Preparing video...
0:00 / 0:00

היסוד של ר׳ חיים בענין לחמו של מזבח

0 views
Lakewood Daf Yomi avatar
Lakewood Daf Yomi

Transcript

Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.

Going back to the first part of today's doct and that is said and was like didn't understand what that even means and the gar tweaked it from the fact that the of a of a pigle has the ability to be it has the ability to be must be it's a and if it's a pig was a little bit in terms of what is and even what is and what came out was talking about when the was but where is and the is that although ordinarily anytime you have pickle that goes on the but once it's already then the is not only is it but at this point it's going to be as well as didn't say this already once said once it's already at that point is it's going to be already said yeah did already say it once that's 100% true but at the same time there's as it relates to the because you could have thought that all the different components of the are viewed as individual inim and being that they're viewed as individual so you could have thought that maybe you only have them that actually touched them as that went into the fire but as it relates to the that touch. So maybe over there it's going to be different. And that's the that wanted you to know that this is true even as it relates to this is true even as it relates to the infer and this is in has a very intense on this of just to be knocked and that is said that there's another suggestion of and that's inus the over there says this is a well-known Mishna even though it's a real but it comes up a lot it's possible for a person to eat one yet you're gonna be four and one so you ate one and from that one that the person ate He's going to end up having to bring four and even going to have to bring an what's the mitas is somebody was and he ate and it was also which means it was hish and on top of that you ate it on. So again there was a person that was he ate the of a that was noer on this person has to bring a times four he has to bring an asham as well. What's the bringing four? Number one, he ate. You eat at says no. He ate onion. If you eat and he was tummy that if you eat you're going to be why does he have to bring asham because he was act. And because he was actual it sounds like the is trying to come up with this case. Why couldn't the T of the come up with you would be what would be the case the let's make anle it's talking about where the person ate a kaz of pigle meaning let's be it was also pickle and if it was also piggle if you eat pigle and if that's the case I have five so the says it doesn't work like mish is talking about where the person ate from and if it's one you can't have one that's going to be no pickle either it's nice or it's pickle but it can't be both why not maybe the case is talking about where the carbon was pickle and then you took a of the carbon pickle and you alab When you were the pickle went away that if you take you put on the now once the pickle goes away. So now if you leave it around too long now it's TO BECOME NICER ONCE the the so when the says it doesn't mean only that it's from the same but it means also it's the same and it's impossible to have one a that's going to be piggle and one a that's going to be nicer and it's for that reason you had to mention one of the two the picked nicer could have picked pigle I guess but I picked nicer but the bottom line is that and it's for that reason it's impossible to have one a that would be nicer pickle that of is true not only with regards to the den of our and that is but it's also true with regards to the that is of pigle goes away for a said anyways has no you see even from that of the that would remove the it didn't work in's of because that anyways has no and if that's the case must be coming to tell me something else but the bottom line is you sort already in the that and that is that is true also with regards to removing the in other words there's two applications in shas where you find this den of pakabulo one place where you find the concept of paigula is with regards to emier yalu another place that you find pakabulu is with regards removing the issul any soul that's quote unquote whatever that means the says there is there's certain any if it goes on and says this is the we really need the next says what would be if this apostle didn't just go on but rather it went into the fire was even if it went down. You can put it back up and you can go with the what's the even though it's true when it comes to that really but there's an idea of now is going to This is if you take you put it on the once the fire of the consumes the majority of the pigle and at that point the is going to go away. What's the mccart to that? It's it's the same idea that once it's at that point it's it's and we even said that it's not only true for it's true for as well and that's that the idea is that if you take and you put it on and it's at that point it's going to be in other words as it relates of which is as it relates to the iserus being removed the if you look at the ra the ra seems to contradict himself very subtle but very profound why because when the rama brings the ra's is as long as it was at that point in the brings the it's one it's happens once it's sounds like that in the of that was yet in the of T is that has to be at first glance it's just two applications of the same if the is then the should have been consistent and if it means okay so then should have said it in both cases seems to suggest as long as it's and as it relates to the idea of the is going away it sounds like it has to Emma says that brings it to already and he says says if this which is mentioned right here in is mentioned a little more on if you look at that. So over there says the same exact and that is that if you have a so is that it's and it's over there that the reason it's is because that says what's this idea of just to explain this a little bit better. There's an idea that you find in kachen where you take something that really has no mock to go into and it's the makes it and now that it becomes so now is it's allowed to stay on the so what's the he said I can hear two one said is that means that any soul