I'm saying the two last
sources in the source
sheet these are the last verses of pud
the context is the mishk was built it
was
erected puts up the entire tabernacle
all of the vessels are brought in and
the dream has been fulfilled. The dream
has come true. One last thing is missing
and that is the final product and that
is the one who's supposed to occupy the
home got to move in. And in this case
it's Hashem. So the Tyra says lo and
behold the cloud covers the mo the tent
the tabernacle. the glory the the glory
of Hashem fills the
mishk to the point that can't even enter
enter into the mishk why because the
cloud is over it and hashem's glory
fills it and then the
adds when the cloud departs from the
mishk when it goes up that's when the
Jews know it's time to travel. All of
the journeys happen when the cloud lifts
itself up and moves away. And this is
the sign we're not staying here any
longer. We're moving on. In other words,
the cloud was over always over the
Mishkan, hovering over the tabernacle.
Literally like a blanket covering the
tabernacle, which was quite long. It was
Amos. So, you're talking about around
150 ft, 130 ft. Or if it was only the
Maya, it was still a very long uh 30 30
Yamas which would be around 60 ft
because the Mishkan had an inner
sanctuary which had a roof and it had a
courtyard. So that that cloud was
hovering over it literally like a
blanket, like a bed almost like Hashem
lying on top of the Mishkan. Now when
the cloud moves up and goes away, it
departs. It goes in the direction where
they're supposed to travel. Everybody
knew it's time to go. That's why we say
in
the
alpashem was the GPS God's positioning
system. It says before ways in Google
maps and that's what guided them and
then they knew it's time to start taking
apart the Mishkan and the Cayenne and
the Levian got to work. They took apart
the Mishkan and they began the journey
to the next location in the desert. And
since the Mishkan was a portable
sanctuary, it was a portable home. It
was easy to take apart and carry and
then put it up in the new location. The
new location they could be there for a
year. They could be there for a few
days. The Torah says they could be there
for a few weeks, for a few months. One
place they were 18 years, but other
places they may have been just for a few
days. The cloud went over the Mishkan
and then when it went up they were
traveling. That's what the is now
saying. As the cloud departs, they knew
it's time to travel.
What if the cloud doesn't go up? They
don't
go until the day that the cloud goes up
and leaves the it lifts itself up and
departs and then they know you have to
leave key. And this is the last verse of
key because the cloud of Hashem was on
the Mishk by
day. And at night there was a fire so
they could see. By day there was a
cloud. By night it was replaced with a
flame before the eyes of the whole house
of Israel. Everybody could see
this in all of their journeys. In all of
their journeys. So the finishes that the
cloud was on the Mishkan and the fire
was there at night. The cloud was there
by day in all of their journeys. You see
the problem here? Anybody knows this is
a huge
problem? The word mam says twice. You
see the word says in the
beginning and what does it mean there?
It means when the cloud departed from
the Mishkan they traveled in all of
their journeys they waited till the
cloud departed. The last words of is
also what does it say over there that
the cloud was on the Mishkan in all of
their journeys. Was the cloud on the
Mishkan in all of their journeys?
Something is very strange here. You're
just contradicting yourself. You just
told me that the cloud was on the
Mishkin only when they did not journey.
When they journeyed, the cloud was not
on the Mishk. In fact, it couldn't be on
the Mishk because the Mishkin was being
carried by people. Everything was
disjointed. Everything was taken apart.
It's only when the Mishkin was in one
place that the cloud could be over it.
But then when they started to travel,
they would just carry the Mishk. And the
cloud in fact went ahead of them to show
them where to go. It was not on the
Mishka. So we literally have a
contradiction. First he says when the
cloud departed from the Mishkan that's
when they
traveled all of their journeys took
place once the cloud lifted itself up
and went away from the Mishkan. But in
the last verse he
says and all of their journeys literally
the same word but they can't mean the
same thing. Something is off. You
understand the question? So Rashi is
bothered by this. And Rashi says the
second time does not mean in all of
their journeys. It
means wherever they would go to, that's
where the cloud would
rest. Rashi says the journey includes
the place where they rested. Even the
place where they rested is also called a
journey. And he brings
Because since when they rested
somewhere, they dwelt somewhere from
there they continued the journey. They
didn't stay there. It was a continuous
journey for 40 years. So therefore, even
the place where they were stayed is also
called a journey. So the second time
doesn't mean when they were actually
traveling. It means when they stayed in
one place. So why is it called masam?
Because from there they continued the
journey. And since from there they
continue the journey. This is also part
of a journey. It would be like if you're
taking a road trip to Miami from my you
stop in a gas station or you stop in a
motel or you stop in a picnic area and
somebody calls you and says where are
you? And you say I'm on a trip. I'm
traveling. And they say you're actually
in the car traveling. No, we're actually
sitting at a picnic table. So why are
you saying you're traveling? You're not
traveling. You're actually sitting in
one place and eating delicious tuna
sandwiches with pickles. Why do you say
you're traveling? You say because we're
on a journey. We're not on a You're not.
You said you're in one place. Yeah, it's
just a little break because I can't
drive 25 hours straight. So, we took a
break for lunch. But even the break is
part of the traveling. So, Rashi says
that since when they stopped in one
place, they knew that this is part of a
journey, they're going to continue. So
even when you're in one place, it could
be called a
journey. So that's why the second time
it says, this is Rash's answer. It's
still difficult. Why would the T want to
confuse us and use the same word in two
sukim near each other and mean opposite
things? The first time it means
literally when they're traveling. The
second time it means when they're not
traveling, they're in one place, but
they're going to continue to travel. And
the interesting thing is that these two
words culminate all of safer safer is
the book dedicated to exile and
redemption. The Ramban calls it the book
of gul. In medish it says in berius that
this is the
safer the book in which they left
darkness and emerged into light. It
starts off in exile in Egypt and it ends
up in redemption. So this is the safer.
We
know the garra says in is page 12 when
it comes to blessings we always look at
the final words that's the main thing
even if I made a mistake in the
beginning but if the final words were
good you're good you always go with the
end you know the grand finale
the end say end with a bang how do these
two words culminate the entire book of
redemption what's the connection I mean
it's an interesting thing the Jews were
traveling and here it doesn't even mean
traveling it means they were in one
place but they would continue to travel
and how does it connect to the beginning
of Pakudi? As we said, the end and the
beginning are always connected and also
it's connected to the beginning of
Schmice because this is the end of
Schmice which is connected to the
beginning of
Schmice. Another interesting thing is
there's a custom by Jews that whenever
you finish a safer intera everybody
screams
out and this is done even before the
final blessing meaning vers gets the
last aliyah they finish the last words
even before he makes the last blessing
they interpose with a
declaration which means be strong be
strong and let's strengthen each other
now the kazak always goes on the whole
safer because you finished the whole
book but obviously especially connected
to the last para that they read
especially the last verse and the last
words that they read which is the thing
we read right before we
say so there's always a special
connection between the last words of aer
and the message
of but in this case what would be the
strengthening message in these words of
the Jews
traveling and as Rashi says it doesn't
even mean they were traveling it means
they were in one place because only then
was the cloud on top of
them. Okay, so let me just summarize all
of my
questions. Question number one was in
the beginning of the para, why was it so
important for Mosha to give such a
detailed account? And even if it was
because of the rabble rousers, the
nudnik, those who suspected him to teach
us transparency why does the enumerate
the detailed account rather than just
tell us he did it and was vindicated.
