Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
This Torah class is brought [music] to
you by tora anytime.com.
>> Good evening everyone.
>> Good evening.
>> Okay, in this week's para we are
introduced to someone, one of the
greatest figures of all time. We're
introduced to Abraham Au. Actually, in
the beginning of the para, his name is
not Abraham. His name is Abra.
And every morning during
we say
in we say look at number one
you are hem our God.
You chose Abra. What does that mean?
Hashem chose. What is that supposed to
mean? He chose him. But there was a hat
with a bunch of names on it and he
picked out the name of what does that
mean? We have to look into that.
You took him out of
and
you made his name Abraham.
You found his heart to be faithful to
you. So we see we say every morning that
Hashem chose Abra. What does it mean
Hashem chose Abra? What is that supposed
to mean? What does that mean? We have to
ask ourselves. We're gonna do two
questions. Ready? Two questions. Good.
The first thing is the parish starts off
comes to and he says leave your
homeland. We have to ask ourselves who
is
anywhere else in Tanakh when Hashem
speaks to a Na'vi first it gives you the
credentials. It says let's say for
instance
found favor inem
it tells you all about the it explains
to you why this guy is worthy of
speaking to him and then it says
mean first it has to establish who is
this person you know there are a lot of
people in the world why did choose to
speak to I'll tell you
He's a good guy. He's a sadic. He's a
he's this. He's that
comes we know there 10 generations from
right
and so on and so on until you get to at
the end of it lists there's a man named
Tak had three sons. What were their
names?
>> A nar.
Does it say one word about Aram? No. It
said he married a lady called Sar.
Anything about Har? No. He married a
woman named Milka. So we have all these
names. We have seven eight names. We
don't know anything about any of them.
And bang.
Hashem spoke to Abra. Who's Abra? Say
Abra's a sadic. He he is a TI. He walks
with Hashem. He's the first person to
discover Hashem first. Why does the
Torah just jump into without telling you
who is Ara? Why is Ara worthy of Hashem
speaking to him? By it explains a whole
thing, a whole bio, a whole biography.
Who's then it says Hashem spoke to him?
But why? It doesn't say one word. That's
question number one.
>> What does it mean?
>> He chose Abra.
>> Hashem chose Abra found him.
>> Hashem chose Abra.
>> Not that Abra found.
>> No. So that's the first question. The
first question is why does the Torah not
say one word about Abraham was a sadic?
He was a Tim. He believed in Hashem.
Nothing. just straight into it.
You don't find this anywhere else in the
whole Torah. Yeah. Hashem speaks to
Moshe. But you know why? Because he went
out to be with his brothers who were
being enslaved in Mitim. It gives you a
whole bio about who is Mosha Rabenu took
him after him. Who's Mosha? And then
Hashem speaks to him. It tells you who
he was. Then Hashem spoke to him. Not
one word. Not one word. We don't know
anything about him. We don't know if
he's a sadic. He's a Russia. For all all
we know is that his father was Tak. Why
did Hashem speak to Abra and not? Why
him not? Why him not? We don't know.
Doesn't say. Plus, there is something so
earthshattering that happened to Abra
that the Torah does not make one word.
Doesn't say one word about it. What does
it say? What's the incident? We know
that Ara was the son of Tara. What did
Tar do for a living?
>> He sold gkas, right? He sold idols,
right? He had big idols, small idols
with big noses, small noses, tall,
skinny, fat, everything, right? If you'd
ask, you know, how's business? Say,
"Thank God."
>> So, so that's what Tar did for a living,
right? That's what Tak did for a living.
And we know one day Tar tells Arab, I
have to go on vacation. I'm going uh
going to Florida. I'm going to Florida.
Take care take care of my business. So,
Aram takes care of the business. He
takes a big bat. He smashes all the
idols. comes home from vacation and he
sees there's a bat in the hand of the
biggest idol and he says, "What did you
do to my idols? Not me. I didn't do
anything. You see this big idol over
here?" He took the bat. He smashed all
the other idols. Said, "What are you
talking about? This idol is made out of
stone. It can't can't talk. It can't
think. It can't do anything." So Ara
says, "Why don't you listen to what
you're saying? If you acknowledge that
idols have no power, so why do you
believe in them?" Says, "What do I do
with you?" He brings him to Nimrod.
Nimrod said, "We're throwing you in the
fire." Abraham says, "Throw me in the
fire. I don't care." They throw him in
the fire.