any issue that this carbon head once it's and it becomes that goes away meaning that whatever was there is gone and as a result now there's a that you're allowed to keep it on the mean that's the punchline of says doesn't mean that whatever issue is there goes away but rather means you have all the issues you have all the PROBLEMS OF NOW AND ONCE you at this point now there's a new with all your problems with all your issues with all your baggage there's a that's called have two rias to the second the first is a whether if somebody would take of a carbon and you would put it on the fire of the whether there would be Now because of says in the regular that you have with a carbon there's no place to ever be m there's no place to ever be m there at a carbon right yet if that is touched the fire now all of a sudden there's a together of it's a new also if it's a new terra So you'll tell me that this includes in it even the regular doesn't but this maybe would but if you're going to tell me the whole gather of is that it removes any problems all it does is it reinstates its kosher status the way the carbon was well never had a never had a how's all of a sudden giving it a m because it's that the is true for now what's means where the didn't do a a proper first the wasbach on and then you put it into the so is that the carbon's pos so that's really another right but without getting involved in that Let's push it that nishbach includes in it that it's missing a you can't do a you can't do a with d that was has to have a proper in order for you to be able to go ahead now and do so even on aim that never had a so if the is that it removes the soul that's here so that's very good if you have ber that's ple and now you want to put it on the SOB right the is a it has an ability to make it go away now that it makes it go away so now you'll be able to HAVE A BUT WE HEAR THE PROBLEM IS I'M don't have to the it's from here it's from here said that what it's that together that together of is that you don't meet the criteria for what you would need in order to be able to proper but at the same time this is a new yeah you need you have to be cauter you have to be aim you can't be out but we're not a whole you have to it's a paradigm shift so A WHOLE NEW THIS MUDASHES THIS OCTASHES DOESN'T FUN this octash can be doubleclud. But the point is from the fact that you seem as it relates to and you find the concept of as it relates to as it relates to even a carbon that's pulled that's missing as such as where it's from there that the of iso of is that it's this new well if that's the case if that's the case I don't Understand said that right the is it goes on the fire of the way the explained the now all of a sudden the pigle goes away why did need that it's part you'd say needed so there should be a dim now of dua Because if it's how you putting IT BACK ON THE SAID that's a throughout and that's the is that it's where do you see that it's said from the fact that it includes from the fact that includes an that means there's a new parish of that happens when when it's as soon as it's it's now there's a new so it's so what do I need. Why did say I don't need a could be piggle all day EVERY DAY. IT'S NOT AND WHAT IT'S not at that point. It's going to have a NO where you find the also shouldn't. So why do I need just say a little over there? It's says that Because if it's pickle, it could be a pickle. It's like eating. So you have to come on to needs because that's once it's you find throughout there's an idea of and that works with the baggage with all the so if it for that for there's no reason it should be able to for SOMETHING THAT'S PLE WITHOUT THE concept of and if that's the case why is of once it's predicated on it should not be that it was said a little bit of a hard vart to explain this and that is said that that's and the fact that once it's require Okay because the only time the only time it's that if something goes on the and it's the is that it's going to be considered is if it didn't touch the fire it has to go on the fire it has to go on the fire but if it went on the fire it touched the fire. Oops, I I burnt myself. Right? If that's what happened, that wouldn't make it. So said that once the becomes at that point there could be a on the even if it has its status of piggle where is getting into the weeds and where is to engul is because understood that the only way it could become in the first place is if it was And that already requires that already requires that on some level it should be a proper. So came to and said that if somebody would take a clement piggle and he would put it on the fire of the it would be but he said one second you're putting piggle in the fire and it's becoming no way. It's so and so from that there's no way in the world that that would be able TO that would say go ahead and be despite the fact that it's possible. It's for that reason that said that the is that when you put the it's and being that it's when it's considered when it's considered a considered and it's a therefore now it's a regular now ready you're going to be shy going to be subject to this new said how do I know right how do I know that if the is said I'll prove it to you because you need that in order to CREATE THE PICKLE SO it's a it's a it's considered a that can create a and once it creates at that point you're going to be okay in other words the reason needs in the is there needs it if you don't have so you have nothing he's trying to say that when you take the you put on the now all of a sudden the pickle's going to go away the nice is going to go away the tum is going to go away you see that is if the pickle goes away so now all of a sudden you're going to be okay where needs the inim is not to say that there's a a dhak of he doesn't need it could be even with pigle you don't need here's the punch line you don't need to have au because the yalo is based on that is not governed by the and if you find it with regards and regarding there's no reason there shouldn't be truth as well we're Then does need inim the fact that it's he needs it for it to become once it's he needs it to become because the way it becomes is when it's and the has to be of and for that you would need