Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
One of his letters, one of them is the
problem is the solution.
Always. The problem is
it's true in learning. Like the bigger
the kasha, the more of a hidush you're
going to arrive at, right? So, also in
life. The bigger the problem
Or you could say this, the the bigger
the helem, the bigger the giluy.
>> That's the Rebbe's approach when he asks
questions in learning.
>> In learning, right.
>> So, the bigger the question, the bigger
the answer. Or in terms of chassidus,
it's
>> in the question.
>> the helem, the bigger the giluy that
ensues. But, in life also, and you see
in Igros, the bigger the conundrum the
person is facing, the more clarity
they're about to
to come into.
>> Receive.
>> Right. And it's not just the lefi erech,
it's also the oifen, the manner of it.
Because the answer is embedded in the
question.
The
the famous simple example of it is
Jonathan Sacks writes to the Rebbe,
"Should I become the next Chief Rabbi of
England?" "I should." Right. "I should."
And then it took made the transposition
editing marks. Turns "Should I" into "I
should." Right?
You're asking it as a question, I'm
telling you you're saying it as an
answer. Or a mold of red to zik, right?
The vine dub story, right? Famous. Okay.
We have many such illustrations of this.
>> Now,
side note.
>> Yeah.
>> You go back. Just hold your thought, but
>> Yeah.
>> one of the most gishmack parts of that
story with Rabbi Sacks,
they saw
I think it's a I think it's a gem or
video where he's describing how he wrote
to the Rebbe about whether he should
become the Chief Rabbi, and he got that
answer. He told his wife, "Okay, I'm
going to write to the Rebbe, but are you
ready?
>> [snorts]
>> Because whatever the Rebbe's going to
say, I'm going to do."
>> Right.
>> So, it was like a very chassidish
>> Right.
>> Like
I don't know if I should write. You want
me to write?
>> Right. To commit.
>> [laughter]
>> Yeah.
So, the answers in the questions. A guy
writes to the Rebbe
and he says, "I can't do hisbodedus
because I don't have time and I don't
have concentration.
I'm thinking all day long about other
things and I just I can't do it. I can't
think about Hashem.
So, the number writes him back.
And I'm paraphrasing, but it's like,
"Oh, good good news. So, you do have
time and concentration."
>> You're just using it for the wrong
thing.
>> Using it for the wrong thing.
>> [gasps]
>> Like, I was afraid that maybe you're
going to tell me, "Pasha, you can't
think. You don't have Some people just
can't think." Nope, clearly you can
think. You can concentrate. Good news.
You're just thinking about the wrong
things. Okay.
So, that's an example of the problem is
the solution, right? Question is in the
answer, or the answer is in the
question. But, what I was saying before
about So, we have problems in life
and we're in pain.
Different degrees of pain. It could be
like massive massive pain, or it could
just be
a general discomfort, right? Okay.
And we know that we we need clarity. We
need some way to frame this, some way to
to look at this, so we can get through
the day.
And then, what do we do?
And I
you know, I'll include myself. I'm not
I'm I'm not perfect here. I
We look for for for look for answers in
other sources.
And
that to me is the tragedy.
Because
it's just satisfying enough
that it delays the need
to search further.
It feels like
>> Those other those other sources.
>> What?
>> Those other sources.
>> Yeah. So,
you know, podcasts and books and
whatever other sources.
Some are clip schnitzel and some are you
know, lower, but the point is
that
someone sent me
>> I believe I mentioned this also
somewhere in another podcast, but
the alum will have to forgive me if I'm
repeating myself.
But
>> someone sent me a um
a meme
that is a new discovery that if you help
others, then actually helps with your
happiness.
>> Okay.
Right?
>> And I was like, "Good morning."
>> [laughter]
>> Like, "W- Welcome to What is the
difference that anybody is writing about
that they don't want to tick on and they
want this
to go be involved in the youth and help
>> Right.
>> And I was like, "Okay, so you got the So
you got So you're saying you're delaying
some of the But you're going to You have
to go go further and you're going to get
the the the real source anyways."
>> By the way, this is a story momish story
that I have been told. I have been told
a story that the the the the the Rebbe
Rashab
says that uh
he was at a seder.
So it's Yom Tov, I think it was. And
there was someone there at the seder, I
think from Beis Rivka.
And this person was listening to
podcasts. So I guess in the 1890s they
didn't have podcasts. It must have been
a must have been a book. I don't know
what it was. Bicher, yeah.
>> That was the cliffhanger. That was the
podcast of the day.
>> That was the podcast. So the guy says,
"Hey,
>> My head is mashpia to pinya korif. He
used to still talk about bicher.
>> Bicher, yeah. So he says
that the professors found out that when
you look up, it helps you remember. And
when you look down,
>> It's a story in Likutei Sichos.
>> And when you look down, it helps you to
concentrate because there's a vein in
the brain and it brings blood to
different parts of the brain that do
different functions.
And the guy, you know, he said he was
all excited about it. He thought it was
very interesting. And afterwards, the
Rebbe Rashab went and got
a
uh a maamar of the Mitteler Rebbe.
And he showed him
didn't say that a shtaust
And uh then that's why sodiach sechel
kayin a person that he when he he's the
person is also made that way. And when
he wants to remember, he looks up. When
he Look when he wants to concentrate, he
looks down.
So, the Rebbe tells this story as an
illustration that everything's in the
Torah. And this guy, never he had to get
excited that he heard it on a podcast or
he read it in a book or whatever it is,
it's in Seder.