Miraculously, God said, "God himself."
The angel said, "We're going to go save
him." Hashem said, "No, no, this is not
a job for you. Abraham is one in the
world. I'm one in the world. I'll take
care of this myself." Hashem cools off
the fires. He saves Abraham. So, the
question we have to ask, question number
two is not did this happen. Of course,
it happened. It's a medish. But why does
theish not say one word about it? Not
one word is mentioned in the whole.
>> And why does the say it's left?
>> Why does the sitter mention?
>> The sitter doesn't say. All it says is
Hashem took him out of a city called
Orcazm.
>> We don't he took him out. We don't know.
It doesn't say exactly.
>> We don't know the story
>> from the medish the perk.
>> How does they know?
>> Hashem gave the Torah on a written law
and an oral law. Every word of the
medish was given on harina. The question
is why was it omitted from the Torah?
Okay, so here are the two questions.
Number one, why does the Torah not say
one word about who is Abraham, right?
The Torah doesn't say who he was. It
just says, it starts off.
We don't know. We don't know. This is
for this. I'm sorry.
>> But right here.
>> Um, so the first question is why does
the Torah not establish give you the
credentials of Abraham? And number two,
why does it not say one word about
Oracazm? How Abraham was miraculously
saved from the fire? Okay. So the second
question of why the Torah doesn't tell
us about this miracle at ordan
addresses. Okay. Look at look in the
Ramban number two. By the way, the
Ramban was born in 1194 in Garona,
Spain. He eventually passed away in the
year 1270 in Arat Israel. In the year
1263,
he was summoned by King James of Aragon
to dis have a disputation with the
Dominicans and they debated. They
debated. Damban was victorious. The king
proclaimed Damban victorious in the
debate. He awarded him 300 golden coins.
However, the Dominicans began spreading
rumors that we won the we won the
debate. So, the Ramban for the sake of
accuracy and history recorded the debate
in a safer called safer.
>> Was it a religious debate?
>> Religious debate Judaism against
Christianity. And the king
>> Yeah. The king awarded the Ramban with a
victory. He he rewarded him with 300
golden coins
>> and the Dominicans started spreading
rumors that no, they won the debate. So
Ramban recorded the debate. The
Dominicans took the safe, showed the
king, look this is heretical. This is
apostasy. This is against the church.
The king said, "You're right. We got to
get rid of him." So they summoned the
Ramban. The Ramban said, "What do you
want from me?" I didn't want to go to
the debate, but the king, you told me
I'll have freedom of speech. Doesn't
matter. The Ramban was exiled from uh
Barcelona from Spain. He had to go
elsewhere. Eventually he came to Aris.
>> Who was first? Him and Rabani grown up.
>> They were contemporaries.
>> They were in the same time.
>> They were related according to that too.
>> No.
>> Did you get the the book in English?
>> The I don't know.
>> I don't know if they translated.
>> I don't know. They may have.
Okay. But in any event, look at the
number two.
This para did not explain anything.
Why did Hashem tell him to leave
and I'll benefit you with a benefit that
no one was ever benefited with? In other
words, Hashem tells Abra, "Leave your
land and you know what? You'll have
children. You'll have money. You'll have
fame. You'll have everything. You'll
have everything."
Wh why why doesn't Hashem say,
"Why? Why is Hashem offering him all
this? The Torah doesn't tell you why
Hashem offers Abraham all of this, all
of these gifts. Normally, whenever the
Torah says, "Hashem is going to give you
good things." Hashem says, "Listen to my
mitzvah. Follow the Torah and I will
reward you." And here, Torah doesn't say
one word about Hashem's telling Abraham,
"Follow the Torah and I'll reward you.
Just free gifts. Go there and I'll give
you good stuff."
>> So, Hashem doesn't tell him why to go.
It doesn't say that Abraham was at
Saddic. It doesn't say any good quality
about Abraham. Just immediately, Hashem
speaks to Abraham. So, I'll just tell
you outside very quickly. Raman learns
that the Torah purposely avoids, if you
want to look at inside, you can see the
third line from the bottom. The Torah
doesn't want to say anything about the
episode of Abraham being saved from the
fire. You know why? Because what's the
Torah gonna say? There was once a man
named Abraham. He believed in one God.
But there were these idoltors. They bow
down to to statues with big noses and
they they had big stomachs and they
believed they were God. Well, the Torah
is going to start telling you about some
ridiculous belief that that other
nations have. The Torah doesn't do that.