But it really gets into all of the
details so that we should know.
Obviously, there's a profound lesson
here. Even though it's not a story that
we repeat itself, it's not like a
mitzvah that would happen again where
people are going to donate these type of
donations and we're going to give an
accounting and nonetheless we need to
know all of these details. Then we spoke
about how the beginning and the end are
always connected. So we went off to the
end of the safer which speaks about the
journeys of the Jewish people and we
spoke about the textual difficulty of
the wordam repeated twice but each time
in an opposite meaning and rashi tells
us something doesn't make sense here. So
the second one must mean not when they
journeyed when they rested because only
then was the cloud on the mishkan. So
why does it say when they journeyed when
they journeyed the cloud was not on the
mishk. So it actually says it doesn't
mean when they journeyed it means when
they were in one place but since they
continued their journey from that place.
So even when they were in one place,
it's also called part of the journey and
we asked why does the Torah have to
confuse us could have just used a more
clear word especially when a previous
verse you use the word in the opposite
context. We also asked why is why are
these the culminating words of why are
these the words that trigger
the how is it connected to the beginning
of how is it connected to the beginning
of if you didn't get all of this you
could review the class later and get the
questions especially the rash's question
because that's important here and
sometimes with the text I know sometimes
people uh um uh what's the word uh zoom
out zoom out or tune out tune out
[Music]
Okay. There's a very very profound
subtle truth that is always is often
undercover and when we unravel it, it
emerges. The word pud, the name pud
really contains a very very profound and
moving message. You see essentially the
whole safer schmis is a book that's
dedicated you could call it to nation
building. It's the building of a nation
in safer and I'll ask you a question.
It's a little trivia for those who
remember kish from your uh 11th grade in
Bakov or wherever you
went and that is when is the first time
the Jewish people are called a nation in
Kh? Anybody knows?
Huh? Yakavinu tells his sons come. So
when Yakavinu tells his sons, they're
still called children of Israel. Ben
Israel, he he gathers them. When is the
first time they become an am a people
through?
Huh? Very good. Parishes
throughout we're never called a nation.
We're called a family. Always a family.
Ben is the children of Israel. Israel is
Jacob. That was his second name. And we
are his children. He has 12 sons. He has
a daughter, Dina. Everybody creates
families and dynasties and it's
considered one I wanted to say happy
family wasn't always a happy family but
let's put it this way one family one
family that went through ups and downs
and upheavalss and many vicissitudes etc
but all is well that ends well at the
end of batious the family made peace
they're living together but they're
still a family children of Israel it's
only in safer that we get the n the name
am and who is the first one to coin us
with this n with this name anybody knows
par Yeah. The first one to call us a
people, not a family is par. It's
interesting. Not Mosha, not God, not the
Jewish people themselves. Par is the one
who sees the family. And it
says, he uses both words. This nation of
Ben
Israel, they're becoming much greater
and much more powerful than
us. We must be very, very sly and
clever.
This family is going to increase and
they shall pose a danger to our entire
society. One day they will declare war
against us and expel us from the land,
occupy Egypt. They know how to colonize
other countries. They're a nation of
occupiers. We need to be very very
clever with this nation. Suddenly we are
turned into a nation. It's interesting
that parro is the first one to call us a
people. Another fascinating thing is our
first reference as a people is already
associated with anti-semitism. What is
the definition of this nation? Danger.
The first time we are defined as a
people, not as a family. It's in context
of they're a dangerous nation. Quite
fascinating. Unbelievably fascinating.
That's the first time we're identified
as a nation. I actually heard this
insight from Rabbi, the former chief
rabbi of Israel, Rabbi Israel, Mayor
Laauo Shalita today in Tel Aviv and uh I
once heard this insight from that the it
was fascinating the first time we're
called a nation rather than a family.
It's by par and it's in terms of these
are dangerous. These are dangerous
people. This is a dangerous
nation. A nation by definition is not
about an
individual. A nation by definition can't
even be about an individual. Individuals
are wonderful people, but they're not
nations. So, safer is really the book
dedicated to nation building. It's a
nation that ends up in exile. And the
bigger thing is it's a nation that is
liberated. It's a nation that is molded
and crafted. And it's not an easy task
to turn people, a group of people into a
nation. A nation needs an identity. A
nation needs a mandate. A nation needs a
vision, a dream, a trajectory, a
destiny. And as a result of that,
Sephoris is so saturated with this theme
of how Jews become a nation. And it's
not easy. We see how Mosher Rabenu
himself watches the quarrels between the
D two Jews fighting etc. And it's a
struggle to be able to turn individuals
into a healthy, a cohesive, an
integrated, a unified nation. We see how
much the sages extol that moment
of when they come to midbar it says in
the in the singular it it rested like he
rested it was an
entire
so in berius we're a family and
sometimes a very fragmented family it's
only in exodus where we're called an am
and this becomes the pervading thread in
fact if you look at berius it's more or
less the story of individuals you have
the story of
of Kava the snake
cenyak a site hagar Ishmalitzk
etc riifa as yakov raa yhuda yf
individuals as part of a family
but is a book about a people a nation of
course individuals are mentioned
especially in schmise you have par you
have shifra you have pua you have Miriam
you have par's daughter, you have YV,
you have Misha, you have Aaron, you have
Tipporra, you have Y Isra. But all these
names are discussed as part of building
a people, representatives of a nation.
We're in middle of forming a new people.
So Schmis is about the collective, not
about the individual. The people leave
Egypt together. The people face the Red
Sea together and they cross the sea
together. The people collect the mana
together. They fight a mullik together.
They stand in front of Hari together.
They worship the golden calf together.
They build the Mishkan together. Of
course, it was led by individuals. You
had Bat Salah. You had Ali. They were
the artisans. They were the craftsman.