that it should be because if it's in a state of pigle that would be a problematic that being that you find that that is for if you find that it's then it means it's a regulator if it's a regular so now this is going to be able to work for this as well says you can explain the very beautifully I'll read this paragraph inside that as it relates to all you need is but as it relates right when it happens a little bit or is when it happens most of it you know why at the end of the Because the fact that it's saying is not what's that as it relates to that's going to be enough. But as it relates to the for that you have to be the mean said that it's only when it's hold only happens when it's at least we just explained it directly that's only with regards to the so that it should be considered created a so that it should become but once it's each one gets its own at the end of the day the end of the day the whole reason why said is not because he needs the pickle to go away he doesn't need the pickle to go away. He just needs that the pickle would go away. And being that the pickle would go away, that's just a sim, right? It's not a it's a sim. It's a sim that it's a regular it's a regular. If it's considered a even a little bit again's point is there's no direct link between and the only reason is connecting them is at the end of the day they're tied by the hip speaks this out clearly earlier in the it's just because at the end of the day if we view this as then it's going to be and if you view this as a well then it's going to be a that makes it a so then now you can go ahead and have a but you don't need the in order to have the all you need is the which would also make it au is that there's a so at the end of the day for that you need to have a what's The definition of a that's always what it is. The is what do you mean you're handling over here? How's this a No, this that's we know for sure that when you put on the it is so it's considered it's considered then it's also going to be able to become as it relates to you need the of the need of the realm of host the only time it's ever going to be is if you're going to remove it 100% And that's why so again at the end of the day what saying is is that in as much as said is you don't need the in order to have the when increases your says that regarding the bus and regarding the yeah there you need the you have to remove the in order for not you don't need the reason this why don't you need it because once it's and it works with all the baggage with all the you're going to have a why then does say is saying because needs needs the s of why it's because IT'S MORATZA. THAT PART OF THE equation needs for this as well. Needs the fact that this is the fact that it's beget that's the of but he doesn't need the doesn't need the punch line. He needs what got him to is the fact that it's and that he needs for this. But at the end of the day in All he needs is that it was for that any little is going to be enough. He needs that the pickle should be removed. In order for the pickle to be removed, you have to remove you just have to touch the fire. You need the whole thing to be removed. What's the say no inim talking about the definition of in the definition of didn't seem to say that they're yeah it seemed to say that said it's really not they're not it's in the sense that they're bound by the hip and that's why when makes you end up with two if putting the on is is a is a well then it's a which is going to be and it's also going to remove the it's two things that are going to happen but at the end of the day it's going to become when it's only that's and it's going to remove the piggle when it's that's already the one thing that comes out of this says is that just notice it became before was Because what emerges just from the album that's Clark that once it was you tell me it's not but it's not until it's already that never bothered me forget that's what we want that doesn't bother me because the whole of that could be all day that was never an issue why it sounded like you needed in order to be in order to shaft this But the fact that what comes out is is that it's already that's beautiful. That's part of why this is so because that's why it SHOULD BE CUZ THAT'S WHAT'S from that you can become even even when you're in a state of it being pulled either way. This is just to bring out one point again we're stopping here but just to bring out one point you know the ninth paric is that's the where the are discussed right something that underpins the entirety of of if you look at the first right the per begins what does it They say over from that learned this. What's Rashley saying? Rashi is saying that the isle so that later it should be able to become or the way the said it it has a to now make it. In other words, was gave us a gift and love this and that is the idea of is when you think of the of so you think of to go ahead and be of a carbon was that there's two DNA and a carbon there's the of carbon and then there's the of a carbon that is nondiscriminatory right it could be even a nishbach right it could be a pigle it could be It doesn't the regular of what's the gather of that? It's what's referred to in as how does it happen once it's once at that point it becomes so the said right in the beginning of what does it mean if you take it you put it on you go on the fire it's not you just touch the it gives it a kad what's the get what's the of that it gets a to be which Usually is it happened already means it gives it a now TO HAVE A NEW WHAT'S THE IT'S not because it's first going to become when it's but it has a this is 101 as relates it flows from this now again this is the that we walk away from the what's the but the of the is that's the you want the that's the is that is not that removes all the issues together is it has you have issues but I'm coming anyways right it's still a d to put me on the misb with all my imperfections. I still have a becoming now. If that's the case, why didn't you? The bottom line is the is that there's a new lman and brisk called and with that from that even the whole of it gives it a kadusha so that now you actually have a usually you don't have once now all of a sudden it gets that den