Torah Torah, every word is sacred. It's
going to start explaining to you what
they believed. And Abraham said, "No,
you're wrong. You're wrong." And they
said, "No, we're right. We'll prove it
to you because last night, you know, I
had a headache and I went to the I went
to my uh my idol and I dive into him and
I was healed." So, what the Torah is
going to start talking about this? No,
the Torah is not going to lower itself
to tell you what these nations believed,
what kind of idols they had. So they
said better to omit the whole thing.
>> They still have it today.
>> Torah doesn't want to discuss. Just like
whenever the Torah speaks about
idolatry, it doesn't get into what
exactly they believe, what these idols
were like. The Torah omits it
completely.
But still the question we have to ask,
and this is a very fundamental question.
Why when it comes to Abrau
does the Torah not say one good thing
about him? Not that he was a sadic. Not
that by the way it says in pashah told
us
these are what happened in the heaven
and earth when he created them and the
says no don't read it beh
the whole world was created in the merit
of Abraham. And yet the Torah for some
reason doesn't say he was a sadic.
doesn't say he was the first person to
believe in Hashem. Immediately, Hashem
speaks to him. Why? Okay. So, you ready
for this? This is such a beautiful
thought. It's to come here just to hear
with this one thought
from the Mari Prague. Maral. Who is
Maral? Maral was deoi Benal.
Okay. Maral was born in the year 1526
according to many. Some say as early as
1512. He passed away in6009
and
says Marel or read it inside. When
Hashem chose Ara,
it was different than when he spoke to
Noah. When he spoke to Nyak, all Hashem
was interested in was this. Okay. So why
would Hashem speak to this individual?
So the Torah has to say, well, this
individual was a sadic. He was a Tim. He
deserved it. When Hashem chooses an
individual, that person has to be
worthy. It has to be for a reason.
Hashem doesn't just choose an individual
for no reason at all. There has to be a
reason. This person has to deserve it.
But when Hashem spoke to Abraham, guess
what he was doing? He wasn't just
speaking to Abraham. He was choosing
Clai Israel for all eternity. Abraham
was our father. He was the beginning of
Clai Israel. So when Hashem chooses to
speak to Abraham, he's not just choosing
that individual. He's speaking and
choosing all of the Jewish people for
all eternity.
Why does Hashem choose us? So if the
Torah would have wrote that Abraham was
a sadic and Abraham was willing to be
thrown into a fire for God and Abraham
was the first person to believe in God
and he made many converts and he was the
greatest balet who ever lived. You know
what we'll think? That's nice for our
forefather Abraham. But what about us?
Maybe we no longer deserve Hashem's
relationship. Maybe we don't deserve
Hashem's relationship anymore because we
don't have and enjoy the same qualities
that Abraham did. So therefore, maybe
Hashem's love for us, if the Torah would
have wrote that Abraham was a sadic,
Abraham was deserving, then maybe we
would think that's for Abraham. But what
about his progyny? What about his
descendants? Maybe we're not worthy.
The Mishna Pavo says that there are two
types of love. One type of love is you
love someone for an external factor,
right? You love someone because they
look beautiful. Says the Mishna, if you
love someone for a reason, as soon as
that reason doesn't apply, you don't
love them anymore. If you if you married
somebody for their looks, so if they
don't have it anymore, you're not going
to love them anymore. If you married
someone for their money, if they lose
their money,
there's no more ava. But if you love
someone for some inherent quality that
they have that's part of their makeup,
then the love will last forever because
you don't love them for something that
they did or something that they have.
You love them for who they are. The same
thing with Hashem didn't love us because
Abraham was a sadic. Abraham was willing
to jump into the fire. You know why
Hashem chose us? There's something about
the makeup of Clal Israel that Hashem is
love so much. not something that we do,
not something that we have, but who we
are. And that love will never end. And
therefore, since when Hashem chose
Abraham, he wasn't just choosing him. He
was choos choosing all of Israel. The
Torah is making it very clear. You know
why Hashem chose us? Not for any
specific reason. It's some inherent
quality that every Jew has that you
can't say it's because we're sadikim.
It's because we have this quality, that
quality. Hashem loves us for who we are,
and therefore it's eternal.
>> Why does he love us? It's an
>> maybe we'll come to we'll explain it
more. Let's read it inside. Really, it's
a very incredible idea in number three.
Let's take a look.