You always have individual people who
have to run the show. Moabu is in
charge. But nonetheless, it's a story of
how a massive massive group, 600,000 men
between 20 and 60, and at least an equal
amount of women, maybe more. So, you're
deal and then you have children and you
have senior citizens. So you're talking
about anywhere between two 3 4 million
people. We don't know the exact number
who joined together. They were
oppressed. They were disjointed. And
they're transformed by Mosha as a
messenger of Hashem into a collective
body, a collective nation. From
disintegration, we become a collective
and we
achieve the title
of nationhood. And that's where it
continues. It continues with we're
giving a unified vision. And then in
collective insanity a moment of
collective insanity 40 days later we
worship the calf which is a colossal
failure. And then after that as a fixing
as a remedy together we build the mishk.
So every project in every major moment
in parish in safer is
about the nation. The nation and we see
it most when it comes to the mishk. The
mishkan he doesn't say I want a few
people to donate. Everybody, men, women,
children, and whoever wants, it's
voluntary. And who does he choose to run
the show? Rashi says from Shvet Yehuda,
a halyah from Shvet Don. Two tribes that
were very, very different. They came
from different mothers. Yehuda was
considered the king of the Yehuda would
ultimately produce David and Schlim and
Mashiach, family of royalty. Don was the
last tribe that went in the desert. And
he says, Hashem wanted to show everybody
equal. It's not like but Salah has the
right to run and build the Mishkan. He
does it as a partnership with Ali.
Meaning this is a collective effort
where everybody everybody joins
together. So this is a home of the
people. Every single member of the
Jewish people could contribute without
any distinction whatsoever. It didn't
have to be a cayenne or a ley or is or a
woman or a child or a man or any age.
This was open to everybody and it was
built with the donation of every single
Jew who wanted to donate. It was built
for the people. This is the first time
something was created. If we want to uh
use Lincoln's memorable phrase, of the
people, by the people, for the people,
of course, with the instruction of God
Almighty. And at last, the long journey
is complete. The grand finale is
here. The national project is done right
here at the end of Aayak, the beginning
of Kud. Everything is done. Soon the
Mishkan would be erected. the divine
presence would come down. It's a charged
moment. It's a dramatic peak in a very
very long and difficult and challenging
and turbulent journey. After so many ups
and downs, God
says, "All is good. All is well that
ends well. And it's time to move in to
our new home to be with you together for
eternity." Right here, there is always a
profound challenge. And it's this
profound challenge that coup addresses
in a very very elegant, subtle and
beautiful way. And that is does nation
building by definition come at the
expense of
individuals? Sure, you can't have a
nation without individuals joining
together. A nation is made up of
individuals. As they say, Israel is made
up from
rebels. That's true. But does the word
cluster by definition focus more on the
collective and lose sight of the
individual woman, the individual girl,
the individual boy, man or child? In
other words, often when you see a
collective whole, you could come to
think that the value of the individual
is in so far that he or she is part of
the whole. As part of the collective,
you're very very valuable, extremely
valuable. Because if everybody runs in
different directions, we have no
collective. But the value of my eye or
your eye is in a deep place due only to
the fact that it contributes to the Wii.
Yes, you can't have wi without a lot of
eyes. I even have proof of that. And
that is a game called Wii and it's
spelled with two eyes. True. But the
only value ask your child or ask anybody
who plays we the only value of the two
eyes is that it gets the game going and
the game is called wei. So in a very
very subtle way even though it's hard to
admit but does the individual in the
group feel that ultimately what is my
contribution I make part of the group
but I'm part of the group and if the
moment I'm not huh I can't even look at
you. you don't really have value or
certainly you don't have much value. And
sometimes people get this feeling
consciously or unconsciously. It's
sometimes communicated directly or it's
communicated indirectly. Sometimes it's
communicated even unwillingly. Sometimes
it's communicated just because of people
the way they're feeling about themselves
and maybe they pass on that feeling not
even fully aware of what they're doing.
But sometimes we all know that a sense
of peoplehood has for a long time
characterized the nation called amis and
that has been a blessing because
especially with our circumstances and
our experiences it's the support of
community it's a support of family it's
the connection of people it's the
mitzvah
of love your fellow like yourself that
has been indispensable to our survival
and our success. Yes. And it's true till
this very
day is remembered by every single Jew as
a people that left Egypt and remained a
people since. And it's really
incredible. It's incredible that it's
more than 3,300 years and the people not
only survived but still thrives. And
that's why wherever Jews arrived, they
always knew community must be built.
They came to a place. They built a
yeshiva school. They built a they built
a home for assistant living. They built
charity
organizations whatever it is, girls
schools, boys schools and a center where
people could come together creating a
sense of belonging. So they established
communal social, religious organizations
and systems of communal responsibility.
The whole idea that we give 10% or 20%
of our of our revenues for
Alif these are all institutions of that
emphasize the fact
that we say in if I'm not for me who
will be for me but if I'm only for
myself who am I but it's interesting
that before the
words if I am just for myself what am I
Hill says this in the first chapter of
the ethics of the fathers First he says
but if I am not for myself who will be
here for me but if I'm only for myself
then mo ani what am I? So over the
generations Jews have been inculcated
with this idea of allegiance of
dedication dedication to family
dedication to
community. Heaven only knows the guilt
and shame of what you have been told if
you don't show up to the Kaneka party.
What Bubby is going to think about you
if you don't show up to the shabas
table. all the sacrifice and blood and
sweat and tears that went in for you to
show up at this sim and meal and you're
really not going to fly in from
California. Why? Cuz 5 and a half hours
you have to be on the plane now and
we're not sponsoring a first class
ticket for you and you're really not
going to fly in whatever it is. But this
allegiance to family community has been
a very very profound blessing. But like
every blessing it also can come with a
challenge and that is sometimes a very
deep feeling. And again, it could be
unconscious but very deep. And that is
that if I'm not part of the big picture,
then I have to search for myself
elsewhere. There's not really a place
for me. And this is where paras comes
in. And that's why it has such a
profound and revolutionary message.
Before we conclude the project, before
we conclude the book that's dedicated to
nation building, building a people, the
Torah dedicates the final portion and
gives us the name. And the word purude
means focusing on the individual because
whenever you count, it's always about an
individual. I can't count a group of 10
million people. I have to count one and
then two and then three and then four
and then five. So the Tyra almost
interrupts the narrative shifting the
story from creating a space for Hashem
in this world to the work of counting
every individual contribution which came
in. There may have been a child who
collected some pennies in his uh what's
it called those bags? Huh? Piggy bank.
Piggy
bank. And then when he heard from
Mishraenu the excitement that Hashem
asked that everybody should donate this
little child hesitantly and sheepishly
went over to Moshenu. He may have been
even a little scared and he may have
thought it'll be thrown back into his
face like what is this? Come on. We only
take from the real from the real who can
donate something. What are you going to
give me an old rusty shekele that you
got from Kanekal from your poor uncle
who's cheap? And yet this child gave it
to andu took it and at the end said I'm
going to give an account of what
happened with this boy's penny with this
boy's nickel with this boy with this
girl's dime or quarter. something that's
missing a lot today.
