בענין החידוש הידוע של הגרי״ז במחשבת שלא לשמה בקדשים (א)

I think we're ready to attempt to go through together what is without a question the most in the beginning of it's not the from it's also probably the most that is the as it relates to the sug of so we're going to do this raid bite in two parts part one will be tonight where we'll go through and part two will be tomorrow where we'll go through some of the raid as it relates to the way the brisker went and upon this but as it relates to Tonight we're just starting with the basics. We're just going to go through different as it relates to how you know that there's an idea that if one of the were brought with it would impact the carbon right up until this point what do we know we know that the is the par of the carbon there's many references in the parish of the carbon that teach me the of and from There I learned okay I know by how do I know it? So for that I have the said just like there's a concept of the same is going to be true as it relates to as well. One second. If there's then if you have shouldn't the carbon be possible? It's a good but said it says even if you have a you still meaning it's still what is it not? It's not. So if you need to bring a carbon you can't satisfy your obligation with this carbon. But in terms of it being kasher, you could do it could be we treat it like an adva and this would be kasher as well. Another thing we saw this was the last that we just learned here on we know why we know why it's based on the but you have two additional you have a whole second set of it's coming to teach me that it's even what does it mean it's even it's going to be possible so that's coming up tomorrow's asks says we know this says in the name of you know how you know that a carbon has to be brought Because it says in the from the word I know that it has to be brought in that if you bring a lashim it's not going to be okay. The Tyra says the word is and from the word is I learn. The Tyra says and from the word I learn that it's has to be the says and I learn from there that a carbon has to be brought. And finally the says and I learned from says the name of I know I know it from one in the in the parish of now this is ine which by the way is five of the six. But either way, what's going on over here? This seems to be another to the concept of zeb another to the concept of the two sugis in that talk about don't seem to be talking to each other. Hey, right. It's still going. We're in the middle of it. The garam says that what is the to the idea of when it comes to it's learned from the p of here I have a where the learns from that you see from here that there's a that has to be brought is the parish of or is the right here the parish of the so has a very big says that when the mishna said even though it means And if it means as well, it also means it also means a also has to be done. Being that it also means the Gmorra here understood that it couldn't rely on the we had because those areas only for the there was no mention up until this point for there to be a that even has to be. Therefore, the Gmorra felt that it needed a new aar to teach me that this is not only going to be true for but it's going to be true for as well. So the GRA says you want to know what the is. tell you what the is the and in this which is a that's talking about I learn that just like this that has to be so too has to be as well but the reason we need this new here is because also means in fact I don't have a from I don't have a mar from the parish of and it's for that reason I have to come on to a new and that's why I need this right here if you take a look at Rashi on it's clear that Rashi did not learn this the way on learns it's clear that Rashi learned that this is a that the need to be brought And if that's the case, it sounds like the way Rashi's learning is a that the have to be brought and if that's the case that why do I need this here on the days from the parish of what happened to the of the all All the differently and the we're in the middle of learning right now seem to be two independent there's no on there's no why do I need these two makas so the biscarov said as fouls if you take a look at the insal the rama brings the ofish says when brought the carbon when he did the so he had to think six things says the in the event that the coin did theam He didn't have in mind any of these but he also didn't have in mind it's going to be like we explained earlier. So the rama brings and the says that even though but let's say you didn't have the let's say you didn't it's going to be and the both they sounds like in the that as it relates to it's going to be but what would be if the would have well then it sounds like would be that would it actually be possible what's going on over here if there's anything that we've spoken at already so many times here in the beginning of the it's that even though but all the talk about that if it's one of the first two of the six If it's but as it relates to the other for that's only there's no if that's the case which would seem to suggest that if it would be would be it's not true regarding the it's true regarding it's true regarding but it's not true with regards to the other four things. And said is true regarding all which clearly suggests that if the all were done with it would be possible and everybody knows this is the beginning of 101 that as it relates to the other there's no such thing as a yeah it's a it's an extra credit type of yeah it's something that you're supposed to do but in terms of it passing the carbon it's not going to pass It's not going to make all that is which would seem to suggest that if it was done it would be possible that's true it's not true for all sixes because it is says that I think I think that when the rab said he didn't mean because for the you don't need to save him because it's only HE MEANT IT FOR THE FIRST TWO HE meant it we're applicable he meant it but said it's not so to say that you know why because earlier already said it we just says the so the ram one earlier singled out and kaidesh which of course is unique. The Rama mentioned that is that stomach is going to be cautioned. NOW THE REALM'S COMING. HE'S TALKING ABOUT THE NOW I'M