>> Let's maybe we'll see. Let's look at it
inside.
This is a prag on the Mishna that says
any love which is not dependent on
something will last forever. Says
you could say
that which the Mishna says.
Any love which is not dependent on
something will never become nullified.
Why do I need to know that a love which
is not dependent on something will never
become nullified?
Is coming to let us know
what hope and what confidence can we
have in exile
because you know after all Hashem
expelled us from Israel. Could we really
be sure that we still have Hashem's
love? So the mission is telling us, yes,
it's impossible for the love of Hashem
to ever be nullified.
The love that Hashem loves us,
it's not dependent on anything.
Since the love is not dependent on
anything,
the love will never become. It will
never be nullified. How do I know
Hashem's love for us is not dependent on
anything?
This is very clear.
The says at the beginning of this week's
parashem
says to leave your land
and asks
in his commentary to the what do you
mean hashem says to to who is he? Who is
the Torah doesn't say who is
that because of that righteousness
spoke to him? Why doesn't the Torah tell
you you know why Hashem spoke to him?
Because he was willing to be thrown into
the fire. All it says
all it says is Hashem talks to him. Why?
It would be more appropriate for the
Torah to give an introduction. What kind
of introduction say
how great Abraham is in his
righteousness?
But for Hashem just to tell him to go
and not say one word about
it's like something's missing.
Why would Hashem speak to him?
We don't know anything good about him.
So what do we see from here? Now maybe
you'll say that's the Torah doesn't give
credentials. The Torah is not a book of
a biographical account of everybody's
lifetime. No, but we know that elsewhere
when Hashem speaks to other people, it
tells you exactly who they are. Look,
we will see
when he spoke to Noah, he didn't just
speak to him
before this wrote
in Noah found favor in Hashem's eyes.
And then it wrote
that Hashem spoke to him. The eight. Now
don't say, "Well, maybe because the
Torah had nothing nice to say about
Abraham." What do you mean the Torah had
nothing to say? They had plenty of nice
things to say. He believed in God
against the whole world. He was called
Abraham. Why was he called Abra? Because
the whole world believed one thing. He
believed something else. There plenty of
things to say about Abraham. One of the
greatest people who ever lived.
Abraham and by Abraham
where there were so many things we could
have said about him.
Why wouldn't it say his righteousness?
So listen to what he says. We're up to
the word.
We're going to explain the reason is
Abraham is the head of our genealogy. In
other words, who was the first Jew?
Abraham.
Hashem chose him now. But not just him.
In Abraham, Hashem saw all future
generations. And by choosing him, he was
in essence choosing
like the says in number one.
You chose Abraham. Listen to this.
If the Torah would have first wrote
Abraham's righteousness,
a person may think,
>> you know why Hashem chose him? Because
he's righteous,
no, we're not.
>> And it would be a love that's dependent
on something. What was it dependent on?
>> The righteousness. No.
>> Or being thrown into the fire. That's
why he didn't say anything.
>> And now that his descendants are not
righteous, so maybe doesn't love us
anymore. But
now that the Torah doesn't say one nice
word about who Abra is, now we realize
that there is some inherent quality of
something about our makeup, our internal
makeup that Hashem loves. Nothing to do
with what we do. But now the man just
let the cat out of the hat because it
said the story of our costume. So now we
know why Hashem loves Abra and not us.
>> No, but the fact that the Torah
specifically omitted something which
should have been there, it's coming to
>> many things especially or so Abra was
was first first Abra found favor in the
eyes of Hashem through Orum and then
Hashem reciprocated.
>> But that's not why Hashem chose him.
That's not
>> That's exactly what you're saying. No,
>> cuz the first two questions you asked
was how come it doesn't say how come it
doesn't say anything about reconciles?
>> No, it says both.
>> It doesn't say it because that's not why
Hashem chose him. Hashem chose him for
his inherent quality, for Israel's
inherent makeup. Even if we're not
righteous.
>> Say both.
>> One second.
>> Wait, just say both.
>> Because other if it would say Abraham's
righteousness, you would think that
Hashem chose us because of his
righteousness. And now that we're not
righteous, Hashem doesn't love us
anymore. So it purposely left out any
good quality about Abra.
>> So why did that Hashem choose Abra?
[clears throat] for some inherent
quality that he has. We'll see. Come one
second.
I'm sorry.
Now that it doesn't say Abraham's
righteousness
teaches you,
it wasn't for any particular reason.