That's why I'm talking about
it. There's no contribution that is not
worth being accounted for. But why not?
Come on. Let's talk about the big
ones. It's not going to build you a
mishk. The answer is because what
Moshaenu is teaching is that there's no
individual person that is not recognized
also as an individual with his or her
own hopes, dreams, aspirations,
disappointments, and challenges. It's
not only because every dollar counts. Of
course, every dollar counts. One billion
dollars are made up of single dollars.
You can't make up $1 billion. And in
fact, people who are rich are sometimes
more stingy because they know the value
of a dollar, right? There's an old
Don't trust the benefactors. A guy who
has nothing chew, he's going to help
you. Sometimes the people who have
nothing chew, they're going to help you.
That's of course true. Every dollar
counts. But also because the life and
contribution of individuals matters in
and of itself. In fact, we see here a
fascinating thing. There's another count
that happens in middle of the building
of the Mishkan. And nobody knows how
exactly how it comes in. Truman tatava
is interrupted with para's kisa. And
then you go back to
vayakudava is the commandment to build
the mishk is the execution. The middle
is kisa. How does kisa start? If you
look at the second
source right here, hashem tells I want
you to count the Jewish people. Let
everybody give a shekel and count them.
And these half shekels were used in the
construction of the Mishk. But the word
he uses for counting is so interesting.
What's the
word? What does that mean? When you lift
up the head of the Jewish people, why is
that counting? Counting. He should say
when you count them
like and has to explain because it
doesn't
make when I'm counting people, I'm
lifting up their heads. I hope I'm not
lifting up their heads. I mean I mean
it's nice to lift up heads if you make
sure that the whole body gets uplifted.
What does this really mean? Here again
in middle of this grand project of
building the Mishkum, Mosha conducts two
counts. He counts the people in parishes
through the half shekele that they
contributed and then he counts the
contributions themselves, not the
people, the contributions in
parishes. And it's unique that this
census is defined asa lifting up the
heads. Hashem says don't count people to
turn them into numbers.
rather to highlight the uniqueness of
each one counted. That's what it means
to lift up their head. Sometimes we
could make a count because everybody's
just a number. I just have to know how
many numbers I have, how many people
like in prison they count. And it's all
about making sure everybody is here.
Nobody escaped. So counting is a very
very
very sensitive issue. That's why he says
don't count them directly. Count them
through a half a shekel. He in fact he
says it could be a plague if you count
them directly.
the opposite of the whole idea,
right? You're going you're going now to
the contrary. In the middle of this
project, we're highlighting the opposite
idea of the individual because that's
the only way you could count. And that's
why he says don't even count them
directly. Count their coins. There could
be a plague if you count them directly.
Until today, we don't count Jews
directly because of this mitzvah. It's a
funny mitzvah. If you go into a they're
looking for a minion, right? People who
are used to it are used to it. But
strangers are very like Jews, they don't
go like 1 2 3 4 5. are like not one, not
two, not three, not four. Like Gentiles
who come in the first time, we're like,
"Wow, this is an interesting people. Not
three, not seven, not eight." And then
in our imagination, we did it even
better. We just do
like or even a better one, this is what
people do when they're
hungry. Let's hope your number came out
in the right one. You didn't become you
didn't become errits. But the point is
that was just a joke. The point is we
count it does say in pkim that when we
do is many people put both of their
hands on top of the bread with 10
fingers because the braa has 10 words in
it. But what's what's the idea here? The
idea here is you know whenever you make
a count whenever you make a count you
always have to be careful because the
reason we make our senses is to flex
muscles. Google or Microsoft will tell
you we have 10,000 employees, 20,000
employees. This shows the power of a
company. An army may say, America may
say, you know, we have more than 1
million troops. Don't start
up. Uh, a country makes a census and
might say, we have 300 million people.
This shows how much taxes we get. Our
labor force. Whenever you make a census,
it's to flex muscles and to demonstrate
power. And here we have a serious
crisis. And that is God knows that if if
Jews are going to start counting
themselves and they're going to see
their numbers, it can lead to
depression. When they look at
themselves, they
say we constitute today 14 15 million
people. That's not even a quarter of 1%
of civilization. Listen to that again.
It's not even a quarter of 1% of
humanity. Okay? Not even 25 of Not even
a quarter of 1%. It's less than a
quarter of 1%. In fact, an error on a
Chinese statistic is larger than the
population of the Jewish people. That's
the fact. If 1.3 billion Chinese as I'm
talking another million were born and
the Jewish people were literally
struggling for every single number.
Literally, you have I don't know almost
three billion Christians. You have 1.9
billion Muslims and then uh Jews you
have 14 million. So now Jews are looking
at themselves and saying we're supposed
to not only survive, we're also supposed
to change the whole world and bring
redemption to the world. Like really? So
God says don't count
Jews. Count their
contributions. Don't count them. Count
what they give. And when you look at
what they give their contribution, you
realize that it's far beyond what you
imagine.
So means when you count, you need to
lift up. you lift up the people. If
you're not going to lift up the people,
if it's just going to make people into
numbers, that's not a count that we
recognize. The count is there to count
you. There's something about you that is
indispensable. You're not just part of a
you're also a major part of a
group, but it starts off
with me. If I am not for me, who am I?
And that's who will be here for me. And
that's why there's
a bottle. We have a concept of B right
of meat. If a little drop of milk falls
into a big pot of chand and there's a
ratio of 1 to 60, it gets nullified. It
gets subsumed. These are called of BL in
Kashminion. Something that's counted
individually. The is there's no B.
There's no BL. In other
words, when you have something that's
counted, it's sold individually rather
than by weight. Sometimes you sell
things by weight. But if something is
sold individually, it's called dabin.
You count it as an individual. The is
it's never nullified even in a mixture
of a thousand or a million others. Why?
Because since it's sold as an
individual, so it shows it's significant
and therefore it can get nullified even
in a huge a huge number. So this is a
huge called the shallah says that's why
God keeps on counting the Jewish people.
That's what caused them never to be
nullified and
assimilate during history. Because
usually if you have a small group exiled
all over the world and the majority is
from other cultures, other nations,
other religions after a few years, you
lose your identity. It's just natural.
You forfeit your identity. What happened
to all of the other empires and nations?