GOING TO TELL YOU SOMETHING YOU DIDN'T KNOW. But you also have to know and delineates what are and then he says you should know regarding THE when he said that line HE MEANT LIKE I TOLD YOU EARLIER I JUST TOLD IT TO YOU ONE SECOND AGO. WHY DO YOU HAVE TO TELL IT TO ME NOW AGAIN? It's very not that way in the didn't want to learn this way in the he is mooching very very stark very very stark sounds like from that it's not only when there's a concept of that can make it so you have to know that's true he's the other it sounds like when the I'm saying he means it regarding the other. So really the way the piece starts I'm reading it a little bit out of order but the way the piece starts is with two graceashes. The first is and the second is that there seem to be two that give independent for the concept of we learn from the carbon it's learned out from the carbon the cash on the raam is When he brings, he adds the line which would seem to suggest that which would seem to suggest that if it was done with you had it would be a problem. The whole of only is an idea of that's only true regarding that require societ when it comes to The by carbonus the first is that the of a carbon has to be brought and this is true like a lot of things that require right has to be brought has to be done there's an idea of that you find throughout the and one of those places is a carbon a carbon has to be brought that is a is something that can disqualify a carbon and this is a this is something that's unique and exclusive. This is something that you only find by so what did the brisk mean? So let's take a step backwards. We know that is that when it comes to it was a whole and he came up with a what was the and it's for that reason as opposed to obligation and it's for that reason is not but is stomach is lishma when it comes to kach if you ask the man on the street why is it that is kasha by kach or better what does it mean what's together that is kasha I think he would say this I think he would say that the of essentially states that even though there's a dimm when it comes to kach the dimish does not mean that you have to have a positive of all it means is don't mess it up right that's all it means what it means is that don't have a but if you're going to have a of meaning you're just going to not think or you're going to space out that in and of itself would satisfy what it is you need for the of other words when there's a lushma does mean you actually have to think or does it mean you don't have TO THINK FOR WHEN WE say when it comes to essentially what we're saying is is that if you have NO just don't MESS IT UP. JUST DON'T think now if you're going to think well okay now you don't have you don't even have what you have is if it's well now you're missing but as long as you didn't have a even though I don't have all I had was but is enough right that is the way you would understand when a person brings a carbon stomach. He didn't think but it's fine because he also didn't think and the of that's learned out from is teaching me that you just can't have a but as long as it's that in it of itself would be fine. Now ask the man on the street a follow-up question. What happens when you have a right what happens now? Oh you have it's possible. Why is it possible? because I don't know that's that's the it's not it's right this is so obvious like what are we even saying right it's so this is what of is there's a could have meant you have to have a no isma what does that mean it means that is basically saying that just don't mess it up is not it's just a saying don't have if it's Even though you didn't think that's fine cuz you don't need to think. don't need a positive of the doesn't have to be the it just has to not be and as long as it's then it was not when it's a problem because now it's not now it's not now it's and it's for that reason now it's going to be an issue as intuitive as it feels like this is how stumbalishma works said Marag is that's not said in the stomach is not that even though it's not because it's only stomach and stomach is not lishma it's good because you don't need lishma all you need is stomach and as long as it's stomach that in of itself is going to be okay the way stomach works is is that when a person a ken doesn't avoid the stomach it's that the was done. And the reason is because being that the carbon is to be brought what that means is that that's done is automatically considered to have been done as if to say the is an automatic built-in thing based on the of and the reason is is not because I don't need all I need is it's because when I bring THE CARBON STOMACH. I HAVE LISHMA. What do you mean I never thought? Here's the news flash. You don't have to think in order for it to be BECAUSE THE COMES AUTOMATIC. IT'S A BUILT-IN THING. BEING that means that the automatically is considered to have been done. And even though you never thought, it's built in. It's ma. It's automatic that it is. And it's for that reason sto going to be kishma. But the biscarov took it a step further. And the said that this is so true that even in the event that now the would have a it's not the now you had the it's going to be puzzle because now I don't have what do you mean I I didn't think I didn't even think now I had and if I had oh it's going to be that's not the works because being that is a carbon it's an automatic thing that when you do the it's considered that you did a that automatic thing is true even if you had a and there's no in the world that has the ability to be that because it's something that's built in it's something that's automatic so even if you're going to go now and you're going to have a it's not going to be the now you don't have the because you don't have the lishma it's going to be POSSIBLE BECAUSE YOU HAVE THE LISHMA. WHERE DO I have the lishma? I have the lishma because of the stomach. I know but it wasn't stomach. But I don't need to even be a to have the is an automatic built-in thing to the system that being that it's considered. So why then if I have is it going to be possible? Why is it possible? I have a because of so I satisfied all the obligations that I have. I need that to be you're telling me that so that even if I have no ability to be that