He chose them for their inherent
quality. Okay, a very beautiful idea.
The Torah doesn't say anything about who
Abraham is. So that we shouldn't think
that Hashem loves us because of a
mitzvah we did or something we achieved.
There's something about that Hashem
loved and he chose
>> maybe also because the Torah left it out
on purpose so people wouldn't get let's
say it's going to be like a few
qualities described five six qualities
people get attached to like well I'm
like a like Muslims they're very
hospitality is very high for them but at
the same time at the end they can cut
your head off. It's you know they feed
you up to you know
>> if the Torah would have said certain
qualities of then we would focus only on
that
>> right so that's why probably was also
left out
>> perhaps perhaps that's another reason
but here the moral is saying the Torah
didn't want to say Abraham's greatness
so you shouldn't think Hashem chose him
for a particular reason now listen to
this so what are we saying now that when
Hashem chose Abraham was he just
choosing him
>> no
>> no he was choosing Israel Okay, look at
the second P in this week's par number
five. Okay,
I will make you a great nation.
I will bless you.
I will make your name great.
You will be a blessing. Rashi says two
explanations. What does it mean?
You will have children because you'll be
a big nation. What does it mean I will
bless you? You'll be wealthy. What does
it mean? I'll make your name great.
You'll be famous. Okay, so that's a very
logical explanation for the words. What
does it mean? You'll be a great nation,
many people. What does it mean? I'll
bless you. Money, right? What else? And
I'll make your name great. You'll be
famous, says Rashi. Another
>> one second. One second.
>> One second.
You know what it means? I'll make you a
great nation. Look at Rashi.
L Abraham. You know what it means? I'll
make you great that the Jewish people in
essay will say three times a day like
hey you know what it means I will bless
you. It means the Jewish people will say
like hey you know what it means I'll
make your name great. The Jewish people
will say like hey
where does Rashi get this from? Where
does Rashi see in these words? What did
Hashem say to Abraham? I will make you a
great nation. He's saying you will be a
great nation. So how does Rashi derive
from there that we could that we're
going to say
right where do you see in these in this
I'll make you a great nation. So we're
thinking in our mind what does it mean
to be a great nation a big nation a
successful nation? No. Rashi says you
know what it means we'll say
what does it have to do with being a
great nation?
Okay, you have to realize anytime Rashi
says any commentary on the sukim, it's
not just Rashi heard an interesting
explanation, he writes it down. It's
because Rashi is bothered by a question
and Rashi is telling you the simple
meaning of the words. So Rashi feels the
simple meaning of the words that you
will be a great nation is that the
Jewish people will say
how how where does Rashi see that? Rashi
is a commentary on Kish. There are
dozens and dozens of commentaries on
Rashi. By the way, in English, a
commentary on a commentary is called
>> a super commentary, right? A super
commentary. The most prominent super
commentary, one of the most prominent
super commentary you have on Rash you
have something called
you have something called Gor which you
have something called Mizrai. Now,
nothing to do with the political party
Misrai. The Misrai was lived in Turkey
in Constantinople. He was born in 1450.
He passed away in 1525.
Okay? In the year 1500,
the Misrai became the chief rabbi of
Turkey. Now, just think for a second.
We're talking the year 1500, we're
talking about Turkey.
What did he busy himself with as soon as
he became chief rabbi? Well, what
happened eight years earlier? 1492 the
Jews were expelled from Spain. Where are
they going?
>> Turkey.
>> They're going to Turkey. They have no
money. The Mizrai spent the greater part
of a year collecting money for the
absorption of the Jewish communities of
Spain into Turkey. And
>> where do you collect it from?
>> Jews always have sources, you know. But
listen,
and he he writes in one of his
responses, one of his chuvas that he was
burnt by one of these Spanish uh um
exile exile,
>> that's not the correct word, but someone
who was exiled from Spain because uh he
the misra had a son Gon who one of the
uh people who exiled from Spain got
angry at him at the Mizrai and spread
rumors about his son that he proclaimed
one day the authority of Muhammad. They
spread rumors about his son and if you
accept publicly the authority of
Muhammad and you don't practice as a
Muslim, they'll kill you. So his son had
to run away from Turkey and the Mizrai
writes in great regret how he spent so
much of his time helping out these
people from Spain and he unfortunately
was hurt by them. But listen to what the
MRAI says. says, "Where does Rashi see
in the words um
I'll make you a great nation that the
Jews will be able to say?"