As they got exiled from their countries,
they got lost. They got assimilated in
other nations. In fact, in 1989,
interesting story. The Daly Lama called
a few Jews and he said that he has a big
problem because in 19 1950 I think 59
the Chinese exiled the Daly Lama the
Buddhists from uh from Tibet right and
so they're living in exile in India and
this is from the 1950s so this was in
1989 so like a few decades passed and he
called the Jews and he said I have a
problem we have now a second generation
growing up not in their native homeland
and I don't know how to preserve their
identity so I called in the Jews cuz you
have done for 2,000 years. You've been
exiled and you preserved the identity.
Could you give me the secret? How did
you do it 2,000 years later? I don't
know what they answered him, but one of
the ideas is that says Hashem counted
the Jews again and again. And this is
the first
one to lift up their heads because a
real count means that when you're
anchored in your own essence, wherever
you are, you don't get lost. I can only
get nullified because I'm vulnerable to
the power of the majority. But that's
only when I'm vulnerable. When I'm
anchored in my own essence, which is
infinite and eternal. It's rooted in
God's essence. So I don't care if
there's another thousand, there's
another million, there could be another
billion, but you're not subjected to
that type of loss of self because of
that deep deep connection. And as a
result of that, he
says, and that is whenever you do a
census has to be done in a way to signal
the value of an individual. You're a
unique gift. There's a contribution only
I could bring because of your very
presence before anything else. And to
lift someone's head means to recognize
their uniqueness. One of the most one of
the most valuable things in life, maybe
even the most valuable is when we can
see people for who they are. When people
can truly truly be seen, be able to
truly see a person. Now, I don't think I
can do that if I have never been seen.
If I have never been seen, we don't even
know what it means. And again, I don't
mean in words. We could say words and
they're beautiful and they're eloquent,
but I'm talking about energetically. To
really, really be able to see somebody,
just to see them. To see them in all of
their depth, to see them in all of their
light, to see them in to see their
entire soul and their entire body, to
really really be able to see. And
therefore when this person is giving one
shekel or two shekelsenu says I'm going
to count it. I want to see it. I want to
notice it. That's what it means to lift
up heads. There's something extremely
healing when somebody is seen. When
somebody is truly truly seen even by one
person, there's something so healing and
transformative about it. Sadly, I would
say many people live their entire lives
or at least many years and nobody ever
saw them. And how do they even know how
to see themselves? They can see
themselves because as we grow, we need
an example for somebody to teach us what
it means to be seen by somebody seeing
me. In fact, I would say that some of
the greatest of the great, what allowed
them to really become great was there
was at least one person in their life
who truly saw them. They didn't see them
as a tool to use them in a good way,
even in a good way. They didn't see them
as an instrument that they're going to
contribute something. it. That's that's
much much later. What they just saw is
they saw them. They truly saw them and
they saw them in all of their
colorfulness and all of their depth.
They just saw them as they were, but not
externally only, completely internally.
And when you have somebody who really
really sees you, then it's a gift of a
lifetime and beyond because then you
could see yourself. And the moment you
can see yourself, everything is
different. The moment you really see
yourself, you're now connected to your
life force and energy. And there's
nothing in the world that comes close to
being connected to your own life force
and energy. Because your life force and
energy is literally the divine life
force and energy that's flowing through
you, through me, through you, through
you, and it's yours. That's the idea of
eay nailey. This is not about arrogance
or horniness. Some people who don't
understand what this is think that to be
seen is a form of like you have to stand
out. You need attention. It's the exact
opposite. Those who are not seeing need
much more attention than those who are
seeing. Because if I'm not seeing, I'm
looking to be seen. And I'm looking for
people to tell me who I am. So if I can
get validation from this one or that one
or that one, maybe it's a hope that
maybe I'll be seen. But it's a fake
seeing because what I'm being seen is
usually for something external. And
that's why you'll see that it feels not
good. It feel doesn't feel good because
it doesn't fill the real real void. To
be seen is actually to be appreciated
for your true being and presence which
is the soul that God gave you which
is which even though it's connected to
every other soul, it's still a distinct
manifestation of divine energy. Which is
why the Mishna says that everybody needs
to
say for me the world was created. It's
not narcissism. It's the opposite. It's
really knowing that there's something,
there's a light that you bring to the
world with your presence that nobody
before and nobody after can bring to the
world. The gift of seeing your children,
the gift of seeing yourself, the gift of
seeing another human being, family or
friend or stranger is a gift like no
other. And when nation building comes at
the price of that, it exacts a very very
profound
cost. It's hard because if I'm running a
classroom and there's 20 children and
some of our schools there's 30 children
and in some minimum there's 35 kids in
the class and they can't afford another
teacher to split the class and I come in
as a teacher. What does it even mean
that I could see each one as individual?
I'm trying to run a class and if you're
a mother or a father of a big family can
har even not a big family every person
to see is really it's a tremendous
tremendous opportunity but it takes a
tremendous internal work in myself
because I have to be completely
regulated to be able to see my son or my
daughter or any other human being in
their truest and deepest space without
any judgment without preconceived
notions without opinion
And it's not about what I say. It's an
energy that I feel in my heart and then
they'll feel it. And if I don't feel it
in my heart, I could mask it with
beautiful, beautiful words, which many
of us are very good with words,
including myself. Some of us have the
gift of gab. But if it doesn't come with
inner authentic energy, it's as the the
old cliche, words are cheap. Words are
cheap when they're just words. When
they're not manifesting that deeper
truth that we're feeling. And I really I
don't think I'm capable of feeling it
with somebody else if I never really
felt felt felt it with myself. How can I
give somebody something that I don't I
don't even know what it looks like. I'm
just going to give them what I was
given, which is unconscious guilt and
shame to be able to do the right thing
and give me nas. And of course, it's all
because of love because I love you and I
don't want to get you in trouble and I
want you to have an amazing amazing
life. So it's always done with good
calculation, especially when it's done
by parents or educators who really love
these children and really want the best
for them. But in a paradoxical way,
there's something painful deep inside
because the person truly truly doesn't
feel seeing even if they can't
articulate it that way. And that's why a
coupe is so so powerful. I maybe once
told you a story. It's really an
incredible story. There was a uh a
century ago there was a great symphony
conductor. He was an Italian maestro.
