You Must Drink the Oil!

just got to mention one Yerushalmi. This Yerushalmi is is really rate for another day. We spoke about this in the last master, maybe not in the Zohar, but at some point in the school and it's a very soy Yerushalmi. Please bring the Yerushalmi here on the almond. I think it would be malpractice not to mention this Yerushalmi. Cuz really in our Gemara we have this interesting borderline out of the ordinary exchange between Rav and Shmuel. Right, it's a little feistier than most in Rav and Shmuel. Right, Shmuel tells Rav, I understand if you're right Daniel didn't have some lawyer the Ludo. He says, why are you going to tell me about the the Mazal and the ones? Right, we spoke out when we learned the daf. This doesn't feel very Rav-like. This is out of character literally. So, if you take a look at the Yerushalmi, the Yerushalmi says as follows, right? In Halacha Ches. So, he's mentioned right after he went to Ashkach Lo D'Romi. So, in our Gemara he's referred to as Rav Lo D'Ludo. In Yerushalmi he's referred to as D'Romi, the Southerner. He also and he said the following to Rav. Rebbe didn't he say that Rebbe and their was Shaman. So, either way Shmuel hears this. So, he goes to Bavel and he reports back. He says you should know that Rebbe didn't say his they were Shaman. Shmuel when Shmuel heard that he said pass the Shaman Akum. And he ate it. Rav didn't eat it. Rav said I'm not eating it. I'm not going to eat it. I'm looking for the Shaman Yisrael. I'm a Shmuel. So, Shmuel told Rav, you ready? He said eat. The law came cuz if you don't eat I'm a Zok in Mamre. I'm going to spread the word that you're a Zok in Mamre. Unbelievable. So, Rav told him I don't know Tamon. I know you that man are all there. Said I know who the one is that's spreading this word that Shaman Akum is really Moter. It's Lo D'Romi. Right? In our Gemara it's the Ludo. In Yerushalmi it's D'Romi. Right? And I'm not to do whatever he says. I'm going to listen. Shmuel said Mar Shaim Garme. You need to say that Shmuel said this on his own. He didn't say it on his own. He said it over in the name of Rebbe Yehuda Nasi. He said it over in the name of Rebbe Yehuda Nasi. Either way Shmuel pressured Rav until finally Rav said, you know what? You want me to take a little bit of Shaman Akum. And he went ahead and he ate it. It's a fascinating Yerushalmi. So, Rav wants to be Rav feels I want to keep on the original which according to Rav comes from the times of Daniel. But Shmuel says no, Rebbe Yehuda Nasi said it's Moter it's Moter. And he said if you're going to be I'm going to write about you that you're a Zok in Mamre. Now, he's a Zok in Mamre. First of all, to be a Zok in Mamre you need the Agudah. It has to be Agudah. Right, it's not so simple to just be a Zok in Mamre. In fact, what came to mind is the words of the Ramban that we've mentioned many times over the years in the Sugya of Rebbe Agudah. The end of a very long Ramban, the Ramban says that as it relates to Rebbe Agudah and what went on in that famous the whole thing says the Ramban that Rebbe was in the times of the times of the Zok in Mamre. He would have became a Zok in Mamre. That's why they put him in the way they put HIM IN THE IT'S PROBABLY something along those lines that the Yerushalmi means. Maybe, I don't know. But the bottom line is is that this is what Shmuel tells Rav. YOU HAVE NO RIGHT TO BE SO, THIS YERUSHALMI is a very interesting Yerushalmi. What you can't be Is that what this means? What happened to Shachner? Right? Wink wink. I'm not into that. You're not allowed to be ALL OF A SUDDEN? Like what's going on? ARE YOU A ZOK in Mamre if you're You know, truth is what came to mind was another Yerushalmi. This Yerushalmi everybody knows. The one here in we just mentioned. Not everybody knows. But the next Yerushalmi everybody knows cuz the brings it in Sukkah. He brings it if it's raining on Sukkos. So, you're you put them in a Sukkah. But let's say you want to be So, Zok stating Yerushalmi THAT IF SOMEONE'S PUT there from something and he does it anyway, he's right? It's a little Yerushalmi I think. Like what are you doing? I said you're put there. It's Moter eat it. YOU DON'T HAVE TO SIT IN A SUKKAH. SIT IN THE SUKKAH. YOU'RE A ZOK IN MAMRE. YOU'RE BUT THE TRUTH is that the we need some sort of You can't just walk away and say oh, if something's Moter you're not true. There's an idea There's an idea of underpinning all of Halacha. Now, what exactly is the So, again, this is not right for today. But this Yerushalmi is the postscript this Gemara and it's a critical Yerushalmi. If you want one if you take a look at the in his in you and he comes up with a little bit of a or I'm related right by this.