Look throughout Tanakh. Do you ever find
Hashem associating his name with one
individual? You ever say, did Hashem
ever say, "I am Hashem.
I am Hashem
David." Never. It's always Israel
because God doesn't associate himself
with individuals. No matter how great
you are, you're not worthy of Hashem's
>> direct association.
>> Uh with respect to the prayers, wasn't
the prayers that we currently use uh not
instituted officially till much later?
>> Yes. But on the other hand, the garra
says that Abraham was enacted
and then the garra says well the I
thought the anchor the men of the great
assembly the last of the prophets
enacted it. So what it means is they
enacted the precise language but the
main ideas were already enacted from the
time of Abraham and this is one of the
main ideas that we say Hashem is a god
of Abraham. So the question is if it is
true if Hashem only associates his name
with people Israel
and he does not associate his name with
individuals Moshe. So how could we say
in
Abra I thought Abra's only an
individual? No. What does Hashem tell
Abra
I will make you a great nation. In other
words, you will be accorded the status
of a nation. You are considered Israel.
You You're one person. But when Hashem
is choosing you, he's not just choosing
you. He's choosing all of Kal Israel. So
you have the status of Israel.
>> But why?
>> Because he's the father of our people.
So he's considered in him is the whole
future of Israel. So therefore we could
say Abra is
>> no because Abra is
because since Abraham is the founder of
our of our people he is already
considered Israel and we're allowed to
say Ara but I thought Hashem doesn't put
his name on one person. Abraham's not
one person he's
>> so therefore one second when the says
I will make you a great nation it means
you will be a great nation you.
Therefore, we could say that's what
Rashi means. How does how does Rashi see
in these words that you're allowed to
say? Because Hashem is saying you're
gonna be a people. Oh, you're a people.
So, so you could say Yeah. One second.
>> I heard an idea recently. Yeah.
>> All Jew, there's no like one Jew. All
Jews are connected.
>> Yeah.
>> Like I'm not you, you're not you. You're
not him. All one. That's it. Like that's
what I recently I don't know about how
we but this is the same idea. No, here
we're saying that within Abraham a
father has a bunch of children but he
within him he has all the the DNA of
those children.
>> Hashem is the DNA.
>> So but in a certain sense or Hashem
Hashem
>> Hashem is not a human being
>> but but he's the father of the Jewish
people.
>> But that's what we're saying. Abra is
Abraham is Abraham. Yeah.
>> We don't ser we don't worship
>> but he's our father.
>> I understand.
>> We don't worship is the father
>> in a certain sense. What does that mean?
>> Whoa.
Do you worship Abraham or you worship
Hashem?
>> You're getting very deep now.
>> It's very simple.
>> You worship.
>> We don't worship Arab, but he's our
father. He's our father. Abraham.
>> Hashem is the father
is Hashem, not Abra.
>> What does that mean?
>> I don't know.
>> We'll discuss that. We'll discuss that.
>> Another question. What about SC?
>> Ah, so that's the next thing. What does
it mean? I will bless you that not only
are you accorded the status of a nation
but will also be accorded that status.
And what does it mean by not only but
Jacob also meaning Hashem is saying that
all of our the garra says you're not
allowed to call Moshe Moshe a not it's
an
Hashem is giving this role of father
only to Abraham and Moshe was very
great. Mosha is the greatest person who
ever lived but he's not considered our
father. He is Rabenu. He's our teacher,
but he's not our father. And to be a
father, that means you are considered
the Jewish people. Now, listen to this.
Listen to this.
Abraham come. What does Hashem tell
Abraham? Leave. Leave. Can leave or
leave. Come to Israel. He comes there.
He unpacks his baggage. He goes to the
mat. There's no food. No food. He goes
to, you know, to to tower.
no food. He goes to Aaron's no food
there. What happened? There's a famine
as soon he packs his bags and he goes to
goes to Mitsim. There's no food in
Israel. So, Hashem tells him basically
uproot your whole life, right? Leave
your family. Don't say anything to your
friends. You have nothing to do with
your family, nothing to do with your
friends, nothing to do with your
homeland. You come to Israel. He comes
there. He can't live there. So, he goes
to Mitsim. Rashi says it was a test to
see here. Hashem tells him to come to
Israel and and now it's uninhabitable.
Is he going to start questioning Hashem?