His name was Arturo Tuscanini. You heard
of Tuscanini? Tuscanini died in 1957. He
lived in Italy. He was an Italian and
then he came uh he came to New York and
he led concerts all over the world. Now
he was known as an absolute
perfectionist also as an eccentric and
he had few peers. He had a biographer
who would interview him periodically
over the years as part of a major book
project. He was writing about Arturo
Tuscanini. Anyway, one evening he was in
town. He calls Tuskanini, the biographer
calls Tuscanini and he says, "I'm going
to be in town tomorrow night. can I come
over to interview you? And Tuskcanini
says, "I can't. I'm very very
busy and I really can't. Uh I don't have
time for for any
conversation." He says, "Even a few
minutes." He says, "No, it's something
that requires absolute concentration. I
really can't communicate with you. It's
not the right night. I can't be
interrupted." The biographer says he he
feel he knew this is an opportunity. You
know, how do you get to know somebody
better than this? He says, "Maestro,
could you tell me what it is?" He says,
"Yeah, there's a concert being played
overseas. I used to be the conductor of
that particular s symphony orchestra
today. Somebody else conducts it and I
couldn't be there. I couldn't be there
this year. Somebody else is conducting
it. I'm going to listen to this concerto
on shortwave radio. I don't know if
anybody knows if everybody knows what
shortwave radio is, but I'm going to
listen to it on shortwave radio and hear
how the other conductor is leading this
uh symphony. and I don't want to be
interrupted. I need to listen to it very
very carefully. So he says, "Maestro, it
would be my honor if you would allow me
to come to your house and just watch
you. I want to watch you listening on
short rave radio to the to the concert.
I want to hear how you listen to an
orchestra played by someone else, but
one that you used to lead and direct. I
promise I won't say a word. I won't
interrupt you. I'll sit on the other
side of the room quietly." So he says,
Tuscanini says if you promise to be
perfectly
quiet, we didn't say the he said or
whatever, you can come. The next night,
the biographer comes. He sits quietly.
He watches our tourini listening to the
concert. It takes at least an hour, an
hour and a half. When it ends, the
biographer turns to Tuskanini and he
says, "Wow, that was magnificent. That
was a masterpiece." Tuskanini says,
"Nah, not really." He says, "Why not?"
He said, "There were supposed to be 120
musicians, including 15 violinists.
There were only 14 violins playing."
This is on shortwave radio. This is not
on
video. So, he thought Tuskanini is
either a little crazy or he's joking.
How could he know from 6,000 miles away?
How can he know over shortwave radio
that one of the violinists was missing?
It just didn't make sense to him. So, he
had his doubts, but he didn't want to
say anything. And he went home. The next
morning, he called the concert hall
overseas. He couldn't call that night.
It was already late in Italy, but he
wherever it was in Europe, but he called
them overseas and he asked for the music
director and he inquired how many
musicians were supposed to have been
playing the night before and how many
had actually shown up. And what happens
is the concert hall director tells him
that there was supposed to be 120
musicians including 15 violinists and
only 14 had shown up. This man was blown
away. This guy is sitting on a couch or
on a chair listening on the radio and he
knows this. From 120 he knew there were
119. This just did not make sense to
him. He was amazed. He comes back to
Tuscanini and he says, "I owe you an
apology. When you told me what happened,
I thought this was senseless. This is
ridiculous. You were just being dramatic
or joking. I thought you were just
making it up. I see you weren't. Tell
me, how did you know? How did you know a
violinist was missing? So, Tuscanini
looks at him and says, "There's a very
profound difference between you and me."
To the audience, everything sounds
wonderful, but I'm the conductor. The
conductor has to know every note of
music that has to be played. When I
realized that certain notes were not
being played, I knew without a doubt
that one of the violinists was missing.
I know every single note of that
symphony. And I knew to get every note
you need 15. Not every note was touched,
was captured, was internalized, was
played. And that's how I know somebody
was missing. And uh when I read this, I
was like,
"Wow, that's the idea. That's the true
idea. For the audience, there's a violin
here, a violin there. Who knows the
difference? But for the
creator, there's an indispensable note
called you. That note cannot be played
by anybody else in history. Not before
you and not after you. And it's not
because you are I'm the greatest saint
who ever lived. It's just because it's
you. It's your soul that is manifested
in your body that is absolutely unique.
This is your shekel. It's what you give.
It's your light. It's your presence. And
maybe for others, they may not even see
the difference. But for the creator, for
the the conductor of the symphony, this
is absolutely indispensable. And this is
where our truest value is. My truest
value could never be in what people
think about me. Of course, it's nice if
people have a positive opinion about me.
Do you? Okay. Thank you. It's nice. I'm
never I'm never going to sue anybody for
giving me a compliment, but that's not
really where true fulfillment happens.
Feedback is great. Constructive
criticism is even greater. Jewish
constructive criticism is the most
amazing thing in the world. It keeps
your ego small for 120 years and then
some. So, it's a beautiful, beautiful
blessing. And everybody needs feedback
and should get feedback. But it's really
about truly truly appreciating your own
life force and energy which is the
direct
flow. It's like a rope that goes all the
way to the highest level and comes down
and you're holding on to that rope every
single moment. And it's that rope that I
sway and it's ripple effects that makes
the changes in all of the the cosmos and
in all of the worlds that I make. I once
heard you know of freed right the famous
singer. So he had a father his name was
Rabbi Freriedman. All of a su Hungarian
Jew and uh he uh so I heard from his
brother I think I heard from his brother
Rabbi Manis Friedman a story about their
father Freriedman after the war was in
Prague which was a communist country and
he was liberating Jews from there
getting them out to be able to go to
freedom and he was caught and he was
arrested in Prague and it was pretty
serious. This is after the Holocaust.
And uh in in in in prison, he added and
he would say to him and uh he made a
very deep resolution. He saw how much
the tahillum was helping him and
connecting him to Hashem and to his
soul. And he made a resolution that if
he goes out, he's going to say a huge
amount of tahillum every single day for
the rest of his life as gratitude. And
so he was liberated. And that's what he
did. And every day he had his tahillum
and he said whatever the number of
kapitlak chapters he did. Anyway, years
years passed he was working for a
yeshiva in flatbush. And one day early
in the morning he was woken up by the
fire department like 4:00 or 5 in the
morning that this yeshiva was on Ocean
Parkway was in flames. I think it was
arson or something else and he right
away flew down there to to to Ocean
Parkway to be able to be there as they
extinguish the flames of the yeshiva.
And he was there literally all day with
the with the fire department. And late
afternoon it was like crisis after
crisis after crisis. He had to save the
building. Then he realized, you know,
that he didn't dive in yet and it was
late and he ran back home and he got his
fill in. And he put on fillain and very
soon it was and very soon it was
sunset. Okay. Now at that time his son
said he was negotiating with somebody
about buying a house in Crown Heights.
It wasn't that easy. He didn't have
really money. So, it was hard. You know,
it wasn't so easy to buy a house. Even
those days when the houses were like
$19,000 on President
Street and every Jew is like, if I would
have only bought, I would have today
been a multi-millionaire. You know,
every Jew who walks by the houses in
Borak. If I only would have been aim
whatever his father, but my father was
too idealistic in any case. So, uh but
he needed a house. He had a big family,
the whole Freedman family. And uh so he
had this this this question. So a few
days earlier he wrote a letter to the
labavatureba describing the whole
situation with the house and he asked
advice and a blessing if he should go
ahead and borrow the money get the down
payment and buy the house and so forth.
