Preparing video...
0:00 / 0:00

בענין כל העושה על דעת ראשונה הוא עושה

0 views
Lakewood Daf Yomi avatar
Lakewood Daf Yomi

Transcript

Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.

I was discussing with my son Zalman today. So he was telling me over a brisker of that they say over in the shiyurin it's I couldn't find it in the swarm that we have, but in the shiyur they say over from Maran Agriz that the brisker of asked the murder of a kashan. Because Rish Lakish l'maisa is m'farish Ram Meir in the mishna maseches menachos that he holds kaloiso d'as rishaino oisa. Right, that's the shita of Rish Lakish. Rish Lakish holds kaloiso d'as rishaino oisa. Again, pigul b'kormes oiv l'vaina v'lo v'lo v'lo v'lo b'kainam. That's Ram Meir holds that it's pigul. And the chiyuv of an old kash chamtzei ain m'faglin, right? Ain b'kores asher l'maisa. So we know chamtzei ain m'faglin b'chatima holds Ram Meir holds. Sounds like he holds b'faglin b'chatima. But Rish Lakish was m'chadesh, no. D'lo oilam Rish Lakish holds that Ram Meir holds ain m'faglin b'chatima d'or vos. D'or vos. He's talking about where first you were m'faglin, right? First you brought the kormes l'vaina and then afterwards you weren't. And it's in that case that he holds kaloiso d'as rishaino oisa. Right, that's uh that's what Rish Lakish holds. In other words, shitas Ram Meir is kaloiso d'as rishaino oisa. Shitas chachamim b'chiyur is that you don't say kaloiso d'as rishaino oisa. So the brisker of asked that if you remember the Gemara that beizam and beiz. The Gemara was handling stum l'shma or stum is not l'shma. The Gemara The Gemara was trying to bring rayas here or not. The Gemara said have a raya. Because the mishna says that if somebody would bring a carbon l'shma and sh'lo l'shma. So the halacha would be posul. It sounds like if you would bring it l'shma in stum would be kosher. So choyuv a raya that stum is kash. The Gemara says no. Let them all tell you stum is posul. Let them all tell you stum is posul. I why then l'shma v'sh'lo l'shma is kosher? Because kaloiso d'as rishaino oisa. Break the brisker of. Break the brisker of kaloiso d'as rishaino oisa. It's machlokes Ram Meir and chachamim. It's machlokes Ram Meir and chachamim. And it's shitas Ram Meir. It's not the shitas of the chachamim. We posul like the say how could the Gamara say that in that mission is out that's the case that Gamara is going to be that mission is going to be it can't be that's that was the question that in our Gamara it's what do you say and the Gamara that throughout the also you want to know why some is culture by the small and some is because the color going to race lockish that sheet from mayor is not the sheet of the so the said the said that there's an after me now between the colors of the on the base and the colors of the on the on the from the base and that is how many people people becomes right you was by the first of the four but he wasn't by the latter three there's an idea of colors of the so the and his people stare a carbon people stares a carbon people stares a carbon because you had a a bad but let's call the my is what stares the carbon right for lack of a better word the my is but the my is what goes ahead and what stares the carbon you doing the and at the same time you doing the you multitasking you also having this very bad thought so it's the my that goes ahead and does it from mayor said a from mayor said that you had the my in the first part of the even if you didn't have it by the next part of the this is going to be a color of the as if to say is going to have the ability to carry and to transfer over this bad that you had the into the latter part of the I didn't do a my at this part of the I didn't do a my I did a my but the color OF THE TWO A MICE THAT I DIDN'T DO, A MICE over that I didn't have. But the same morning agrees on the base of it what's going on. On base of it what's happening is you you have a to do an avoid with a mice over some of the wants to say maybe is possible, right? You have a to do a mice over the small is possible. What about the small and small kind of the that it's kosher, right? It's that way. Isn't that a mice over some of the kosher? No. Well, let me tell you some is possible. Why is it kosher? Because the beginning was done with a mice over and I could say that that then that a avoid that has to be done with small is not the type I have to have a mice over