okay so then why when I have it going to be possible the reason is going to be possible is because when you have a it's the itself that because one of the that you find in is there's a concept that ava just having a bad thought a hearer that has the ability to pass what's the mur to mashling piggle So there's an idea of a passing and there's so many different that permeate the is of is just an example. It's a dogma of and at the end of the day the reason it's going to be a problem is simply because of the in other words the is being was saying that the reason when a person has is the carbon is possible is not because we say that when you have the now the carbon is lacking in the and because the carbon is lacking in the me of the carbon is going to be possible. The reason when you have a is that the carbon is because there's a and if you do you bring a carbon with that is that the carbon now is going to be it's not that you're lacking in the you have the how could I have the if I had it's because I said but I wasn't I had it's because the of is it's an automatic thing it's a built-in thing to the system otherwise is what is the that it's an automatic thing and it's so automatic that even if I have you can't be so why then if I have is it possible it's not because of what I'm lacking it's because of this terrible thing that I added on to it's because of the fact that I just had this the brings two big ri out of the gate we're just going to mention one the other one's that's beyond on the scope but said I'll prove it to you because we know that says what did say is going to be possible is going to be and what's the reason that it's because the I don't understand how it's possible that if you bring a is that it should be a carbon has to be right it has to Now if it's also fine but is nothing it's not and it's also not cuz I had a so what are you going to tell me right that very hard we learn from that it's all fine of at the end of the day where's my I didn't have AND BECAUSE AT the end of the day I thought I didn't think stumble said what do you see from here you see THAT IS AN AUTOMATIC THING YOU CAN'T BUDGE the is something called and that's why is considered but is not going to be considered but either way this is the just to read a few more excerpts inside Okay. I'm skipping a little bit. says the biscuit rack. The carbon In other words, this second in is something that's unique to this is not something that you're going to find anywhere else. One of the things that the prerov said is so I'll this is it's so clear is that in this is in the beginning of giml says as follows there are three read the first And then the gives you the whole over here and of said that that you would think that there's a between and between over there. The reason the carbon is possible when you have that is because you had a bad it's the improper thought that you had while you were bringing the carbon at first glance is not a problem because of the improper thought that you had while you were bringing the carbon. If you learn then why is a problem because you're missing in the is not the what's the IS THE FACT THAT THE CARBON doesn't have the it's the reason it's the it's the intermediary it's the why is it that I'm missing because I had IT'S A no is not the isel I don't have and as a result I have a problem. The reason I don't have is because I had a bad thought. But at the end of the day, the reason the carbon is ple not the reason the carbon is ple because I'm missing. No way. IS NOT A POSSIBLE because I don't have I stumble BUT IT'S NOT EVEN BECAUSE I thought I had the wrong and as a result it's not even it's the fact that the calls it means what's the is the that's the problem over HERE THE IS THE IT'S NOT WHAT COMES ABOUT as a result of the THE OF THE IS Why is the is because and like the said is even that doesn't have ability to be accurate. Why then is a poss. So we're going to see is that a is not allowed to have a bad and actually says not means that you can't have a bad it's not what I did it's not what I HAVE IT'S WHAT I DON'T HAVE IT'S WHAT I'M LACKING said that's not the way works the is that it's no different It's the same exact thing. You should have a a stumblish would tell you that as it relates to the regular of that should be satisfied. Have here this is what messes it up. Just want to go one speaks out this paragraph and that is said that is like this. He said that between whether or not the is that because of the now you're lacking the it's not even for so that reason there's a problem or is that it's why it's going to be problem I'll tell you you know what would be he said what would be if a went and a did the did the did the and he did the with Could you go now and do another assuming there's to be received and this time get it right? If the iselt in the So there's no in this carbon right now. There's no that's hovering on this carbon. You just didn't do a cabala the way you're supposed to do a cabala. Okay. So the cabala was lacking one of the prerequisites. No problem. There's more blood out like just go quickly. And now this time get it right. Try not to make the same mistake a second time. If however is a like well then already if someone would do a whole carbon is pos and now you can't even go ahead and do another so in these two ways to understand would be in the event that you did a there's more time to be had could I be in that with a proper kabala or could I not be makin with a proper kabala The emmesis the emmesis I hold that the we're saying here in how works and even this is something that's boil it's right by right held that it's by it's and I had a whole trying to figure out How do you know ST is kosher? How do you know ST is possible? Right? So RA has to go ahead and he has to prove that it's that it's really said the brisk said the brisk. I don't know how at first glance the could had it sad that stom is possible. Right? The is not there's no s in the world. You know why? So I'll prove it to you. Number one the isle right but ultimately said that it's learned from a right remember the it's from a what's the and we learn from there that is right so the is coming to teach me the is coming to teach me that is a problem if it's but is not a problem