When he came home that night and he he
uh he put on his fill in he finished
avening and the fire was settled all all
it worked out but was a difficult thing.
one of the secretaries of the Reb that
night called that the Reb just gave out
an answer and he gave him a blessing. It
should be with and you should go ahead
and buy the house and it'll be with and
it's the right thing to do. I think it
was a house on president near Kingston
in any case and he finished and he
finished the answer and then the
secretary says but the Reb on the bottom
wrote a word that's very strange. He
wrote question
mark and what does this mean? And then
he realized this was the first day he
forgot to say his tollum from when he
was in Prague because of the fire and he
came home and it was nightfall and he
forgot to say his tollum. So he wrote to
him question mark and then he realized
nobody knew about this. Nobody knew
about this and a Jew sits and takes it
to and says five chapters one chapter
10. Who even notices? So it's what your
did. It's what the alaba did. It's what
the elaba did it. But somehow in the
cosmic symphony there are the notes that
your violin plays. It's your heart. It's
your soul. It's your prayers. It's your
expression to Hashem. And and
and who's sensitive to those frequencies
felt that that day there was something
missing. Laavd Tuscanini in his world
knew there was a violin missing. That's
what Tuscanini understood. And you
couldn't argue with him. Don't argue
with me about this. Tuskanedi would say,
"I am the conductor. I know my notes."
On a higher, deeper spiritual level,
there are the spiritual notes of music
that every single person contributes
simply with their soul, their presence,
and our words and our thoughts and our
actions could become manifestations of
it. And that was it. It was just a
question mark. It was like something was
missing in the world today because of
your chapters, your chapters of Tahill.
And that's really the idea of the Alip
Kishkan. I once I once saw a uh there's
a magazine called the diplomat. It's an
old magazine. So there was a Chinese
scholar and he explained that there
Trump would like this. He explained the
difference between the China dream and
the American dream. So this guy wrote
like this. The China dream is the dream
of a nation. The American dream is the
dream of an
individual. That's what he wrote. I told
you Donald Trump would like this. Now,
what is the dream of Judaism, Laavdo?
What is the dream of Judaism? Is it a
China dream or is it an American dream?
And I think it's certainly it's
certainly the dream of a nation, but
it's equally the dream of an
individual. It's really attempting what
may sometimes seem like the impossible,
but it only seems as the impossible when
we don't understand the true depth of a
nation and the true depth of an
individual as an anchor of God's light.
Yes.
Is it possible that
Yeah, exactly.
What happens often isel came from mass
hysteria. Mass hysteria means when
people lose their individual presence
and they just surrender. I remember I
was once in the airport with my wife. We
were going somewhere and there was a
crazy crazy long security line and I'm
like EST. Oh my god. I don't think we're
going to make the plane. Like look at
this. Like the line it wasn't just a
long line. It was like going to another
floor. like you had to wait on the
escalator all the way till you went to
the next floor. It was like a huge line.
I mean, it looked like at the moment, I
don't know, an hour, an hour and a half,
maybe more. And uh I said some I said to
her, I said, you know, I think somehow
at the end of the at the end of the hall
there may be another
line. So, we went maybe somebody told
me, maybe I asked, I don't remember. We
went and sure enough, that line was
open. It was open. We went through, I
don't know, like five minutes. And my
wife says to me, "Look at the lesson.
Look at the lesson. People saw everybody
going into this line. They didn't even
think that there may be another option.
Everybody knows what they're doing. By
the way, everybody doesn't know what
they're doing. Sometimes everybody knows
what they're doing and sometimes
everybody doesn't know what they're
doing. And you have to know just because
everybody went here, this may be the
wrong line to go. I remember huh the
caterpillar we spoke about exactly the
processionary caterpillar. Don't always
go in the same circle. That circle is
going to kill you. Go where the food is.
Go where the food is. And you know
sometimes it comes even with our
children and our students you know we
feel all the kids went to this school or
all the kids are doing this all my
neighbors all my nephews our whole
family and therefore I should also push
him or her to go in this place but
sometimes it's a completely completely
flawed decision even if it's done with
good intentions.
Sometimes we need to completely be
sensitive to where the person is, what
their presence is, who they are, and
what's their potential of shining. And
it's a very very sensitive, it's an
extremely sensitive subject. I remember
Kofi Anan was the general director of
the UN. And in the middle of all the
suicide bombings, he turned to Israel
and he said in one of his speeches, he
said, "Are you going to tell me that
Israel is the only country that's right
and the whole world that's criticizing
her is wrong? Are you going to tell that
to me? It doesn't make sense." So I
wrote in an article, yes, Mr. Hanan,
absolutely. When 6 million Jews were
gassed and a million and a half children
were gassed, the whole world was silent.
You also think the world was right and
the Jews were wrong. So this is very
important in people's lives to be able
to trust themselves. When you But you
have to know when you can trust
yourself. In other words, I have to be
able to trust not my addictions and my
craziness and my insanity and my but
when you are experiencing your violin,
when you're experiencing your
music, people have to learn to be able
to really trust themselves because it's
that trust that carries you through a
difficult world and allows you to
actually give your light. Yes.
Right.
It's a great question. So I think and
yeah your question was how do you
communicate and educate your children as
an example of good deeds and kindness
and so forth if you don't talk about it
because you don't want to be a big shot
I think with most of our children they
know almost
everything instinctively huh
right a lot by
osmosis you don't say very often I think
they feel the energy they feel how
regulated and present and you are And
how you know? Huh?
My children don't know that.
So you're saying that
talk about everything. She says talk
about everything.
I think so. I think if it's done with
the right intention. Yeah. I think so.
Yeah. you really I don't know that
there's a rule. It's it's really it's
really showing up with with sincerity
and authenticity. If I'm trying to brag
to my kids, obviously what's the point,
right? If I'm really sharing something
that touched me, you know, you may say,
I called up the Spanish gardener to
thank them and I saw how touched they
were and I realized, you know, the
impact of such a telephone call. Like
how often do they get, you know, like
such types of things could be extremely
moving, especially if it's done with
real sincerity and real authenticity of
communicating something that touched us
to people that we love.