mice over of the small while I'm doing the avoid. What do I need? I need that the mice over that I'm doing should be with small. Right? It's possible to say. I need a positive mice over with small in the wonders of it. That's not what I need. I just need that the period of the mice over that I'm doing right now should be that that it was done with small. See, it was like that. NEED SOME MICE OVER MICE OVER WITH SMALL. OH, WAIT. IT JUST YOU NEED THAT it was done with same decision, right? That's what you need. I just need that the avoid was done with small. The mice over is not a mice over there said more than agrees. It's just the type. It's the of how the mice over that I'm doing was done. So, there we could say that if the mice over the avoid was done with small, then that should be like that indeed everyone's going to agree. When it comes to people I need a mice over mice over so over there they could say that's what they but when it comes to this, when it comes to here, it's going to be different. So, the said a more than this is so involved. You take a look at this. Maybe this should have been a right back. Take a look at that and this is something so more than this. Let's let's read inside. That she is deeper than that. Right? So far good? And then Rashi adds one line. The whole Machshava of the Karchin Moitzi the Pail. Every Machshava in Karchin you have to be Moitzi the Pail. This Rashi is sister to Maran Agrees. It's Maran sister to him. Now, this is a very important Rashi. Kol Machshava of the Karchin you have to be Moitzi the Pail. We spoke about it right on the base. Right? This is the first thing we spoke about in Zohar. After the first Tosefta on the base, what about the word "Amati"? THIS IS WHERE RASHI FELT HE WANTED TO GIVE YOU this information. Kol Machshava of the Karchin Moitzi the Pail. So, said the Pasker up, "I'll tell you." WHERE DID RASHI SAY IT? HE SAID THE KHACHAMIM SAY YOU DON'T SAY KOL OD RISHON OD. WHY NOT? WE SAID IT ON THAT BASE. MECHA TAISI NOT. THE TAIRUTZ IS BECAUSE OF MACHSHAVA PAIL. WHEN YOU TALK ABOUT A MACHSHAVA Pail you have to be Moitzi the Pail. It's not a Machshava that's being Mepharish the Ma'aseh. It's a new Kol Od. THE WHOLE IDEA OF THAT IS OD AND OD AND OD AND OD. WHAT OD AND OD AND OD AND OD AND OD AND OD AND OD AND OD AND OD AND OD and Od and Od and Od AND OD AND OD AND OD AND OD AND OD AND OD AND OD AND OD AND OD AND OD AND OD AND OD AND OD AND OD AND OD AND OD AND OD AND OD AND OD AND OD AND OD AND OD AND OD AND OD AND OD AND OD AND OD AND OD AND OD AND OD AND OD and Od and Od AND OD AND OD AND OD AND OD AND OD AND OD AND OD AND OD AND OD AND OD AND OD AND OD OD AND OD AND Od and Od Od and Od and Od and Od and Od Od and Od Od and Od and Od and Od and Od and Od and Od and Od and Od and Od and Od and Od and Od and Od and Od and Od and Od and Od and Od Od and Od and Od and Od and Od and Od and Od and Od and Od and Od and Od and Od and Od and Od and Od and Od and Od and Od and Od and Od and Od and Od and Od and and Od and Od Od and Od and Od and Od and Od and Od and Od and Od and and Od and Od and Od and Od and Od and and Od and The Tairutz is it was Negay of Shatin the Sugya. Because Rashi held you can't understand the Shitas of Khachamim in light of the base of the base UNLESS YOU THAT THAT'S WHY THERE'S NO THE REASON THERE'S NO IT'S BECAUSE YOU CAN'T just give me this much if as a but is a it's a bear it's a it's a deeper it's a whole right so that's the case you need to have it and you can't get it through a that's what you say no way. On the base of the base we're going that we need to just knock out that it the stomach shouldn't be a stomach. The fact that I did with schmo that JUST MEANS LIKE IT SHOULD BE IN THE THAT IT WAS A SCHMO FOR that already you can take for that already you can take they make sure and share that if you look on the base and on the so so on the base says the on the base on the base and over here says the base on the base and they say could be he just says I'm shocked I don't say one word he just says the and those are the that he gave away. This was bothering he wasn't just telling you to take a look at the but this is not how many times does it take he is not playing those games right so what's what's not a trivial question what's doing he was he was watching he was bothered he said our class that he told us my class is and over here it's a little bit of either way that's that's the rate.