if it's going to be the brisk if is pos then why do I need a to tell me that is pos it's anyways because it's anyway rubb it's pel prove it from here prove it from there I have the best proof in the stomach because if then what's the over here of I'll tell you more we had a said in the that it depends that's going to be possible how does he know it we're going to learn the it's learned out from what are those all about if possible then then what lash is ple it's it's it's It's it's can't be better than the so of the biggest is the biggest yet didn't say that it's I'll tell you more learned out from a it's learned out from a what's THAT TELLING IS POSSIBLE. WHAT DOES IT STAND LIKE? All these we in the that are teaching me the of that should be the biggest in the world that what that is going to be yet that should be possible you have to say that even if was possible it wouldn't be the same as that's possible that's possible says is you went ahead and you did the now that you did the you're lacking in the that is maybe a problem it's going to be possible but even if you hold that it's still neg because of is a bigger than the stole as if it's POSSIBLE that's what it would mean as opposed to that's a that's a new that this in what's there has to be and I'll tell you what the is like the we said but this is the said would be could you go ahead and could you be in it let's say the would do the and he would do right he would do a pistol could you go now this time with a regular O of stomach assuming stomach was ple it would be fine because all I did was I did a not in the proper way go ahead and be mak in it if however I did it with a now the carbon is possible but the bottom line said you see clearly that there's a and is not just that it's lacking in the it's a and you see that that soul gives me demon that you wouldn't have simply based on the fact that you're lacking and even on side of the stole it's still neg but the bottom line is the bottom line this is the big side of the risk so now let's just wrap up if that's the case it comes out we have the brought and after the brought the says And everyone's mama says I don't understand what's behind this the says regarding regarding there's no such concept of even except there's no concept means the whole is only so of being why is that relevant why is that even important said that this whole thing is Just like there's a when it comes to when it comes to the other for as well and says what should be the difference why should be that the here but it's not OVER THERE AND THE IS 100 IT'S not a mitzvah it's But here's the good news is being that IT'S SOMETHING THAT YOU HAVE AUTOMATIC. SO YOU have the so says the I want you to know and he lays out the six things. But he says you want to know that just means that at the end of the day this is the way it's supposed to be. So you don't have to worry about the stating that there's two places you do have to worry about the WHY THERE'S SOMETHING CALLED THERE'S SOMETHING called known as sometimes referred to as there's also something called what is the types of that's very nuance it means that's a new That din creates even where everything else was fine. Even where the carbon was brought even though but that is going to pass the not because it makes it doesn't have the ability to make it because of that new but that's only true. It's not true regarding the other four things. It's for that reason as it relates to the other four things. You're never going to have to worry about it. What do you mean? What would be if somebody went ahead and he brought a Who cares? You can't be that's not something you have the ability to do. But once that automatically that's always going to be a moot point. YOU KNOW WHERE IT'S NOT A MOOD POINT. But not because when you have it's NOT IS HERE TO STAY. You can't throw him out. That's the way it is. That's because of a new D. That new is true for that new is not true for the other four things. That's what's going on over here. That's why you have this distinction this dichotomy between all six and that's why you have to come on to because if there was no one didn't stumble you'd have a real problem over here. I is a new it's completely different. It's no is to the once we have stumbled you're good to go. What is that other? That other that other is where if you have a backwards something called that is a very nuanced it's only true by two of the six things that's those two things but the bottom line is is that's why it has no to the to the if it's so clear in that there's two when it comes to there's the where you have and then there's where there's a concept said it's why he says what's the brought you know what the answer is it's not it's not it's this is the to the of this is the and from there we see however so therefore it really has no implication get it right but at the same time it's not going to have a real implication because at the end of the day there's a right whatever the is and as a result this is good to go what's the isling The is a whole different idiot. That's true. That's true. You know why it's only true by those things? That's one of the only things we had for and it's for that reason. It's only true by those things. But it's two completely different the days for the requires that's to be that's right. There's different ins that's true by too. And you know the mcc to that 46b that is the mik to that just so happens and because at the end of the day you do have it you don't have it you have it you have it backwards upside down it doesn't matter at the end of the day is automatically going to be the way it's going to be there's a that's unique to that you don't find anywhere no if a cipher writes a with a certain the IS LIKE A BOMB and it whacks out the whole there's no such mits in the whole world that's true by kach when you a parachute are and one of them is because there's such a just like there's a mus of a pigle and there's such a concept of that is unique to it's only by and even then it's only by that is the And how you understand how you understand this from the more so than all the was literally tomorrow we'll go into some of the details of exactly how it turned the world upside down but for now we're going to stop Yeah.