Okay. There was a comedian who once said
that a graduation ceremony is an event
where the commencement speaker tells
thousands of students dressed in
identical caps and gowns that
individuality is the key to success. And
B, it's also usually somebody who made 7
billion dollars and he's telling
everybody, you know, forge your own path
and don't listen to anybody else just
like me who was thrown out of all the
schools and today I'm worth almost a
hundred billion dollars. But a wise man
once said, "Diversity is the one thing
that we all have in common." The truth
is that when I truly am connected to my
deepest self. So then diversity becomes
a natural thing. Not because I'm trying
to, you know, put down or to be
different. It's almost some people have
this mitzvah. I have to be different. I
have to stand out. But the reason I have
to stand out is again because I'm not
connected to myself. So I need you to
see that I'm standing out. The
eayy really idea is that the person is
truly a manifestation of a particular
life force and energy that that that
that come
out. I once read an article by Rabbi
Jonathan Saxs All of a Shalom the former
chief rabbi of England and he said there
was a Catholic writer he died a little
while ago. You may have heard of him.
His name was Paul Johnson. Paul Johnson
wrote a book called the history of the
Jews. It's a beautiful book by a non-Jew
where he really touched such beautiful
things that he noticed about the Jewish
people. And uh he writes, you know,
sometimes from an outsider, you get to
see things that you don't
realize. Remember he writes a line there
that the Jewish people paved paved paved
a way of purpose in the jungle of
history like just very beautiful things.
So, Rabbi Saxs asked him what most
struck him about Judaism and the Jewish
people in the years that he spent
researching his work history of the
Jews. And uh Rabbi Sach says that Paul
Johnson replied roughly in these words.
He says there have been in the course of
history societies that emphasize the
individual like the secular west today.
There have been others that placed most
weight on the collective like communist
Russia or China for example. Judaism was
the most successful example we know of a
tradition that managed the delicate
balance between both giving equal weight
to individuals and collective
responsibility coming with that. Judaism
was a religion of strong individuals who
knew what it means to trust yourself and
also strong communities. He said this
was extremely rare and difficult in
history and he felt that it constituted
one of the greatest greatest
achievements of Judaism. This is what
Paul Johnson told uh Rabbi Sachs and
when I thought about it I realized that
this goes back all the way to the
Genesis. How did this happen? Hashem
made a promise to after a which we say
every day in Ding after the binding of
we read it on rash in the we read it
every morning. And what did he
say? You
remember I will increase your children
like the stars of heaven and the sand of
the sea. Now at that time nobody knew
how many stars there were in heaven.
They thought there were a couple of
stars in heaven. You know you go out at
night and you see a couple of stars.
Today we know that the numbers of stars
are unimaginable and mind mind
staggering. And that's only the stars we
know about. But Hashem says two things.
I'm going to increase them like the
stars of heaven and like the sand of the
sea. Why? Two examples. The stars are
numerous. And we all know that the sand
is quite numerous. Go to the beach and
you'll see there's a lot of sand out
there on the beach, not on the beach.
Hashem uses both illustrations. Now, in
fact, I would say choose stars over sand
because the stars actually exceed even
the sand. It's surprising, but there are
more stars than sand. So to speak about
sand after stars is superfluous once you
set stars it's actually much more than
sand and I want to show you here the
majesty of how every word is precise a
single grain of sand is valueless what
are you going to do with a single grain
of sand tell me you're going to sell it
on eBay take one grain of sand then what
are you going to do with it you can't
even plant anything compon combined
together they make up a wonderful beach
if you have one grain of sand at the
water you say what a beautiful beach.
I'm going to lie down on the grain of
sand in the sun and read a book. But you
have a lot a lot a lot of grains of
sand. Hundreds of thousands, millions
and millions, hundreds of mill billions,
and you have an amazing amazing beach.
You have a field, you have soil, you
have a farm, you have earth, you could
plant, you have produce, and you have
what we call earth. If you go to Hawaii,
you go to Greece, or you go to the
Riviera, and I know Trump wants to make
Gaza the next Riviera of the Middle
East. main you go to a you go to a lot
you go to Cancun you even go to Miami
beach the second natural habitat of the
Jewish nation in lie of New York
whatever these people one grain of sand
won't amount to anything but together ah
this is a thing of value the sand can
form a beach and mud and glass and
computer chips it's all made of sand now
let's talk about
stars are
individuals each one is a powerful
source of light and an energy on its In
fact, two stars coming together can be a
destructive force. Two stars that
collide create an explosion. They
destroy each other. So, Hashem tells
Abraham, "Let me tell you the secret of
your children. They will be blessed to
be like stars and be like sand. On one
hand, we're all united. We're one." Ask
the anti-semites. They don't see no
difference. A Jew is a Jew is a Jew is a
Jew that brings out our collective
oneness like
the it's literally made of one because
in the source everything is truly truly
one and unified with the ultimate source
with no
division that's why we
say if I'm only for myself what am I I'm
missing so much without the relationship
without the connection
without on my own I'm a grain of sand
That's why I need the other sand and
that's sand represents humility because
it's humility that allows us to really
connect to people. It's humility that
allows us to see other people to feel
other people to empathize with other
people to really connect to other
people. When I connect my life with
others, beginning family and community
etc. the Jewish people we become larger
and deeper and a beautiful, beautiful
beach. But there's another side to the
promise. Your children are going to be
like
stars. Literally like stars. Each person
has a unique individual. Every star has
its personality, so to speak, its
chemistry, its shape. And some of them
are larger than the sun. It's
unbelievable. You know, you look at a
star, it looks tiny. Go a little closer,
it could take you four billion light
years. Go a little closer and you'll see
they're larger than the sun. We call
them small only because of our retina
goes crazy. From such sizes, it can't
relate to it. It's our retina turns it
into small turns it small but really
it's larger than the sun. So sometimes
you look at an individual including
yourself and you say at best I'm just a
little little tiny tiny thing but the
moment you get closer the moment you
really see the star from close it's
literally a star. You're a star and
you're not a star because somebody said
it and you're not a star because
somebody complimented you. You're a star
by your very very creation. It's your
unique light that the star casts. It's
your unique warmth. It's your unique
energy. This is the value of an
individual is also divine. Everybody
have a beautiful, beautiful week.
Thank you.
Okay. Thank you for
coming. You know this this thing about
you know that the lady was asking about
that question about how to be the
children. Look at look at Rabbi Bender
in in Dar, right? Yeah. I don't know.
You know the story I think about
the the um they made a whole big deal
about the security guard that's been in
the school 40 years. Right. Beautiful.
Yeah. Right. It's such a kid. But you
know what? You know what he taught those
students, right? Exactly. And you know
what? When we were growing up, you know,
when those snowplow guy came in the
winter, my h my father always gave him a
cup of hot cocoa. And you know, I did
the same thing. And guess what? Your
kids are going to do the same thing. I
see you doing by example. Yeah.
So, thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
That means a lot. Yeah. You know, let me
just shut it one. Let me just shut the
[Music]