So according to Rashi
weapon,
>> according to Rashi, he was supposed to
leave Israel, but the test was that he
shouldn't question Hashem. The Raan says
no, he should not have left Israel. He
should have stayed there. What do you
mean? There's nothing to eat. Doesn't
matter. He should have had and Hashem.
Hashem will provide for him. Look in the
Ramban in number seven. Ramadan says
his leaving the land
that he was commanded to go to because
of the hunger.
It was a sin. Abraham sinned according
to the Ramb by leaving.
God will God will come up with a way to
say to feed him. Let me ask you a
question. If you live in Israel, are you
allowed to leave?
>> Nope.
>> Not allowed to leave.
>> Only in the old city. You're not allowed
to leave.
>> You're not allowed to leave. If you live
in Israel, you're not leave. But but
there are various hat, right? There are
a lot of hat. What are they?
>> Businessa
to learn Torahim.
All kinds of, right? What about if
there's a famine, you're allowed to
leave? Yeah. The Rambam says if there's
a famine, you're allowed to leave
Israel. So how could the Raan say that
Abraham sinned by leaving Israel? You're
allowed to leave if there's a famine.
What's the sin?
Let me ask you a question. If there's a
famine in Israel, an individual is
allowed to leave. Could the Jewish
people in mass say, "Look, there's a
famine. We're packing out. We're uh
we're deserting the land." Jewish people
can't do that. Individual could do that.
Clau can't do that. Abraham was not an
individual. Abraham was Abraham was
accorded the status of the Jewish
people. for him to leave Israel. It was
like the Jewish people in mass forsaking
the land. Therefore, it was a sin for
him to leave the land because he's not
an individual. He is kali. So, he's
accorded the status of the Jewish
people.
>> Repeat that.
>> I'll tell you after
one more thing. Two more things.
Abraham comes to Mitim and he looks at
these guys. They were what Rashi says.
They were black.
>> Thank you.
>> Rashi says they were sworthy. They were
ugly. They never they don't they don't
know what it means to be beautiful. And
if they would lay their eyes on Sara,
you know, it wouldn't be good. It
wouldn't be good. So Abraham says,
"Look, if they think we're married,
they're going to kill me and and take
you. So do me a favor. Tell them you're
my sister. This way, you know, they'll
do with you whatever. You know, there'll
be nothing holding them back, but at
least I'll live."
>> Why don't you run away? At least I'll
live.
>> Why don't you agree to go there?
Understand?
>> It's a very dangerous.
>> Okay. So, Abraham says, "Just tell them
you're my sister. They'll live with you.
Okay, they'll violate you, but at least
I'll live."
>> Now, one second.
>> Abraham's life was on the line. Are you
allowed to sin to save your life?
>> No.
>> Absolutely. If somebody comes to you and
says, "You see this piece of pig over
here? Eat it. Otherwise, I'll shoot you
in the head. What do you do?
>> You eat the pig.
>> Come back.
>> You eat it.
>> Take the pig and throw it in the face.
>> Relax. You eat it.
>> Yeah.
>> Right. You're allowed to do an a to save
your life. What if somebody says either
go commit adultery
or I'll kill you. What do you do?
>> You die.
>> You die. What if somebody says, so that
means basically you're not allowed to
commit adultery to save your life. What
about to save someone else's life? Well,
if you can't do it to save your own
life, you certainly can't do it to save
someone else's life.
So, how is Sorah allowed to just go tell
the we're not related. Do with me
whatever you want. She's basically
committing adultery to save Abraham's
life. How is he she allowed to do that?
So, there's a similar issue was
presented to the Huda who's land one of
the greatest authorities of all time
1713 to 1793. Okay. He's direct
descendant of Rashi and he was presented
with the following question. Listen to
this. Question was a group of robbers
came to the city with the intention of
killing everyone and violating the women
and there was one woman there beautiful
woman and she says you know what let me
try to seduce the head bandit. I'll you
know smooth talk him and I'll distract
him. I'll live with him and the rest of
the people will escape. Is she allowed
to intentionally commit adultery to save
the rest of the city? So the NHuda says
this question was posed to one py and
they said yes. Yes. And the proof is
what do you think Esther did?
>> Esther goes to willingly she lives with
him for the sake of saving. So we see
you're allowed to commit adultery to
save
>> Jews. So in this case also she should be
allowed to seduce this guy to save the
city. says,
"This pisc is making a big mistake
because Esther, you know why she was
allowed to do it? Because she was saving
the entire Jewish people. She was saving
Clai
all the Jews.
>> One second.
>> But to save the city, there are only 100
inhabitants in the city. There only 100
inhabitants. Just to save a 100 people,
you can't commit adultery to save 100
people. When are you allowed to do it?"
To save Cli Israel, Esther was allowed
to do it.
Why was Sarah allowed to save Abraham by
saying she's my he's my sister? Because
Abraham is not an individual.
>> Wait a second. Wait,
>> this is like you know
>> all the Jews back then lived in in in
Iran.
>> No, they lived everywhere but they were
all under there they were under the says
there are four kings Shamalipa that
ruled over the whole world had dominion
over every inch of the world. Gomorrah
says, "And therefore her intention was
to save every Jew. To save all of Clown
Israel, you're allowed even to commit
adultery to save the Jewish people. To
save a few individuals, you're not
allowed to." So I heard from Rabbi Isaac
Bernstein,
>> who is was a great rabbi in London,
passed away a number of years ago.
>> Streamed
>> that I don't know that. Why was Sara
allowed to commit this offer herself in
adultery to save Abraham? Because
Abraham's not an individual. Abraham's
not one person. Abraham is clal Israel.
The same way Esther was allowed to offer
herself to save the Jewish people. Sora
could offer herself. What do you mean?
Abraham is just one guy. No, we say Ara.
How can we say Ara? I thought Abraham's
only one person. No, he's not one
person. He is the Jewish people. He has
the status of the Jewish people.
>> Okay. Now, let's just end off with this.
Why did the Torah not tell you anything
good about Abraham? Right? What do we
say? So that you shouldn't think Hashem
chose us for a specific reason. Hashem's
love for us is unconditional.
Says the Raala the exact opposite
reason, but it fits. I'll tell you after
who is he?
>> What is it? What's the mean?
>> It's a he mean in English.
>> The reward for the bride.
>> Okay.
>> He says like this.
>> Sorry, we don't have time to read
everything inside, but he says like
this. more time.
>> You know why the Torah doesn't tell you
that Abraham was thrown into the fire?
Cuz you might make a mistake and say,
"Here, Hashem comes to Abraham." He
says, "Leave your homeland." What does
Abraham do? Books the next flight. He's
off. Abraham says, Hashem says, "You
know, you waited 100 years to have a
son. Go kill him." What does he do? He
wakes up early in the morning for the
vas and he goes to do it. Everything
Hashem says, damn, he does it right
away. Well, why does Abraham love Hashem
so much? Oh, I know why he doesn't
really love Hashem, but he owes him big
time because when he got thrown into the
fire, Hashem came to pull him out of the
fire. So, we might say Abraham's not
such a good guy. He's indebted to
Hashem. Hashem saved him from the fire.
You may think Abraham's love for Hashem
is dependent on something and it's not
altruistic. It's not pure. No. The Torah
says, you know why Hashem Abraham is
listening to Hashem? Nothing to do with
the fact that he saved him from the
fire. It's pure. It's not dependent on
anything. You know why Abraham loves
Hashem? Because he recognizes that God
created the world. It's not dependent on
the fact that Hashem saved him. So it
works both ways. Abraham's love for
Hashem, it's unconditional. It's not
because Hashem saved him. It's because
he recognizes Hashem's greatness. And
the other way also, Hashem's choice of
Kalisol is not dependent on our
righteousness. It's also for our
inherent value. So the love between
Hashem and it's
not dependent on anything. Abraham loves
Hashem
purely because he's the creator of the
universe. Not because Hashem helps him
out. And Hashem loves Abraham not
because of Abraham's righteousness, not
because of the Jewish people's
righteousness, but because of some
inherent quality. And we're going to
explain what is that inherent quality.
The inherent quality is our nishama is a
divine piece of Hashem. It is so pure.
There is nothing closer to Hashem than a
Jewish nama. And that connection between
a of Hashem, which is an Hashem himself,
it's a relationship that it's not
dependent on anything. Why is metal and
a magnet? It's attracted to each other
because it's from the same properties.
Hashem and it's made out of the same
material. It's not dependent on
anything. It's naturally connected. And
therefore, what do we learn from this
week's param?
We don't know anything about Abra
because Hashem doesn't choose him for a
reason. Hashem chooses him for no
reason. And Abraham doesn't choose
Hashem for a reason. Abraham recognizes
also Hashem's inherent value.
You've just experienced [music] another
Torah class brought to you by tora
anytime.com.